Unemployment refiled by phone lower weekly benefit amount how to fix it with California EDD
So I reopened my claim back in October after getting laid off from a warehouse job I'd had for about eight months. My original claim from early last year was still in its benefit year so I called in to reopen it rather than filing brand new. The agent I spoke with walked me through everything on the phone, seemed straightforward. But when my DE 429Z showed up in the mail the weekly benefit amount was noticeably lower than what I expected based on what I was earning at the warehouse. We're talking something like $285 a week when I figured it should be closer to $390 based on my recent paychecks. I think what happened is that my original claim was built on older wages from like 18 months ago, and reopening it just revived those old numbers instead of recalculating with my more recent earnings. The warehouse job paid better than my previous work, so the gap is real and it's hurting. Has anyone dealt with this after refiling by phone? Is there any way to get EDD to look at the new wages and recalculate? Or am I locked into whatever the original base period was?
70 comments

Ryan Young
Ended up in the exact same hole last spring — reopened a claim by phone, saw the amount on my DE 429Z and thought the agent had made a mistake somewhere. Before I figured out what was going on, I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to EDD because the hold times were eating my whole morning. The video explaining how to reach a live person at EDD is at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 if you want to see what it looks like. Anyway I ended up talking to an EDD agent and asked why my weekly amount looked so low. She pulled up my claim and walked me through which quarters were in my base period — it was the standard four quarters, and the warehouse job wages I'd earned recently fell outside that window entirely. The agent said the alternate base period wouldn't help me either because my standard base period already made the claim valid, so EDD wouldn't switch to the alternate. She confirmed the DE 429Z amount was calculated correctly for that base period, then said if anything on the award looked wrong compared to what EDD actually had on record for those quarters, I had 30 days from the mailing date to appeal in writing.
0 coins
Samantha Hall
AuthorThat tracks with what I'm starting to understand about how the base period works. So basically my warehouse earnings just came too recently to count — not an error, just bad timing on when I reopened the claim?
0 coins
Sophia Clark
Yeah the base period thing bites people all the time. If your original claim already had enough wages in the standard four quarters to be valid, they won't use the alternate base period no matter how much more you made recently. The system isn't broken, it's just built in a way that punishes people who earned more in their most recent job.
0 coins
Katherine Harris
Wait so there's literally no recourse if the warehouse wages fall outside the window? That seems like it should be something you can at least dispute.
0 coins
Madison Allen
Worth double-checking your DE 429Z against the actual quarters it lists before doing anything else. The notice should show which calendar quarters EDD used and what wages it has on record for each one. If those numbers match your pay stubs from those quarters, the amount probably isn't wrong — it's just based on older wages like the person above described. But if any of the wage amounts on the form are lower than what your W-2 or pay stubs actually show for those quarters, that's a discrepancy worth appealing because then EDD might genuinely have incomplete information.
0 coins
Samantha Hall
AuthorThe DE 429Z I got doesn't actually list the individual quarterly wages, it just shows the weekly benefit amount and the maximum benefit amount. Where do I find the breakdown of what quarters and wages EDD used?
0 coins
Madison Allen
You'd need to look at the Notice of Unemployment Insurance Award more carefully — sometimes the quarterly breakdown is on a separate page or EDD can tell you over the phone or through a UI Online message what quarters were included. Definitely worth asking because you can't really evaluate whether the amount is right without knowing what wages they counted.
0 coins
Joshua Wood
Mine had the quarterly wage amounts listed right on the second page of the DE 429Z when I got it last year. Maybe it varies or maybe some people get a shorter version of the notice.
0 coins
Justin Evans
Had a question about this whole situation — when you reopen an existing claim by phone versus filing a completely fresh claim, does EDD ever recalculate the base period with newer wages? I always assumed reopening just picks up where you left off but now I'm not sure.
0 coins
Sophia Clark
Reopening uses the same base period as the original claim because it's the same benefit year. A fresh claim filed after the benefit year ends would get a brand new base period calculated from that point, which could potentially pull in more recent wages. The tradeoff is that a new claim takes longer to process and you serve another waiting week.
0 coins
Justin Evans
Ah that makes a lot of sense actually. So the lower amount isn't fixable on this claim — it's just the result of using that same older base period from when the original claim was filed.
0 coins
Emily Parker
right but if the benefit year is about to end or already ended, filing new might actually get you a higher amount if your recent wages qualify. worth checking when your current benefit year runs out
0 coins
Ezra Collins
Something that keeps tripping people up — the alternate base period isn't a magic fix that bumps up your weekly amount. I've seen people in other threads convinced they can request it to get a higher payment, but EDD only uses the alternate base period when your standard base period doesn't have enough wages to make the claim valid at all. If your claim is already valid under the standard period, requesting the alternate does nothing because EDD won't use it. The rule exists to help people qualify, not to give people a higher weekly amount once they're already in.
0 coins
Victoria Scott
Someone in a Facebook group told me I could call EDD and ask them to switch to the alternate base period to get more money. Sounds like that's just wrong then?
0 coins
Ezra Collins
Yeah that's not how it works. The alternate base period is automatic — EDD checks it on its own if the standard period doesn't qualify you. You can't call and ask for it as a way to increase an amount on a claim that's already valid. Whoever said that in the group was probably mixing it up with something else.
0 coins
Victoria Scott
Ugh. I've been holding off calling EDD because I thought I had an option. Back to square one I guess.
0 coins
Benjamin Johnson
The 30 days to appeal the DE 429Z is real though — if you think any of the wage information EDD has is actually wrong, that appeal window is the move. Just have your pay stubs ready.
0 coins
Zara Perez
Have you checked whether your benefit year is still open or if it already ended? Because if the benefit year from your original claim is done, you might be in a position to file a completely new claim right now, and that new claim would pull in a base period that could include the warehouse wages you earned. The timing on this matters a lot.
0 coins
Samantha Hall
AuthorMy benefit year runs through mid-February based on what the DE 429Z shows. So I've got a few months left on this claim. I think I'm stuck with the current amount for now unless I find a way to appeal the wage information.
0 coins
Zara Perez
Then yeah, filing new isn't an option until after mid-February. If you find any error in what EDD has for your wages in the quarters it actually used, appeal within 30 days of the DE 429Z mailing date. If the wages are correct and it's just a base period timing issue, you're probably looking at filing new when this benefit year ends.
0 coins
Daniel Rogers
Quick thought — even if you can't fix the amount now, keeping detailed records of your warehouse earnings means you'll have everything ready when you do file the new claim after February.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
Before my current situation got sorted, I went three weeks trying to get through to EDD about a pending week that wasn't moving. DE 429Z had already come through and my amount looked right, but one specific week was stuck and I couldn't get anyone on the phone. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) and finally got a live EDD agent on the line. She looked at my account and told me the pending week was flagged because a wages question from a part-time gig I had was being reviewed — said to expect a DE 4800 notice about a phone interview for that issue. That cleared up why I was stuck, and I knew what to watch for in the mail after that.
0 coins
Ella Russell
DE 4800 is the interview notice right? I got one of those and had no idea what it meant. Good to know it's just EDD scheduling a call about a specific eligibility question.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
Exactly, it's the notice for the phone interview EDD schedules when there's something they need to ask about. The date and time for the interview are on the form itself and also show up on your UI Online homepage. You just keep your phone nearby at that time.
0 coins
Mohammed Khan
Does the DE 4800 always come before they freeze your payments or do they sometimes hold weeks first and then send the notice?
0 coins
Gavin King
Real frustrating situation and I feel this. The phone refiling process seems simple but it locks you into that old benefit year setup. Had a similar thing happen where my new job before my second layoff paid almost double what I earned in the original base period quarters, and none of those better wages counted toward my weekly amount. EDD's calculator on the site can at least help you model out what a new claim might look like once your benefit year ends, so you're not going in blind when February comes.
0 coins
Samantha Hall
AuthorEDD has a benefits calculator on the site? I didn't know that. I'll look for it — if I can run the numbers on a potential new claim using the warehouse wages, that would at least tell me whether it's worth waiting until the benefit year ends to file fresh.
0 coins
Gavin King
Yeah it's on edd.ca.gov, called the Unemployment Benefit Calculator. It's just an estimate based on what you enter, but it gives you a ballpark figure. The real amount will be on whatever DE 429Z you get from the new claim.
0 coins
Nathan Kim
The calculator is pretty handy for planning. My estimate was off by about $30 from my actual weekly amount, so close enough to be useful when you're trying to figure out whether to wait.
0 coins
Nathan Kim
Something that might matter here — did you certify for any weeks during the period when your warehouse job was active, or was that job during a time when you weren't claiming at all? Because wages from a job you were working while actively certifying would have been reported wages, and those quarters might already be reflected or excluded differently than wages from before the original claim started.
0 coins
Samantha Hall
AuthorThe warehouse job started after my original claim ended — I went back to work, did about eight months there, then got laid off again. So all the warehouse wages came after the original benefit year had paid out. I wasn't certifying at all during those eight months.
0 coins
Nathan Kim
Got it, so those wages are real and documented but they just fall outside the base period window for the reopened claim. That's the core issue. When you file new after February, the standard base period for that claim will cover different quarters and might pull in some or all of the warehouse work depending on exactly when those quarters fall.
0 coins
Eleanor Foster
Paperwork from my warehouse layoff situation got really tangled too. Had a wage discrepancy where EDD had a lower number than my actual earnings for one quarter. Used Claimyr to get through to EDD and talked to an agent who confirmed the wages EDD had on file for that quarter. Turned out my employer had reported my wages late, so EDD's records didn't have the full amount yet. The agent said I should appeal the DE 429Z with my pay stubs to get the correct wages on record, which I did, and the corrected amount came through a few weeks later.
0 coins
Nathan Kim
That's actually useful context — late employer reporting is a real thing that can affect what EDD has on file. Worth cross-referencing what your pay stubs show for the quarters EDD is using, not just assuming their numbers are right.
0 coins
Lucas Turner
Does anyone know if you can appeal the weekly benefit amount on a reopened claim specifically, or is the appeal process the same as for a brand new claim? I'm asking because I reopened mine last month and the amount also seems lower than expected, and I'm not sure if I even have grounds to appeal or if it's just the base period math working against me.
0 coins
Sophia Clark
Appeal process is the same either way — you have 30 days from the mailing date on your DE 429Z to appeal in writing. The form to use is the DE 1000M, which should come with the notice, or you can send a letter to the address on the notice. The key thing is knowing what you're appealing: if the wages EDD used are correct for the base period quarters, the amount is probably right. If EDD has the wrong wage amounts for those quarters, that's what you'd be disputing.
0 coins
Lucas Turner
My DE 429Z mailing date was about three weeks ago so I'd need to move fast if I'm appealing. I'll dig out my pay stubs tonight and compare them to whatever quarterly wage info I can get from EDD.
0 coins
Benjamin Johnson
The 30-day appeal window on the DE 429Z is something people sleep on. I've seen folks come back to these threads six weeks after getting the notice saying they want to dispute it, and by then the window is already shut. If you have any doubt about the wages EDD used — wrong quarter, wrong employer amount, anything — appeal first and gather docs at the same time. You can always withdraw an appeal if you find out the numbers were right.
0 coins
Katherine Harris
Can you actually withdraw an appeal once you've submitted it? I didn't know that was possible.
0 coins
Benjamin Johnson
Yes, you can withdraw. The appeal goes through EDD first, and if it goes to the CUIAB hearing level, you can still withdraw before the hearing. Better to file and then drop it than to miss the deadline entirely.
0 coins
Kai Rivera
Filing and then deciding you don't need it seems way less stressful than scrambling to meet a deadline. Good call.
0 coins
Mohammed Khan
What counts as a 'discrepancy' that's worth appealing versus just the base period math doing what it does? Like if EDD correctly used older lower-wage quarters and the amount is accurate for those quarters, is there anything to appeal or do you just have to accept it?
0 coins
Madison Allen
If the wages EDD has for those quarters are accurate, the amount is correct and there's not really grounds for an appeal on the amount itself. What you can appeal is if EDD has the wrong wages — say your employer reported less than you actually earned, or EDD attributed wages to the wrong quarter. That's a factual error. 'I earned more in a different period' isn't an error, it's just how the base period works.
0 coins
Mohammed Khan
That's a clear way to put it. So the question to ask is whether EDD's records match my actual earnings for the specific quarters they used, not whether those quarters had my best earnings.
0 coins
Ella Russell
Tried calling EDD three different mornings this week and got the 'high call volume' message and the line dropped each time. For people in this situation who need to actually talk to someone about their wage records and base period questions, any advice on getting through that's actually worked?
0 coins
Joshua Wood
Early mornings right when they open at 8 have worked better for me than trying mid-morning. But even then it's not guaranteed — some days the lines are just slammed.
0 coins
Ella Russell
Tried 8:01 on Tuesday and still hit the high volume message. It's genuinely demoralizing when you have a specific question that you can't answer without talking to someone.
0 coins
Gavin King
The UI Online live chat through the Help button works Monday to Friday, 9 to 2. I've had luck there for simpler questions, though for base period wage questions they sometimes tell you to call anyway.
0 coins
Kai Rivera
My situation was different but the weekly amount confusion is real. When my DE 429Z came I thought the max benefit amount was my weekly amount and I was calculating how long my claim would last based on the wrong number. Took me a week to realize I'd been reading the form wrong and my actual weekly amount was lower than I thought.
0 coins
Samantha Hall
AuthorOh no — that's actually a mistake I could see myself making. The form has a few different dollar figures on it and it's not super clear at first glance which one is what.
0 coins
Kai Rivera
Exactly. The weekly benefit amount and the maximum benefit amount are both on there and the max is a much bigger number so your eye goes to it. Worth reading it carefully and making sure you know which line is which.
0 coins
Emily Parker
the max is just your weekly amount times 26 weeks basically (or less if your total base period wages cap it out). once you know that it's easier to keep them straight
0 coins
Sophia Clark
If you end up needing to file a new claim after your benefit year ends in February, keep in mind the new claim starts on the Sunday of the week you apply and you'll have another waiting week before the first paid week. Don't wait until March to file — file the week your current benefit year actually ends so you're not leaving any weeks uncovered.
0 coins
Samantha Hall
AuthorGood to know. I've been thinking of February as a hard deadline but I guess I should track the exact end date and file right at that point rather than whenever I get around to it.
0 coins
Sophia Clark
The claim year end date should be on your DE 429Z. Mark it and apply that same week — the new base period for that claim will be the first four of the last five completed quarters as of when you apply, so the timing of when you file matters.
0 coins
Justin Evans
is there a way to file early like a week before the benefit year ends or does it have to be after the year is fully done
0 coins
Sophia Clark
Has to be a new application, and EDD processes it from the Sunday of the week you apply. If your benefit year is still active you're on the existing claim. Once it ends you can apply and that starts the new one.
0 coins
Katherine Harris
Honest question that might be dumb — if you file a brand new claim instead of reopening, do you lose whatever weeks you have left on your current claim? Like is reopening always better than starting fresh when you still have balance left?
0 coins
Ezra Collins
If your benefit year is still open and you have weeks and balance left, you can't use those weeks on a new separate claim. You'd still be on the existing one. A new claim only starts when the benefit year ends or if you're starting from a completely different qualifying period. So no, reopening isn't something you're choosing over a new claim right now — if the benefit year is active, reopening is what you do.
0 coins
Katherine Harris
Okay that makes more sense. So the choice between reopen and file new only really comes up once the benefit year is actually over.
0 coins
Joshua Wood
Have you tried sending a message through UI Online to ask EDD directly what quarterly wages they have on file for your claim? Sometimes that's faster than calling, especially for a simple 'what numbers do you have' question. They usually respond within a few business days and it creates a written record of what EDD told you.
0 coins
Samantha Hall
AuthorI hadn't thought about UI Online messaging for this — I've only been thinking about calling. I'll try that this week to at least get the quarterly breakdown in writing before the appeal window closes.
0 coins
Joshua Wood
Messages through UI Online also give you something to reference if you end up appealing. 'EDD confirmed in a message on this date that they had X wages for quarter Y' is useful documentation.
0 coins
Emily Parker
the alternate base period confusion gets me every time i see it in these threads. people think they can just ask for it and get more money but that's not what it's for. EDD automatically looks at the alternate only if the standard period leaves you with not enough wages to qualify at all. if you're already qualified, alternate doesn't come into play, period
0 coins
Victoria Scott
Someone should sticky this in every EDD thread because this confusion is constant.
0 coins
Ezra Collins
Agreed — and what makes it worse is that people conflate two separate things: qualifying for a claim at all versus the amount the claim pays. Alternate base period addresses the first one, it doesn't touch the second.
0 coins
Daniel Rogers
For anyone coming to this thread later with the same situation — the short version: reopening a claim uses the same base period as the original filing, so more recent higher wages may not count. If you think EDD's wage records for the quarters they used are wrong, you have 30 days from the DE 429Z mailing date to appeal with your actual pay stubs. If the wages are correct but just from an older lower-paid period, the amount is accurate and you'd need to wait for the current benefit year to end before filing a new claim that could use more recent wages. The EDD Unemployment Benefit Calculator on edd.ca.gov can help you estimate what a new claim might look like.
0 coins
Samantha Hall
AuthorThis is the clearest summary of my situation I've seen in this thread. Thank you — I now understand what's actually happening with my claim and what my actual options are.
0 coins
Zara Perez
Worth pinning to the top of this whole thread honestly. The base period explanation is the key thing most people are missing when they're confused about why the amount came out lower than expected.
0 coins
Benjamin Johnson
The appeal window point is critical. 30 days from the mailing date goes fast, especially if you spent the first two weeks confused about whether there was even a problem.
0 coins