Best Ways to Reduce Capital Gains Tax Burden? Is TurboTax Worth It for Investment Sales?

Hey everyone, trying to keep this brief... For years my tax situation has been super straightforward - no property, nothing fancy, always took the standard deduction. But 2023 threw me a curveball because I sold some stocks and put everything into Money Market accounts and Treasury Bills. Ended up with about $13,900 in capital gains and another $3,700 in dividends/interest income. Now I'm looking at owing roughly $2,600 federal and $950 state taxes when I'm used to getting a few hundred back! **Am I missing some kind of "loophole" or "deduction" that could reduce this tax hit?** Just to note - when I sold the stocks, I immediately reinvested in money markets and t-bills, never actually transferred anything to my checking account. Also, TurboTax wants me to upgrade to their premium service and pay $230 this year just to file these taxes. Would an actual accountant be worth it instead? Could they find deductions that TurboTax might miss? Or is there a better/cheaper online option than TurboTax for someone in my situation? Really appreciate any advice you all might have!

0 coins

18 comments

Sadie Benitez

•8M

That capital gains tax bill can definitely be a surprise when you're used to getting refunds! Unfortunately, there aren't many "loopholes" for capital gains once they're realized. The fact that you reinvested immediately doesn't change the tax situation - the IRS still considers that a taxable event when you sold the original stocks. A few things to consider: Check if you have any capital losses from previous years that you can carry forward. You can offset up to $3,000 of ordinary income with capital losses each year. Also, make sure you're accounting for your correct cost basis on the stocks you sold - sometimes people forget to include reinvested dividends in their basis, which can reduce your gain. As for tax software, TurboTax is definitely on the expensive side. For investment transactions, I've found FreeTaxUSA to be much more affordable (around $15 for state filing, federal is free) and just as effective for handling capital gains. H&R Block and TaxSlayer are other options that typically cost less than TurboTax but can handle investment income well.

0 coins

Sadie Benitez

•8M

Unfortunately, the IRS doesn't care that the money never hit your checking account. What matters is that you sold the original investment, which triggers a taxable event. The only exception would be if you did a direct transfer in a tax-advantaged account like an IRA, but for regular taxable accounts, selling is selling regardless of what you do with the proceeds afterward. If you're looking to be more tax-efficient with investments in the future, you might want to consider tax-loss harvesting throughout the year or holding investments long-term (over a year) to qualify for lower long-term capital gains rates.

0 coins

Laila Prince

•8M

I was in a similar situation last year with unexpected capital gains and tried everything to reduce the tax burden. I ended up using https://taxr.ai because TurboTax was going to charge me almost $200! The service actually analyzed my investment transactions and found that I had incorrectly calculated the cost basis on a few stocks I had owned for years (I had forgotten about some dividend reinvestments). Saved me over $800 in taxes I would have overpaid. What I really liked was how it explained the exact tax rules applying to my situation - like how reinvesting immediately doesn't change the tax impact of selling. They even helped me understand how to structure my investments better for this year to minimize taxes going forward.

0 coins

Laila Prince

•8M

You just upload your tax documents and investment statements, and it reviews everything using their AI system. It's pretty impressive how it catches things - in my case it noticed some inconsistencies in my basis calculations that I would have completely missed. It's not that it uses different tax laws than TurboTax, but it's more thorough in how it analyzes your specific situation. TurboTax is designed for everyone, but sometimes misses nuances in investment situations because it depends on you inputting everything perfectly. This service is specifically focused on finding these kinds of issues and explaining them to you in plain English.

0 coins

Isabel Vega

•8M

Just wanted to update after trying taxr.ai for myself. It actually found that I had been reporting some of my Treasury Bill interest incorrectly for the past two years! The interface walked me through how to properly report my capital gains and even suggested some loss harvesting opportunities in my portfolio that I hadn't considered. I was able to offset about $2,200 of my gains with some losses I didn't realize I could claim. The whole process took about 15 minutes and was WAY cheaper than the TurboTax premium tier. Definitely recommend giving it a try if you're dealing with investment income!

0 coins

Marilyn Dixon

•8M

If you're still having issues understanding your tax situation, you might want to try calling the IRS directly. I know it sounds insane, but I finally got through using https://claimyr.com and talked to a real agent who explained exactly how capital gains are calculated when you reinvest. They also confirmed which software options support investment reporting without charging premium fees. Check out how it works: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c I was on hold with the IRS for THREE HOURS before I found this service. Got connected to an agent in about 20 minutes after using it. The agent actually walked me through some specific questions about my investment taxes and confirmed I was filing correctly.

0 coins

Marilyn Dixon

•8M

Yes, you absolutely can talk to a real IRS person! They'll answer specific questions about how to report different types of income, which forms you need, and clarify tax rules you don't understand. They won't give tax planning advice, but they're surprisingly helpful for factual questions about reporting requirements. This isn't a scam - it's just a service that holds your place in line. I tried being "persistent" for three hours before trying this. Life's too short to spend hours on hold when there's a better option. The time I saved was worth way more than what it cost, especially when I was stressing about getting my taxes done correctly.

0 coins

Dominique Adams

•8M

I need to eat some humble pie here. After posting my skeptical comment earlier, I was still struggling with figuring out how to properly report some complicated capital gains situations. Out of desperation I tried Claimyr and got through to the IRS in about 15 minutes. The agent was actually super helpful and explained that I was eligible for lower long-term capital gains rates on some of my investments that I was about to report as short-term by mistake. This literally saved me over $1,200 in taxes! I've been filing my own taxes for 20 years and never managed to get actual help from the IRS before. Consider me converted.

0 coins

TommyKapitz

•8M

Regarding your TurboTax question - I switched from TurboTax to FreeTaxUSA three years ago and never looked back. They handle all investment stuff including capital gains, dividends, etc., for their basic price ($0 federal, around $15 state). I had about $22k in capital gains last year plus various dividends and interest, and FreeTaxUSA handled it all perfectly. TurboTax's "premium" requirements are mostly artificial paywalls they create to force you into higher tiers. Most tax situations including investments can be handled by much cheaper alternatives.

0 coins

TommyKapitz

•8M

I actually did run both TurboTax and FreeTaxUSA side by side the first year I switched, and they came up with identical refund amounts. The only real difference was the interface - TurboTax looks fancier but FreeTaxUSA gets the job done. You can always download your tax return PDFs from previous years and have those for reference. You'll need to manually enter some basic info the first time you use a new service, but after that initial setup, it's smooth sailing. The hundreds of dollars I've saved over the past few years has definitely been worth the small hassle of switching.

0 coins