Unemployment benefit amount lower after refiling when benefit year ended - what happened?
My benefit year ended last month and I had to file a brand new claim since I'm still out of work. The whole process seemed fine until I got my DE 429Z in the mail and my new weekly benefit amount is $87 less than what I was getting on my old claim. I didn't expect it to be identical but I genuinely don't understand why there's such a big drop. My situation hasn't changed dramatically - I was laid off from the same industry, same general wage history. Is this normal when you refile after a benefit year ends? Did anyone else experience this and figure out why their new weekly amount came out lower? I'm budgeting around this and $87 less per week is actually a significant difference for me right now.
68 comments

Zainab Ahmed
Layoff notice came March of this year, so my situation is pretty close to yours - I refiled after my benefit year ended and my new weekly amount dropped by about $110. Spent two weeks confused before I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to an EDD agent. The video they have on reaching a live person at EDD - https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 - made it clear what I was actually calling about. Asked the agent why my new DE 429Z showed a lower weekly benefit amount than my previous claim, and she pulled up my claim and explained that the base period for the new claim covers different calendar quarters than the first one did. The quarters that had my highest wages from before the layoff had already rolled out of the calculation window, so the highest quarter they were looking at now was lower. That's why the weekly amount dropped. Ended up accepting it and adjusted my budget accordingly.
0 coins
Connor Gallagher
Pulling up my own DE 429Z right now after reading this. Mine dropped too and I had no idea the base period quarters actually shift when you refile. That explains so much.
0 coins
Miguel Diaz
AuthorThe base period shifting is exactly what I needed to understand. So basically the quarters with my best paychecks are no longer in the window they're calculating from. That would completely explain the drop.
0 coins
AstroAlpha
Same thing happened when my benefit year ended in August. The quarters with my highest earnings from when I was still fully employed had rotated out. Nobody warned me that would happen.
0 coins
Yara Khoury
$87 less per week would throw off my whole budget too. The way the base period works is that EDD looks at the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters before your new claim started. When you filed the first time, your strongest earning quarters were probably inside that window. By the time your benefit year ended and you refiled, the calendar moved forward enough that those same quarters fell outside the window and got replaced by quarters where you earned less - probably because you were already on unemployment or working reduced hours.
0 coins
Miguel Diaz
AuthorReread your explanation twice and it clicked. Those quarters where I was earning full salary are just gone from the calculation now. The quarters they're pulling in are ones where I had reduced income. I wish EDD explained this somewhere obvious on the DE 429Z itself.
0 coins
Keisha Taylor
EDD really should put a plain-language note on the DE 429Z that the base period shifts with each new claim. Would save so many people from panicking.
0 coins
Paolo Longo
$450 is the maximum weekly amount in California anyway, so if someone's first claim was near that ceiling the drop might not be as dramatic, but for people in the middle range like this it really hits.
0 coins
Amina Bah
The alternate base period came up when I refiled and I thought it was going to fix my lower weekly amount. Someone at my job center told me it would bump my payment back up. That turned out to be wrong - the alternate base period only matters if the standard one doesn't give you enough wages to have a valid claim at all. It doesn't recalculate a higher weekly amount if your standard base period already qualifies you. Lost two days chasing that before I figured it out.
0 coins
Yara Khoury
The job center person got that wrong, unfortunately. The alternate base period - the last four completed quarters instead of the first four of the last five - only kicks in automatically when the standard window doesn't get you to a valid claim. Once you're valid on the standard base period, the alternate one doesn't come into play to raise your weekly amount.
0 coins
Miguel Diaz
AuthorGlad you said this because I was about to ask EDD about the alternate base period as my next step. Sounds like it won't help my situation since my new claim is valid, just lower than before.
0 coins
Oliver Becker
The job center told me the same thing about the alternate base period once and I spent a week expecting a higher payment that never came. Frustrating when the advice from people who are supposed to help is just wrong.
0 coins
CosmicCowboy
Had a conversation with someone in my building going through the same thing - her first weekly amount was $312 and after refiling it came to $241. She kept calling it an 'error' and wanted to file an appeal. I had to explain to her that if the DE 429Z number looks wrong, she has 30 days from the mailing date on that notice to appeal in writing, but if the base period just shifted and her actual wages in those quarters were lower, an appeal probably won't change anything because EDD calculated it correctly from what was actually earned.
0 coins
Miguel Diaz
AuthorAppeal in writing within 30 days of the mailing date - I didn't realize that was even an option on the DE 429Z. I looked at mine and I'm past that window now anyway, but good to know for anyone else reading this.
0 coins
Natasha Orlova
The appeal window on the DE 429Z catches a lot of people off guard. 30 days goes fast when you're dealing with everything else a job loss brings.
0 coins
Javier Cruz
If the wages they used to calculate it were actually wrong - like a quarter was missing or a paycheck wasn't counted - that's worth appealing. But if it's just the base period shifting with time, the math is probably right even if the result stings.
0 coins
Emma Thompson
Used to work in HR and saw a lot of people go through this confusion. The part that surprises everyone is that your weekly benefit amount on a new claim has nothing to do with what you were getting before. EDD doesn't look at your previous claim when calculating the new one - it starts fresh from whatever wages are in the new base period window, finds your highest quarter in that window, and runs the math from there. If your highest quarter in the new window is lower than it was in the old one, your weekly amount will be lower.
0 coins
Malik Jackson
Starts fresh every time is the part I didn't get. I assumed there was some continuity between claims. Good to know it's completely independent.
0 coins
Isabella Costa
Quarters where I was actually working full time had shifted out of my window too when I refiled. Used Claimyr to get an agent on the phone about it because I thought EDD had made an error on my wages. The agent confirmed my wages were recorded correctly - the high-earning quarters were just outside the base period now. Went back and updated my budget that same afternoon.
0 coins
Miguel Diaz
AuthorKnowing it starts completely fresh actually makes the math clearer even if the result is frustrating. At least it's not arbitrary.
0 coins
StarSurfer
The minimum weekly benefit amount in California is $40 and the maximum is $450, but most people don't realize how much your weekly amount can swing between claims if your highest quarter in the new base period is significantly different from the old one. Even a $5,000 difference in that highest quarter can translate to a noticeable change in what you get each week.
0 coins
Keisha Taylor
The range from $40 to $450 is wider than I thought. Someone getting near the minimum would barely be covering groceries.
0 coins
Connor Gallagher
EDD has an Unemployment Benefit Calculator on its site that lets you plug in quarterly wages and see an estimate. Useful for anyone wondering what their new claim might look like before the DE 429Z arrives.
0 coins
AstroAlpha
My benefit year ended in September and when I refiled I was really worried the new claim wouldn't even be valid because I had quarters where I earned almost nothing while on unemployment. The standard base period ended up being valid because one of the quarters before I lost my job still had decent wages. Weekly amount dropped by $94 though.
0 coins
Yara Khoury
To have a valid California claim you need at least $1,300 in one quarter of the base period, or at least $900 in your highest quarter with total base period wages of 1.25 times that. The fact that some quarters had little income doesn't automatically invalidate the claim as long as the wage thresholds somewhere in the window are met.
0 coins
AstroAlpha
Exactly what happened with mine. One strong quarter saved the claim but the weekly amount still dropped because that strong quarter was lower than the one I had in my first claim.
0 coins
Ravi Malhotra
Good to know there's a validity floor. Had been wondering if I'd even qualify for a second claim at all.
0 coins
Freya Christensen
Waiting week tripped me up when I refiled too. Thought since I'd served it on my first claim I wouldn't have to do it again. Nope - every new claim has its own one-week unpaid waiting period. DE 429Z came and I went straight to certifying thinking I'd see payment for both weeks and only one week paid. Tried calling EDD for days with no luck before I ended up talking to an agent through Claimyr - asked about the missing week payment and the agent confirmed the first week certified is the waiting week on the new claim and doesn't pay out.
0 coins
Malik Jackson
Serves a waiting week on every new claim is news to me. Assumed it was a one-time thing for your lifetime of claims. That's a painful surprise when you're already short on cash.
0 coins
StarSurfer
The waiting week doesn't change the total the claim can pay - it's just unpaid upfront. But when you're counting on that first payment to cover rent it doesn't feel like a small thing.
0 coins
Miguel Diaz
AuthorHadn't thought about the waiting week applying again on the new claim. Something else to plan for.
0 coins
Omar Hassan
CalJOBS registration caught me off guard when I refiled. I had been registered from my first claim but I got a new Notice of Requirement to Register for Work (DE 8405) and had to make sure my resume was still current. Wasn't sure if my old registration was still good or if I needed to start over. Called my local America's Job Center of California and they helped me sort it out without it affecting my payments.
0 coins
Emma Thompson
CalJOBS registration is tied to the new claim cycle. Getting a new DE 8405 and having 21 days from that date to make sure everything is active and your resume is posted is the standard. Missing it can hold up payments.
0 coins
Omar Hassan
21 days felt tight when I was also dealing with everything else about refiling. Made it with a few days to spare.
0 coins
Keisha Taylor
The job center staff are genuinely helpful for CalJOBS questions even if they can't do anything about EDD claim processing itself.
0 coins
Natasha Orlova
Saw a lot of people on other threads suggest you can just reopen your old claim after a benefit year ends. That's not how it works. Once the benefit year is over, you can't reopen or extend it - you have to file a new claim from scratch. The new claim gets calculated on whatever wages are in the new base period window, which is why the weekly amount often comes out different.
0 coins
CosmicCowboy
Someone told me the same reopening myth when my first benefit year was ending. Good thing I didn't wait around for that because I would have lost weeks without filing.
0 coins
Oliver Becker
The only time you reopen an existing claim is when a job ends while your current benefit year is still active. That's a different situation from a benefit year actually expiring.
0 coins
Miguel Diaz
AuthorWorth repeating that it's a completely new claim, not a reopen. That framing helped me understand why the weekly amount recalculates from scratch.
0 coins
Javier Cruz
Something that surprised me when I refiled - the new claim's benefit year starts on the Sunday of the week I applied, and runs for 52 weeks from there. I had a small gap between when my old benefit year ended and when I refiled because I was hoping to find work first. Those weeks in the gap can't be recovered, so anyone reading this who hasn't refiled yet should do it as soon as the old benefit year ends.
0 coins
Ravi Malhotra
Filing immediately when the benefit year ends is advice I wish I'd gotten before my gap. Lost about three weeks thinking I had time to wait.
0 coins
Yara Khoury
The 52-week benefit year clock starts the Sunday of the application week. Even if EDD takes a few weeks to process the new claim, the benefit year is running from that first Sunday, so earlier is always better.
0 coins
Malik Jackson
EDD's Unemployment Benefit Calculator on its site is something I used before even filing my second claim. You can plug in the wages from each quarter in your expected base period and get an estimate of what the weekly amount might be. It doesn't guarantee the exact number - the real one is on your DE 429Z - but it at least prepares you mentally for a lower number if that's what the math suggests.
0 coins
Amina Bah
Used the calculator before my second claim and it estimated $203. DE 429Z came back at $198. Close enough that I wasn't shocked when the real number arrived.
0 coins
Miguel Diaz
AuthorGoing to try the calculator on EDD's site with my actual quarterly wages to see if the math lines up with what my DE 429Z shows. Even just understanding the formula would help.
0 coins
Connor Gallagher
The calculator being pretty accurate before the DE 429Z even arrives is legitimately useful. Takes some of the anxiety out of waiting.
0 coins
Ravi Malhotra
Direct deposit setup messed me up on the new claim. Thought my payment preference from the old claim carried over automatically. It didn't - had to set it again in myEDD. Spent an extra week waiting for a Money Network card I wasn't expecting because I assumed the old settings transferred.
0 coins
StarSurfer
Payment preferences not carrying over between claims is something EDD could really communicate better. The Money Network card shows up and people think something went wrong when actually they just need to update their preference in myEDD.
0 coins
Javier Cruz
Went through myEDD to switch to direct deposit right after filing the new claim specifically because I'd heard this. Glad I did it early.
0 coins
Oliver Becker
The maximum benefit amount on the new claim also recalculates. The first claim, the total payout cap was 26 times my weekly amount or half my total base period wages, whichever was less. Same formula applies on the new claim but with the new weekly amount and the new base period wages. So the total the new claim can pay may also be less than what the old one could have paid.
0 coins
Emma Thompson
The maximum benefit amount dropping alongside the weekly amount is something a lot of people don't think about until they're trying to figure out how many weeks of payments they can expect.
0 coins
CosmicCowboy
So the lower weekly amount hits twice - less each week and potentially fewer total dollars available. That's a double impact on the budget.
0 coins
Miguel Diaz
AuthorHad not thought about the total cap recalculating too. Need to look at that number on my new DE 429Z.
0 coins
Keisha Taylor
Phone interview question - when I refiled, EDD didn't schedule a new phone interview because I had been laid off again from a temporary assignment. But someone I know who quit their last job before refiling had to go through the whole interview process again on the new claim. The interview isn't a one-time thing; EDD schedules one any time there's a question about eligibility on that claim.
0 coins
Natasha Orlova
The interview being tied to eligibility questions on each individual claim makes sense once you know it. If you quit or got fired, EDD needs to look at the circumstances all over again even if they already did it on a previous claim.
0 coins
Malik Jackson
Assuming the interview is a one-time lifetime hurdle is exactly the kind of thing that catches people off guard. Good distinction to make here.
0 coins
Paolo Longo
Taxes on the new claim work the same as the old one. Benefits are federal taxable income but California doesn't tax them. If you had 10 percent federal withholding set up on your first claim, it doesn't automatically apply to the new one - you choose again at each certification. Form 1099G for the new claim will be in UI Online under Payments by January 31 of the following year.
0 coins
Ravi Malhotra
California not taxing unemployment benefits is one of the few things about this whole process that feels like a small break.
0 coins
Omar Hassan
Federal withholding not carrying over automatically is worth flagging. Already opted back in on my first certification for the new claim.
0 coins
Chloe Robinson
Months on a pending claim with no explanation is what sent me to the phone on my second claim. The UI Online Claim History showed weeks as Pending but I couldn't tell if it was an identity issue or a wage question. Used Claimyr and got an EDD agent on the line - turned out there was a CalJOBS registration flag holding things up from the DE 8405 deadline. Agent confirmed once I updated the registration the pending weeks would process. Got into CalJOBS and updated everything that same day.
0 coins
Freya Christensen
Logging into CalJOBS to fix the registration after an agent flags it is way faster than trying to figure it out through Ask EDD. Glad that resolved quickly.
0 coins
Oliver Becker
Pending weeks because of a CalJOBS flag is more common than people realize. Updating the registration clears it faster than waiting for EDD to send a notice about it.
0 coins
Connor Gallagher
Severance pay question for anyone who had it when refiling - I got a small severance from a contract job that ended right before my benefit year did. Filed the new claim right away as soon as the benefit year ended because I'd read that severance doesn't delay when you can file. Had to report it when certifying though. EDD decided how it affected that week's payment. Didn't hold up the new claim from starting.
0 coins
Yara Khoury
Reporting severance when certifying is the right move. It goes in the week it was earned or paid depending on how EDD treats it, and EDD makes the call on how it affects the payment amount. Filing the new claim immediately is the right call regardless.
0 coins
Paolo Longo
Thought severance meant I had to wait to file and lost two weeks because of it. Report it and let EDD sort it out is the right approach.
0 coins
Isabella Costa
Payment showing up in UI Online versus actually hitting the Money Network card took me a couple of days on my new claim and I panicked thinking something went wrong. UI Online shows payment information updated daily and payments often post to the card within 24 hours of certifying online. The first payment on the new claim just felt slower because I was anxious about everything else.
0 coins
Amina Bah
Watching UI Online obsessively after certifying for the first time on a new claim is a rite of passage at this point. The 24-hour window feels longer when you're watching it.
0 coins
Miguel Diaz
AuthorKnowing the UI Online payment info updates daily and the card usually reflects it within 24 hours of online certification helps. I'll try not to refresh every hour.
0 coins