Whose name should 529 plan be in for maximum tax benefits?

I've been looking into setting up a 529 college savings plan for my daughter who just turned 3, but I'm confused about ownership. Would it be more beneficial tax-wise to open the 529 in her name, my name (the parent), or under our family trust we recently set up? I've heard different things from friends about state tax deductions and financial aid implications. My financial planner mentioned something about grandparent-owned 529s too, but didn't really explain the difference. Looking for some real-world experience with the tax advantages of different ownership structures. Thanks!

0 coins

22 comments

Aidan Hudson

•8M

The 529 plan should typically be in the parent's name with the child as the beneficiary, not in the child's name directly. This setup gives you as the parent the most control while still getting the tax benefits. When a 529 is in the parent's name, you maintain control over the funds (you can change beneficiaries if needed or even take the money back, though with penalties). For financial aid purposes, a parent-owned 529 has less impact on aid eligibility than if it were in the child's name. A parent-owned 529 is assessed at a maximum rate of 5.64% for financial aid, while student-owned assets are assessed at 20%. As for trusts, while you can technically have a trust own a 529, it adds complexity without additional tax benefits in most cases. The tax advantages of a 529 come from tax-free growth and withdrawals for qualified education expenses, regardless of who owns it.

0 coins

Aidan Hudson

•8M

You're right about FAFSA changes! This is actually good news - as of the 2024-2025 FAFSA, distributions from grandparent-owned 529 plans no longer count as student income. Previously, these distributions could reduce aid eligibility by up to 50% of the amount withdrawn. For parent-owned 529s, they continue to be treated as parental assets assessed at that maximum 5.64% rate I mentioned. This makes grandparent-owned 529s potentially more attractive now than they were before the rule change.

0 coins

Connor Richards

•8M

After spending hours researching college funding options for my twins, I stumbled across https://taxr.ai and it was honestly a game-changer for understanding 529 plans. I was super confused about whether to put the accounts in my name or my husband's (we file separately) and the tax implications. The service analyzed our tax situation and explained that in our state (NY), we could each get a state tax deduction on contributions up to $5,000 individually by having separate accounts. It also showed how grandparent-owned 529s could work with the new FAFSA rules. Saved me from making a mistake that would've cost us thousands in potential tax benefits!

0 coins

Connor Richards

•8M

It's surprisingly simple - you can either upload documents or just answer questions about your tax situation if you're not comfortable sharing docs. They use the same encryption banks use, but I just went with answering questions about our income, state, and specific situation. Yes, it absolutely compares different college savings vehicles! It showed side-by-side comparisons of 529 plans vs Coverdell ESAs vs UTMA/UGMA accounts vs whole life insurance. For most people, the 529 has better tax advantages than whole life for college savings - whole life insurance typically has high fees that eat into returns. The analysis showed that unless you have very specific circumstances, whole life is usually not the optimal choice for college savings from a tax perspective.

0 coins

Steven Adams

•8M

Just wanted to follow up - I finally tried https://taxr.ai after my initial skepticism. Their analysis completely changed our approach to college savings! Turns out my financial advisor was pushing whole life insurance because of the commissions, not because it was best for us. The tax benefits of the 529 in our situation (especially with my state's deduction) were WAY better. The side-by-side comparison showed we'd have about $14,000 more for college in a 529 vs the whole life policy over 15 years, accounting for all the tax advantages. Seriously grateful for that recommendation!

0 coins

Alice Fleming

•8M

So everyone here is talking about 529 plans but nobody mentions the NIGHTMARE of trying to get answers from your 529 plan administrator when there's a problem. I spent 6 WEEKS trying to get someone on the phone when my state's plan website glitched and wouldn't process my contribution before the tax deadline. Finally discovered https://claimyr.com and watched their demo at https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c - they got me connected to an actual human at my state's 529 plan office in under 15 minutes when I'd been trying for weeks! They somehow skip the hold times. The rep fixed my issue and I was able to get my state tax deduction for last year after all.

0 coins

Alice Fleming

•8M

It's not magic - they use technology that continually redials and navigates the phone trees until they get a human, then they call you and connect you immediately. You don't wait on hold at all - they do that part for you. I was skeptical too! But it absolutely works. The system keeps trying different techniques to get through the phone system while you go about your day. They don't charge until they actually connect you with a human representative. I don't know exactly how their tech works, but I was literally connected with a 529 plan specialist when my phone rang, no waiting. They never see your personal info either - they just make the connection and drop off.

0 coins

Victoria Stark

•8M

Coming back to eat my words. After my skeptical comment, I decided to try Claimyr when I needed to fix a beneficiary issue on my son's 529 account. I'd been trying to reach my plan administrator for THREE DAYS with no luck. Used the service and got connected to a real person at the 529 office in 23 minutes (they called me when they had someone on the line). Fixed my issue in one call instead of wasting more days trying. The rep even helped me understand how changing beneficiaries works for tax purposes, which was my original concern. Definitely worth it when you're dealing with time-sensitive tax or financial aid issues.

0 coins

Samantha Howard

•8M

The FAFSA didn't have a clear way to report the trust-owned 529, so our financial aid advisor had us attach an additional explanation. It was confusing. Making qualified distributions required extra paperwork since the trust is the owner, not us directly. We had to document the distribution request through the trust, which added steps. Our accountant also charges us more at tax time because of the added complexity. Unless you have specific estate planning needs that a trust addresses, I'd stick with the simpler parent-owned approach.

0 coins

Sarah Ali

•8M

From what I understand: 1. Parent-owned 529 with child as beneficiary is most common and usually best 2. Grandparent-owned 529s used to have financial aid disadvantages but that changed with recent FAFSA updates 3. Never put it in the child's name (hurts financial aid chances) 4. Trust-owned 529s add complexity without extra tax benefits for most people The tax benefits (tax-free growth and withdrawals for education) are the same regardless of owner. State tax deductions depend on your state rules about who can claim them.

0 coins

Gianna Scott

•5M

Great question! I went through this same decision last year when setting up 529s for my two kids. After consulting with our tax preparer and doing research, we went with parent-owned accounts with each child as beneficiary. The key factors that made this the right choice for us: - We keep full control over the funds (can change beneficiaries between siblings if needed) - Better financial aid treatment compared to child-owned assets - Still get our state's tax deduction for contributions - Much simpler than trust ownership One thing I'd add that hasn't been mentioned - check if your state offers additional benefits for using your own state's 529 plan versus an out-of-state plan. Some states only give tax deductions if you use their specific plan, while others are more flexible. Also worth noting: you can always change the beneficiary later if circumstances change, which gives you flexibility as your daughter grows up and you see how her educational path unfolds.

0 coins