Back to California Unemployment

Faith Kingston

What percentage of unemployment should I withhold for taxes on a California EDD claim?

Filing my California EDD claim after getting laid off from my warehouse job last month and I'm trying to plan my finances carefully. Got my DE 429Z and I'm seeing my weekly benefit amount is going to be around $390. What I can't figure out is whether I should have taxes taken out automatically and if so, how much. My buddy told me to just deal with it at tax time next April but that sounds like a recipe for a nasty surprise. Does California EDD let you choose a withholding amount during certification? Is there a standard percentage that most people go with? I'd rather lose a little each week than get hit with a huge bill later.

Got laid off from a restaurant last year and went through exactly this question when I first started certifying. EDD lets you choose whether to have federal income tax taken out at a flat 10 percent of each weekly payment — that's the only option they give you during certification. You flip that switch and 10 percent comes off the top automatically before anything hits your Money Network card. The thing your buddy got wrong is that California state income tax is a different story entirely: unemployment benefits are exempt from California state income tax, so you don't owe Sacramento anything on those dollars. The federal side is what you need to plan for.

0 coins

So the 10 percent federal withholding is the only rate EDD offers — there's no way to choose like 15 or 20 percent through them?

0 coins

EDD's withholding option is set at 10 percent flat, that's it. If you feel like 10 isn't enough based on your other income for the year, you'd need to handle the extra yourself through estimated quarterly payments to the IRS, but that's outside the EDD system.

0 coins

The exempt from California tax part is a relief I did not expect when I looked into this. Federal 10 percent is manageable, way less stressful than I thought going in.

0 coins

EDD withholds only the 10 percent federal option — no state withholding because there's nothing to withhold for California on UI. The choice comes up each time you certify through UI Online at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ or through Tele-Cert. You pick yes or no on the withholding question and 10 percent gets taken before payment posts to your card.

0 coins

Can you change the withholding election between certifications if you decide you want to switch it on or off?

0 coins

You can change it going forward, yes. Whatever you choose on the current certification applies to that payment, and you can choose differently next time. It doesn't retroactively change past payments.

0 coins

Didn't know you could flip it each cycle. Thought once you chose it was locked in for the whole claim.

0 coins

The DE 429Z on my claim showed $375 a week and I was completely lost on the tax question. Claimyr (claimyr.com) is what I ended up using to get a live EDD agent on the phone — there's a video they put out about reaching a live person at EDD that's worth a look: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. I asked the agent whether having no withholding on my first few payments would cause any penalty issues. She pulled up my claim and confirmed the payments already issued had no withholding and said as long as I elected it going forward or handled it through estimated payments I'd be fine with EDD's side — the federal penalty question she said was between me and the IRS but that most people with a single UI claim and no other income do okay at 10 percent for the year.

0 coins

The confirmation that skipping it early doesn't trigger some EDD problem is useful, I'd been worrying about that.

0 coins

Underpayment penalty from the IRS is its own thing separate from EDD — if your total income for the year between UI and any other work is high enough, you'd want to run the numbers with a tax person or use the IRS withholding calculator, not just rely on what EDD offers.

0 coins

My claim started in August and I hadn't turned on withholding for the first month, then switched it on. Curious whether partial-year withholding covers enough of the federal bill come April.

0 coins

10 percent withholding is the ceiling and the floor as far as EDD is concerned. If your weekly benefit is $390, that's $39 taken out per payment, so about $78 each two-week period. Whether that's enough depends on your full tax picture for the year — other income, deductions, filing status. EDD sends a 1099-G each January showing total benefits paid and total withheld so you have exact numbers for your return.

0 coins

The 1099-G — where does that show up, do they mail it or is it somewhere in UI Online?

0 coins

EDD mails a paper 1099-G in January unless you chose paperless. It also shows up in UI Online under Payments and then Form 1099G by January 31, and EDD keeps five years of them there.

0 coins

Got hit by a surprise bill one year before I realized the 1099-G was sitting in UI Online the whole time. Worth checking there first so you have the number before your tax preparer asks.

0 coins

Nobody explained to me when I first filed that the California exemption on state income tax only covers the EDD unemployment benefits themselves, not any wages I earned while partially working. Spent a whole month confused about why my pay stubs still had state withholding while my UI payments had none. Completely different pots of money taxed completely different ways.

0 coins

That distinction makes sense when you spell it out — your wages are still wages even when you're partially on UI. Good to have it clarified.

0 coins

Exactly. And if you're doing partial week certifications where you report some earnings, EDD adjusts the payment using that earnings formula where the first $25 or 25 percent of what you made goes uncounted, whichever is bigger, and reduces the rest from your weekly amount. The tax still follows each type of income separately.

0 coins

The partial work and the earnings formula trip people up constantly on this forum. Glad someone spelled it out cleanly.

0 coins

The 10 percent federal withholding question on my claim came up at an odd time — I'd had some freelance income earlier in the year before the layoff, so I was trying to figure out if 10 percent on the UI payments would leave me short at the federal level. The weekly amount on my claim was $340. I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr about whether the withholding choice changed anything about how EDD processed my payments, and the agent confirmed it doesn't affect eligibility or the amount EDD pays out — 10 percent just routes directly to the IRS on your behalf. I decided to turn on withholding and also made one estimated payment to IRS mid-year to cover the gap from the freelance side.

0 coins

The freelance wrinkle makes this more complicated than my situation but good to know the withholding election itself doesn't mess with how EDD handles the payment.

0 coins

Right, the two are completely separate. EDD calculates your payment based on eligibility and the earnings formula, then the withholding just peels off 10 percent of whatever that final number is before it hits your card.

0 coins

The IRS estimated payment approach is worth knowing about for anyone with mixed income. EDD's 10 percent covers only what comes through EDD, so if you have self-employment or freelance sitting on top of it you can end up short in April.

0 coins

Someone earlier mentioned the 1099-G and I want to add — if you ever get a 1099-G in the mail for a claim you never actually filed, don't try to verify your identity through it or ignore it. EDD has a fraud reporting line and an Ask EDD form specifically for that situation. Happened to someone I know and it was a whole mess.

0 coins

The fraud case is very different from normal withholding questions but useful to flag. The number for reporting a 1099-G on a claim you never filed is 1-866-401-2849 or through the Ask EDD contact form.

0 coins

Yes, 1-866-401-2849 or Ask EDD — and do not verify identity for a claim you didn't file, that's the key thing they stress.

0 coins

Tried to find a third withholding option somewhere in UI Online thinking there had to be more than just yes or no at 10 percent. There isn't. EDD keeps it simple: either you elect the flat 10 percent federal withholding or you handle it yourself. The certification flow just asks the question and you answer it, no percentages to type in.

0 coins

Knowing there's literally nothing else to configure in UI Online on the tax side makes this easier — just turn it on and move on.

0 coins

Pretty much. The only other thing that touches your tax picture through EDD is the 1099-G at year end, which just totals everything up. The withholding decision is the only lever you have.

0 coins

Keeping it simple is probably intentional given how many people are stressed out when they're on UI. One yes/no question is manageable.

0 coins

My first certification I accidentally skipped the withholding question by rushing through and said no without thinking. EDD didn't flag it or stop my payment — it just processed with no withholding that week. I turned it on the next certification and it's been on since. No penalty from EDD's side, the only risk of skipping it is owing more at federal tax time.

0 coins

Good to know rushing through a certification and saying no by accident isn't irreversible — you can just fix it next time.

0 coins

Correct, and if you decide you want to revisit a past week's answer for some reason you'd have to contact EDD directly since the Report Wages option only adjusts wages not the withholding election.

0 coins

The certification flow does move fast if you're not paying attention. Worth slowing down on that specific question.

0 coins

Before my layoff I honestly had no idea unemployment benefits showed up on a federal return at all. The week my DE 429Z arrived I had a lot of questions and ended up getting to an EDD agent through Claimyr to ask specifically whether my benefit amount already had anything deducted or if what I saw on the form was gross. The agent confirmed the weekly benefit amount on the DE 429Z is the gross amount before any withholding and that the 10 percent election happens at each certification going forward, not at the application stage.

0 coins

The 'gross on the DE 429Z' detail is easy to miss. If you see $390 on that form and think that's what lands on the card, you'd be off by $39 each payment once you turn on withholding.

0 coins

Exactly — $390 gross becomes $351 on the card if you elect withholding. Good to know before you're doing budget math and something doesn't add up.

0 coins

The California-exempt piece catches people off guard in both directions. Some folks panic thinking they owe California and they don't, others assume they owe nothing at all and forget about federal entirely. The 10 percent federal withholding through EDD is enough for plenty of people whose only 2026 income is the UI benefits and maybe some part-time work, but if you had a full salary earlier in the year before the layoff you might owe more than 10 percent covers at the federal level.

0 coins

My layoff happened in November so most of my W-2 income is from earlier this year, which means my tax bracket for 2026 is probably still based on my salary not on the UI rate. That could mean 10 percent isn't enough.

0 coins

Exactly that situation is where people get caught. Run your year-to-date wages plus however many weeks of UI you expect through a tax estimator — the IRS has a withholding calculator on their site. EDD's 10 percent is a decent default but not guaranteed to be right for everyone.

0 coins

The IRS withholding calculator is genuinely useful for this. Plug in your W-2 income from the first part of the year and your expected UI and it'll tell you if you need to cover more some other way.

0 coins

Related question — does the withholding election apply per certification period or per individual week when you're certifying two weeks at a time?

0 coins

EDD certifies in two-week periods but the withholding is calculated on each week's payment individually. So if you certify for two weeks and both are paid, 10 percent comes off each week's amount separately.

0 coins

Got it so 10 percent of week one and 10 percent of week two, not 10 percent of the combined total — same end result but good to know how it's calculated.

0 coins

Worth knowing the waiting week plays into the first certification in a way that surprises people. The first time you certify it usually covers the waiting week, which is unpaid, and one paid week. EDD withholds from the paid week but there's nothing to withhold from the waiting week since you don't get paid for it. So your first certification might look odd on the payment side.

0 coins

The waiting week being inside the first certification and being unpaid — does that show up separately in Claim History or does it just show as a lower payment for that period?

0 coins

In Claim History you'd see the waiting week marked accordingly and the paid week separately. The 10 percent withholding only touches the paid week since nothing is paid out for the waiting week.

0 coins

My first payment looked wrong to me until someone explained the waiting week situation. Thought EDD underpaid me by a week.

0 coins

UI benefits being taxable at the federal level and not at the state level is one of those California-specific wrinkles that trips up anyone who filed in a different state before. The 10 percent EDD withholding is federal only, full stop.

0 coins

The federal-only framing is the clearest way to remember it. If EDD is taking 10 percent it's going to the IRS, nothing is going to the state franchise tax board from that payment.

0 coins

Coming from another state previously where the rules were different makes me glad I found this thread — I would have made wrong assumptions about state withholding.

0 coins

My DE 429Z showed up and I had a week before my first certification, so I used that time to run numbers on what 10 percent withholding would actually cover given my earlier salary income. Ended up turning on withholding and also set aside an extra amount in a savings account each payment as a buffer. Talked to an agent through Claimyr about whether EDD had any guidance on additional withholding beyond 10 percent and the agent was straightforward — EDD's system maxes out at the 10 percent federal election, anything extra is on me to handle outside of EDD, through estimated IRS payments or personal savings.

0 coins

The savings account buffer approach while also electing the 10 percent seems like solid belt-and-suspenders planning, especially with prior salary income in the same year.

0 coins

Exactly my thinking. EDD sends the 10 percent to the IRS and I keep a separate stash. At tax time whatever I owe beyond the 10 percent I covered comes out of the savings set aside rather than being a surprise.

0 coins

The Money Network card payments after withholding post pretty quickly once you certify online — usually within a day. So if you turn on the 10 percent withholding you'll see the net amount hit the card and can track it against what your DE 429Z said your gross weekly amount would be. Easy way to confirm EDD processed the withholding election correctly.

0 coins

Tracking the net against the gross weekly amount is a simple way to verify everything went through correctly without having to call anyone.

0 coins

Right, the math is straightforward: gross weekly amount minus 10 percent equals what shows up on the card, give or take rounding. If the number is off you'd want to contact EDD through a UI Online message or the phone line at 1-800-300-5616.

0 coins

The certification question on withholding always felt oddly casual given how significant the tax decision is. It's just sitting there between a couple other questions and easy to click through without thinking.

0 coins

EDD's certification flow is designed to move fast so people certify consistently, but that can backfire when there's a question that actually requires a moment of thought. The withholding one is a good example.

0 coins

If only there was a note in UI Online on that screen reminding people that this affects their federal tax bill — maybe fewer people would click past it accidentally.

0 coins

Someone upthread mentioned the 1099-G being available in UI Online under Payments — just to confirm it stays there for five years so if you're doing prior year taxes or need to verify an old amount you don't have to hunt down a paper form or call EDD.

0 coins

Five years of 1099-Gs in UI Online is actually useful. Filed an amended return for a prior year and was relieved the amount was right there in the account without having to track down the paper.

0 coins

Amended returns and UI income are a whole other headache but at least having the accurate number from EDD's own system makes that part easier.

0 coins

Employer-side reality check: nothing about the withholding election changes when or how EDD pays you. It just splits the payment between the IRS and your card. Your eligibility determination, your work search requirements, your CalJOBS registration — all of that proceeds the same way regardless of whether you elected withholding.

0 coins

That's clarifying — I half worried that checking yes on withholding might trigger some extra review or delay. Good to hear it's completely separate from the eligibility side.

0 coins

Completely separate systems at EDD. The eligibility and adjudication process runs on its own track, withholding is just a payment split at the end.

0 coins

The CalJOBS registration piece is worth its own attention though — most claimants need to register there and post a resume within 21 days of the date on the notice EDD mails, the DE 8405. Missing that can pause payments.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure