< Back to IRS

Sean Doyle

Need affordable way to get a letter to prove accredited investor status - CPA or appraiser?

I'm looking into joining a private investment opportunity but they're asking me to provide proof of accredited investor status first. I'm not really familiar with the process and don't want to spend a fortune just to get some paperwork. From what I understand, I can qualify either through my income (which is decent but not crazy high) or through my real estate holdings. I own a couple of properties that should put me over the threshold if valued correctly. Two main questions I'm trying to figure out: 1. Can any CPA licensed in any U.S. State produce the accredited investor verification letter? Or do I need someone with special qualifications? 2. If I'm using my real estate holdings to qualify, will they require a formal appraisal from a licensed real estate appraiser? Those can cost $500+ each which seems excessive. Has anyone gone through this process recently? What was the most cost-effective way you found to get this done? Any recommendations for services that don't charge an arm and a leg would be super appreciated.

Zara Rashid

•

The requirements for accredited investor verification have become more standardized since the SEC updated their rules. To answer your specific questions: Any licensed CPA can technically produce the verification letter, but they need to review your financial documentation thoroughly. The CPA doesn't need special "accreditation verification" qualifications, but they should be familiar with SEC regulations regarding accredited investors. For real estate holdings, it depends on how recent your property valuations are. If you have property tax assessments or recent purchase documentation (within the last 3 months), some CPAs may accept those. However, most will recommend getting formal appraisals since they need to certify your net worth meets the $1 million threshold (excluding your primary residence). A cost-effective approach would be to first determine which qualification method is easiest for you. If your income exceeds $200,000 individually (or $300,000 with spouse) for the past two years, income verification through tax returns is usually simpler and cheaper than the net worth route.

0 coins

Luca Romano

•

Thanks for the detailed info. I'm close on the income threshold but not quite there consistently. For the real estate, I have a rental property I bought 4 years ago that's appreciated a lot, plus some other investments. Do you know if online valuation tools like Zillow estimates would be sufficient? Or would I definitely need formal appraisals?

0 coins

Zara Rashid

•

For income verification, the CPA will want to see your tax returns for the past two years, so that's usually straightforward if you meet the threshold. For real estate, unfortunately, Zillow estimates (Zestimates) typically don't qualify as sufficient documentation for accredited investor verification. They're considered too speculative by most professionals. You'll generally need either recent purchase documents, formal appraisals, or in some cases, a detailed comparative market analysis from a licensed real estate professional. Some CPAs might accept a broker price opinion (BPO) which costs less than a full appraisal ($150-$300 vs. $500+), but this varies by the CPA's comfort level and the investment platform's requirements.

0 coins

Nia Jackson

•

After struggling with this exact situation last year, I stumbled across https://taxr.ai when researching options. It was honestly a game-changer for me. I uploaded my financial documents (tax returns, property info, investment statements) and they analyzed everything to determine my best qualification path. Their system identified that I could qualify through my income + investments without needing expensive real estate appraisals. They connected me with a CPA who specialized in accredited investor verification and handled the whole process. I had my letter within 3 days and the investment platform accepted it without questions. Really simplified what I thought would be a complicated process.

0 coins

How does this actually work? Do they just match you with a CPA or do they do something more? I'm confused about what service they're actually providing since a CPA still has to sign off on everything, right?

0 coins

CosmicCruiser

•

Sounds interesting but I'm skeptical. How can they determine if you qualify without appraisals if you're using real estate to qualify? Did you still have to get appraisals done separately or did they have some workaround?

0 coins

Nia Jackson

•

They analyze your financial situation holistically and identify the best/cheapest qualification method based on your specific circumstances. They don't just match you with any CPA - they have CPAs who specialize in accredited investor verification. The main value was in their analysis that showed I could qualify through my income plus liquid investments instead of needing real estate appraisals. They spotted that my investment accounts plus income met the requirements, which I hadn't realized. The CPA they connected me with knew exactly what documentation was needed for my situation, saving me from unnecessary expenses.

0 coins

CosmicCruiser

•

I wanted to follow up about my experience with taxr.ai since I was initially skeptical. I decided to try it after struggling to find a reasonably priced solution. Their system actually discovered I could qualify through my retirement accounts and income rather than my real estate holdings! I had no idea my SEP IRA counted toward the threshold. Their analysis saved me from getting two property appraisals that would have cost around $1,200. The CPA they connected me with was super knowledgeable about SEC requirements and produced a verification letter that was accepted by the investment platform without any questions. The whole process took less than a week and was much more affordable than I expected. Definitely changed my mind about digital services like this!

0 coins

Aisha Khan

•

If you're struggling to reach someone at the SEC or getting conflicting information about accredited investor requirements, I found https://claimyr.com incredibly helpful. I had questions about whether my particular situation qualified and couldn't get through to anyone official for clarification. After wasting hours on hold, I used Claimyr and they got me connected to an actual SEC representative within 20 minutes. You can see how it works in this demo: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c The SEC rep was able to clearly explain the verification requirements and confirmed that I didn't need multiple appraisals for all my properties - just documentation of sufficient assets to meet the threshold. Saved me hundreds in unnecessary paperwork and gave me confidence my verification would be accepted.

0 coins

Ethan Taylor

•

Wait, I've never heard of this. How does it actually work? Does it just keep redialing the SEC for you or something? I'm confused why I would pay for this when I could just call myself.

0 coins

CosmicCruiser

•

This sounds like BS honestly. The SEC doesn't provide individual guidance on whether someone qualifies as an accredited investor. That's what financial advisors and CPAs are for. Pretty sure you just spoke with a general helpline that gave you publicly available information.

0 coins

Aisha Khan

•

It uses an algorithm that navigates phone trees and waits on hold for you. When a human representative answers, you get a call connecting you directly to them. It saved me about 2 hours of hold time with the SEC. The service doesn't just redial - it stays connected and navigates the entire phone system until it reaches a human. I've tried calling the SEC myself multiple times and never got through after 30+ minutes of waiting. With Claimyr, I was speaking with someone in under 20 minutes without having to do anything.

0 coins

CosmicCruiser

•

I need to publicly eat my words about Claimyr. After being super skeptical, I decided to try it when I needed clarification on a different financial regulatory question (not directly about accredited investor status but related to private placements). Was shocked when I got a call back connecting me to a real person at FINRA after only 15 minutes. The representative answered my question about what documentation they consider acceptable for verification purposes and confirmed that broker price opinions can be used in certain circumstances instead of full appraisals. This saved me about $350 per property. The service actually works exactly as advertised - they wait on hold and navigate the phone systems for you, then call you when they reach a human. Definitely using this for any future government agency calls.

0 coins

Yuki Ito

•

Another approach that worked for me was using my broker. If you have an account with a major brokerage firm (Schwab, Fidelity, etc.), they often have a verification service for existing clients. I qualified through my investment accounts, and my Schwab advisor provided the verification letter without charging me anything extra. Worth asking if you already have an established relationship with a financial institution.

0 coins

Sean Doyle

•

That's really helpful! I do have accounts with Fidelity but didn't think to ask them. Do you know if they only verify based on assets held with them, or can they look at your complete financial picture including real estate?

0 coins

Yuki Ito

•

From my experience, they primarily verify based on assets held with them. Fidelity reviewed my account holdings with them to determine if I met the threshold. For a complete financial picture including real estate, they typically require additional documentation that you would need to provide. In my case, I had enough in my investment accounts to qualify without needing to include real estate. If you need to include external assets, you might still need appraisals or other documentation, but the broker can incorporate those into their verification process.

0 coins

Carmen Lopez

•

Watch out for the new SEC rules that came into effect! I just went through this process and discovered that some of the methods that used to work for verification are no longer accepted by certain platforms. The rules around "reasonable steps" for verification have been interpreted differently by different investment platforms.

0 coins

Andre Dupont

•

What specific changes should we be aware of? I'm planning to invest in a private fund next month and don't want to go through the verification process only to find out it's not accepted.

0 coins

I went through this exact process about 6 months ago and ended up using the income route since it was much simpler than dealing with property appraisals. Here's what I learned: For CPAs, make sure they're familiar with the SEC's Rule 506(c) verification requirements. Not all CPAs are comfortable with this type of verification, so ask upfront about their experience with accredited investor letters. If you're close on income but not quite there, consider timing - if you're expecting a bonus or have irregular income, the CPA can sometimes work with projected income if it's well-documented (like a signed employment contract showing guaranteed compensation). One thing nobody mentioned is that some investment platforms have preferred verification providers they work with regularly. It's worth asking the investment opportunity if they have recommendations - sometimes they have relationships that can streamline the process and reduce costs. Also, keep your verification letter - many are valid for 6 months, so if you're looking at multiple investment opportunities, you won't need to repeat the process each time.

0 coins

Mateo Lopez

•

This is incredibly helpful, thank you! The point about timing for income verification is something I hadn't considered. I'm actually expecting a decent bonus in Q2 that would put me over the threshold. Do you know what kind of documentation CPAs typically accept for projected income? Would an employment contract or bonus letter from HR be sufficient, or do they need something more official? Also, great tip about asking the investment platform for preferred providers. I'm looking at a real estate syndication and they probably deal with this all the time. Might save me from having to shop around for CPAs who are unfamiliar with the process.

0 coins

NeonNova

•

I recently went through this process and found a few cost-effective strategies that might help. First, check if your employer has any partnerships with financial services - some larger companies have relationships with CPAs or financial advisors who can provide verification at discounted rates for employees. For real estate, I discovered that if you have a HELOC (home equity line of credit) that was recently approved, the bank's valuation from that process is often acceptable to CPAs for verification purposes. This saved me from paying for new appraisals since I had refinanced within the past year. Another tip: if you're borderline on qualification, consider the timing of your verification. Some CPAs will look at your most recent tax filing plus current year-to-date income if it shows a clear pattern of meeting the threshold. This can be especially helpful if you had a strong Q4 or recently got a raise. Also, don't overlook investment accounts you might forget about - old 401(k)s from previous employers, IRAs, taxable brokerage accounts, etc. Sometimes these add up to more than you realize and can push you over the net worth threshold without needing real estate appraisals at all. The whole process cost me under $300 using a CPA who specialized in this type of verification, and I was able to use the same letter for three different investment opportunities over the next few months.

0 coins

Sean Flanagan

•

This is excellent advice! The HELOC valuation tip is brilliant - I never would have thought of that. I actually did a cash-out refinance last year so I should have recent bank valuations that might work. The point about forgotten investment accounts is spot on too. I just remembered I have an old Roth IRA from a previous job that I rolled over years ago but forgot about when calculating my net worth. Between that and some other scattered accounts, I might already be closer to the threshold than I realized. Really appreciate the practical cost breakdown too - under $300 total sounds very reasonable compared to what I was expecting to pay. Did you find the CPA through a referral or just search online for someone with experience in accredited investor verification?

0 coins

IRS AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
20,087 users helped today