Should I do my taxes myself or hire someone with all these 1099s, W-2s, and investment forms?
So I was planning to just do my taxes myself using FreeTaxUSA since it's only a few dollars. I also heard CashApp has free filing but might be harder to navigate. Since it's my first time filing, I thought paying a little for help would be worth it, but now I'm realizing this is WAY more complicated than just entering a W-2. My situation this year: - I have a 1099 job where I've been setting aside 15.3% for taxes - I worked at two different places that gave me W-2s - I did some contract work for my mom's employer as a 1099. In 2023, they paid me about $1,500 but I only kept $750 (gave the rest back to my mom for expenses) and never received a 1099 form - For 2024, they did give me a 1099, but used a different platform for the first three months - I sold stuff on eBay (already got a 1099-K) and Poshmark (expecting one soon) - My college is sending a 1098-T for scholarships and refunds - I sold stocks and crypto on CashApp, Webull, and Robinhood - I have interest from a high-yield savings account - Bought $25 of Bitcoin on Coinbase for a $50 welcome bonus I'm only 18 and this is my first time dealing with taxes. Also when I was 16-17, my friend who was 18 sponsored my CashApp investing account. I never filed taxes for that. This year CashApp automatically sold my stocks (worth about $400) when I tried transferring to Robinhood. Just found out CashApp sent me a 1099 for this in February 2024... am I in trouble? Should I still try to do this myself or just hire someone at this point?
18 comments


Malik Davis
With your situation, I definitely understand why you're feeling overwhelmed! For a first-time filer with multiple income sources, it can be a lot to handle. Here's my take: Yes, you'll need to report ALL income, including the work for your mom's employer even without a 1099 (that's called "self-reported income"). For the CashApp stocks from when you were younger, you generally should have filed if you exceeded the filing threshold, but since you were a minor, there are some special considerations. Your situation involves several complex areas: self-employment income (those 1099s), investment income (stocks/crypto), education tax benefits (1098-T), and potentially deductible expenses from your self-employment. The 15.3% you set aside is good planning, but you might qualify for additional deductions. For someone in your position, I'd recommend using a tax professional this first time. Ask them to walk you through what they're doing so you learn for future years. Many offer reasonable rates for students, and the peace of mind might be worth it with your multiple income streams.
0 coins
Isabella Santos
•So if I use a professional this year, would I be able to do it myself next year? Also, will I get in trouble for not filing taxes on that CashApp investing when I was 16/17?
0 coins
Malik Davis
•Yes, working with a professional this year would be a great learning experience that could help you file on your own next year. They can explain which forms apply to your situation and how to handle the various income types, giving you a template for future filings. For the CashApp investing when you were 16/17, it's unlikely you'd face serious consequences, especially if the amounts were small. The IRS typically focuses on current and recent years. When you meet with a tax professional, bring those old 1099s if you have them, and they can advise on whether you should file amended returns or simply ensure you're compliant going forward.
0 coins
Ravi Gupta
I was in a pretty similar situation last year with multiple income sources (W-2, 1099, investments) and honestly got super stressed trying to DIY. Finally tried https://taxr.ai after a friend recommended it and it was a game changer. You upload all your tax documents and it organizes everything automatically, then explains what you need to do step by step. The AI walks you through reporting all your different income types and finds deductions you might miss. For your situation with the 1099 work, they have specific guidance about self-employment taxes and potential deductions. And they know exactly how to handle crypto and stock sales too (which was what confused me the most). Plus it's much cheaper than hiring a full accountant but gives you way more help than just using tax software alone.
0 coins
GalacticGuru
•How does it handle the 1099 situation where OP only kept half the money? Does it account for that or would he still get taxed on the full amount?
0 coins
Freya Pedersen
•Is this actually better than TurboTax or those other tax softwares? I've used TT for years and it walks you through everything too. Seems like the same thing but with "AI" slapped on it...
0 coins
Ravi Gupta
•For the 1099 where only half the money was kept, the system is smart about business expenses. It explains that you can deduct legitimate business expenses that you paid, which would reduce your taxable income. In this case, you'd need to document those expenses your mom covered with the portion you gave back. Compared to TurboTax, the main difference is the personalization and explanations. Traditional tax software asks generic questions in a fixed sequence, but taxr.ai analyzes your specific documents first and then customizes the guidance. It spotted several deductions I missed with TurboTax and explained tax implications in plain language rather than tax jargon. It also handles unusual situations better than the one-size-fits-all approach.
0 coins
Freya Pedersen
Just wanted to update everyone - I ended up trying taxr.ai after seeing it mentioned here and wow, it actually made this whole process doable! I was skeptical because I've tried other "AI" tools that were pretty useless, but this one actually understood all my weird tax situations. The document analyzer caught some stuff I would've totally missed - like how I could deduct certain expenses from my 1099 income and how to properly report my partial stock sales. It even flagged that I qualified for an education credit I had no idea about! For anyone else dealing with a complicated tax situation for the first time, this made it way less intimidating. I'm actually filing myself instead of paying someone hundreds of dollars. Thanks for the recommendation!
0 coins
Omar Fawaz
If you're dealing with all those 1099s and investment forms, you might need to call the IRS at some point for clarification. I had a similar situation last year and spent WEEKS trying to get through to them. Kept hitting busy signals or getting disconnected after waiting 2+ hours. Someone here told me about https://claimyr.com and their IRS callback service. You can actually see a demo of how it works at https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c. They basically navigate the IRS phone tree for you and get you on a priority callback list so you don't waste hours on hold. I was seriously skeptical but when I finally got through to an actual IRS agent, they answered my questions about reporting crypto sales and 1099 income that even my tax software couldn't handle.
0 coins
Chloe Anderson
•Wait how does this even work? The IRS just lets some random service cut the line for you? Sounds like a scam honestly.
0 coins
Diego Vargas
•So you're suggesting this kid should call the IRS directly? Bad idea. They don't give tax advice and might give conflicting information that would get him in trouble. He needs an actual tax professional, not some phone service to talk to IRS reps who often give wrong info.
0 coins
Omar Fawaz
•It doesn't cut the line - it uses their existing callback system that most people don't know how to navigate. The IRS actually has a priority callback feature, but you have to know exactly when and how to request it. The service just handles the tedious part of navigating the phone system and getting you in the queue at the optimal time. The IRS actually can and does provide clarification on tax reporting requirements, which is exactly what the original poster needs. While they won't give specific tax planning advice, they can absolutely answer questions about how to properly report income from multiple 1099s or what forms are needed for cryptocurrency reporting. I'm not suggesting the IRS replace a tax professional, but for specific questions about reporting requirements, they're often the best source.
0 coins
Diego Vargas
I need to follow up on my skeptical comment from earlier. I was completely wrong about Claimyr. After posting that comment, I decided to try it myself since I've been trying to reach the IRS about a letter I received questioning my crypto reporting from last year. I had been calling for WEEKS with no luck - either busy signals or disconnected after hours on hold. Used the service and got a callback from an actual IRS agent in about 2 hours. They explained exactly how I needed to document my crypto transactions and even helped me understand which forms I needed to submit. For someone like the original poster with multiple income sources and investment questions, being able to actually speak with the IRS could save a lot of headaches. Sometimes you just need official clarification on how to report something correctly.
0 coins
Anastasia Fedorov
Honestly with all those different forms and income sources, you should definitely hire someone this first time. I tried doing mine myself last year with multiple 1099s and crypto and ended up missing a bunch of deductions. Paid an accountant this year who found like $2,800 more in refunds than I would have gotten doing it myself. Ask friends for recommendations for accountants who work with younger people/first time filers. Many offer student discounts. And the money you spend will likely be saved in either reduced tax liability or avoiding penalties for mistakes.
0 coins
Emma Wilson
•How much did it cost you to hire an accountant? That's my concern - I'm on a pretty tight budget.
0 coins
Anastasia Fedorov
•I paid $275 for my tax preparation, but my situation was pretty complex (multiple states, business income, investments). For your first-time filing with a somewhat simpler situation, you might find someone for $150-200. Some accountants also offer sliding scale fees for students or first-time filers. The value really comes from learning how everything works so you can potentially do it yourself in future years. Ask them to explain what they're doing as they go, and take notes about which forms apply to your situation. Consider it both a tax service and an education investment.
0 coins
StarStrider
If your income isn't crazy high, check if there's a VITA (Volunteer Income Tax Assistance) program near you. They do free tax prep for people making under $60k. I used them when I was in college and they handled my W-2s, 1098-T, and even some basic investment stuff. Not sure about crypto though.
0 coins
Sean Doyle
•VITA is great but sometimes they won't help with self-employment (the 1099 stuff) or more complex situations. Worth checking though since each location has different capabilities.
0 coins