Back to IRS

Asher Levin

Form 5472 late filing penalty abatement — did anyone actually get it removed?

Filed my company's Form 5472 about six weeks late this year. It's a foreign-owned single-member LLC and I completely missed that the 5472 had to go in with the 1120 by the same deadline. The penalty notice came and the number on it was not small. I've been reading that the IRS does grant penalty abatement for reasonable cause, but I have no idea how to actually request it or whether my situation even qualifies. Has anyone gone through the form 5472 late filing penalty abatement process and had any luck getting it reduced or removed? Do I write a letter? Call? File something specific? I'm not sure where to start.

Around March of this year my payment plan's monthly amount suddenly didn't match what the IRS Online Account was showing, and I had to get someone on the phone to sort out the due date and the correct figure. Claimyr (claimyr.com) waits on hold with 800-829-1040 for you so you end up talking to a live IRS agent — Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at the IRS: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c. The agent pulled up my installment agreement and confirmed both the monthly amount and the next due date, which had shifted when I changed bank accounts. What you're dealing with is different but the same line is where you'd start a penalty abatement request by phone if you'd rather not write a letter — the agent can note the account and tell you whether a written request is also needed.

0 coins

The payment plan angle is useful context — I hadn't thought about whether a phone call to 800-829-1040 could get the abatement ball rolling without a formal letter first. I'll keep that number ready.

0 coins

My agent said the same thing about noting the account when I had a penalty question last spring. Sometimes they flag it right there and sometimes they still want a letter — depends on the rep.

0 coins

Useful to know the number works for more than just refund questions. I always assumed 800-829-1040 was only for individual returns.

0 coins

Your situation with the late 5472 — the penalty for that form is set by statute, not by a standard late-filing calculation, so it hits hard even for a short delay. The reasonable-cause argument is your main tool. What most practitioners recommend is a written request addressed to the IRS service center that issued the notice, sent to the address printed on the notice itself. In that letter you'd explain the specific reason you missed the deadline (new to the filing requirement, no prior history of non-compliance, whatever actually happened), show that you acted quickly once you discovered the problem, and ask for abatement under the reasonable-cause standard. Attach the notice and any supporting documents. No special form is required for this — it's a written statement.

0 coins

So it goes to the address on the notice, not some central abatement address? And I just write a letter — no Form 843 needed for this type of penalty?

0 coins

Form 843 is what gets used when you're requesting abatement of certain assessed penalties and you want to do it formally by form rather than by letter. Either can work, but a letter addressed to the notice is quicker to route and tends to be what people use for a first attempt. The form is on the IRS's site if you want to go that route.

0 coins

I went the letter route for a different penalty last year and it did get routed correctly — just make sure you include the notice number and the tax year right at the top so it doesn't get misfiled.

0 coins

The first-time abatement path is worth checking too. If your company has a clean compliance history — no penalties in the three prior years, all returns filed on time — the IRS has an administrative waiver that doesn't require you to prove reasonable cause at all. You'd just request it by calling the number on your notice or by letter, and state that you're asking for first-time abatement. The tricky part with 5472 penalties is that IRS guidance on whether first-time abatement applies to that specific penalty has been inconsistent, so reasonable cause in writing is often the safer argument to make even if you technically qualify.

0 coins

The inconsistency point is what worries me. I've seen conflicting things online about whether first-time abatement even applies to 5472 penalties specifically, or whether it's only for income tax underpayment or failure-to-file on the main return.

0 coins

Exactly the gray area. Some practitioners send both arguments in the same letter — 'first, we request first-time abatement; alternatively, we have reasonable cause for the following reasons.' Belt and suspenders approach.

0 coins

My tax preparer suggested the same dual-argument letter when I had a penalty dispute. It doesn't hurt to raise both and let the IRS decide which one fits.

0 coins

Six weeks late is actually not the worst position to be in for a reasonable-cause argument. The IRS looks at whether you exercised ordinary care and prudence, and a first-time mistake on a form that many single-member LLC owners don't even know they have to file can support that. The key is documenting what specifically caused the delay — a new filing requirement you weren't aware of, relying on a preparer who didn't flag it, a recordkeeping issue — and showing you filed as soon as you found out. Vague 'I didn't know' letters don't work as well as specific timelines.

0 coins

The timeline piece is something I can build out. I do have emails showing when I first learned the form was required and that I filed within a couple weeks of that discovery.

0 coins

Those emails are exactly what you'd attach. The IRS wants to see that the delay had a cause outside your control or was an honest mistake, and that you didn't just sit on it once you knew.

0 coins

The timeline documentation is what made the difference in my experience with a different late-filing situation. Specificity over generality every time.

0 coins

Didn't realize emails to yourself or your preparer could count as documentation for abatement. That's actually encouraging.

0 coins

BEEN THROUGH THIS. The 5472 penalty is brutal and the IRS does not make it easy to find the right person to talk to about it. I sent a letter in April and didn't hear anything for almost four months. Then I got a letter saying they needed more time to review. Still waiting. The notice address and the actual processing center are not always the same thing and it feels like these letters just disappear into a void. I'm not saying don't send the letter — do — but be ready for a very long wait on a response.

0 coins

Four months with no answer except 'we need more time' sounds exhausting. Did you follow up by phone after a certain point?

0 coins

I tried three times. Each time I got a different answer about where the letter was in processing. No resolution yet. I'm honestly considering TAS at this point.

0 coins

TAS is worth looking at if it's been more than 30 days past a response date they gave you, or if the delay is causing real financial hardship. Form 911 or 1-877-777-4778 to reach them.

0 coins

Wait — does the 5472 penalty abatement request go through the same process as a regular penalty abatement for a 1040? I assumed it would be totally different because the form itself is an information return attached to an 1120, not a standalone income tax return. Is the IRS even treating it the same way administratively?

0 coins

The reasonable-cause standard is the same standard — the IRS applies it across penalty types — but the 5472 penalty is a statutory penalty under a different code section than the standard failure-to-file penalty on an income return. The abatement request process (letter to the notice address, Form 843 as an alternative) is the same in practice. What differs is the IRS's track record on actually granting it for 5472 specifically, which has been uneven.

0 coins

That distinction between same process, different outcome track record is exactly what I was worried about. So you do it the same way, you just might have a harder time getting a yes.

0 coins

My preparer told me to also check the IRS Online Account after submitting the abatement request to see if anything shows up on the account transcript for that tax year. Sometimes a decision posts there before a letter arrives. Doesn't help you speed it up but at least you're not completely in the dark.

0 coins

Haven't checked the account transcript yet for this — I've been watching the balance owed figure but not pulling the transcript itself. Good idea to monitor it there.

0 coins

The account transcript for the year in question is where I saw the adjustment post. It showed up about two weeks before the letter reached me.

0 coins

Does the IRS Online Account show penalty detail broken out separately, or just a lump balance? I always see a total and nothing itemized.

0 coins

The account transcript breaks it out more than the main balance screen does — you can see individual assessments and credits by date. Worth downloading the transcript rather than just reading the balance on the main screen.

0 coins

Last year the wage and income transcript for my business showed numbers that didn't match what I thought my employer had reported, so I finally got on the phone using Claimyr to reach someone at the IRS. The agent read off exactly what wages and withholding were on record for that year against my SSN, which helped me figure out where the mismatch was coming from before I filed an amended return. For the penalty abatement question here — same general idea applies if you want a human to tell you what exactly is coded on the account before you send your letter. Knowing the specific penalty code and assessment date lets you write a more targeted request.

0 coins

The idea of pulling the specific penalty assessment details from a live agent before writing the letter — that's something I hadn't considered. It would let me address the exact assessment rather than writing a generic letter.

0 coins

Exactly. When I knew the specific figures on record, the amended return process was much cleaner. Guessing at what the IRS has coded versus hearing it directly are two different things.

0 coins

Hadn't thought about using an agent conversation to prep the abatement letter rather than just to argue it. That's actually a smarter order of operations.

0 coins

The reasonable-cause letter really does need to be specific to your facts. Generic 'we weren't aware of the requirement' letters get denied more often because the IRS sees hundreds of them. What worked when I helped a family member write one was structuring it as: here is exactly what happened and when, here is why this happened despite ordinary care, here is what we did to fix it and how fast, and here is our prior compliance history. Each section short and clear. Attach the notice, attach anything that proves your timeline.

0 coins

The four-part structure is really useful — I've been thinking about it as one big narrative but breaking it into those sections makes it much clearer.

0 coins

The cleaner it is to read, the easier it is for whoever processes it to check the boxes they need to check. These aren't read by people with a lot of time per case.

0 coins

I've heard the same about keeping it short. A two-page letter with clear headers beats a six-page narrative every time.

0 coins

Genuine question from someone who doesn't know — if the IRS denies the first abatement request, is there a way to appeal it or is that just the end? I have a friend who got denied once and assumed it was final.

0 coins

A denial isn't the end. You can appeal within the IRS through the Office of Appeals — the denial letter will explain how to request consideration. That's a separate review by an independent officer. Some people also try a second abatement letter with additional documentation before going to Appeals.

0 coins

The Office of Appeals route isn't something I'd heard of before. Useful to know there's a next step.

0 coins

The denial letter matters a lot — read it carefully because it tells you what specifically the IRS said wasn't sufficient. That shapes what you add in a second letter or an appeal.

0 coins

My LLC had a similar situation two years ago — late 5472, penalty assessed, we sent the reasonable-cause letter. It took about five months from submission to a response. They did grant partial abatement in our case but not the full amount. We wrote a second letter for the remainder and that one is still pending from what my preparer last said. So 'some relief' is a realistic outcome even if full removal isn't guaranteed.

0 coins

Partial abatement is still money back — good to know that's a real outcome and not just theoretical. Five months is a long time to wait though.

0 coins

Five months felt like forever. We checked the account transcript every few weeks and there was nothing, then one day the adjustment just showed up.

0 coins

Partial then second letter is actually a pretty common pattern from what I've seen discussed. The IRS sometimes concedes part on the first pass and you have to push for the rest.

0 coins

Tried calling 800-829-1040 twice last month about my 2024 return's processing status before I finally used Claimyr to get a live agent. The agent told me exactly where my return stood on the account — it had been received and was still in processing, no additional action needed on my end. For the person asking about 5472 abatement, the same line can get you an agent who can at least tell you what the account shows for the penalty assessment before you draft anything.

0 coins

Two failed attempts before finally reaching someone — that matches what I've heard about those wait times. Good to know the account status question is something a phone agent can actually answer.

0 coins

The agent was straightforward — just told me the return was received and processing, no open items. Quick and clear once I actually had someone on the line.

0 coins

The processing status answer is apparently pretty simple when you get through. It's just the getting there that's the problem.

0 coins

Form 843 versus a letter — I want to clear up one thing because I've seen it go wrong. If you use Form 843 for a 5472 penalty abatement, the form asks you to identify the type of tax and the specific period. Some people fill that out for the 1120 year and the IRS kicks it back because the penalty isn't assessed under the income tax sections. The letter approach gives you more room to explain exactly what you're requesting and why, which is probably why most people dealing with 5472 penalties specifically go that route.

0 coins

That's the kind of practical detail I needed. I'll go with the letter rather than Form 843 to avoid a procedural rejection on top of everything else.

0 coins

Agreed on the letter for 5472. Form 843 works fine for some penalty types but the routing issue is real and adds delay you don't want.

0 coins

Have you already engaged a CPA or tax attorney on this? The 5472 penalty space is niche enough that some general practitioners aren't fully up to date on the abatement track record for it. If the penalty amount is significant, an international tax practitioner who handles information return penalties regularly is worth the cost of even a one-hour consultation to review your letter before you send it.

0 coins

I have a CPA but honestly they were the one who missed the 5472 requirement in the first place, so I'm a little cautious about relying on them exclusively here. Looking at whether a specialist makes sense.

0 coins

The preparer-error angle is actually something you can include in your reasonable-cause argument. Reasonable reliance on a tax professional who failed to advise you of a requirement has been a recognized basis for abatement in various penalty contexts.

0 coins

Preparer error as part of the narrative is legitimate — but you'd want to document that the professional was actually responsible for the filing and you relied on them in good faith. The letter needs to show your end of the reliance.

0 coins

Worth noting that this doesn't mean blaming your CPA publicly — it's framing it as 'I relied in good faith on a professional I had engaged to handle these filings' rather than naming them and assigning fault.

0 coins

A notice I received last fall about a different information return issue asked for a response within 60 days, and I used Claimyr to reach an IRS agent who confirmed whether my reply had actually been logged on the account as received. The agent found it had been received and was under review. For the original poster's situation — if you do send a reasonable-cause letter and start wondering whether it even arrived, an agent can tell you the same thing: whether a reply or document is showing on the account for that notice.

0 coins

The confirmation that a letter was received is something I would genuinely want to verify rather than just trust the mail. That's a practical use of the phone call.

0 coins

The agent's answer was brief — just confirmed it was on the account as received and said to wait for the written response. No estimates on timing, just what was there.

0 coins

I never thought to verify document receipt that way. I've been sending certified mail and hoping for the best.

0 coins

Certified mail gives you the tracking confirmation but calling to verify it hit the account is a smarter follow-up. The IRS receiving the envelope and the IRS processing it into the account aren't always the same day.

0 coins

Does the abatement request pause the penalty from growing while it's under review? Or does interest and any additional penalty keep accruing on the original assessed amount the whole time?

0 coins

Interest keeps running on the assessed balance while the abatement request is pending — the IRS doesn't put a freeze on the accrual just because you've asked for relief. If the abatement is granted, the penalty itself goes away and the interest on that portion is recalculated. But during the waiting period you're technically still accruing.

0 coins

So there's a cost to waiting even if the request succeeds. That changes how I'd think about whether to pay the penalty while the letter is pending.

0 coins

Paying while the letter is pending is actually something practitioners often recommend — if abatement is granted you get a refund of the amount, and you stop the interest clock in the meantime. The IRS site has a page on how that works.

0 coins

The TAS option mentioned earlier — is that realistic for a 5472 penalty situation? I always thought TAS was more for hardship cases where someone can't pay their rent because a refund is stuck, not for a business penalty dispute.

0 coins

TAS can help when the IRS hasn't resolved a problem within the normal timeframe — it's not only for financial hardship. If the person above has been waiting more than 30 days past a response date the IRS gave them on their abatement letter, that's the kind of situation TAS looks at. Worth trying if the standard process stalls.

0 coins

The 'past the timeframe they gave you' trigger makes more sense to me than the hardship framing. Good to know there's another avenue if the letter just disappears.

0 coins

My accountant mentioned that the IRS has been more aggressive about 5472 penalties in the past few years and that the abatement grant rate has gone down compared to earlier years. I don't know if that's accurate or just their impression, but it's made me nervous about what to expect if we ever miss that deadline.

0 coins

The enforcement has tightened, that's accurate from what practitioners have reported. Which is exactly why a well-constructed reasonable-cause letter matters more now than it might have five years ago. Generic requests are less likely to succeed.

0 coins

Makes sense that enforcement plus a vague request is a bad combination. The structure advice in this thread is useful even just as future prep.

0 coins

Thank you to everyone in this thread — this is genuinely the most useful breakdown of the form 5472 late filing penalty abatement process I've found. The letter approach, the dual-argument strategy, the timeline documentation, the account transcript monitoring — all of it. OP, keeping an eye on this for your update.

0 coins

Drafting the letter this week. I'll come back and post what happens — both whether they acknowledge receipt and what the eventual response is. Might take a few months given what others have said, but I'll update when there's news.

0 coins

The documentation angle is what I'd focus on most before sending. A specific, well-evidenced letter is the whole game here.

0 coins

IRS AI

Expert Assistant
Secure