Back to New York Unemployment

Mohammed Khan

Can you get unemployment if you were fired for attendance issues? NYSDOL rules explained

So I got let go from my warehouse job about two weeks ago and the termination reason on my paperwork says 'excessive absenteeism.' I had been dealing with some ongoing health stuff that caused me to miss maybe 8 or 9 shifts over a three month stretch. I did call out each time, so it wasn't like I was just ghosting them. HR gave me two written warnings before they finally pulled the trigger. Now I'm trying to figure out if I even have a shot at UI benefits because I've heard that getting fired can get you disqualified automatically, but I've also heard it's not always that case. I filed my claim already and it's sitting in adjudication right now. Really stressed because I have rent due in three weeks and I have no idea what NYSDOL is going to decide. Has anyone been through something like this where they were fired for attendance and still got approved?

Your 8 or 9 absences over a three month window actually matters a lot here. The way NYSDOL looks at terminations for attendance is not a straight disqualification - they dig into whether the absences were within your control. If you had a legitimate health reason and you were calling out each time like you said, that works in your favor. The question they're really asking is whether you were doing something deliberately to get fired or whether life just threw you a curveball. Keep any documentation you have from that period - doctor notes, text messages confirming callouts, anything.

0 coins

I do have a few texts from my supervisor acknowledging my callouts, and one doctor's note from a clinic visit. Would those be enough or do I need like a formal letter from a physician?

0 coins

Those texts are genuinely useful. A formal physician letter helps more if you end up at a hearing, but during the initial adjudication stage the texts showing you notified them can be enough to support your side of the story.

0 coins

My sister - wait no I shouldn't say it that way. My own experience was similar and I had almost nothing in writing and still got approved, so don't panic if your documentation is thin.

0 coins

While you're waiting on adjudication, getting through to an actual NYSDOL agent on the phone is brutal right now. I burned like four mornings trying to reach someone about my own claim. A coworker told me about Claimyr - it basically waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you end up talking directly to a live agent without sitting on hold yourself. Site is claimyr.com and there's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE. For a fired-for-attendance situation where the adjudication outcome could swing either way, actually getting to speak with someone is worth it.

0 coins

Four mornings - yeah that tracks with what I've been dealing with. I'll check out that link tonight, appreciate it.

0 coins

The hold times at NYSDOL have been genuinely terrible lately, not just you. Good to know there are options.

0 coins

I've been trying to get through too and I keep getting disconnected after 45 minutes. This is infuriating.

0 coins

Fired for attendance falls under what NYSDOL calls misconduct, but here's the thing - not every attendance issue rises to the level they define as disqualifying misconduct. There's a distinction between someone who just stopped showing up with no notice versus someone who was calling in, had reasons, and was following procedure. Your situation sounds like the second category. The adjudicator is going to look at your attendance record, your callout history, and whether the company's own attendance policy was consistently enforced.

0 coins

They did enforce the policy consistently from what I could tell - both warnings were documented. Does that actually help or hurt my case?

0 coins

Documented warnings cut both ways. It shows the employer followed procedure, but it also shows you were given notice and kept trying to stay employed rather than just giving up. That second part is what NYSDOL tends to weigh.

0 coins

The consistent enforcement piece is actually important. I've seen people get denied because the employer could show they warned the same person multiple times and nothing changed. But health-related absences are treated differently than just not wanting to come in.

0 coins

Went through this exact thing two years ago - fired for attendance after I had some family medical stuff going on. Missed about a dozen days over four months. I filed, went into adjudication, and three weeks later got approved. The adjudicator asked me in writing about the reasons for my absences and I just explained the health situation honestly. They approved me and I collected for about five months before landing another job. So yes, it is absolutely possible to get unemployment when fired for attendance, at least in NY.

0 coins

Three weeks in adjudication and then approved - that's really encouraging. Did they ever ask your former employer for their side of things too?

0 coins

They did. My old job submitted a statement saying I violated their attendance policy, which was true, but I guess my explanation of why I was absent held more weight. NYSDOL seemed to focus on whether my behavior was intentional or willful, and missing shifts due to health stuff didn't meet that bar for them.

0 coins

This is reassuring to read. I've been scared to even file because I assumed fired automatically meant denied.

