Back to California Unemployment

Liam Mendez

What to expect at unemployment appeal hearing disqualified - my California EDD story

Got my Notice of Determination last week and EDD denied my claim. I was let go from my warehouse job back in September - my supervisor said I violated a company attendance policy but honestly I had doctor's notes for every single absence and HR never gave me a formal warning. I filed for UI and now I have this denial notice in my hand saying misconduct. The Appeal Form DE 1000M was attached so I mailed it in right away. Now I'm sitting here with zero income trying to figure out what actually happens next. What do I expect at the unemployment appeal hearing after being disqualified like this? Do I need a lawyer? Do they let me show documents? Does EDD come to argue against me? I've been reading conflicting stuff online and I genuinely don't know if I should be terrified or if this is something I can handle on my own. Any experience with this would be huge right now.

Attendance policy fired me too, back in spring - had three unexcused absences on paper even though two of them were days I was stuck waiting on a parts delivery my manager knew about. Filed for UI, got denied for misconduct, appealed. Getting anyone at EDD on the phone to ask basic questions before my hearing felt impossible until I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) - it held the line for me and I ended up talking to an actual EDD agent. I asked her whether my employer was going to have a rep at the hearing and what I should bring. She confirmed my appeal had been sent over to the Office of Appeals, that the Notice of Hearing would come by mail at least 10 days before the date, and that I should gather anything that showed what I reported to HR and when. She also said to keep certifying every two weeks so the back weeks could be paid if I won - that part I hadn't thought about at all. Here's the video that explains reaching a live person at EDD by phone: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10

0 coins

Pulled up my UI Online just now and it still shows the denial weeks - does certifying actually do anything if EDD already said no?

0 coins

Certifying while the appeal is open is the most important thing to keep doing. If the judge rules in your favor, EDD can only pay back the weeks you actually certified for. Skip a week and that week's gone even if you win.

0 coins

Okay keeping that habit regardless of how long this takes then. Thank you both.

0 coins

Had no clue about the certifying rule either when I appealed mine. Lost two weeks of back pay because nobody told me. Don't be me.

0 coins

What actually threw me going into my hearing was not knowing who would even be there. Here's how it works - an administrative law judge runs it, you're under oath and you testify about what happened, and your employer can send a rep to give their side. The judge is not an EDD employee so it's not EDD arguing against you, it's your former employer presenting their case. You present yours. The judge weighs both and mails a written decision after.

0 coins

Wait so EDD itself doesn't show up and argue the denial was correct?

0 coins

No, EDD doesn't send anyone to defend the denial at the hearing. It's you and the employer. The judge decided independently.

0 coins

My employer sent nobody to mine and I still had to go through the whole thing and testify. Even with no one on the other side the judge still asked detailed questions about every absence.

0 coins

Same here - employer was a no-show and the judge granted my appeal on the spot basically. But I wouldn't count on that happening.

0 coins

Doctor's notes are exactly the kind of documentation to bring. Print out everything - the notes themselves, any emails or texts where you told HR or your supervisor you were sick, the company's written attendance policy if you have it, and your own record of dates. Organize them chronologically so you can find them fast when the judge asks.

0 coins

Found an old email chain where my manager acknowledged one of the absences was excused. That's worth including right?

0 coins

Yes, that email is solid evidence. It goes directly to whether EDD's misconduct standard is met - the employer has to show your behavior was willful or deliberate, and an email from your manager saying an absence was excused cuts right against that argument.

0 coins

Quick note on that - I've seen people get confused and think any firing is automatically misconduct. EDD's standard is that the employer has to actually prove misconduct. A policy violation alone doesn't automatically mean you're disqualified if there were real reasons behind it.

0 coins

Missed my first scheduled hearing and had to scramble. The Notice of Hearing comes in the mail and it has the date, time, and the specific questions the judge plans to cover. Keep checking your mailbox starting about two or three weeks after you file the appeal. If something comes up and you can't make it, you need to contact the Office of Appeals before the hearing date to request a reschedule.

0 coins

Mine came yesterday actually - date is in about three weeks so I have some time to prepare.

0 coins

Three weeks is a solid window. Use it. Practice saying your version of events out loud, not just reading your notes.

0 coins

The notice also lists the issues the judge will examine - read that section carefully because the hearing stays pretty focused on those specific questions.

0 coins

Severance confusion held up my own understanding of my claim for weeks - I got a small payout when I was let go and kept thinking it would affect my appeal eligibility somehow. Used Claimyr to get through to EDD and the agent pulled up my file. She said the pending weeks on my claim were because they needed to verify my identity, nothing to do with the severance, and that I could keep certifying. Ended up filing my own appeal on a separate denial later and represented myself fine.

0 coins

Did you feel like you needed any legal background to handle the hearing yourself?

0 coins

No legal background at all. Just knew my own facts better than anyone. That's really the main advantage you have - you were there, your employer's rep often wasn't directly involved in the situation.

0 coins

Representing yourself is totally normal at these hearings. Union reps, attorneys, or just yourself - the judge is used to all of it.

0 coins

Heard someone at my AJCC say you only have 10 days to appeal after a denial - that's wrong and I want to flag it before anyone acts on it. The mailing date on the Notice of Determination is what starts the clock, and you get 30 calendar days from that date. Count carefully from the actual date printed on the notice, not the day you received it.

0 coins

Mine was mailed October 3rd and I sent the appeal form back October 9th so I should be well within that window.

0 coins

You're fine - six days in is very timely. Some people wait and then panic at day 28.

0 coins

The 30 days is from the mailing date, that's correct. Worth knowing too that a late appeal can still be considered if you have a good reason for missing the deadline, but it's way easier to just file on time.

0 coins

Oath part surprised me the most. You raise your hand, the judge puts you under oath, and everything you say is official testimony. I'd prepped pretty casually assuming it would be like a conversation - it felt more formal than I expected even though it was a phone hearing in my case.

0 coins

Are most of these done over the phone or do I have to go somewhere in person?

0 coins

Depends on the case - the Notice of Hearing will say whether it's by phone or in person. Phone hearings are common. Either way the oath and the formality are the same.

0 coins

My hearing was by phone and I actually preferred it - easier to have all my documents spread out in front of me without worrying about bringing physical copies somewhere.

0 coins

Lost my first appeal because I froze when the judge asked me to explain the specific dates. The dates matter so much - go through the denial notice, your own records, and your doctor's notes and build a clear timeline. Write it down with just the dates and what happened each day so you can refer to it without searching through papers under pressure.

0 coins

How specific did the questions get? Like individual absence by individual absence?

0 coins

Every single one in my case. The judge went through each date on my termination paperwork and asked what happened. Having a one-page chronology would have saved me.

0 coins

This is a great point - the employer submitted specific dates as the basis for the misconduct claim, and the judge examines each one. Generic statements about being a good employee don't hold up the way specific evidence for specific dates does.

0 coins

Was really worried my employer would bring a stack of documentation I'd never seen. You can actually ask for the employer's submitted materials in advance - contact the Office of Appeals after you get your Notice of Hearing and ask what documents have been submitted by both sides. Knowing what they're working with helps you prepare your response.

0 coins

Had no idea that was an option. Going to do that this week.

0 coins

Yes - and if there's something in their documents you disagree with factually, you want to know about it before you're on the spot in the hearing.

0 coins

The appeals process is meant to give both sides a fair shot. Requesting to see submitted materials is completely normal and judges expect it.

0 coins

The DE 429Z came in my mail showing a weekly amount but EDD had already issued a disqualification on top of it - nothing was moving in UI Online for weeks. Got on the phone with an EDD agent through Claimyr and she confirmed my appeal was logged and that my Claim History showed pending weeks from before the disqualification. She walked me through what the pending status meant and said to keep certifying so those weeks would be there if the judge decided in my favor.

0 coins

The DE 429Z - that's the award notice showing what the weekly amount would be, right? Not an approval of the actual claim?

0 coins

Right, the DE 429Z just shows the calculated weekly amount based on your earnings. It doesn't mean EDD decided you're eligible - that comes separately after the appeal resolves if you're denied.

0 coins

I called that letter my approval for two weeks before someone corrected me. It is very easy to mix those up.

0 coins

Misconduct standard gets misunderstood a lot and it cost me in my first round. I reported to work late four times in a row and assumed EDD would side with my employer automatically because I clearly broke the policy. What I learned is that the employer has to prove the behavior was willful - like you knew the rule and deliberately violated it anyway without any real justification. Having reasons, medical or otherwise, is directly relevant to that question.

0 coins

So bringing the doctor's notes isn't just about sympathy - it actually speaks to whether the absences were willful?

0 coins

Exactly. If you were sick and had documentation, that cuts against the idea that you deliberately chose to violate the policy. That's the core of your argument.

0 coins

Yep. The question the judge is really asking is not whether you violated a policy but whether that violation was misconduct under the law. Those aren't automatically the same thing.

0 coins

What the judge does after the hearing - this tripped me up. There's no decision at the end of the call. The judge takes all the testimony and evidence and then mails a written decision. If you disagree with that decision, you have another level of appeal to the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board itself. So losing at the hearing level is not the end of the road.

0 coins

How long does the written decision usually take to arrive?

0 coins

Honestly I can't give you a number on that - mine took a while but I've heard it varies. EDD or the Office of Appeals would know better.

0 coins

The important thing is that you read the decision the moment it arrives and note the mailing date. If you want to appeal further, that date starts another deadline clock.

0 coins

Tried to get my employer's HR rep to confirm in writing before the hearing that they'd notified me properly about the attendance policy - they ignored me. That's fine. During the hearing I was able to testify that I never received written notice of the final warning they claimed to have issued. The judge took note. You don't need your employer to cooperate before the hearing; just be ready to tell the truth about what you did and didn't receive.

0 coins

They're claiming they gave me a final warning that I never actually received. How do I address that?

0 coins

Testify to exactly what you said - that no written warning reached you. If you kept your work emails or any HR correspondence, check if there's anything that proves communication went one way and not another. Your honest testimony that you never got it is itself evidence.

0 coins

Also check whether the company's own attendance policy says warnings must be given in writing before termination. If their policy required it and they skipped it, that's worth raising.

0 coins

The hearing itself - in my experience it lasted maybe 30 to 45 minutes. The judge introduces everyone, reads the issues from the notice, puts you under oath, and then asks you to tell your side. After that, the employer rep (if any) presents theirs. The judge asks follow-up questions of both sides. Then it's done and you wait for the written decision.

0 coins

That format is really helpful to visualize. I kept picturing something like a courtroom drama.

0 coins

Not quite that intense. It's formal but it's also just two people explaining what happened and a judge sorting it out. The oath makes it feel serious though.

0 coins

Time-wise I'd say 45 minutes is pretty typical. Have a glass of water nearby if it's a phone hearing - you'll be talking a lot.

0 coins

Had a coworker tell me I should just not show up to my hearing because I was definitely going to lose anyway. Terrible advice. Missing the hearing means EDD decides from the information already on file - which at that point is mostly whatever your employer submitted. The appeal exists so you can tell your side.

0 coins

Someone told me something similar - that appealing just makes EDD look at your whole claim harder and might find other problems. That scared me a little.

0 coins

That's not really how it works. The hearing is specifically about the denial issue in your Notice of Determination, not a general audit of your claim. Appeal what's wrong.

0 coins

Agreed - if you have grounds to appeal, appeal. The process is there for exactly this situation and judges actually do rule for claimants regularly.

0 coins

Checked my own past claim files this morning actually - had a disqualification reversed on appeal a while back and the thing that helped most was not over-explaining. Answer what the judge asks, stick to the facts, don't volunteer extra things that could raise new questions. When I rambled about other workplace issues unrelated to the absences, the judge had to redirect me and it probably didn't help my case. Kept it tight the second time and that went much better. Claimyr got me to an EDD agent who clarified which weeks were still in adjudication after my reversal came through - turned out two weeks needed a separate eligibility decision before they'd pay out.

0 coins

The less-is-more advice on testimony is counterintuitive but makes sense. I've been mentally rehearsing long explanations.

0 coins

Short true answer beats long winding answer every time. The judge is experienced and will ask follow-ups if they want more.

0 coins

Had the same rambling problem in my first hearing. Practiced answering questions in two or three sentences max before the second one. Night and day difference.

0 coins

Something nobody mentioned yet - CalJOBS. If you're still certifying during the appeal period, you likely still need to be registered in CalJOBS and have an active resume posted. Missing that requirement can create a whole separate eligibility problem on top of the appeal. Check the Notice of Requirement to Register for Work (DE 8405) if you got one.

0 coins

Went into CalJOBS just now and my registration is still active from when I first filed. Good catch.

0 coins

Good - EDD expects registration within 21 days of that notice going out. While the appeal runs, you're still a claimant and those requirements don't pause.

0 coins

This is a really important one. People in appeals sometimes think they're in a holding pattern where none of the regular rules apply. You still need to be able to work, available for work, and registered in CalJOBS.

0 coins

The written appeal you already mailed - keep a copy of it and anything you included with it. The judge gets that document as part of the file and may reference what you wrote. If you stated facts in your appeal letter that you now want to revise or add to, the hearing is your chance. But what you wrote matters too.

0 coins

I kept it pretty brief in the appeal letter - just said I disagreed with the misconduct finding and listed the dates I had doctor's notes. Should I have written more?

0 coins

Brief is actually fine for the initial appeal letter - you don't have to lay out your entire argument in writing. The hearing is where the detail comes in. What you wrote sets the stage.

0 coins

You can also bring new documents to the hearing that weren't part of the initial appeal filing. The goal is for the judge to have the full picture.

0 coins

Finding local free legal help for appeal hearings is worth looking into - law school clinics, legal aid organizations, some county bar associations have referral programs. You absolutely can represent yourself and many people do successfully. But if your case is complex or you have trouble organizing the facts, a free consultation at minimum might help you structure your argument.

0 coins

Mine feels pretty clear-cut honestly - fired for absences I had documentation for - but I'll keep that option in mind.

0 coins

Clear-cut cases are still worth preparing for carefully. 'I had doctor's notes' is your argument but you have to present it in a way that maps onto the actual questions the judge is asking about willfulness.

0 coins

Agreed - even when the facts are on your side, knowing how to frame them in terms the hearing process cares about makes a difference.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure