Will I get in trouble if I filed as single when married but I'm actually married?
So I just realized that my new job has been withholding taxes from my paychecks at the "single" rate even though I've been married for almost 6 years now! I started working at this company back in February and just noticed this mistake when reviewing my latest pay stub. They've basically been taking WAY more money out of my checks than they should have been all year. I'm worried about two things - first, am I going to get in some kind of trouble with the IRS since my withholding status doesn't match my actual marital status? And second, is there any way to get back all that extra money they've been taking out when I file my taxes next year? I've been trying to get HR to fix this for almost three weeks now but keep getting bounced around between different people who say they'll "look into it." Starting to get really frustrated because that's MY money they're holding onto unnecessarily. Has anyone dealt with this before?
21 comments
Join the conversation
Logan Scott
No, you won't get in trouble with the IRS for this situation. The withholding status on your W-4 with your employer is separate from your actual filing status on your tax return. Your employer uses the W-4 information to determine how much tax to withhold from each paycheck, but it doesn't dictate how you must file. When you file your taxes for 2025, you'll file with your correct status (married filing jointly or married filing separately) regardless of what withholding rate your employer used. And yes, you will get back any excess tax that was withheld when you file your return. The withholding is essentially just an estimated prepayment of your tax liability.
0 coins
Mila Walker
•That's such a relief to hear! So even though they've been taking out too much all year, I'll still get it back when I file? Do I need to do anything special on my tax return to make sure I get those extra withholdings back?
0 coins
Logan Scott
•You don't need to do anything special on your tax return to get the excess withholding back. When you file your taxes, you'll report your total income and your total federal tax withholding (from your W-2). The system automatically calculates your actual tax liability based on your filing status, and if your withholding exceeds your liability, you'll get the difference as a refund. I would still recommend getting your W-4 corrected with your employer as soon as possible. While you'll get the money back eventually, there's no reason to give the government an interest-free loan in the meantime. If HR continues to drag their feet, try going to your direct supervisor or even the payroll department directly.
0 coins
Chloe Green
I had a similar issue last year and was getting nowhere with HR. I finally used this service called taxr.ai (https://taxr.ai) that helped me understand exactly what was happening with my withholdings and gave me a personalized letter to send to HR explaining what needed to be fixed. They analyzed my pay stubs and explained that being incorrectly set as "single" meant I was withholding at a higher rate than necessary. The website has this tool that compares your current withholding to what it should be based on your actual tax situation. Made a huge difference for me because I was able to show HR exactly how much extra was coming out of each check.
0 coins
Lucas Adams
•How does the analysis actually work? Do you have to upload all your pay stubs or just the most recent one? My situation is similar but I'm also dealing with some 1099 income on the side and wondering if it can handle that complexity.
0 coins
Harper Hill
•Sounds suspiciously convenient lol. Did you actually get your money back faster or did it just help with the HR situation? I'm skeptical about these tax services that promise the world.
0 coins
Chloe Green
•The analysis works by examining your withholding patterns against what they should be for your filing status. You can upload just your most recent stub if the withholding has been consistent, but I uploaded several to show the pattern. And yes, it absolutely handles 1099 income - there's a specific section for adding self-employment income that helps calculate proper estimated tax payments. It didn't get my money back faster in terms of my tax refund timeline - that still happens when you file. But it absolutely helped resolve the HR situation faster because I had documentation showing exactly what needed to be changed. Having that professional analysis made them take me seriously instead of just brushing me off.
0 coins
Lucas Adams
Just wanted to follow up about taxr.ai since my last comment. I ended up trying it and it was seriously helpful! I uploaded my last three pay stubs and answered some questions about my 1099 side gig. The report showed I was overpaying by about $278 every month due to the wrong filing status PLUS it gave recommendations for my self-employment tax situation. Took the PDF they generated to HR and suddenly they were able to "find time" to fix my withholding status after ignoring me for weeks. The before/after comparison in my most recent paycheck is pretty dramatic - almost $300 more take-home pay! Wish I'd known about this months ago instead of letting the government hold onto my money interest-free.
0 coins
Caden Nguyen
For anyone struggling to get answers directly from the IRS on withholding issues, I highly recommend trying Claimyr (https://claimyr.com). I was trying to figure out if I could get my overwithholding fixed mid-year and spent HOURS on hold with the IRS without ever reaching anyone. Claimyr got me connected to an actual IRS agent in about 20 minutes. You can see how it works in this video: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c - basically they use technology to wait on hold for you and then call you when an agent picks up. The IRS agent I spoke with explained that I could file a new W-4 with my employer at any time, and confirmed I'd get back any overwithholding when I filed my return. Saved me so much frustration!
0 coins
Avery Flores
•How does this actually work though? Is it legit? Seems weird that they can somehow get through the IRS phone system when regular people can't.
0 coins
Harper Hill
•Yeah right. There's absolutely NO WAY to skip the IRS phone queue. This has to be some kind of scam where you pay money and they put you on hold just like everyone else. I'll believe it when I see proof that isn't a marketing video.
0 coins
Caden Nguyen
•It works by using a system that continuously redials and navigates the IRS phone tree until it gets through to an agent. When an agent answers, it connects you immediately. It's not "skipping" the queue - they're just handling the waiting for you so you don't have to sit with a phone to your ear for hours. I was skeptical too! I thought it would be just another service that doesn't deliver. But I was desperate after spending three separate afternoons trying to get through myself. The difference is that their system can keep trying while you go about your day, and they only call you when there's actually a human on the line. I literally put the phone down, went about my day, and got a call back when they had an agent. No tricks or scams involved.
0 coins
Harper Hill
I need to publicly eat my words about Claimyr. After my skeptical comment, I decided to try it anyway because I was absolutely desperate to talk to someone at the IRS about my withholding issue. I'd been trying for TWO MONTHS to get through on my own. Submitted my request around 10am, went to lunch, and got a call at 1:45pm saying they had an IRS agent on the line. I nearly fell out of my chair. Got connected immediately to an actual human at the IRS who answered my questions about fixing my withholding mid-year and confirmed I'd get back any excess when I file. For anyone struggling with tax questions and getting nowhere with the regular IRS number - this service is worth every penny. Not being stuck on hold for hours is literally life-changing.
0 coins
Zoe Gonzalez
I had the exact same thing happen last year. My employer had me as single even though I've been married for 3 years. Don't worry about getting in trouble - the withholding selection is just how much they take out, not how you actually file. When I filed my taxes, I just filed as married (which is my actual status) and got a much bigger refund than usual because they'd been taking out too much all year. The bad news is you've essentially been giving the government an interest-free loan all this time. The good news is you'll get a fat refund!
0 coins
Mila Walker
•Thanks for sharing your experience! That's actually great to hear. Do you remember if there was anything special you had to do when filing to make sure they recognized the over-withholding? Or does the system just automatically figure it out?
0 coins
Zoe Gonzalez
•The system figures it out automatically when you file. Your W-2 will show the total amount withheld for the year, and when you enter that along with filing as married, the tax software (or the IRS if you file by paper) calculates your actual tax owed based on your correct filing status. Then they subtract what you already paid through withholding, and that difference becomes your refund. It's actually kind of satisfying to see how much you get back! But going forward, definitely get your W-4 fixed so you can have that money in your paychecks instead of waiting for a refund. I ended up submitting a new W-4 directly to our payroll department after HR kept giving me the runaround.
0 coins
Ashley Adams
Be careful about one thing - while you won't get in trouble for the withholding being wrong, make sure you're actually filing correctly based on your marriage. If you've been accidentally filing as "single" on your tax returns when you should be filing as "married filing jointly" or "married filing separately," THAT could potentially cause issues. But it sounds like you've been filing correctly and just noticed the withholding issue, so you should be fine. The withholding is just an estimate of what you'll owe.
0 coins
Alexis Robinson
•Actually this is a really important point! My cousin filed as single for 2 years after getting married because she "didn't think it mattered" and ended up having to file amended returns. The IRS actually sent her a letter about it.
0 coins
Anastasia Fedorov
Don't stress too much about this - it's actually a pretty common situation! The key thing to remember is that your W-4 withholding election and your actual tax filing status are completely separate things. Your employer uses the W-4 to estimate how much tax to take out of each paycheck, but when you file your return, you use your actual marital status. Since you've been married for 6 years, when you file your 2025 tax return you'll file as either "married filing jointly" or "married filing separately" (whichever is better for your situation). The IRS will calculate your actual tax liability based on that correct filing status, and since you've been having taxes withheld at the higher "single" rate all year, you'll likely get a nice refund. For getting HR to fix this going forward - try being more direct. Email them with something like "I need my W-4 updated to reflect my correct marital status. I've been married since [date] and my current withholding is incorrect. Please let me know what forms I need to complete and when this can be processed." Sometimes being specific about exactly what you need helps cut through the bureaucracy. You're essentially getting an interest-free loan back from the government next year, but obviously it's better to have that money in your paychecks now!
0 coins
Ava Thompson
•This is really helpful advice! I especially like the suggestion about being more direct with HR. I've been kind of polite and vague in my requests, but you're right that being specific about exactly what needs to be done might cut through all the back-and-forth. Quick question - when you mention "married filing jointly" vs "married filing separately," is there usually a clear winner in terms of which one saves more money? Or does it depend on our specific income situation?
0 coins
AstroAce
•Great question! In most cases, "married filing jointly" results in lower taxes than "married filing separately" because you get access to higher income thresholds for tax brackets and can claim more deductions. The joint filing status is usually the better choice unless there are specific circumstances like significant differences in income, one spouse has high medical expenses, or there are student loan considerations. However, it really does depend on your specific situation. If you and your spouse have similar incomes, joint filing is almost always better. But if one spouse makes significantly more or has complex deductions, it's worth running the numbers both ways to see which saves more. Most tax software will automatically calculate both scenarios and recommend the better option, so you don't have to guess. When you file next year, just make sure to check both options - the difference can sometimes be substantial!
0 coins