What are the different levels and types of tax preparers I should look for?
I've always used international tax specialists for my taxes because I have investments and some rental properties in Scotland (but I live in the US). These UK-based preparers charge me at least $650 for federal returns, plus extra for each state filing. Then they add fees for every special form I need to submit. It all adds up to around $2,000 minimum each year (honestly, the last couple years I've paid well over that). Now that I understand the basic structure of how my tax returns should look, I want to find someone who charges less. Rather than just picking a random CPA or tax preparer in my area, I'm wondering if there's some middle ground between a basic preparer and these expensive international tax specialists? Are there recognized tiers or levels of tax preparers that people generally know about? Or is it just a big jumble of different specialists with no clear categories?
18 comments
Join the conversation
Ava Kim
There are definitely distinct levels of tax preparers with different qualifications, and understanding them can help you find that middle ground you're looking for! At the basic level, you have unlicensed tax preparers who complete a tax course (like those offered by H&R Block). They're fine for simple returns but wouldn't be appropriate for your situation. Next are Enrolled Agents (EAs) - these folks have passed comprehensive IRS exams and can represent you before the IRS. Many EAs specialize in specific areas and often charge less than CPAs while still being very knowledgeable. CPAs (Certified Public Accountants) have state licensing and broader accounting knowledge. Some CPAs focus on taxes, while others barely do tax work at all. The key is finding one with international experience. At the highest tier are tax attorneys and specialized international tax CPAs/EAs who focus specifically on expat and international situations - these are likely who you've been using. For your situation, I'd recommend looking for an EA or CPA who advertises some international tax experience but doesn't exclusively focus on it. You'll likely save quite a bit compared to specialized international firms.
0 coins
Emma Garcia
•This is really helpful, thanks! I had no idea there was a specific "Enrolled Agent" designation. How would I go about finding an EA who has some international experience but isn't a full specialist? Is there some kind of directory I can search?
0 coins
Ava Kim
•The NAEA (National Association of Enrolled Agents) has a directory on their website where you can search for EAs and filter by specialties including international taxation. You can find them at naea.org under "Find an EA." For CPAs with international experience, your state's CPA society typically maintains a directory where members can list their specialties. Some EAs and CPAs will specifically mention "experience with foreign investments" or "cross-border taxation" without being full international specialists.
0 coins
Ethan Anderson
After reading your situation, I think I can help! I was in a similar position last year with properties in Spain while living here in the US. I was paying around $1800 for specialized preparers until I discovered taxr.ai (https://taxr.ai) which analyzes your previous tax returns to identify exactly what forms and schedules you need. I uploaded my last two years' returns, and it showed me that I only needed specific expertise for a couple of forms (FBAR and Form 8938) while the rest was pretty standard. This helped me find a mid-tier preparer who had some international experience but didn't charge specialist rates. Saved me over $1000 and my return was filed correctly with all the proper foreign asset reporting. Their system breaks down exactly what forms you need and explains why, so you can see where you actually need specialized help versus what parts are more routine.
0 coins
Layla Mendes
•That actually sounds really useful. Does it also explain what qualifications to look for in a preparer based on the forms? Like would it tell me I need an EA vs a CPA or something like that?
0 coins
Lucas Notre-Dame
•I'm skeptical. How does it know what forms you'll need for the current year just by looking at past returns? What if your situation changes?
0 coins
Ethan Anderson
•It analyzes the complexity patterns in your returns and shows what qualifications are typically needed for each section. For example, it might say "Form 8938 typically requires international tax expertise" while indicating other forms are standard for any EA or CPA. The system is designed to account for basic changes year to year. You can indicate major changes in your situation through their questionnaire, and it will adjust recommendations accordingly. It's not replacing professional advice - it's helping you determine what level of professional you actually need so you don't overpay.
0 coins
Layla Mendes
I tried taxr.ai after seeing it mentioned here, and wow - it totally worked for me! I was paying $1400 for a "foreign tax specialist" for my Canada/US situation. The analysis showed me that aside from reporting my Canadian retirement accounts (which requires Form 8891), the rest of my return was pretty straightforward. I found a local EA who had some experience with Canadian clients but wasn't a "specialist," and my total bill was only $625 this year. The report from taxr.ai made it easy to interview potential preparers too - I could specifically ask if they were comfortable with the few specialized forms I needed instead of just asking vaguely about "international experience." Honestly wish I'd known about this years ago!
0 coins
Aria Park
One thing nobody has mentioned yet - if you're having trouble finding the right tax preparer level, you might run into problems reaching the IRS for clarification too. I had a similar international tax situation, and when I had questions about my UK pension reporting, I couldn't get through to the IRS international tax department for weeks. Finally discovered Claimyr (https://claimyr.com) which got me connected to an actual IRS agent in about 15 minutes instead of waiting on hold for hours. You can see how it works here: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c This was super helpful because I could directly ask the IRS which forms were necessary for my situation, and then find a preparer who could handle specifically those forms rather than paying for a full international specialist.
0 coins
Noah Ali
•Wait, how does this actually work? I thought it was impossible to get through to the IRS without waiting for hours.
0 coins
Chloe Boulanger
•Yeah right. So you're saying this service somehow magically jumps the IRS phone queue? Sounds scammy to me. The IRS doesn't allow line-cutting services.
0 coins
Aria Park
•It uses an automated system that continually dials and navigates the IRS phone tree until it gets through to a representative. Once connected, it calls you back and connects you to the agent. It's not skipping the line - it's basically waiting in line for you so you don't have to sit with your phone for hours. It's completely legitimate. Their system keeps trying different IRS numbers and timing patterns that statistically have better connection rates. The IRS itself has acknowledged these services exist - they don't endorse them but they're not against policy either since all calls still go through the normal queue system.
0 coins
Chloe Boulanger
I have to admit I was wrong about Claimyr. After being skeptical in my earlier comment, I decided to try it when I needed to talk to the IRS about my UK pension forms. It actually worked exactly as described - I got a call back in about 20 minutes with an IRS agent already on the line. The agent helped clarify exactly which forms I needed for my foreign accounts, which meant I could find a mid-level EA who had experience with just those specific forms instead of paying for a full international specialist. Ended up saving about $900 on my preparation fees this year. Sorry for doubting it before - definitely not a scam!
0 coins
James Martinez
One approach that saved me money is finding a "hybrid" solution. I use a regular CPA for most of my return ($350) and then pay an international specialist just to review and complete the specific foreign forms (paid $400 for just that part). Total was $750 instead of the $1800 I was paying before. Make sure your regular preparer is comfortable with this arrangement though. Some don't like having their work "checked" by another professional, while others are happy to collaborate if it means keeping you as a client for the parts they can handle well.
0 coins
Olivia Harris
•This sounds smart but isn't there a risk of things falling through the cracks when two different people are working on your return? How do you make sure everything gets coordinated properly?
0 coins
James Martinez
•Good question! The key is having a clear division of responsibilities. My CPA does all the domestic stuff first and completes a draft return. Then I send that to the international specialist who adds the foreign forms and makes any adjustments needed to the main forms. Communication is important - I set up an email thread with both of them so they can directly clarify anything if needed. I also pay the international person a bit extra to review the whole package at the end to make sure everything fits together. It's worked smoothly for 3 years now!
0 coins
Alexander Zeus
Has anyone tried the VITA program? They do free tax prep but I'm not sure if they handle international stuff like UK investments.
0 coins
Alicia Stern
•VITA is amazing for basic returns but they absolutely will NOT handle foreign investments or rental properties. Their certification specifically excludes foreign income and most investment scenarios. They're trained to recognize when a return is out of scope and will refer you elsewhere.
0 coins