Back to New York Unemployment

Charlee Coleman

Can you be denied unemployment for sleeping on the job in NY?

So I got fired two weeks ago and I'm trying to figure out where I stand before I file my claim. My employer's official termination paperwork says I was let go for 'conduct unbecoming' and when I called HR they clarified it was because a supervisor found me asleep at my workstation twice - once in March and once about a month later in April. Both times I got written up. I'll be honest, I was dealing with some serious sleep apnea that I hadn't gotten diagnosed yet (I finally saw a doctor last week and have documentation now). I work in data entry so it's not like I was operating machinery or anything where safety was a concern. My question is whether NYSDOL is going to automatically deny me or if there's any room to explain the medical situation. I've heard mixed things - some people say any termination for cause means you're out, others say it depends on whether the misconduct was 'willful.' Has anyone actually gone through something like this with NYSDOL? I'm trying to figure out whether to even bother filing or if I'm just setting myself up for a denial and a long fight.

Wait, did they ever give you a formal warning that the job was at risk before the second incident? That detail matters a lot here. My situation was different - I got let go for attendance issues - but when I went through the NYSDOL process, the question they kept coming back to was whether I had reason to believe termination was coming and whether I took any steps to fix it. The 'willful misconduct' standard is basically about whether you knew the rules, broke them anyway with no good reason, and ignored warnings. The medical angle you're describing changes that calculus significantly if you can show the sleep issues weren't something you were just ignoring.

0 coins

Both write-ups mentioned that further incidents could result in termination, so yes, there was warning. But I genuinely didn't connect what was happening with a medical condition at the time - I just thought I was tired from bad sleep habits. The doctor's note now confirms I have moderate-to-severe sleep apnea. Does that retroactive diagnosis help or is it too late since I didn't disclose it to my employer?

0 coins

The warnings existing actually doesn't automatically sink you. What NYSDOL looks at is the totality - were the warnings fair, was the rule reasonable, and was the employee's behavior something they could actually control. A medical condition you didn't know about yet is a legitimate mitigating factor.

0 coins

Honestly just file. You lose nothing by filing. NYSDOL adjudicators are supposed to consider all the circumstances, and you have more going for you here than you might think.

0 coins

Ugh, this whole area of NYSDOL decisions is so frustrating. I went through something vaguely similar (not sleeping but a conduct termination) and trying to get anyone on the phone at NYSDOL to explain how my adjudication was going was absolutely impossible. Hours on hold, then the line just dropped. I never got any real explanation until I got a letter in the mail.

0 coins

The phone situation with NYSDOL is genuinely terrible. I burned probably 15+ hours total trying to reach someone about my claim status before I found a workaround.

0 coins

Fifteen hours sounds about right. I think I hit 12 before I gave up and just waited for the mail.

0 coins

How long did your adjudication take once they had everything they needed? I'm trying to plan around when I might see any money if I do get approved.

0 coins

My adjudication for a misconduct termination took almost six weeks and I nearly lost my mind trying to reach someone. A friend pointed me toward Claimyr - claimyr.com - and there's a video showing what it does here: https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE. Basically it waits on hold with NYSDOL for you so you actually end up on the phone talking to a live agent instead of spending your whole day listening to hold music. I used it when my adjudication was dragging and the agent I spoke with walked me through exactly what documents they still needed from me. Sped things up considerably once I knew what was missing.

0 coins

Six weeks is brutal. What was the actual reason your adjudication ran that long - was it back-and-forth with your former employer?

0 coins

My former employer disputed my version of events and NYSDOL had to do a full fact-finding. They contacted my employer, got statements, then needed my response. The agent I reached explained the whole timeline once I finally had someone on the phone.

0 coins

Waiting that long without being able to reach anyone sounds awful. I've heard adjudications for misconduct terminations take longer than regular claims just because there's more for them to investigate.

0 coins

Here's what I know from going through a termination-for-cause denial and then successfully appealing it. NYSDOL doesn't treat all 'fired for cause' cases the same way. The key legal standard they apply is whether what you did qualifies as 'misconduct' under New York law, and courts have interpreted that to mean behavior that's deliberate, done in disregard of the employer's interests, or in violation of a known rule without any reasonable justification. Falling asleep because of an undiagnosed medical condition you didn't know you had is genuinely a defensible position because there's no 'deliberate' element. You weren't choosing to do it - your body was doing something you didn't understand yet. I'd file immediately, explain the medical situation clearly in your initial filing, attach whatever documentation you have from your doctor, and be specific about when you got the diagnosis relative to when the incidents occurred.

0 coins

This is really helpful framing. My concern is that because I had two written warnings, NYSDOL might see it as 'you were told to fix it and didn't.' But if I didn't know what was causing it, how was I supposed to fix it?

0 coins

That's exactly the argument you make. You didn't know what was wrong, so you couldn't have taken steps to address the root cause. A warning saying 'don't fall asleep' isn't the same as a warning that gives you the actual means to fix the underlying problem. Document that timeline carefully.

0 coins

The timing of the medical diagnosis relative to the termination is going to be your strongest piece of evidence. Make sure the doctor's notes include when the condition likely started, not just when you were diagnosed.

0 coins

Does having a doctor's note now actually change anything if you didn't tell your employer about a medical issue before they fired you? Like I'm genuinely asking because I always assumed NYSDOL only looks at what the employer knew at the time.

0 coins

NYSDOL's adjudication considers the full picture, including facts that explain the claimant's behavior even if the employer wasn't aware. The question isn't just what the employer knew - it's whether the conduct truly meets the legal definition of misconduct. A medical explanation speaks to the claimant's intent and control.

0 coins

Oh interesting, I always assumed it was purely about the employer's perspective. That changes how I think about these situations.

0 coins

There's also the ADA angle, though that's more of an employment law issue than an unemployment insurance question - still worth knowing about if the OP wants to explore other options beyond just the UI claim.

0 coins

I'm panicking reading this thread because I'm in adjudication right now for something completely different but seeing how complicated these cases get is stressing me out. How do you even know what NYSDOL is looking for when you're in adjudication? My account just says 'pending' and I've heard nothing for two weeks.

0 coins

Two weeks is still early for adjudication - try not to spiral yet. The usual range is two to six weeks depending on how complicated the circumstances are and whether your former employer responds.

0 coins

But what if they deny me without asking for any additional information? Can they do that? I haven't gotten any questionnaire or anything.

0 coins

They can and sometimes do decide based on the initial information. If you're worried, try to reach them by phone to ask if anything else is needed - that's usually the fastest way to find out if your file is complete.

0 coins

I've tried calling four times and can't get through. I'm going to keep trying but it's really discouraging when you just need a simple answer.

0 coins

My cousin went through a misconduct termination denial last year and appealed it herself without a lawyer. She won. The appeal hearing is conducted by an Administrative Law Judge and it's a lot less formal than people expect - you can speak directly to the judge, present documents, and explain context that might not have come through in the initial claim. If you do get denied, don't treat it as the end. The appeal is a real second chance.

0 coins

How prepared did your cousin have to be going into the hearing? I'm not in that situation yet but I want to know what I might be dealing with if the initial claim gets denied.

0 coins

She organized her documents chronologically, wrote out talking points, and thought through every question the judge might ask. The judges are allowed to ask both sides questions and they sometimes ask things that catch you off guard if you're not ready.

0 coins

The appeal hearings are usually done by phone now, which makes them a little less intimidating if you've never done anything like that before. Still stressful but less so than showing up to a formal proceeding.

0 coins

Reaching NYSDOL while your claim is in adjudication is genuinely one of the harder things to do. I spent most of a day trying before someone in another forum mentioned Claimyr. I ended up speaking with an actual NYSDOL agent who confirmed my file was complete and told me roughly where I was in the queue. That alone was worth it - just not sitting there wondering.

0 coins

How specific were they able to be about timing? Or was it more of a 'we can't promise anything' kind of answer?

0 coins

Honest answer - they weren't specific about an exact date, but the agent told me whether my employer had responded yet and what the next step in the process was. That context made the waiting much more bearable.

0 coins

Knowing where you are in the process versus just staring at a 'pending' status screen is a huge difference psychologically.

0 coins

There's something worth knowing about how NYSDOL handles misconduct cases specifically. I went through this process and the adjudicator sent questionnaires to both me and my former employer asking for our accounts of what happened. What your employer says in their questionnaire response matters - if they frame it as 'deliberate rule violation' versus 'performance issue,' that framing can influence the initial determination. It doesn't mean you lose if they say the wrong thing, but it does set the stage for what you might need to counter in an appeal.

0 coins

Should I be doing anything proactively to get my version of events into the record, or is it better to wait and see what documentation they ask for?

0 coins

File the claim and in the section where you explain the circumstances of your separation, be thorough. Don't leave things vague. The initial claim narrative is your first chance to frame the situation your way.

0 coins

Agree with this. The initial filing is not the place to be brief. Write out the medical context, the timeline, the fact that the diagnosis came after termination - all of it. More context is almost always better at that stage.

0 coins

Okay but here's what I've never understood about these cases - if you get fired and then appeal and win, does the employer face any consequences? Or do they just get to dispute claims with no downside for trying?

0 coins

Employers in New York have their UI tax rate affected by how often their former employees successfully claim benefits against them. So there is a financial incentive for them to dispute claims, but winning claimants do get their benefits and the employer's account is charged accordingly.

0 coins

Huh, I didn't realize the tax rate thing was a factor. So employers who fight every claim aren't necessarily doing themselves any favors long-term if they keep losing.

0 coins

The whole experience rate system is actually a decent check on frivolous employer disputes - in theory at least.

0 coins

My file sat in adjudication for almost eight weeks because my employer was slow responding to NYSDOL's questionnaire. By the time it was resolved I'd already found a new job, so it almost didn't matter anymore, but I remember how stressful that period was. If you're in a situation like the OP where the facts are genuinely ambiguous, brace yourself for it taking a while.

0 coins

Eight weeks is a long time to be in financial limbo. Were you able to do anything to speed up the employer's response or is that completely outside your control?

0 coins

Pretty much outside your control. NYSDOL sends the questionnaire to the employer and sets a deadline, but following up on whether the employer responded isn't something you can easily do as the claimant. The agent I eventually reached confirmed my employer had a deadline they were approaching.

0 coins

This is why being able to actually talk to someone at NYSDOL is so valuable - you can at least find out if the holdup is on the employer's side versus something missing from your own file.

0 coins

Let me add some context on the medical defense specifically since I work in HR (not for NYSDOL, just at a company). When an employer writes up a termination and the stated reason is attendance or conduct, they typically don't go back and revise their position even if the employee later presents medical documentation. So what happens in a UI claim is that the employer submits their side saying 'terminated for misconduct - sleeping on the job, two written warnings' and NYSDOL has to weigh that against whatever the claimant says. The claimant's job is to introduce enough factual doubt about the 'willful' element that the adjudicator can't definitively call it misconduct.

0 coins

So from your HR perspective, would employers typically address the medical angle in their questionnaire response or would they just restate the documented reason for termination?

0 coins

In my experience, most employers just restate the documented reason. They don't engage with mitigating factors - they describe what happened and what the documentation says. That actually works in your favor because it leaves the medical context as something you're introducing that they haven't actively argued against.

0 coins

That's a really interesting way to frame it. The employer can only tell their side and if they just describe what happened without calling it willful, the door is open for the claimant to explain why it wasn't.

0 coins

I had a friend who used Claimyr when his misconduct claim was stuck and he finally got to talk to an agent after spending two full days trying to reach someone. The agent was actually helpful and told him he needed to submit an additional statement, which he did within hours. His claim got approved about two weeks after that. I keep it in mind as an option now whenever I hear people going in circles trying to reach NYSDOL.

0 coins

Two full days trying to reach someone and then it got resolved pretty quickly once he actually had the conversation - that timeline tells you everything about where the bottleneck really is.

0 coins

Exactly. The information needed to move things forward was available, it just required getting a person on the phone. Everything he needed to do was simple once he knew what it was.

0 coins

This is making me want to try something different. I've just been redialing manually which is clearly not working.

0 coins

To the OP and others worried about misconduct denials - the initial determination is not the final word. I've seen stats suggesting something like 40% of appealed unemployment denials in New York get reversed. The appeal process exists specifically because initial determinations sometimes don't have the full picture.

0 coins

That's a more encouraging number than I would have guessed. I guess I assumed if NYSDOL denied you they were pretty confident in that decision.

0 coins

The initial determination is often made without a full hearing - it's based on questionnaire responses and documentation. The appeal is where you actually get to present your case in a more complete way and have a judge hear it in real time.

0 coins

The reversal rate reflects how often the written record is incomplete compared to what comes out when both sides can actually explain their positions.

0 coins

Has anyone actually gone through a misconduct hearing specifically for sleeping on the job and gotten approved? I know the general principles but I'm curious if anyone has direct experience with that specific situation or something very close to it.

0 coins

I've seen forum posts over the years where people prevailed on exactly that issue when medical evidence was involved. The cases that lost tended to be ones where the person had no explanation other than just being tired, with no underlying condition. The medical diagnosis changes the character of the behavior fundamentally.

0 coins

That tracks with how the legal standard works. 'I was tired' is very different from 'I had an undiagnosed condition causing involuntary sleep episodes without my awareness.

0 coins

The language you use matters too. 'Involuntary' is doing a lot of work in that framing - it's the word that takes the 'willful' element off the table.

0 coins

Filing the weekly certifications while you're in adjudication - do you still have to do those even if you don't know if you're going to be approved? I got confused about this when I was going through my thing and almost stopped filing because I thought it was pointless.

0 coins

Yes, absolutely keep filing every week even during adjudication. If you stop and then get approved, you don't get retroactive credit for weeks you didn't certify - you lose those weeks permanently. It's one of the most common mistakes people make while waiting.

0 coins

I figured this out eventually but it wasn't explained to me at any point in the initial process. I just stumbled on it in a forum like this one. NYSDOL should really make that clearer up front.

0 coins

Good to know - I've been doing the weekly certifications and was second-guessing whether that was the right call. Sounds like it definitely is.

0 coins

The job search requirements during adjudication are another thing that trips people up. You still have to do your three contacts per week and log them even while your claim is being adjudicated. If you get approved and they audit your job search log and find gaps, that creates a whole new problem on top of whatever you just resolved.

0 coins

Three contacts per week - does applying online count the same as a direct application or phone contact, or is it weighted differently?

0 coins

Online applications count. The requirement is documented contacts, and an online application generates a record. Keep screenshots or confirmations of applications submitted as part of your log in case you ever need to prove it.

0 coins

I've been doing my job search activities but I'm not logging them as carefully as I should be. This is a good reminder to be more systematic about it.

0 coins

My experience with the adjudication process was that the written questionnaire NYSDOL sent me was actually pretty leading in a way that caught me off guard. The questions were phrased in ways where it wasn't obvious what the 'right' answer was - like, answering too briefly made you look like you had nothing to say, but over-explaining felt like it might raise new issues. Did others find that?

0 coins

The questionnaire is designed to gather facts, not to trap you, but I understand why it feels that way. My approach was to answer each question directly, not volunteer information beyond what was asked, but to be complete within what was asked. Concise but thorough.

0 coins

That balance of concise but thorough is exactly the right framing. I think I erred on the side of over-explaining in ways that might have introduced things that didn't need to be there.

0 coins

If you're ever unsure how to answer a specific question on the questionnaire, that's genuinely a good reason to try to reach an adjudicator by phone before you submit it.

0 coins

Wrapping up my situation for anyone following - I filed the claim yesterday. I explained the medical situation in detail in the separation narrative section, noted the timing of the diagnosis relative to the termination, and attached the doctor's documentation. The rep I spoke to when setting up my account said the adjudication process starts immediately. Weekly certifications are submitted. Job search log is running. Now I wait and try to stay calm. I'll update when I know more. Thank you to everyone who weighed in - this thread gave me a lot more confidence going into it than I had a few days ago.

0 coins

You did everything right. The documentation plus the detailed narrative is the best position you can be in at this stage.

0 coins

The fact that you didn't just file and hope but actually understood the standard you're being evaluated against is going to show in how you wrote up your circumstances. Good luck - I'd be surprised if this one didn't go your way.

0 coins

Keep us posted. And if the adjudication runs long and you need to reach someone, you now know what options you have for getting through.

0 coins

Related posts

New York Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure