Back to IRS

StarGazer101

Contractor won't provide SSN for 1099 — what do I do at tax time?

Running a small photography business and I hired a freelancer to help with editing work this year. Paid her well over the threshold where I'd need to file a 1099-NEC. Asked for her SSN or ITIN back in the spring so I could have everything ready, and she just... keeps dodging it. First she said she'd get it to me, then she went quiet for two months, now she's saying she doesn't want to share it for 'privacy reasons.' I don't know if she's worried about identity theft or just doesn't understand what I'm required to do, but I'm stuck. The year is almost over and I need to know what I'm actually supposed to do when a contractor refuses to give you their taxpayer ID. Do I just not file the 1099? Do I leave the SSN blank? Is there some form I fill out to protect myself? I want to handle this right because I don't want the IRS coming after me for something that isn't my fault.

Refund from my 2024 return had been sitting at 'approved' in Where's My Refund for almost eleven weeks with nothing hitting my bank, so I had to track down what happened. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through the IRS's 800-829-1040 line without spending my entire workday on hold — I ended up talking to a live agent who pulled up my account and found the refund amount and the date it had been issued, which let me know it was already on its way out. Here's the video if you're trying to reach a live person at the IRS: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c. Anyway, your situation: when a contractor refuses to give you their SSN or ITIN, you're supposed to send them a formal written request using Form W-9 first. If they still refuse after that, you're required to withhold backup withholding from any future payments. And you file the 1099-NEC anyway with whatever you have — the IRS knows people try to dodge this.

0 coins

That's the direction I was hoping for — file anyway rather than just skip it. Do I literally leave the SSN box blank on the 1099-NEC if she never gives it to me?

0 coins

You'd put 'refused' or leave it blank, yes. The point is that you document that you made the request with Form W-9, that she refused, and you file what you can. That paper trail is your protection. The IRS's instructions for Form 1099 address this directly — worth reading through before filing season hits.

0 coins

The backup withholding piece is real. I had a contractor situation a few years ago and my accountant said the same thing — once you've made the written request and they refuse, you're supposed to start withholding a flat percentage from their pay going forward. Worth asking your preparer exactly what rate applies in your case.

0 coins

The Form W-9 request is the key step here. The W-9 is literally a 'Request for Taxpayer Identification Number' — it's the official way to ask, and sending it creates the paper trail that shows you did your part. If the contractor refuses to fill one out after you've asked in writing, that shifts the responsibility. You file the 1099-NEC without the number if you have to, noting the refusal. The IRS has a process for exactly this situation.

0 coins

Should I send the W-9 request by email or does it have to be actual mail to count as 'formal'?

0 coins

Email works, but certified mail gives you a delivery record that's harder to dispute. I'd do both — email so she gets it fast, and a certified letter so you have proof. Keep copies of everything.

0 coins

My accountant told me the same thing last year when I had a subcontractor who kept stalling. The certified mail timestamp ended up mattering when I was putting together records. Worth the two dollars.

0 coins

Went through almost this exact thing with a graphic designer I hired for contract work in early 2026. She kept saying she'd send the W-9 and never did. I ended up filing the 1099-NEC without her SSN and writing a note in my records about the refusal. No issue from the IRS, at least not yet — but I also started withholding on the final payment I made her, which she was not happy about. That's apparently what you're supposed to do.

0 coins

Did you use any specific language in your written request, or just ask normally?

0 coins

I found a template online that referenced Form W-9 by name and stated that backup withholding would apply if she didn't respond. That formal language seemed to get her attention at least a little — she still didn't send it in the end, but I had the documentation I needed.

0 coins

The language about backup withholding is what usually gets people's attention. Most contractors don't want anything withheld from their pay.

0 coins

Wait, I'm confused about something. Does the contractor actually owe the IRS money on this income either way? Like, if she refuses to give her SSN and doesn't get a 1099, does she still have to report what you paid her?

0 coins

Yes, she's still required to report all her self-employment income whether or not she gets a 1099. The 1099-NEC is an information return that helps the IRS match up what businesses paid, but the contractor's own filing obligation exists separately. Not getting a 1099 doesn't make income disappear from a tax standpoint.

0 coins

That makes more sense. So she's kind of hurting herself by being difficult about this.

0 coins

Exactly right. The IRS gets copies of 1099s, but they also have other ways to match income. Someone not getting a 1099 doesn't get a free pass — it just makes it harder for the IRS to catch discrepancies, not impossible.

0 coins

My first year hiring contractors I didn't know any of this. Had a situation where I forgot to get W-9s signed before the work started, and then chasing them down in December is a nightmare. Learned to get the W-9 signed before the first payment goes out, every single time. Prevents this whole situation.

0 coins

That's the lesson I'm taking from this. Signing it at the start before money changes hands is so much smarter.

0 coins

Agreed. Making the W-9 part of your onboarding for any contractor is just good practice — same as a contract or a scope of work. By the time the first check is written you have everything you need.

0 coins

My accountant actually built it into the invoice template I use for contractors now — there's a note that says the first payment is contingent on a completed W-9. Zero problems since.

0 coins

I read somewhere that you can get penalized for not filing the 1099-NEC even if the contractor refuses to give you their number. Is that true? Feels really unfair if the IRS can fine you for something the other person won't do.

0 coins

There can be penalties for not filing or filing without a taxpayer ID, but the documentation of your attempts matters a lot. If you've genuinely made the required request using Form W-9 and the contractor refused, that goes into the 'reasonable cause' argument for why the number is missing. The IRS does have a process for this — filing without the number and noting the refusal is better than not filing at all.

0 coins

So filing incomplete is better than not filing. That's good to know, I was worried doing nothing was the safer option.

0 coins

Carrying a balance from a couple of years back because of some freelance income I underreported, and the IRS account was showing a different number than what I thought I owed. Claimyr got me to a live agent on the 800-829-1040 line and she confirmed the exact balance owed for that tax year on the account, which helped me figure out how much to put toward it before interest added more. On your situation — the backup withholding rule is real, and the percentage comes out of future payments once the contractor has refused a proper W-9 request. It's not optional on your end once that threshold is crossed.

0 coins

Good to know backup withholding is mandatory, not just something I could choose. I want to follow this correctly so I'm not the one who ends up in trouble.

0 coins

The mandatory piece is what people miss. It stops feeling like a punitive choice once you understand the IRS expects you to withhold when a contractor refuses to give their number — it's compliance, not retaliation.

0 coins

My accountant flat-out told me: never start work with a contractor without collecting the W-9 first. She's seen clients get tangled in exactly this, paying someone thousands and then the contractor ghosts when you ask for their info. Getting it upfront while they still want the work is the only reliable moment.

0 coins

Upfront is the answer. I'll never let this happen again after this year.

0 coins

She also said to keep the W-9 in your records for at least four years — same as other tax documents related to that contractor. If the IRS ever questions a deduction, having the W-9 on file shows the relationship was above board.

0 coins

Four years is the minimum I'd keep anything contractor-related. Some people say longer just to be safe, but four aligns with what the IRS generally uses for how far back they can audit ordinary returns.

0 coins

Has anyone actually had the IRS come back and question a 1099-NEC that was filed without an SSN? I'm in a similar spot with a contractor and I want to know what 'filed without the number' actually looks like in practice.

0 coins

Haven't been questioned on mine yet, but I also filed it with a note in my own records about the W-9 request and refusal. The form itself goes in without the SSN box filled, and the IRS's instructions acknowledge this can happen. It's not a situation they've never seen.

0 coins

The IRS may send a notice asking about the missing number, and you respond with documentation of the request. That's the whole point of keeping the paper trail — you have your answer ready.

0 coins

Okay, so it's not automatically treated as fraud or anything, just potentially a follow-up request. That's less scary than I was imagining.

0 coins

I actually looked up the IRS instructions for Form 1099-NEC because of my own contractor questions this fall. The instructions are pretty clear that you're supposed to solicit the taxpayer ID number, and there are specific rules about what 'solicitation' counts. First request at account opening, then a first annual solicitation, then a second annual solicitation. If you've done all three and still nothing, you've generally met your obligation on that front.

0 coins

Three solicitations — I didn't know there was an actual structure to it. I've sent one, so I need to do more formal requests before the year closes.

0 coins

The timing matters too. The IRS instructions on this are worth reading directly — they're clearer than a lot of the third-party summaries out there. The form's own instructions on the IRS's site lay it out step by step.

0 coins

The formal solicitation structure is what separates 'I asked once' from 'I complied with the requirement.' Most small business owners don't know there's a specific sequence, so contractors who drag their feet end up costing their clients more work in the documentation department.

0 coins

BEEN DEALING WITH THIS FOR THREE YEARS with the same contractor I use for occasional audio work. Every year she 'forgets' and every year I'm scrambling in January. I've started withholding from every payment to her, and while she complained at first she understands now that it's the rule, not my choice. The IRS is NOT going to look kindly on me if I keep filing without her number and don't show I tried to get it. Backup withholding is real and it's the lever you have.

0 coins

Three years of this — that sounds exhausting. Using the withholding as the actual enforcement mechanism makes sense.

0 coins

It's the only thing that worked for me. When the money started coming out of her payments, suddenly she was a lot more interested in getting me the information. Still took another year for her to actually do it, but it happened eventually.

0 coins

Tried to find clarification on this at a local IRS Taxpayer Assistance Center appointment earlier this year — I had a whole different question about my own account, but the agent also walked me through what documentation they'd want to see from a business owner who filed 1099s without taxpayer IDs. They said the W-9 request and any responses (or non-responses) needed to be in my records. That matched everything I'd read on the IRS's site.

0 coins

Knowing the TAC agent said the same thing as what people are finding online makes me feel better about the approach. Document everything, file anyway.

0 coins

Exactly. And you can get an appointment at a TAC through 844-545-5640 or the office finder on the IRS's site at https://www.irs.gov/ — if you have more questions than a forum can answer, talking to someone there in person is worth it.

0 coins

TAC appointments are underused for business owner questions. People assume it's only for personal return stuff, but they handle a lot.

0 coins

My bookkeeper pointed out something I hadn't considered: if the contractor is using an ITIN instead of an SSN, the W-9 process is the same but they'd put their ITIN in the taxpayer ID field. Some contractors who are foreign nationals have ITINs for exactly this purpose. If your contractor's hesitation is about privacy, it might help to explain that an ITIN exists specifically to protect people who can't get SSNs — it's a federal tax ID, not a Social Security number, and it doesn't confer any work authorization or immigration status.

0 coins

Hadn't thought about the ITIN angle. She might not know that's an option — could explain some of the hesitation.

0 coins

Worth raising it directly with her. Some contractors genuinely don't know about ITINs. If she doesn't have one and can't get an SSN, the ITIN application process exists for exactly this scenario — Form W-7, filed with a tax return.

0 coins

I didn't realize ITINs were separate from SSNs like that. So someone could have an ITIN for tax purposes but no SSN at all?

0 coins

Right — ITINs are only for federal tax filing and are specifically for people who aren't eligible for SSNs. They start with the number 9 and have a specific range in the fourth and fifth digits. The key thing for your situation is that it fills the same box on the W-9.

0 coins

Had a question about my own installment agreement — specifically what my monthly amount was supposed to be after I'd changed payment methods. Claimyr put the hold time on 800-829-1040 on its end so I could keep working, and I ended up talking to an agent who confirmed the payment plan's monthly amount and due date currently on my account. Turns out it hadn't updated after my change, and the agent told me I could fix it in the IRS Online Account directly. On the contractor topic: the advice above about multiple solicitations is correct. The IRS instructions use the word 'solicitation' and define each step, which is more formal than most people expect.

0 coins

Good to know the payment plan stuff can be managed in the IRS Online Account — I didn't realize you could make changes there. And thanks for the solicitation confirmation.

0 coins

The IRS Online Account at https://www.irs.gov/your-account handles a lot — payment plan changes, transcripts, balance info. Worth getting signed in if you haven't, especially if you're running a business and dealing with the IRS at all.

0 coins

The online account is so much faster than trying to get through on the phone for routine things. I use it for pretty much everything now that doesn't require actually talking to someone.

0 coins

Former office manager here — handled contractor payroll for a small firm for several years. The W-9 collecting process was part of onboarding before we issued any payment. When someone refused or stalled, the payment literally didn't go out until we had the form. That policy ended the problem entirely because contractors understood there was no money until we had what we needed. For your current year situation: you're a little late to hold payments, but you can still issue the formal requests before year end and then file with whatever you have.

0 coins

Holding the payment was the lever in that situation — I wish I'd done that earlier. At least I can still get the formal requests out before filing.

0 coins

Even sending the W-9 request now with a note that backup withholding will apply to any additional payments this year is better than not doing it. Documents that you followed the process, even late in the game.

0 coins

The IRS has a specific topic on information returns and the penalties for not filing them or filing them incorrectly. Worth searching the IRS's site for 'information return penalties' because the penalty structure is tiered depending on how late the form is and whether you filed at all. The penalties for not filing are higher than the penalties for filing with a missing number, which is another reason why filing incomplete is better than not filing.

0 coins

So there are actually different penalty levels depending on what you did wrong? Filing late is penalized less than not filing at all?

0 coins

Generally the penalty for filing with a missing number is lower than for not filing at all, yes. But the specifics depend on the situation, and the IRS's site has the actual amounts. The takeaway for your situation is: file, even if the form is imperfect.

0 coins

The tiered structure is real — I had an accountant explain it to me when I missed a 1099 deadline one year. The IRS would rather have you file late and incomplete than not file and pretend the payments didn't happen.

0 coins

Contractor on the other side of this question here — I've had clients ask me for my SSN and I always provide it because I know they're required to file the 1099 and I'd rather have everything match up when I report my income. If your contractor is worried about identity theft, there's a real answer for that: the W-9 goes to the payer, not to the IRS. The payer uses the number to fill out the 1099 form. The IRS gets the 1099 form, not the actual W-9. That might help explain why sharing it with you isn't the same as broadcasting it.

0 coins

That's actually a really helpful framing — the SSN goes to me for the form, not directly to the government. I'll try explaining it that way.

0 coins

A lot of people don't realize that distinction. The W-9 stays with the business that hired them. It's not a form that gets submitted anywhere — it's just the business's record of the contractor's information.

0 coins

This is the explanation that actually worked for one of my contractors who was worried about privacy. Once she understood the W-9 isn't sent anywhere and I'd be storing it securely, she signed it the same day.

0 coins

Situation from my second year of freelancing — a client asked for my W-9 and I didn't know what it was and panicked, thinking they were going to send my number everywhere. The client explained what it was for and I signed it immediately. Your contractor might genuinely just not understand what a W-9 is or why it stays with you. A quick explanation might solve what feels like a refusal.

0 coins

Worth trying the explanation before assuming bad faith. I've been treating it as a refusal but maybe she just doesn't understand the form's purpose.

0 coins

Exactly. Lead with the explanation, have the form ready to send, and then escalate to the formal written request with the backup withholding notice if she still doesn't respond after that. Some people just need to know what they're signing.

0 coins

The fear of 'what will they do with my number' is really common among first-time contractors. An explanatory email that walks through what the W-9 is for, where it goes and where it doesn't go, can clear the whole thing up before you have to go through formal solicitation steps.

0 coins

Accountant told me something worth passing on: even if you end up filing the 1099-NEC without the SSN and paying any penalties that come from it, those penalties may qualify as ordinary business expenses. I'm not in a position to say how they'd be treated in your specific situation — that's a tax professional question — but it's worth knowing that having an imperfect 1099 situation isn't necessarily the end of the world financially.

0 coins

Not the end of the world — that's what I needed to hear. I've been treating this like a catastrophe. File what I can, document the attempts, deal with any fallout.

0 coins

The IRS has seen every version of contractor tax drama. Your situation isn't unusual, and the fact that you're asking these questions and trying to handle it correctly puts you in a much better position than someone who just pretends the payments didn't happen.

0 coins

The 'pretend it didn't happen' approach is what gets people in real trouble. Filing something, even imperfect, signals good faith.

0 coins

For anyone who ends up getting IRS notices about missing information on 1099s and can't get answers on the phone line, TAS — the Taxpayer Advocate Service — is worth knowing about. They're at 1-877-777-4778 and their site is https://www.taxpayeradvocate.irs.gov/. They can help if the IRS hasn't resolved something within the normal timeframes and it's causing financial hardship. Not saying that's where you are, but it's a resource worth having.

0 coins

Filing this away for the future. Hopefully getting the W-9 requests out now and filing correctly means I won't need TAS, but good to know the option is there.

0 coins

TAS is specifically for when things drag on past normal timeframes or when a tax issue is causing real financial harm. Most people don't know it exists until they're already deep in a problem.

0 coins

Had no idea TAS was free and independent from the IRS. That changes how I think about what to do if a notice situation ever gets out of hand.

0 coins

IRS AI

Expert Assistant
Secure