Back to IRS

Honorah King

FreeTaxUSA coupon code 2020 — filed free but now dealing with an IRS mess years later

Filed my 2019 taxes through FreeTaxUSA back in 2020 using one of those coupon codes that were floating around. At the time I thought I was done and dusted. Fast forward to now and I'm getting notices from the IRS about that same return — apparently there's a discrepancy between what I reported and what my employer sent them. So here I am digging through returns I thought were ancient history. Has anyone dealt with the IRS coming back years later on something you filed through a tax software? I'm not even sure what records I need to pull or what transcript to request to see what they actually have on file for that year.

My installment agreement from a few years back is what got me here. The monthly amount the IRS had on file didn't match what I'd agreed to, and after a few weeks of busy signals and dropped calls on 800-829-1040, I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) — it waits on hold for you so you end up talking to a live IRS agent. Video on reaching a live person at the IRS: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c. The representative pulled up my payment plan and told me the monthly amount and next due date as it sat on the account. That matched my original agreement, so the confusion was on my end — I'd been looking at an old notice. For the person above, your situation sounds different, but getting someone on the phone is probably the fastest way to find out what year the discrepancy is tied to.

0 coins

My payment plan had a similar mismatch and I couldn't figure out if I was looking at the right tax year in the IRS Online Account. Ended up sorting it out there once I checked each year separately.

0 coins

Your point about the account showing the wrong year is actually what I'm worried about — I don't know if the notice is referencing 2019 or if something got crossed with a later year.

0 coins

The IRS Online Account at https://www.irs.gov/your-account breaks things out by tax year, so you can at least confirm which year the balance or discrepancy is tied to before you call.

0 coins

Wage and income transcript is what you want here. It shows what your employer actually reported to the IRS — the W-2 or 1099 data they submitted — and you can compare it against what you put on the return. If there's a gap, that's usually where the notice is coming from.

0 coins

So the wage and income transcript is different from the tax return transcript? I assumed they were the same thing.

0 coins

They're totally different. Your tax return transcript shows the lines from your return as you filed it. The wage and income transcript shows what your employer, bank or whoever sent to the IRS separately. If those two don't match, that's what triggers a notice.

0 coins

Tripped over that exact distinction myself last year. Requested the wrong one first and had to go back and pull the other.

0 coins

The IRS's Get Transcript tool in the online account lets you pull both kinds right away. You sign in with ID.me or Login.gov and both are available to view or download immediately. No waiting for mail, which matters if your notice has a response deadline.

0 coins

My notice does have a date on it, so speed matters. I'll try the online account first.

0 coins

Agree on the online account being faster. Mailing takes 5 to 10 calendar days and you don't always have that kind of room.

0 coins

Worth noting that the online transcripts also go back further — the wage and income transcript goes back nine prior years in the online account, so a 2019 year should still be there.

0 coins

My 2018 return came back to bite me in a similar way, also software-filed. The IRS sent a CP2000 — that's the notice they send when income they received from an employer or bank doesn't match what you reported. It's not an audit, it's more like a proposed change, and you can agree or disagree. If you disagree, you respond by the date on the notice with documentation showing what you actually had.

0 coins

Mine looks like it might be a CP2000 actually. I didn't realize I could push back on it — I assumed whatever they said was final.

0 coins

You have the right to respond to a CP2000. The notice itself explains what they think is different and what you owe if you agree. If your records support your original filing, send them in by the deadline.

0 coins

Went through a CP2000 two years ago. Responded with my W-2 and a letter explaining the discrepancy and the IRS adjusted it back to close to what I'd filed. It took a few months but it got resolved.

0 coins

Last year my W-2 from a part-time job looked off on my transcript — the withholding amount didn't match the paper copy I had. Ended up using Claimyr to get a live IRS agent on the line, and the representative read me the wages and withholding the employer had reported for that year. The figures on the IRS's end matched my paper W-2 exactly, so the error was actually in how I'd entered a number when filing. That told me I needed to look at my own return more carefully before responding to the notice.

0 coins

That's exactly the kind of thing I'm worried about — not knowing whose numbers are off, mine or the employer's. Good to know an agent can actually read you those figures from the account.

0 coins

My employer switched payroll systems mid-year and the numbers that ended up on the W-2 were slightly different from my pay stubs. Getting the wage and income transcript from the IRS showed me what they actually received from the employer.

0 coins

The transcript comparison is the right starting point — you're basically triangulating between what you filed, what your employer reported, and what the IRS thinks you owe.

0 coins

freeTaxUSA itself doesn't keep old returns forever and the coupon situation from 2020 is irrelevant to what the IRS has on file now. What matters is the return you submitted and what the IRS received from third parties like your employer. If you saved a copy of the return, start there.

0 coins

I do have a PDF of the 2019 return, thankfully. That's going to be my starting comparison.

0 coins

Always save a copy of your filed return, people. This is exactly why. The IRS's tax return transcript is a good backup if the original PDF is gone, though.

0 coins

My 2020 notice situation dragged for months because I kept waiting and not responding. The IRS does not stop the clock if you ignore it — the balance grows with interest and a late payment penalty starts adding on top. Whatever the notice says, responding by the date they give you is the most important thing right now.

0 coins

How much time do they typically give to respond? Mine looks like it's maybe six weeks out.

0 coins

The notice itself says the response date — it varies. Six weeks is enough time to pull your transcripts, compare the numbers and get a response in. Don't wait until the last week.

0 coins

Agreed on responding promptly. And even if you can't pay whatever they say you owe, responding and showing you disagree or setting up a plan is better than silence.

0 coins

Something that tripped me up: I thought filing through tax software meant the IRS had everything the software had. It doesn't work that way. The software sends your return; your employer separately sends a W-2 to the IRS. If those two data points don't line up, the IRS reconciles them and sends you a notice. The software has nothing to do with what your employer reported.

0 coins

That makes sense now. I think I assumed the software was pulling from some live data source, but you're right that it's just what I typed in.

0 coins

The IRS's wage and income transcript is the only way to see what employers, banks and brokerages actually reported. The tax software only knows what you tell it.

0 coins

Quick question for anyone who's been through this — if the discrepancy is small, is it worth fighting or do most people just pay it to make it go away?

0 coins

Even a small amount is worth checking. Sometimes the discrepancy is an error on the employer's side, in which case you shouldn't have to pay anything. Pull the wage and income transcript first before deciding.

0 coins

Agreed. I've seen cases where the employer submitted a corrected W-2 late and the IRS had an old version. If that's the case, your response with the corrected W-2 usually resolves it.

0 coins

Didn't realize the employer could have filed a corrected version. I'll check that angle too.

0 coins

Around eighteen months after filing my 2024 return, Where's My Refund stopped updating and the IRS Online Account showed my return as still being processed. Tried 800-829-1040 several times across a few weeks and kept getting cut off before anyone answered. Eventually tried Claimyr and ended up on the phone with an IRS agent who pulled up the return's status directly on my account — the representative said the return was received and in processing, with no notice issued yet. No dollar figure, no timeline, just that it was in and moving. At least I knew it wasn't lost.

0 coins

The 'in processing' answer is frustrating but I get why you'd want confirmation it hadn't disappeared. That's kind of my fear too — that something got lost between the filing and their system.

0 coins

The agent couldn't say how long, which I expected. But confirming the return was actually on record was worth the call.

0 coins

Where's My Refund not updating is so common and so stressful. Good that you at least confirmed it was in the system.

0 coins

I had the same experience where the tool just froze on 'still being processed' for weeks. Calling was the only way to get any real confirmation.

0 coins

Tax account transcript is what you want alongside the wage and income one. It shows changes made after filing — if the IRS has already posted an adjustment related to your discrepancy, it shows up there. The return transcript only has what you originally filed, not what happened after.

0 coins

So I need both — the return transcript to see what I filed, and the account transcript to see if they already made a move on my account?

0 coins

That's the right read. And the wage and income transcript to see what your employer sent them. Three separate things, all free, all in the online account.

0 coins

The record of account transcript actually combines the return and account transcripts if you want both in one document. Covers current year and three prior years.

0 coins

My employer from 2019 went out of business since then, which made my situation worse — I couldn't just call HR. The IRS wage and income transcript was the only way I had to see what they'd actually reported, since I couldn't get it straight from the source.

0 coins

That's a nightmare scenario. At least the IRS keeps that data going back years.

0 coins

Exactly — wage and income transcripts go back further than the return transcripts in some cases. Nine prior years online means 2019 is still there if you're checking now.

0 coins

Even better, if the employer is gone, the IRS is probably the only place with an accurate record of what was reported for that year.

0 coins

My CP2000 response had to include a written explanation, a copy of the relevant W-2 and a copy of the original return page where that income appeared. Sending just one or two of those wasn't enough — the IRS wanted the full picture together.

0 coins

Good to know they want it all together. I'll make sure to put together a complete package, not just the W-2.

0 coins

The notice usually lists what they want included in the response. Read that section carefully before you mail anything.

0 coins

Certified mail with a tracking number for any response you send. You want proof of the date it was mailed and that it arrived.

0 coins

My 2019 return had two W-2s from two different employers and the software combined the withholding correctly, but one of my employers had entered my SSN wrong when they filed their version with the IRS. That meant one of the W-2s on my IRS wage and income transcript showed zero withholding instead of what was actually on my paper form. The employer had to file a corrected W-2 to fix it.

0 coins

An employer typo causing all this — that is exactly the kind of thing I wouldn't have thought to check. How did you even find out it was their error and not yours?

0 coins

Comparing my paper W-2 against the wage and income transcript line by line. The numbers on the IRS side were off by an amount that matched exactly what one employer was supposed to have withheld. That's when I realized the mistake wasn't mine.

0 coins

This is why the transcript comparison matters so much. Without pulling it, you'd assume the IRS is right and just pay.

0 coins

My first instinct when I got a similar notice was to call the number on the notice rather than the main IRS line. That turned out to be the right move — the number on the notice goes to the team actually handling that specific type of case, and the representative knew exactly what notice I was talking about.

0 coins

I hadn't thought about using the number on the notice itself. I've been trying the main 800 number and getting nowhere.

0 coins

The notice number routes you better. The main line eventually works too but the specific number is faster for whatever that notice is about.

0 coins

Seconding that. The number at the top right of your notice is the one to use for questions about that specific notice. The main line is for general questions.

0 coins

My situation from a couple of years back taught me that an extension to file doesn't extend the time to pay. I'd assumed they were the same thing. Filed on extension and owed money — the interest and penalty had been running from April even though my return came in later. If your 2019 discrepancy results in something owed, the amount might include interest going back further than you'd expect.

0 coins

That is a really important distinction I would have gotten wrong too. So if they find I owe from 2019, the interest has potentially been building since 2020?

0 coins

Potentially, yes. The notice will show what they're calculating and from when. That's one reason to respond quickly rather than waiting — interest keeps adding until it's paid.

0 coins

And this is why the CP2000 amount often looks bigger than expected. It includes the proposed tax plus interest calculated through the date of the notice.

0 coins

Taxpayer Advocate Service is worth knowing about if this drags on. They're free, independent within the IRS, and can help if the IRS hasn't resolved something within the normal time frame or if you're facing real financial hardship because of a tax problem. The site is https://www.taxpayeradvocate.irs.gov/ and you apply with Form 911.

0 coins

How long does something usually need to be dragging before TAS will step in?

0 coins

Their guidance is more than 30 days past normal processing time, or if a response deadline was missed without resolution. Financial hardship is the other path in. They don't take every case but it's free to ask.

0 coins

Didn't know TAS existed. Good to have in the back pocket if the CP2000 response doesn't go smoothly.

0 coins

My records from 2019 and 2020 were a mess because I changed jobs twice and had three W-2s that year. The IRS wage and income transcript was the only place everything was pulled together in one document. I could see all three W-2s plus a 1099-INT from my bank that I'd completely forgotten about — that forgotten interest income was exactly what triggered the notice I got years later.

0 coins

A forgotten 1099 is probably more common than people realize. I had a small savings account that year that I may not have included. That could actually be what this is.

0 coins

The IRS gets copies of every 1099 your bank, brokerage or any payer files. If it's in your name and SSN, it's on the transcript. If it's not on your return, that's the gap they flag.

0 coins

Even small interest amounts get reported and cross-matched. It doesn't take a big number to trigger a CP2000 — just a number that wasn't on the return.

0 coins

Filing through any free software from 2020 is long in the past — the software handled the math but the IRS has been sitting on its own data this whole time. The coupon or software you used doesn't factor into how the IRS handles the discrepancy at all. What matters now is what your return said versus what their records show.

0 coins

Yeah I realize now the FreeTaxUSA part is kind of a red herring for the current problem. The issue is just between my return and IRS records.

0 coins

Exactly. And honestly it's the same issue whether you used that software, any other software or a preparer. The IRS reconciles returns against third-party data regardless of who filed.

0 coins

My amended return for a prior year took about 11 weeks to process. If you end up needing to file a 1040-X to correct something on that 2019 return, build in that kind of wait. Status shows up online about 3 weeks after you submit it and you can check with just your SSN, date of birth and ZIP code — no sign-in required.

0 coins

If the CP2000 turns out to show I owe because of my own error, is a 1040-X the right move or do I just respond to the notice?

0 coins

Responding to the notice directly is typically the path — the CP2000 itself walks you through agreeing or disagreeing. A 1040-X is for when you're the one initiating a correction outside of a notice. Worth clarifying with the IRS or a tax professional which applies in your case.

0 coins

The IRS wants a response to the CP2000, not necessarily a separate amended return. Reading the notice carefully tells you exactly what they're asking for.

0 coins

Pulled my own wage and income transcript last spring for a question about a prior year and was surprised how complete it was — W-2s, 1099-NEC from some side work, 1099-INT, 1099-DIV, even a 1098 from my mortgage. Everything any payer had sent the IRS for that year was in one place. If you haven't looked at yours for 2019, that's your first real look at what the IRS actually has.

0 coins

Going to pull this tonight. I've been dreading it but reading all of this I realize it's the only way to actually understand what they're seeing.

0 coins

Let us know what you find — especially whether the gap is on your side or the employer's side. It changes the response completely.

0 coins

If the numbers on the transcript match your paper documents, that's actually a good sign. The issue might be simpler than the notice makes it sound.

0 coins

IRS AI

Expert Assistant
Secure