< Back to Pennsylvania Unemployment

PA UC denied after 12 weeks pending - employer lied on separation info

After waiting for nearly 3 months with my PA unemployment claim stuck in pending, I finally got a determination letter yesterday - DENIED! The reason they gave makes my blood boil. My previous employer (retail chain) told UC that I was fired for 'willful misconduct' because I supposedly abandoned my position. THIS IS COMPLETELY FALSE! I gave proper 2-week notice in writing to my manager after getting harassed by a new supervisor. I worked every scheduled shift during those 2 weeks and even trained my replacement! My manager even wished me good luck on my last day! The determination letter says I have 15 days to appeal but I'm totally lost on how to prove my side. Has anyone successfully appealed when their employer flat-out lied? What kind of evidence do I need to gather? I still have text messages with my manager about my notice period and my final schedule. Would that help? This is so unfair and I'm beyond stressed. Bills are piling up and I've been looking for work with no luck. Any advice would be so appreciated!

Natasha Petrov

•

You absolutely need to appeal this ASAP. Don't wait until the 15 days are almost up. This happens more often than you'd think - employers contest claims to keep their UC tax rates down. For your appeal, gather: 1. Copy of your written notice (hopefully you kept this) 2. Those text messages with your manager 3. Any final pay stubs showing you worked through your notice period 4. Written statement detailing the harassment issues 5. Names of coworkers who can verify you trained your replacement In your appeal letter, stick to facts and timeline. Avoid emotional language even though I know you're upset. The referee needs clear evidence that contradicts the employer's claim of job abandonment.

0 coins

Javier Morales

•

Thank you so much for this detailed response. I do have the text messages and my final pay stub showing I worked until my end date. I'm worried because my notice was handwritten and I don't have a copy - stupid mistake. Would getting statements from coworkers who saw me work my final weeks help? And should I mention the harassment or just focus on disproving the abandonment claim?

0 coins

Connor O'Brien

•

omg the EXACT same thing happened to me last year!!! my boss said i was a no-call no-show but i had PROOF i called off sick following company policy!!! these companies will say ANYTHING to avoid paying!!! fight this!!!

0 coins

Javier Morales

•

That's so frustrating! Did you win your appeal? What kind of proof worked for you?

0 coins

Connor O'Brien

•

YES i won!! took like 2 months tho. i had screenshots of my call log showing i called the store and a coworker who testified that managers knew i was sick. the referee totally saw thru their lies!!!

0 coins

Amina Diallo

•

I helped my brother through this exact situation in 2024, and I can confirm that witness statements from coworkers can be extremely valuable in your appeal. The key is getting statements that specifically address the employer's claim about job abandonment. For your appeal hearing: 1. You'll receive a notice with the date/time (usually by mail and in your UC portal) 2. Hearings are mostly done by phone now 3. You can have witnesses participate 4. The employer will be on the call too 5. Both sides present evidence and testimony One critical thing - if you can't find your written notice, check if you sent any emails or texts MENTIONING the notice. Something like "As I mentioned in my notice last week..." can help establish you did provide notice. And yes, you can request a copy of your employer's statement to UC through your online portal or by calling the UC service center.

0 coins

Javier Morales

•

This is incredibly helpful, thank you! I just checked and I do have a text where I mentioned "my last day per my notice" to my manager when confirming my final schedule. Would that help establish I gave proper notice? Also, how do I get coworkers to provide statements? Do they need to be notarized or is there a specific form?

0 coins

GamerGirl99

•

Those UC people don't care about our side AT ALL!!! My employer said i was fired for being late but i was late cuz THEIR SCHEDULING SYSTEM kept changing my start times!!! The whole system is RIGGED against workers!!!!

0 coins

Natasha Petrov

•

The system isn't perfect, but appeals are actually decided by independent referees who don't work for the UC office or your employer. I've seen many decisions reversed on appeal when claimants provide good evidence. It's worth fighting if you have documentation.

0 coins

I know how frustrating it is waiting for UC to process claims only to get denied. I was in a similar situation last year and spent weeks trying to reach someone at PA UC to discuss my appeal. After hundreds of busy signals and dropped calls, I discovered Claimyr (claimyr.com). They got me connected to a UC representative in under an hour - totally worth it for getting my questions answered before my hearing. They have a video showing how it works: https://youtu.be/CEPETxZdo9E?si=WL1ZzVZWG3KiHrg2 For your specific situation, speaking directly with a UC rep before your appeal is crucial because they can tell you exactly what documentation the referee will be looking for and whether your text messages will be sufficient proof.

0 coins

Isabella Costa

•

does this actually work? i tried calling PA UC like 50 times yesterday and couldnt get thru

0 coins

It worked for me when nothing else did. I was skeptical too but was desperate after trying for days. Got connected in about 45 minutes when I'd been unable to get through for weeks on my own.

0 coins

Malik Jenkins

•

Appeal! Appeal! Appeal! I went through similar nonsense in January. My employer claimed I quit without notice when actually they cut my hours to basically nothing (constructive discharge). Initially denied but won on appeal. Here's what I learned that might help you: 1) If you can't reach UC by phone, use the message center in your dashboard for questions 2) For witness statements, they don't need to be notarized but should include the person's name, contact info, relationship to you, and specific facts they can verify 3) Print EVERYTHING for your appeal hearing - texts, emails, schedules, etc. 4) Be super specific about dates and times in your testimony 5) Don't interrupt when the employer is speaking (even when they're lying) My hearing was scheduled about 6 weeks after I filed my appeal. The referee was actually very fair and carefully considered all evidence. Take a deep breath - you've got this!

0 coins

Javier Morales

•

Thank you for the encouragement! Did you have a lawyer for your hearing? I'm worried about handling this on my own against my former employer who will probably have their HR and legal team there.

0 coins

Malik Jenkins

•

I didn't have a lawyer and still won! Most employers just have an HR person or manager, not actual lawyers. The referee walks everyone through the process. Just stick to facts, stay calm, and have your evidence organized. You'd be surprised how often employers trip themselves up when they're not telling the truth!

0 coins

Isabella Costa

•

wait so if u appeal do u still file weekly claims during the process? im confused

0 coins

Amina Diallo

•

Yes, absolutely continue filing your weekly claims while your appeal is pending! This is extremely important. If you win your appeal, you'll only get paid for weeks you properly certified. Missing weekly claims during the appeal process means permanently losing those payments, even if you ultimately win your appeal.

0 coins

Connor O'Brien

•

i forgot to ask, did u check ur determination letter carefully?? sometimes they deny ppl for dumb technical reasons like u answered a question wrong or didnt report some tiny income. might be easier to fix that than fight about the separation if thats actually the problem

0 coins

Javier Morales

•

Good point! I just double-checked and it specifically cites "willful misconduct - job abandonment" as the reason. It references my employer's statement that I "stopped showing up to scheduled shifts without notice" which is completely false. Nothing about technical issues or reporting problems.

0 coins

Natasha Petrov

•

One more important tip - when you file your appeal (do it online if possible), clearly explain the specific facts that disprove the job abandonment claim. Don't just say "I disagree" or "This is unfair." For example: "I appeal this determination because I did NOT abandon my position. I provided written two-week notice on [date], worked all scheduled shifts through my final day on [date], and even trained my replacement. My manager [name] acknowledged my notice and final day. I have text messages and witness testimony to verify these facts." This approach immediately focuses the referee on the key dispute. Good luck with your appeal!

0 coins

Javier Morales

•

Thank you for the template! I just submitted my appeal using similar wording. Now I'm gathering all my evidence and trying to contact former coworkers for statements. I'll update here once I get a hearing date or any news. Thanks to everyone for the guidance - I feel much more confident about fighting this!

0 coins

TaxRefund AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
6,865 users helped today