0 coins

Fired definitely does not mean automatic denial in NY. I was in a similar boat and I'd heard the same thing you did. Ended up getting approved and I only got that confirmed because I finally reached an agent through Claimyr after weeks of not being able to get anyone on the line at NYSDOL.

0 coins

There's a lot of confusion in these threads about what 'misconduct' actually means under unemployment law. People throw the word around like it's the same as 'you did something wrong at work' but legally it's a much higher bar than that. For NYSDOL to disqualify you for misconduct they basically have to show you intentionally or repeatedly did something you knew could get you fired AND you didn't have a good reason. Health absences with callouts don't typically clear that bar. The employer can say whatever they want in their statement but the adjudicator makes the final call.

0 coins

I did NOT know the legal bar was that high. I've been assuming I'd get denied no matter what because my termination letter literally says misconduct.

0 coins

Your termination letter using the word misconduct doesn't legally make it misconduct under unemployment rules. NYSDOL decides that independently of whatever your employer called it. Employers often use strong language on termination paperwork that doesn't actually translate to a UI disqualification.

0 coins

This happened to me too - my employer wrote 'gross misconduct' on my separation notice and I still got approved for unemployment. The language the company uses is their own internal categorization, not the legal standard.

0 coins

My absences were also the reason I got let go, though mine were more of a transportation issue than a health thing. I was 20 minutes late like six times in two months because my bus route got cut. Filed for unemployment and ended up in adjudication for almost five weeks, which was nerve wracking. The adjudicator mailed me a questionnaire asking me to explain the situation, I filled it out and sent it back, and I got approved about ten days after that. The whole process felt opaque but it did work out.

0 coins

Five weeks is a long time to be in limbo. Did you have any way to know where things stood during that wait, or were you just completely in the dark?

0 coins

Completely in the dark, honestly. I checked my Unemployment Services account every day but it just kept saying 'adjudication in progress.' The questionnaire arriving in my mail was the only sign anything was happening.

0 coins

Transportation being cut by the city causing someone to lose their job and then having to fight for UI is the kind of thing that makes you lose faith in systems. Glad it worked out.

0 coins

You mentioned health stuff - worth knowing that if your absences were related to your own serious health condition, there's an argument that they were 'good cause' even beyond just the misconduct standard. If you end up getting denied and have to appeal, that's a stronger case at a hearing level where you can actually present medical evidence. I'm not saying you'll need to appeal but it's good to know there's a next step if adjudication doesn't go your way.

0 coins

Good to know there's an appeal route. What does a hearing actually look like, is it in person or over the phone?

0 coins

NYSDOL hearings are typically done by phone now. An administrative law judge runs it, both you and the employer can speak, and you can submit documents beforehand. It's less intimidating than it sounds, more like a structured phone conversation than a courtroom.

0 coins

The appeal process saved my claim. I was denied at adjudication and won at the hearing stage. The key was I had documentation I hadn't originally submitted.

0 coins

i got fired for being late too many times and i thought i was totally screwed. filed anyway basically hoping for the best. they put me in adjudication and sent me a letter asking why i was late all those times. i explained that I had a kid in daycare that kept having to close for covid stuff (this was a while back) and they approved me. point is just file and be honest, you never know

0 coins

Being honest seems to be the common thread in all these responses. I've been debating how much detail to include but sounds like more is better.

0 coins

yeah just tell them exactly what happened and why. trying to spin it or leave stuff out can come back to bite you if they talk to your employer and the stories don't match

0 coins

The adjudication questionnaire is probably coming your way if it hasn't already. When you fill it out, a few things help: be specific about dates when possible, explain the health situation without overstating it, and make clear that you were following the callout procedure every single time. What NYSDOL is essentially trying to figure out is whether you wanted to keep your job and were trying to do so. Your facts - calling in each time, having a health reason - both point toward yes.

0 coins

I haven't gotten any questionnaire yet, been about ten days since I filed. Is that normal timing or should I be concerned?

0 coins

Ten days without a questionnaire isn't alarming. Some adjudications move faster and some slower depending on NYSDOL's current backlog. They may have already reached out to your employer and are waiting on that response before sending you anything.

0 coins

Ten days feels like forever when you're waiting and stressed about money. I was in the same position with my adjudication dragging on. Ended up reaching out through Claimyr and actually got to speak to someone who explained exactly where my claim was sitting in the queue.

0 coins

The employer response timeline is something a lot of people don't realize. NYSDOL gives employers a window to respond and adjudication usually doesn't move until that closes.

0 coins

FIRED FOR ATTENDANCE AND THEY WANT ME TO JUMP THROUGH ALL THESE HOOPS?? I went through this last year. Was out sick three times, had a doctor's note for two of them, and my job fired me anyway. Then I had to fight NYSDOL for SIX WEEKS to get my benefits started. Six weeks with no income while they 'investigated.' The system is designed to make you give up. File everything, document everything, and don't let them wear you down.

0 coins

Six weeks is brutal. I'm only on week two of adjudication and I'm already at my limit.

0 coins

Week two feels like nothing once you've hit week five, trust me. But I'm proof it can still resolve in your favor. Just keep filing your weekly claims the whole time, that part is crucial - a lot of people stop certifying while in adjudication and then lose those back weeks.

0 coins

This is such an important point about continuing to certify weekly. I almost stopped because I thought 'why bother if I'm in adjudication' and someone warned me not to. If you get approved, they pay you for all those certified weeks.

0 coins

My adjudication dragged so long I finally got desperate and tried Claimyr to reach NYSDOL. The whole thing basically waits on hold for you so you eventually end up with a live NYSDOL agent on the line. I spoke to someone who actually pulled up my case and told me the employer hadn't submitted their response yet, which was why everything was stalled. That one piece of information saved me weeks of guessing.

0 coins

That's exactly the kind of information I need right now - just knowing what's actually causing the delay. I've been completely guessing.

0 coins

Knowing whether the stall is on NYSDOL's end or the employer's end is genuinely useful because it changes what you can do about it.

0 coins

Exactly - if it's the employer, there's not much you can do except wait. But if it's sitting on NYSDOL's desk, the agent I spoke with was actually able to flag it.

0 coins

For anyone worried about the job search requirements while in adjudication - you still have to do them. Three job search activities per week is the current requirement in NY. Keep your log even before you're approved because they can audit those records. I know someone who got approved after a long adjudication and then had benefits paused because they couldn't document their job search activities during the wait period.

0 coins

I've actually been doing the job search activities but not logging them carefully. Going to fix that immediately.

0 coins

Log the date, company name, contact method, and position applied for. The more detail the better. NYSDOL's format for this is flexible but those four elements cover you.

0 coins

I had no idea you had to do job searches even while your claim was in adjudication. I thought you only had to do that after approval. This thread is genuinely helpful.

0 coins

My whole claim hinged on whether my employer submitted their separation statement accurately. They didn't - they said I had been warned five times when it was actually twice. When NYSDOL sent me the questionnaire I pointed that out and asked them to verify with the documentation. That discrepancy apparently mattered. If you have documentation of exactly how many warnings you received versus what your employer might claim, hold onto it tightly.

0 coins

I've got copies of both warning letters, which at least pins down the number. Good call flagging that.

0 coins

Those warning letters are valuable. They pin down the official record and prevent your employer from inflating the history later.

0 coins

Termination letters that say 'excessive absenteeism' have a different weight than terminations for things like theft or insubordination. NYSDOL adjudicators see attendance cases constantly and there's a pretty well-worn path: were the absences for reasons beyond your control, did you notify the employer, and was this a pattern of willful neglect or just life happening. Your situation reads like the latter and that tends to go better in adjudication.

0 coins

Does NYSDOL treat health-related absences differently than other kinds of absences, like is there a formal category for that?

0 coins

There's not a formal checkbox but it factors in heavily when the adjudicator is weighing whether the absence was within your control. Health issues generally aren't considered willful, which is what they're really looking at.

0 coins

The 'willful' standard is the key term. If your behavior wasn't intentional or deliberate, it usually doesn't meet the misconduct definition NYSDOL applies for disqualification.

0 coins

I keep second-guessing my own situation reading this thread. I was fired for attendance also but mine was more complicated - I was showing up late rather than fully absent. Like 15 to 20 minutes late maybe two or three times a week for about six weeks. Got two warnings then terminated. Is lateness treated the same as full absences by NYSDOL or is that a whole different thing?

0 coins

Your lateness pattern - two or three times weekly for six weeks - would likely go through the same misconduct analysis. The question is still whether it was willful. If you had a consistent reason for the lateness that was outside your control, that matters.

0 coins

My car was in the shop for three of those weeks and I was relying on rides. I did tell my supervisor that was happening.

0 coins

Telling your supervisor and having a reason changes the picture. Document anything you have from that period, even just a text saying your car was in the shop.

0 coins

After my own claim finally resolved I told everyone I know who was dealing with NYSDOL phone issues to try Claimyr. My brother had a totally different kind of claim issue and he used it and ended up getting actual answers from an agent in the same week instead of waiting around for weeks hearing nothing.

0 coins

Your brother's situation - getting answers that fast - sounds like a dream compared to what I'm dealing with right now.

0 coins

His situation was different from mine but the phone access problem is the same for everyone. NYSDOL's lines are just overwhelmed regardless of what kind of claim issue you have.

0 coins

The phone situation at NYSDOL has been rough for years but it got noticeably worse recently. Even people with straightforward claims can't get through.

0 coins

You asked earlier about documentation - once your adjudication resolves either way, there are a few dates you need to watch. If approved, your first payment usually hits within a week of the decision. If denied, you have 30 days from the determination date to file your appeal. Don't wait until day 29 to file an appeal because NYSDOL can be strict about that deadline.

0 coins

30 days from the determination date - writing that down right now. That's the kind of specific detail I needed.

0 coins

The appeal form is called a request for a hearing before an Administrative Law Judge and you can file it online through your Unemployment Services account or by mail. Online is faster.

0 coins

The 30-day window goes fast when you're stressed about money and trying to find a new job at the same time. Set a reminder the day your determination comes in.

0 coins

Two weeks ago I was in almost the same spot as you, waiting on adjudication after being fired for not showing up enough. I got my determination letter yesterday - approved. The letter explained that my absences were found to be non-willful because I had notified my employer each time and had underlying reasons beyond my control. Sharing this because two weeks ago I couldn't find any recent examples of people getting approved for attendance-related terminations and I was spiraling.

0 coins

Yesterday - congratulations, seriously. And thank you for sharing this because I am absolutely spiraling the same way you were.

0 coins

The spiraling is real but it doesn't help and I wish I'd been able to turn it off. The adjudication process is slower than you want it to be but it does actually evaluate your specific situation rather than just rubber-stamping the employer's characterization.

0 coins

The word 'non-willful' in that determination letter is exactly what this thread has been building toward explaining. Good outcome.

0 coins

Your stress about rent in three weeks is real and I don't want to minimize it. What helped me mentally during my adjudication was calculating the minimum scenario: if approved, when would the first payment land, and would that cover the most critical bill. Working that math gave me something concrete to focus on instead of just pure anxiety. Also worth talking to your landlord ahead of time if you haven't - telling them you have a pending claim and expect resolution within X weeks goes over better than just missing a payment with no warning.

0 coins

I haven't talked to my landlord yet but that's actually smart advice. Giving them a heads up is better than just showing up short on rent day.

0 coins

Most landlords would rather hear from you early than be surprised. And if your claim gets approved in time, you never even need to have that conversation again.

0 coins

Filing your weekly claims on time each week while adjudication is pending cannot be stressed enough. I want to make sure this is loud and clear because it comes up after every adjudication approval where someone missed weeks. If your claim is approved, NYSDOL releases payment for all the weeks you properly certified during adjudication. If you stop certifying because you're not sure what's happening, those weeks are gone even if the underlying claim is approved.

0 coins

I've been certifying every week even though it feels kind of pointless right now. Good to know that's exactly what I should be doing.

0 coins

Not pointless at all - those certified weeks are the weeks you get paid for when approval comes through. Keep doing it without interruption.

0 coins

This is the most common mistake I see people mention in these forums. They assume certifying doesn't matter until approval comes in and then they're shocked when only their most recent weeks get paid.

0 coins

My first adjudication I stopped certifying after two weeks thinking I was just going to get denied anyway. Got approved and lost those two weeks of benefits permanently. Painful lesson.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure