Back to California Unemployment

Mei Chen

Unemployment pending after quitting job for lower paying work study job - California EDD question

So I'm stuck in this weird limbo and don't know what to expect. I had a full-time customer service job paying around $22/hour and left it in September to take a work study position at the community college I enrolled in. The work study pays about $14/hour and is only 12 hours a week, so obviously the income dropped dramatically. The work study ended up getting cut after just three weeks because of budget stuff, so now I have basically nothing coming in. I filed for unemployment right away and have been certifying every two weeks like I'm supposed to, but everything shows as Pending in my Claim History on UI Online. I figured there might be a question about why I quit my full-time job, but I haven't received any notice scheduling an interview or anything explaining what EDD needs from me. It's been almost four weeks now and I'm starting to really stress about rent. The thing that confuses me is whether the fact that I took ANOTHER job (even though it was lower paying and part-time) makes my quit look worse or better to EDD. Did I shoot myself in the foot by quitting for a work study job specifically? Has anyone dealt with a quit situation that led to a different job before filing for unemployment? I have no idea what to expect from this process.

Work study on my claim was the exact thing that tangled everything up for me last year. EDD had my weeks pending for almost six weeks while they sorted out the employment status of my campus job. I ended up getting through to a live EDD agent using Claimyr (claimyr.com) - there's a video on reaching a live person at EDD at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The agent pulled up my file and told me a phone interview had been scheduled but the notice went to an old address, so I'd missed the whole thing. She gave me the reschedule process and my payments released about a week and a half after that. The work study question itself wasn't the hold-up - it was the missed interview.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

Four weeks in and nothing in my UI Online about any interview being scheduled - this actually worries me that mine might be the same situation. Did the agent say anything about what happens when you've missed the interview window?

0 coins

Address issue got me too. My DE 4800 went somewhere I hadn't lived in two years. EDD really should let you update the address mid-claim more easily.

0 coins

If you missed the interview, calling EDD that same day is the move - the longer you wait, the worse it gets for getting those weeks released.

0 coins

The pending status when you quit for another job before that job also ended - EDD is basically looking at two separate things. First, did leaving your full-time job meet their standard for a 'good reason.' Second, did you then lose the work study for a reason that makes you eligible now. The fact that you moved to a job, even a lower-paying one, doesn't automatically kill your claim. But EDD will interview you about the original quit before they pay anything.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

So they look at the quit from the full-time job first, before even considering that the work study ended? I was hoping the fact that the work study ended through no fault of mine would sort of reset things.

0 coins

My layoff and a resignation were on the same claim and EDD separated them out exactly that way - adjudicated the quit first, separately from why I eventually lost work.

0 coins

Yeah the quit is the sticking point here not the work study ending. EDD doesn't care that the second job ended through no fault of yours if they haven't cleared the original quit yet.

0 coins

My phone interview notice came on a DE 4800 and I almost missed it because I thought it was junk mail. The letter gives you the date and time and also says it shows up on your UI Online homepage. If yours isn't showing up anywhere, the interview might not be scheduled yet - or the notice went somewhere wrong like the person above said.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

Just checked my UI Online homepage again after reading this - still nothing about an interview scheduled. So either EDD hasn't set it yet or the notice went astray like you all are saying.

0 coins

My DE 4800 showed up in UI Online a few days before the paper letter hit my mailbox. Worth checking the homepage every day if you're in this situation.

0 coins

The notice really does have the question topics listed on it which helps you think about what to say. Missing that letter is worse than people realize.

0 coins

Quitting for school-related work was something my adjudicator asked about pretty specifically during my phone interview. She wanted to know if I'd been told the work study would be ongoing, what I understood about the hours and pay going in, and whether I'd tried to negotiate keeping the original job while attending school. EDD basically wants to understand your reasoning, not just the outcome.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

That's helpful to know. I did ask my original employer about reduced hours to accommodate school and they said no - would that matter to EDD?

0 coins

Yes, absolutely bring that up. Requesting reduced hours and being denied is exactly the kind of thing EDD considers when deciding if leaving had a good reason behind it.

0 coins

Tried to stay, employer said no, then left - that's the story EDD wants to hear. Document anything you have showing that conversation happened.

0 coins

EDD's own language on this is something like 'if you quit, you need to show that you had a good reason.' That's the whole standard - they don't define what good reason means in a list, they just evaluate your specific situation. So 'I quit a $22/hour job for a $14/hour part-time job' by itself isn't going to fly, but 'I requested accommodation to pursue school and was refused, so I took the only position available to me as a student' is a genuinely different story.

0 coins

This framing really matters going into the interview. Same situation landed differently for two people I know - one got paid, one got denied - and the main difference was how they explained the decision-making process, not the facts themselves.

0 coins

My denial came as a DE 1080CZ and I appealed it in writing within the 30 days. The appeal form DE 1000M was attached. I should have framed things better in the first interview but at least I knew I could appeal.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

Reading this I feel a lot better about my chances. The employer refused my request for reduced hours, so I really did exhaust my options before leaving.

0 coins

Budget cuts ended my campus job too, back in spring. That part - the work study ending - went through EDD totally smoothly since it was clearly not my fault. But the pending weeks were from a different issue on my file: EDD flagged that I'd had a gap between my last employer and work study start where I apparently earned a small amount doing some freelance work I'd forgotten to mention on the application. I got on the phone with an EDD agent through Claimyr and she went through my claim line by line, told me exactly which week was flagged and why, and I was able to submit a wage correction the same day.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

Freelance income during that gap - that's a good reminder. I did a couple of small gigs between jobs that I need to make sure I reported correctly.

0 coins

Wages for the week they were earned, not when the payment came in - that's how EDD wants you to report it. Easy to get that backwards.

0 coins

EDD's Report Wages feature in UI Online handles this before you certify but doesn't fix a week that's already been submitted. For past weeks you have to contact EDD directly.

0 coins

Something nobody's said yet: your base period wages matter a lot here. The weekly benefit amount comes from your highest-paid quarter in the base period, and if most of that was your full-time job at $22/hour, your potential weekly amount could be decent. But if EDD decides the quit from that job wasn't for a good reason, they might look at whether the work study wages alone are enough to establish a valid claim. Might be worth checking EDD's Unemployment Benefit Calculator to see what you're potentially eligible for based on those wages.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

I hadn't even thought about whether the work study wages alone would be enough to establish a valid claim. That's a whole other thing to worry about.

0 coins

The standard is at least $1,300 in one quarter of your base period, or $900 in the highest quarter with total wages adding up to 1.25 times that. Three weeks of work study at 12 hours probably doesn't get you there, so the full-time wages are what your claim is likely built on.

0 coins

Exactly - which is why the question of whether the full-time job quit had a good reason is really the whole ballgame here. If EDD disqualifies that, there may not be a valid claim left to pay.

0 coins

My first unemployment claim after leaving a job for school-adjacent work, EDD asked during the interview whether I was able to work full time and available for full-time work. Work study sometimes raises that question because they assume students in work study programs have class restrictions. Make sure you're clear that you're available and able to work full-time hours when you certify.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

Oh that's something I hadn't considered. I am available for full-time work - my school schedule is evenings only - but I should probably be ready to explain that.

0 coins

Availability is a certification question too. Every week you certify you're confirming you were able and available for work that week. Being a student doesn't disqualify you but EDD can ask about it.

0 coins

My interviewer specifically asked about class schedule and whether I had any restrictions on what shifts I could accept. Have a clear answer ready - it goes smoother.

0 coins

Posting because I went through almost this exact setup a couple years ago and ended up getting paid. Left a full-time retail job for a part-time campus bookstore position when I re-enrolled. The interview focused on whether my request to go part-time at the original job had been denied - it had - and whether I'd tried to find other full-time work before or after the campus job ended. I had applied to a few places during the transition period, which helped. The adjudicator seemed to view the whole thing as one continuous chain of events rather than two separate employment choices.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

This is genuinely encouraging. I did apply to a couple of places after the work study got cut, so I have some work search activity to point to as well.

0 coins

Keeping records of where you applied matters - dates, company names, positions. EDD can ask about work search activities during the claim period.

0 coins

My records were pretty informal just a notes app list but I had dates and company names. That was enough when asked.

0 coins

Four weeks of pending with no interview scheduled is on the longer side. You might want to try messaging EDD through your UI Online account to ask what's happening with your claim rather than just waiting it out. Sometimes a message gets someone to look at the file and either schedule the interview or tell you what's missing.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

Can you message EDD through UI Online about a pending claim status? I hadn't realized that was an option, I thought the messages were only for other things.

0 coins

There's a message option in your UI Online account - you can send EDD a question about your claim and they usually respond within a few business days. Not as fast as the phone but it creates a record.

0 coins

My UI Online message about pending weeks got a response in about four days pointing me to what document they were waiting on. Worth doing if calling isn't working out.

0 coins

The timing of the quit relative to when the work study was set to begin might matter too. EDD sometimes treats it differently when you left one job to start another versus when you left and then had a gap before the new job began. If the work study start date was essentially immediate after leaving your full-time position, that shows you were making a planned transition, not just quitting impulsively.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

The timing was actually almost immediate - maybe five days between my last day at the full-time job and my first work study shift. I have both dates documented.

0 coins

Five days is essentially a direct transition. That kind of continuity of intent tends to work in your favor when explaining the situation to EDD.

0 coins

Bring documentation if you have it - offer letters, emails, anything with dates. EDD phone interviews are verbal but the agent can note what you've told them.

0 coins

My denial after a quit came in as a Notice of Determination and the Appeal Form DE 1000M was attached. I want to make sure people know you have 30 calendar days from the mailing date on the notice to appeal in writing - not 30 business days. And you should keep certifying during the appeal because EDD can only release payment for weeks that were certified. Missing certifications during an appeal is a costly mistake.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

Good to know about keeping up certifications during an appeal. I've been certifying every two weeks even with everything pending - glad I'm doing that right at least.

0 coins

Appeals go to CUIAB - the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board - and you get a hearing with an administrative law judge. It's not as scary as it sounds but you do need to present your case clearly.

0 coins

The judge hearing is under oath and they give you a chance to tell your side. Having a clear written timeline of events helps a lot.

0 coins

Two weeks of pending turned into seven on my claim after I quit a retail manager role to take a university IT support position that was hourly part-time. EDD held everything while they looked at the quit. I eventually talked to an EDD agent through Claimyr - she found that my file had been assigned to an adjudicator but the interview hadn't been booked yet because of a backlog. She said to expect a DE 4800 within about two weeks. It did show up, I did the interview, and three of my pending weeks got approved.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

Seven weeks is a long time to wait. Knowing that sometimes it's just a backlog and not something wrong with the claim is oddly reassuring.

0 coins

Adjudication backlog at EDD is real. My claim sat for five weeks once just because of volume, not because anything was wrong with it.

0 coins

Before your phone interview, write out your timeline in plain language: what date you gave notice, what conversations you had with your employer about alternatives, what date the work study offer came through, what you understood about the work study position's stability, and what date it ended and why. Reviewing that before the interview keeps you from getting flustered when the questions come fast.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

Writing the timeline out is a great idea. I've been keeping mental notes but actually putting it in writing will help me stay organized during the call.

0 coins

Add any emails or documents to that too - you can reference them during the interview even if you can't submit them in the moment. Knowing you have backup helps your confidence.

0 coins

My interviewer appreciated when I said things like 'I have an email from my manager dated X that confirms they declined my request' - it shows you're not just making things up.

0 coins

Couple of things worth noting from my own experience: EDD looks at the base period wages to calculate your weekly benefit amount, and that runs from $40 to $450 a week in California. Even if most of your strong earnings came from the full-time job you quit, those wages still count in the base period calculation as long as they fall in the right quarters. I had a situation where my claim WBA came out to $387 based almost entirely on wages from a job I'd resigned from, and EDD still paid me after the interview cleared the quit. Used Claimyr to reach EDD when my DE 429Z showed a weird number and the agent walked me through exactly which quarter was used.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

The DE 429Z is the Notice of Unemployment Insurance Award right? I got that in the mail and the weekly amount seems to reflect my full-time wages which is a relief.

0 coins

Yes, that's the one. If anything looks wrong on it, you have 30 days from the mailing date to appeal it in writing.

0 coins

DE 429Z shows what the claim could pay if approved - it's based on wages, not a final yes or no on eligibility. Easy to confuse it for an approval letter but it isn't one.

0 coins

One thing that sometimes trips people up in quit situations: if EDD decides the quit doesn't qualify, they might still look at whether you have enough wages from other periods to establish a valid claim through an alternate base period. EDD runs the alternate automatically if the standard base period doesn't produce a valid claim. It doesn't get used to bump up your weekly amount if the standard period already works, but it can sometimes save a claim that would otherwise fail.

0 coins

Alternate base period uses the last four completed quarters. Standard is the first four of the last five. EDD switches to it on its own - you don't have to request it.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

I didn't know there was an alternate base period option. This whole system has so many layers to it that I hadn't even begun to understand.

0 coins

Most people never need to think about it because the standard base period covers them. But it's good to know it exists if your recent wages are significantly higher than your older ones.

0 coins

My work search requirement started right away after I filed even though my claim was still pending. EDD expects you to be actively looking for work every week you certify, regardless of the pending status. Keeping notes somewhere about where you applied and when is just a smart habit during this process.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

I've been applying to jobs while waiting, mostly because I need income, but I should keep better records of that for EDD purposes.

0 coins

Even informal notes - company name, date, position - are worth keeping. EDD doesn't require you to submit work search logs but you should have them if asked.

0 coins

EDD doesn't publish a specific number of contacts you have to make each week - just that you have to be actively looking. So don't stress over hitting an exact count, just actually be searching.

0 coins

My CalJOBS registration was something I almost forgot about while dealing with all the pending stress. EDD sends a Notice of Requirement to Register for Work - DE 8405 - and you have 21 days from the date on that notice to register on CalJOBS and post a resume. Missing that deadline can hold up payments. If you haven't gotten that notice yet, watch for it.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

I think I did get something about CalJOBS early on and completed it, but now I'm second-guessing myself. I should log in and confirm my registration is showing as complete.

0 coins

CalJOBS is at caljobs.ca.gov - you can log in and check your registration status and whether your resume is listed as active. Doesn't hurt to verify.

0 coins

My CalJOBS registration somehow wasn't linked to my EDD claim at first and I had to call EDD to sort it out. Worth confirming they see it on their end.

0 coins

If EDD denies the claim after the phone interview, the Notice of Determination comes with a DE 1000M appeal form. Some people assume the denial is final but it really isn't - the appeals process through CUIAB is a whole separate step where an administrative law judge hears both sides. I've seen people win appeals that looked pretty difficult on paper by just clearly explaining what happened and why they made the choices they did.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

Good to have the full picture even if I'm hoping not to need the appeals process. Knowing there's a next step if things go wrong makes this less terrifying.

0 coins

Appeals are more common than people think and the judge hearing isn't as intimidating as it sounds. You can represent yourself and just tell your story under oath.

0 coins

Submit the appeal in writing within 30 days of the mailing date on the denial notice - that deadline is firm and a late appeal needs a written reason for missing it.

0 coins

Circling back to the original question about whether quitting for lower-paying work study hurts you - EDD isn't going to penalize you just for taking a pay cut. What they want to know is whether the original decision to leave your full-time job had solid reasoning behind it. The fact that you tried to stay by requesting reduced hours and were refused is a meaningful fact in your favor. The fact that you immediately moved to another job rather than just quitting cold also shows intent. Neither of those guarantees anything but together they build a reasonable case for 'good reason.

0 coins

Agreed - the story you can tell matters as much as the raw facts. 'I tried to stay, couldn't, transitioned directly, then lost that job through no fault of mine' is a coherent narrative.

0 coins

Mei Chen

Author

Hearing it laid out that way gives me more confidence going into the interview. I actually do have a reasonable story, I just needed to understand how EDD would frame the question.

0 coins

The interviewer isn't there to trap you. They're trying to gather information. Answer the questions directly and don't overthink it - volunteering extra information that wasn't asked for can sometimes create new questions.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure