Should I answer call from former employer while waiting for appeal hearing?
My appeal was filed about two weeks ago after EDD denied my claim and mailed the Notice of Determination. I'm waiting to get the Notice of Hearing in the mail and I'm just sitting here stressing. Yesterday my phone rang and the caller ID showed my former employer's name. I did not pick up and they didn't leave a voicemail. Now I'm spiraling about whether that was a mistake. Was that maybe EDD's interview call that I somehow mixed up with my employer? Or was it actually my employer trying to reach me for some other reason? I have no idea if I'm even supposed to talk to them before the hearing. My whole claim was about being fired and I don't want to accidentally say something that hurts me at the hearing. Has anyone dealt with this during an appeal?
74 comments

Theodore Nelson
Termination date on my separation papers was March 3rd and EDD denied me saying there was misconduct. Filed the appeal right away with the DE 1000M. Getting a live EDD agent on the phone to understand what exactly was flagged felt impossible until I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) — ended up talking to an agent who pulled up my file and told me which weeks were still pending and that my Notice of Hearing would come at least 10 days before the date. The agent also said to keep certifying every two weeks so those weeks stay on record and can be paid if the judge rules in my favor. Here's their video on reaching a live person at EDD by phone: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10
0 coins
Carmella Fromis
AuthorWait, the agent actually told you which weeks were pending? I thought EDD just showed Pending in Claim History and that was it. Did they say anything about whether talking to a former employer before the hearing was a problem?
0 coins
Theodore Nelson
Pending in UI Online is exactly what mine showed too, and yeah the agent confirmed the specific weeks and what was holding them. As for the employer question, the agent didn't get into that — said the hearing is handled by the CUIAB and their office doesn't advise on that side of things.
0 coins
AaliyahAli
Worth knowing that you should absolutely keep certifying while the appeal is open. If you stop certifying and win, EDD can only pay weeks that were actually certified. Don't let the appeal pause your certifications.
0 coins
Ellie Simpson
Whether or not to pick up a call from your former employer is worth thinking through carefully. The question you'd want answered before anything else is: what do they actually want, and do you have any obligation to speak with them right now? The short answer from an appeals standpoint is no, you don't have to talk to them, and anything you say could be used against you at the hearing. The administrative law judge at the CUIAB hears testimony under oath from both sides. Your employer can say what they want to say in that setting, and so can you. An informal phone conversation before the hearing isn't part of that process and there's nothing stopping them from characterizing whatever you say however they want. If they want to reach you for something unrelated to the claim, that's different, but you'd have no way to know until you pick up. I'd personally wait until after the hearing.
0 coins
Carmella Fromis
AuthorThat's exactly what I was afraid of. I keep thinking, what if it was a friendly call and I'm being paranoid? But you're right, I have no way of knowing before I pick up. Did EDD or the CUIAB ever give you guidance on this or is this just common sense?
0 coins
Ellie Simpson
Nobody from EDD told me this directly — it's just what made sense to me going through my own appeal. The Notice of Hearing I got said testimony is under oath and the judge runs the hearing. That framing made me think anything outside that official setting was risky.
0 coins
Arjun Kurti
The employer not leaving a voicemail is interesting. If it were something urgent or administrative, they'd probably leave a message. The silence makes me think it was either a mistake or they were testing whether you'd pick up.
0 coins
Raúl Mora
Before the hearing even happens, make sure the Notice of Hearing actually arrives with enough time. EDD has to send it at least 10 days before the hearing date. If you don't get it and the hearing date passes, phone EDD the same day you realize what happened. Missing the hearing without notifying them first can mean the judge decides based only on what the employer submitted.
0 coins
Carmella Fromis
AuthorMine hasn't come yet and I filed two weeks ago. Is that normal? I keep checking the mail every day. I don't even know when the hearing is scheduled.
0 coins
Raúl Mora
Two weeks in is probably fine — the CUIAB schedules hearings and the timing depends on their calendar, not just when you filed. Keep checking your mail. The notice will show the date, time and what questions are likely to come up at the hearing.
0 coins
Margot Quinn
My Notice of Hearing came about three weeks after I filed my appeal. So it can take a little while. The worst part is not knowing when to expect it.
0 coins
Evelyn Kim
Something that helped me prep for my hearing was writing down the exact sequence of events that led to my termination before any more time passed. The judge asks you to walk through what happened, and having it clear in your head — dates, what was said, who was present — makes it easier to give consistent testimony. The employer is going to have their version. You want yours to be just as specific.
0 coins
Carmella Fromis
AuthorHave you actually been through one of these hearings? I'm trying to figure out how formal it is and whether I need an actual attorney or if I can represent myself.
0 coins
Evelyn Kim
Went through mine last year. Testimony is under oath but it's not a courtroom — it's often done by phone. You absolutely can represent yourself. The notice itself will describe the format. A union rep or attorney can sit in with you if you want, but plenty of people go in alone.
0 coins
Diego Fisher
Appeals over a firing usually come down to whether the employer can show the reason for termination was actual misconduct. EDD's standard is that the employer has to prove it, not just claim it. If your employer can't back up their version, that matters.
0 coins
Henrietta Beasley
The phone hearing format threw me off when I went through mine. I expected it to feel more official but it was really just me, the judge and my former supervisor each talking, the judge asking questions. Keep your notes in front of you.
0 coins
Lincoln Ramiro
Overpayment notice showed up in my mailbox the same week I filed my appeal, which was a whole extra layer of stress. Needed to talk to someone at EDD directly to understand whether the overpayment was connected to the denied weeks or separate. Ended up speaking to an agent through Claimyr — they confirmed the overpayment was tied to the same eligibility question the appeal covers, and that I shouldn't pay it back until the appeal is decided in case the judge reverses the denial. That detail mattered a lot to how I handled the next few months.
0 coins
Carmella Fromis
AuthorWait, can the overpayment actually get reversed if you win the appeal? I didn't even think about that angle. I might have a pending overpayment situation too and I didn't know the appeal could affect it.
0 coins
Lincoln Ramiro
The agent explained it as: if the judge rules you were eligible for those weeks, the payments were correct and there's no overpayment. But I'd check with EDD on how it applies to your specific claim — mine was pretty clear-cut because the same weeks were in question.
0 coins
Faith Kingston
The connection between an overpayment notice and an active appeal is something a lot of people miss. If you get one of those notices and you're in an appeal, definitely ask EDD about it before doing anything.
0 coins
Emma Johnson
About the employer call — there's also the possibility that it had nothing to do with the UI claim at all. Former employers sometimes call about final paychecks, W-2s, benefits paperwork, stuff like that. If you're concerned it's about those things specifically, you could let it go to voicemail again and see if they leave a message this time. That way you'd at least know what they're calling about before you decide.
0 coins
Carmella Fromis
AuthorTrue, I hadn't thought about that. My last paycheck was fine and I already got my W-2 so it's hard to imagine what else they'd need from me at this point. Which makes it feel more likely it was claim-related.
0 coins
Emma Johnson
That's fair. If there's no obvious loose end they'd need to tie up with you, the claim context makes more sense for why they'd be calling now. Silence seems like the right move until after the hearing.
0 coins
Liam Brown
Former employers calling around the time of an appeal hearing is not unusual. They're preparing their side too. You are not required to cooperate with their prep.
0 coins
Olivia Garcia
One thing that sometimes trips people up at this stage: the appeal hearing is different from the EDD phone interview. The phone interview, if EDD scheduled one, happens before they issue the Notice of Determination. By the time you're at the appeal stage with the CUIAB, the interview has already happened or already been skipped. So if you're waiting for a 'phone interview' now, that's actually the hearing. Just flagging this because a lot of people use the terms interchangeably and they're completely different steps.
0 coins
Carmella Fromis
AuthorOh I actually did have the phone interview before the denial. That's how the whole thing started — EDD called for the interview, I explained my side, and they still denied me. So the appeal is the next step after that, right?
0 coins
Olivia Garcia
Exactly right. The interview feeds into EDD's decision, then the Notice of Determination comes with the denial. The appeal goes up to the CUIAB and an administrative law judge looks at it fresh. Different process, different people, different standard.
0 coins
Noah Lee
Yep the interview and the hearing are two completely separate things. The interview is EDD trying to gather facts. The hearing is you making your case to a judge after EDD has already decided. Mixing them up is really common.
0 coins
Ava Hernandez
Keep certifying every two weeks regardless of what's happening with the appeal. This comes up in every appeal thread and people still forget to do it. If the judge reverses the denial, EDD can only issue payment for weeks you actually certified. Stopping because you assume you won't be paid is the mistake that leaves money on the table permanently.
0 coins
Carmella Fromis
AuthorI've been certifying every two weeks since before the denial. Should I certify through the whole appeal process even if EDD shows me as disqualified?
0 coins
Ava Hernandez
Certify every single cycle until the appeal is fully resolved. The disqualified status in UI Online doesn't mean you stop certifying — it means EDD hasn't paid yet. If the judge sides with you, those certified weeks become payable.
0 coins
Isabella Martin
Certifications during an appeal are essential. I learned this the hard way after my first appeal — I stopped certifying thinking there was no point, and ended up with a gap in my record that couldn't be filled in after I won.
0 coins
Elijah Jackson
Do you have a union or was this a non-union job? Asking because some union contracts have grievance procedures that run separately from the CUIAB appeal process, and a union rep could potentially attend your hearing. If it's non-union, you'd either go in alone or find an attorney, but plenty of people represent themselves at these hearings and do fine.
0 coins
Carmella Fromis
AuthorNon-union, so it's just me. I'm not planning to hire an attorney for a hearing — I don't think the amount at stake would justify that cost. The notice said I can represent myself so that's what I'm planning.
0 coins
Elijah Jackson
Self-representation is totally workable. The administrative law judge runs the hearing and asks the questions. It's not like arguing in front of a jury. Just know your timeline, your facts, and what documents support your version of events.
0 coins
Sophia Miller
The DE 1000M you filed to appeal — did you include any documentation with it, like texts or emails or write-ups from work? If you didn't, the hearing is your chance to bring that in. The Notice of Hearing usually describes what evidence you can submit and how. Read it carefully when it arrives.
0 coins
Carmella Fromis
AuthorI sent the form without documentation because I didn't know I could include things. Can I still bring evidence to the actual hearing even if I didn't attach anything to the DE 1000M?
0 coins
Sophia Miller
The hearing is where evidence typically gets presented. The DE 1000M just kicks off the appeal. Read your Notice of Hearing carefully — it'll explain the format and what to bring or submit. The judge will give you a chance to present your side.
0 coins
Mason Davis
Bring whatever you have — emails, texts, performance reviews, anything that speaks to what actually happened at the end of your job. The judge weighs both sides' accounts and documentation can tip the credibility question.
0 coins
Diego Fisher
Former employer prep for hearings sometimes involves gathering documentation they didn't submit to EDD initially. The appeal process is a fresh look, so they might bring things the original claim review didn't have. That's another reason staying quiet until the hearing is smarter than a pre-hearing conversation with them. Used Claimyr to get through to EDD when I had questions about my own termination appeal — the agent confirmed my hearing was still on calendar and that any employer documents submitted would be reflected in what the judge receives, not sent to me directly in advance.
0 coins
Carmella Fromis
AuthorThey can bring new documentation to the hearing that I haven't seen? That's a little alarming. Is there any way to know what they're planning to bring ahead of time?
0 coins
Diego Fisher
The Notice of Hearing should describe what the process looks like for your specific case. Ask the CUIAB if you're not clear on what gets shared in advance — that falls under their procedures, not EDD's side.
0 coins
Mia Rodriguez
The hearing format can vary but the judge does manage the evidence. If the employer springs something new, you usually have a chance to respond. It's not supposed to be an ambush.
0 coins
Margot Quinn
My appeal was about being fired too and the whole thing felt unmanageable while I was waiting. What helped me most was printing out my Claim History from UI Online and noting every week that was pending, then certifying consistently so there were no gaps. When I finally won, the back payments came through for every week I'd certified.
0 coins
Carmella Fromis
AuthorThat's genuinely encouraging to hear. Did you end up receiving everything you were owed once the judge ruled in your favor? I keep wondering how long the payment processing takes after a decision.
0 coins
Margot Quinn
The back payment took a couple of weeks to process after I got the judge's written decision in the mail. It wasn't instant but it did come through for all the certified weeks. Keep your certifications clean and current.
0 coins
Henrietta Beasley
The whole waiting period between filing the appeal and getting the Notice of Hearing is the hardest part. There's genuinely nothing to do except keep certifying and try not to overthink every caller ID you see. Your employer calling doesn't mean they have something new — it might just mean their HR department is going through the motions.
0 coins
Carmella Fromis
AuthorHonestly yes, the waiting is the worst. I've been refreshing UI Online way too often checking for status changes that aren't going to come.
0 coins
Henrietta Beasley
UI Online won't reflect the appeal status in a way that tells you much. The hearing notice coming in the mail is the actual update. Everything in between is just waiting.
0 coins
Arjun Kurti
The UI Online Claim History showing Pending during an appeal is normal. It doesn't mean anything went wrong with the appeal itself.
0 coins
Liam Brown
If your former employer does leave a voicemail next time, you can listen to it to find out what they want without technically being in a conversation with them. That gives you information without giving them an opportunity to draw something out of you before the hearing. If it's just paperwork stuff, you can decide from there.
0 coins
Carmella Fromis
AuthorThat's actually a smart way to think about it. I can hear what they want without committing to anything. If it's just administrative I'd probably just handle it over email anyway where everything is in writing.
0 coins
Liam Brown
Email is exactly the right instinct if you do need to respond to something routine. You have a record of everything said, and nothing can be mischaracterized from memory.
0 coins
Faith Kingston
Misconduct under California's standard means more than just making a mistake at work or even repeated poor performance. EDD's framing puts the burden on the employer to prove the conduct crossed that line — it's not enough to say you were fired, they have to show why the firing qualifies. That's worth remembering when you're preparing your version of events for the hearing.
0 coins
AaliyahAli
Careful with that framing though — the burden of proof question is specifically about misconduct, not about every type of denial. If the denial was based on something else, the standard shifts. OP said theirs was a firing, so misconduct standard applies, but it's not a universal rule.
0 coins
Faith Kingston
Fair point. The firing and misconduct standard is specific to that situation. Someone who quit, for example, is in a different position — they'd need to show they had a good reason. Those are two separate tracks.
0 coins
Raúl Mora
EDD's own language on this is worth keeping in mind: for a firing, the employer proves misconduct; for a quit, the claimant shows a good reason. Neither side gets a free pass just because the other side didn't show up.
0 coins
Noah Lee
While you're waiting, it might be worth going back through any written warnings, emails or HR correspondence from before you were fired. Even things that felt minor at the time can be relevant to whether the employer's stated reason for firing you holds together. The judge is going to hear their story and your story and decide which one makes sense.
0 coins
Carmella Fromis
AuthorI do have some emails. I wasn't sure if paper trails from inside the company are actually admissible at these hearings or if it has to be more official documentation.
0 coins
Noah Lee
Emails, texts, written warnings, notes — anything contemporaneous can support your account. The judge decides what weight to give it, but bringing it is better than not bringing it.
0 coins
Evelyn Kim
Internal company emails are regularly part of these hearings. If you have them, print them out and have them organized by date. The more specific your documentation, the clearer your timeline becomes.
0 coins
Mia Rodriguez
Former employer not leaving a voicemail actually tells you something: if they had a legitimate administrative reason to reach out, most HR departments leave a message. The fact that they didn't suggests they were hoping to catch you in a live conversation. That's worth factoring into whether you pick up if they call again before the hearing.
0 coins
Carmella Fromis
AuthorThat's exactly the read I had on it and it made me feel like not picking up was the right instinct. I'll let any future calls go to voicemail and decide from there.
0 coins
Mia Rodriguez
Voicemail first is the right approach. You learn what they want without giving up any control over the conversation.
0 coins
Emma Johnson
Employers preparing for hearings sometimes call hoping the other party will say something helpful to their case. It's not sinister exactly but it's not casual either. Voicemail is a reasonable filter.
0 coins
Isabella Martin
Worth making sure your contact info with EDD and the CUIAB is current so the Notice of Hearing actually reaches you. If you've moved or your phone number changed since you applied, update it in myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ as soon as possible. Missing the notice because it went to an old address is a fixable problem before the hearing and a painful one after.
0 coins
Carmella Fromis
AuthorMy address is the same as when I applied so I should be fine there. But is myEDD where I'd update it, or is there a separate CUIAB process?
0 coins
Isabella Martin
myEDD handles the EDD side of things. The CUIAB is a separate agency and their contact information comes on the appeal confirmation. If you need to update your address with them specifically, check whatever paperwork they mailed you acknowledging the appeal.
0 coins
Mason Davis
Keeping both EDD and the CUIAB informed of your current address is worth the extra step. Mail from the CUIAB going to the wrong place is how people miss their hearing date entirely.
0 coins
Arjun Kurti
Has anyone here dealt with an employer who was particularly aggressive during the appeal process — multiple calls, trying to get you to sign something, that kind of thing? I'm asking for a friend dealing with something similar and wondering how to handle it.
0 coins
Henrietta Beasley
That kind of pressure before a hearing is unusual but not unheard of. If an employer asks you to sign anything after you've filed an appeal, that's worth being very cautious about. What you sign outside the formal process could affect what happens inside it.
0 coins
Mia Rodriguez
Signing anything from a former employer while an appeal is pending should come with serious caution. If it's a release or settlement, it could affect your ability to collect on the appeal. Reading what it says carefully and understanding what rights you'd be giving up matters a lot.
0 coins
Elijah Jackson
Anything that looks like a settlement offer or a release during the appeal period is worth getting eyes on before signing. The formal hearing process is there for a reason.
0 coins