Back to California Unemployment

StormChaser

When did employees stop paying into unemployment insurance? California EDD explanation

So I've been going through my old pay stubs and comparing them to my current ones and I noticed something that's been bugging me. Back when I worked at a retail job like six years ago I swear I saw a deduction labeled UI or unemployment on my check every week. Now I work in logistics and there's nothing like that anywhere on my current pay stubs. My coworker says employees never paid into unemployment and I must be misremembering, but I really feel like I saw it. Did California change this at some point or am I totally confused about what I was looking at? I want to understand this because I just filed a claim last week after getting laid off and I'm trying to figure out how the system works and who actually funds it.

Ask yourself what that deduction was actually labeled, because that detail matters a lot here. If it said CASDI or SDI, that's State Disability Insurance, which does come out of your paycheck. Workers pay into SDI to fund disability and paid family leave benefits. Unemployment insurance is funded entirely by your employer, nothing comes out of your wages for it. So your coworker is right that employees don't pay into UI, but you weren't imagining a deduction either, it was just for a different program.

0 coins

CASDI, that's exactly what it said. I feel so dumb for confusing those two for years. So the SDI deduction on my check is completely separate from unemployment?

0 coins

Completely separate programs. SDI covers you if you get sick or injured and can't work, or if you need to bond with a new baby. Unemployment is for when you lose your job through no fault of your own. Two different funds, two different pots of money, employers pay the UI side.

0 coins

Same confusion I had when I first filed. Took me an embarrassingly long time to figure out what CASDI even stood for.

0 coins

Weeks on pending status after my layoff from a warehouse job finally made sense once I actually got an EDD agent on the line. The layoff paperwork my employer submitted had a wrong end date and that's what was holding everything up. Claimyr (claimyr.com) got me through to a live agent after I'd spent two days hitting dead ends on the phone, and there's a video showing how reaching a live person at EDD works at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The agent pulled up my claim and told me exactly which week the date discrepancy affected and said to expect a corrected Notice of Unemployment Insurance Award in the mail. On your original question though, employers have always been the ones paying the UI tax in California, nothing was ever taken from worker paychecks for it.

0 coins

The pending weeks situation is lowkey my biggest fear right now. Did the corrected notice come pretty fast after they flagged the date issue?

0 coins

DE 429Z corrections in my experience took about a week to show up in the mail after the agent noted the fix. Might vary but that's what happened on mine.

0 coins

Interesting that the wrong end date caused that kind of delay. I always assumed EDD cross-references employer records automatically but apparently a manual correction is sometimes needed.

0 coins

People get this wrong constantly and it causes real confusion when they file. The question to ask yourself before certifying is whether you reported all your income correctly, because what you're not paying into is UI, but what you are on the hook for is accurately reporting any wages you earn while collecting. The earnings offset formula means your first $25 or 25 percent of weekly gross, whichever is higher, doesn't count against your benefit, then the rest is subtracted from your weekly amount. This matters a lot more than the funding question once you're actually in the system.

0 coins

Part-time work while collecting is something I might actually need to deal with. If I pick up gig work some weeks does that count the same way?

0 coins

Report everything earned in the week you did the work, not when you got paid. Gig income, tips, any of it. EDD will apply the formula from there. The key is the week it was earned, not the payment date.

0 coins

Does the 25 percent calculation use gross or net? I always second-guessed this when I was certifying.

0 coins

Gross earnings for the week. What you made before taxes, not what hit your bank account.

0 coins

Employers have been carrying the full UI tax burden in California for as long as I can remember and I've been in HR for a long time. The reason people get confused is partly because other states handled it differently at various points in history, and partly because the SDI deduction is real and visible on your check while the employer UI contribution happens invisibly on their end. Your employer files quarterly wage reports and pays into EDD's UI fund based on their tax rate. You as the worker never see any of that.

0 coins

HR perspective makes sense. So my employer has been paying some rate based on how many people they've laid off historically or something like that?

0 coins

The rate depends on a few things on the employer's side that EDD tracks, but I'd steer away from getting into rate specifics here because that's really the employer's side of things. What matters for your claim is that the fund exists and you're eligible to draw from it because your employer participated.

0 coins

Does that mean companies that never lay anyone off pay less into the system? Just curious how the incentive structure works.

0 coins

Employer contribution mechanics are EDD's domain and I wouldn't want to give you a number I'm not sure of. EDD's site has the employer section if you're really curious, but for a claimant's purposes it doesn't change anything about your benefit amount or eligibility.

0 coins

Nobody is deducting UI from your paycheck and nobody ever was, at least not in California. What kills me is how many people I've seen delay filing because they thought they hadn't 'paid in enough' or some variation of that, and then they miss out on weeks they were owed. File as soon as you're out of work, that's the whole point.

0 coins

Waiting to file cost me about three weeks of benefits last time I got laid off. The claim starts from the Sunday of the week you apply, so every day you wait is potentially a week gone.

0 coins

Already filed last week so at least I did that part right. Still waiting to hear about my weekly benefit amount though.

0 coins

DE 429Z is what you're waiting for in the mail, that's the award notice that tells you your weekly amount. Should show up within a couple weeks of your application being processed.

0 coins

My first time filing I thought the same thing, that maybe I hadn't contributed enough weeks to qualify. Spent an hour on EDD's site trying to find where my 'contribution balance' was before I realized the whole premise was wrong. The eligibility question is about your wages in the base period, not anything you personally paid in. Specifically, whether you had at least $1,300 in your highest earning quarter or $900 in your highest quarter with total base period wages at least 1.25 times that.

0 coins

Base period is the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters before I filed, right? I want to make sure I understand which wages they're looking at.

0 coins

Exactly right. And if for some reason that standard window doesn't get you to a valid claim, EDD will automatically check the alternate base period, which is the most recent four quarters. EDD runs that check on its own, you don't have to request it.

0 coins

I didn't know EDD ran the alternate check automatically. That would have been helpful to know the first time I filed and panicked about my wages qualifying.

0 coins

Something worth flagging for anyone reading this thread who's also newly filed: not paying into UI doesn't mean EDD won't scrutinize your claim carefully. If there's any question about why you stopped working, like a quit or a firing rather than a straight layoff, they'll schedule a phone interview before anything gets paid. The notice comes in the mail as a DE 4800 and it'll have the date and time the interviewer phones you, same info is on your UI Online homepage. Keep your phone with you at that time.

0 coins

Mine was a layoff with a letter and everything, so hopefully no interview needed. But good to know about the DE 4800 in case something comes up.

0 coins

Layoffs generally don't trigger the same level of review, but if your employer contests anything EDD might still reach out. Unlikely with a clean layoff but just keep an eye on your UI Online homepage and your mail.

0 coins

DE 4800 is exactly the notice that showed up for me after my termination. Adjudication held my payments for almost a month. The agent I eventually got through to on the phone using Claimyr found that my employer had reported the reason for separation differently than I had, and EDD was waiting to hear both sides. After the interview everything moved.

0 coins

Conflicting separation reports are one of the more common reasons adjudication drags out. The interview is basically EDD's way of getting the whole story from both sides before it decides.

0 coins

The confusion about UI contributions trips up a lot of first-time filers. Here's a way to think about it: CASDI on your paystub is the program you personally pay into, covering disability and family leave. UI is the program your employer pays into, covering job loss. When you file for unemployment, you're drawing from the employer-funded pool. When you file for disability because you're sick or injured, you're drawing from the worker-funded pool. They run parallel but they're completely separate.

0 coins

That parallel explanation is actually really clear. Both deducted from wages or paid by employer depending on the program.

0 coins

Right, and the practical takeaway is you never 'run out' of UI contributions from your end, your eligibility is always based on wages earned, not payments made into a personal account.

0 coins

Useful framing. I've tried explaining this to people and usually just confuse them more. The personal account analogy is the wrong mental model for UI.

0 coins

CalJOBS registration tripped me up more than the funding question ever did when I first filed. Got a Notice of Requirement to Register for Work in the mail and had a 21-day window from the date on it to get my profile and resume posted on caljobs.ca.gov. Missed it by a few days on my first claim and had a payment stopped. When I filed again this past spring I used Claimyr to reach an EDD agent because I wanted to confirm my registration had gone through before the deadline, and the agent checked my account and confirmed the resume was showing as received. No more missed deadlines that way.

0 coins

DE 8405 is the notice you're talking about? I haven't gotten one yet but now I'll be watching for it.

0 coins

That's the one. The 21 days runs from the date printed on it, not from when you get it in the mail, so open it right away and don't sit on it.

0 coins

CalJOBS is a whole separate headache from UI Online. Worth setting it up early and keeping the resume updated even before you get the notice.

0 coins

Severance pay and whether to report it confused me more than the who-pays question. Left a tech job with two months of severance and wasn't sure if I should wait to file. UI Online showed pending on my first few certified weeks and I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr about it. The agent told me my specific certified weeks were pending because EDD was reviewing how the severance was categorized on my claim, then cleared up that my benefit amount wasn't affected by the lump sum since my employer paid it under a company policy. The agent said to watch for the DE 429Z confirming my weekly amount.

0 coins

Severance is something I might have as well depending on how my final check comes through. So you filed right away even with severance coming?

0 coins

Filed the same week my job ended. The severance question is EDD's to sort out, the right move is to file, report what you receive during certification, and let them decide how it affects each week.

0 coins

Reporting the week you earned it rather than when you received it matters a lot with severance. EDD's certification asks about income for the week, not the payment date.

0 coins

The agent confirmed it's reported in the certification for the period it covers, which in my case was the weeks after my last day. EDD handles the math from there.

0 coins

Work search requirements catch people off guard too, especially when they're focused on the funding question and think everything is automatic once they file. For every week you certify you need to have been able to work, available to work, and looking for work. EDD doesn't publish a specific number of contacts you need per week on their public pages, but you do want to actually be looking and to keep your own notes on where you applied.

0 coins

Keeping a personal log of applications sounds smart even if EDD doesn't require a specific format. Just in case something comes up in a review.

0 coins

Exactly. If a question ever arises during an audit or interview you want to be able to speak to what you were doing each week. Dates, company names, position titles, that kind of detail.

0 coins

I kept a simple spreadsheet during my last claim and it felt like overkill until one week I got a question during certification about work search activity. Having the records ready made it easy to answer honestly.

0 coins

Something that helped me understand the EDD funding structure was realizing that the amount of benefits you can receive is based entirely on what you earned, not on some balance you built up. Your weekly benefit amount comes from your highest-paid quarter in the base period and runs between $40 and $450 a week. The maximum total on a claim is 26 times your weekly amount or half of all base period wages, whichever is less. EDD has an estimator tool on their site if you want a rough number before your DE 429Z arrives.

0 coins

That calculator is worth bookmarking. I used it before I filed and the estimate seemed reasonable, just waiting to see what the actual DE 429Z says.

0 coins

The official number on the DE 429Z is the one that counts. The calculator gives a ballpark but sometimes base period wages land differently than you expect depending on which quarters get included.

0 coins

My estimate was off by about $30 from the actual award. Close enough to plan around but I'm glad I didn't count on the exact number.

0 coins

Nonprofits sometimes work differently on the employer side, which is a common misconception I see floating around. Some nonprofits pay into the UI fund like any other employer while others operate under a reimbursable arrangement with EDD where they repay the exact cost of benefits paid to their former workers. Either way, as a worker at a nonprofit your claim process is exactly the same as anyone else's. You file, you certify, EDD decides. Nothing changes on your end.

0 coins

I had a friend who worked at a nonprofit and thought she couldn't file because her employer wasn't paying UI taxes. She ended up not claiming anything she was owed.

0 coins

That's unfortunately common. Working for a nonprofit is not on EDD's list of work that isn't covered. Former workers of nonprofits file and collect like anyone else.

0 coins

Wish someone had told my friend that two years ago. She left a lot of money on the table because she assumed nonprofits were exempt.

0 coins

ID.me verification is the step that gums up newly filed claims more than almost anything else. After you apply online through myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ you need to verify your identity through ID.me, which means creating an account, taking a photo of your ID, and letting ID.me share it with EDD. If EDD can't verify you that way they'll mail a DE 1326C asking you to verify another way. Don't ignore that letter, it's what's holding your weeks in pending if identity is the issue.

0 coins

DE 1326C, writing that down. I went through ID.me when I applied online and thought it went through but now I'm second-guessing whether it actually completed.

0 coins

You'd typically see confirmation from ID.me that the verification was shared successfully. If you completed all the steps and got that confirmation you should be fine, but keep an eye on pending weeks in Claim History just in case.

0 coins

ID.me tripped me up because I didn't have a compliant photo of my ID and had to redo it twice. Worth double-checking that all four corners of your ID are visible in the shot before submitting.

0 coins

Appeals after a denial is another thing worth knowing about now rather than when you need it. If EDD decides you don't qualify they mail a Notice of Determination, which is the DE 1080CZ, and it comes with an Appeal Form, the DE 1000M. You have 30 calendar days from the mailing date on that notice to appeal in writing. Miss that window and you need to explain why to even get the late appeal considered.

0 coins

30 days from the mailing date, not from when you receive it. That's a detail I wouldn't have thought to pay attention to.

0 coins

Exactly. And the advice to keep certifying during an appeal matters a lot too. EDD can only pay back weeks that were certified, so stopping certification while you wait for an appeal decision costs you those weeks.

0 coins

I made the mistake of stopping certification after a denial thinking there was no point. Lost several weeks of back pay even after I won the appeal because those weeks were never certified.

0 coins

Form 1099G is something to file away mentally for tax time. EDD mails it each January but you can also find it in UI Online under Payments, then Form 1099G, and it's available there for five years. Your benefits are federal taxable income even though California doesn't tax them at the state level. When you're certifying you can elect to have 10 percent withheld for federal taxes, which a lot of people skip and then get surprised in April.

0 coins

10 percent withholding option during certification, didn't know that existed. How do you opt into that, is it a question on the certification form itself?

0 coins

EDD asks during each certification whether you want federal taxes withheld. You can change your answer each time, so if one week you have other income and want to withhold you can, or you can skip it.

0 coins

Ended up owing a chunk to the IRS one year because I didn't withhold anything during my claim. Would definitely recommend at least thinking about it rather than just skipping the question.

0 coins

Waiting week is the other early surprise for first-time filers. Every claim has a one-week unpaid waiting period, which is served on your first eligible week. So your first certification usually covers two weeks, the waiting week with no payment and then one paid week. It doesn't reduce what your claim can ultimately pay, it's just the first week being a wash financially.

0 coins

So I effectively lose one week of benefits to the waiting week no matter what?

0 coins

The waiting week doesn't change your maximum benefit amount, it's just unpaid. Think of it as the deductible on the claim. After that first cycle your certified paid weeks run normally.

0 coins

Knowing about the waiting week ahead of time makes the first payment less alarming. I expected two weeks of pay and only got one and had no idea why until I looked it up.

0 coins

Direct deposit versus the Money Network card is worth deciding before your first payment hits. By default EDD sends payments to a Money Network prepaid debit card, but you can switch to direct deposit through myEDD. Payment information updates daily in UI Online and also through 1-866-333-4606 which is available 24 hours a day, so you can check status without waiting to call an agent during business hours.

0 coins

I want to set up direct deposit. Is that something you do through the same UI Online account or is it a separate setup?

0 coins

Change it in myEDD, which is the same portal where UI Online lives. The payment preference setting is in there and doesn't require a phone call.

0 coins

Switched to direct deposit midway through my last claim and it went fine. Just give it a couple weeks before it reflects, the first payment or two after the change might still hit the card.

0 coins

Overpayment notices are worth understanding now so they don't blindside you later. If EDD finds it paid you for weeks you weren't eligible for, it sends a notice telling you how much it wants back. Non-fraud overpayments have to be repaid but there's no extra penalty. If repaying would cause real hardship and the overpayment wasn't your fault and wasn't fraud, you can apply for a waiver using the DE 1446UI. EDD weighs the circumstances but a waiver isn't guaranteed. Accurate certification is the best way to avoid this whole situation.

0 coins

DE 1446UI waiver form, good to have that in the back of my mind. The thought of getting an overpayment notice after all this is stressful.

0 coins

Accurate reporting on every certification is what protects you. Report wages in the week they were earned, every dollar, and EDD handles the math. It's when people guess or round or forget to report that overpayments happen.

0 coins

Report Wages in UI Online is a helpful screen to use before certifying if you had any work during the period. It helps you work out what to report without having to do the math yourself.

0 coins

Using that Report Wages screen is exactly what I'd recommend for anyone with inconsistent income week to week. It's there before certification for a reason.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure