Overpayment voluntary quit determination how to appeal and avoid repaying - California EDD
Got hit with a Notice of Overpayment two weeks ago saying I owe back $2,840 in benefits EDD paid me after I quit my retail job last spring. The letter says I quit without good cause and was therefore ineligible, so everything they paid me counts as an overpayment. Thing is, I quit because my manager had been cutting my hours down to almost nothing for three months - went from 38 hours a week to under 10 - and I finally couldn't cover rent anymore. I reported all my work and wages honestly every single time I certified. Never hid anything. Now I don't know if I fight the determination itself or the overpayment or both. The notice came with a DE 1000M appeal form. I have 30 days from the mailing date on the letter to appeal, and I'm on day 12 right now. I've got pay stubs showing the hour cuts, old schedules, and texts from my manager about the reduction. What exactly do I put in the appeal letter? Do I address the quit separately from the overpayment amount? And is there any chance of a waiver on the repayment while the appeal is going?
70 comments

Andre Lefebvre
DE 1000M on the desk and you're on day 12 - file that appeal today, don't wait for a perfect letter. When I got my Notice of Determination last year after a quit, I sent in a one-page letter with the DE 1000M, explained what happened in plain sentences, listed the evidence I had, and asked for a hearing date. The administrative law judge at the CUIAB hearing is the one who actually weighs it all, so the letter just needs to get you in the door. Your pay stubs showing the hour drop from 38 to under 10 are exactly the kind of evidence that matters at the hearing.
0 coins
Carmen Ruiz
AuthorAlready printed the DE 1000M. Do I staple the pay stubs to it or just reference them and bring them to the hearing?
0 coins
Andre Lefebvre
Reference them in the letter and bring originals plus copies to the hearing. The notice of hearing comes by mail at least 10 days before, so you'll have time to organize everything.
0 coins
Zoe Dimitriou
Mailing it certified mail is worth doing so you have proof of the date it was sent. 30 days goes fast when you're stressed.
0 coins
QuantumQuest
Appeal both things together on the same DE 1000M - the disqualification finding AND the overpayment amount. The overpayment exists because they found you ineligible; if you win the disqualification appeal, the overpayment goes away with it. Write something like: I am appealing the finding that I quit without good cause, and consequently the overpayment of $2,840 established by the Notice of Overpayment dated [date].
0 coins
Carmen Ruiz
AuthorThat framing makes sense. So I don't need two separate appeal forms?
0 coins
QuantumQuest
One letter or one DE 1000M covers both if you name both issues clearly. Keep a copy of everything you send.
0 coins
Jamal Anderson
Agreed - when I appealed my overpayment notice the EDD reviewer looked at the underlying determination first. One form, both issues named.
0 coins
Mei Zhang
Weeks of certified weeks sitting at Pending in UI Online while my overpayment appeal was open made me realize I had to actually talk to someone at EDD, not just wait for mail. Claimyr (claimyr.com) got me on the phone with a live EDD agent after I'd given up on the hold music. The video they have on reaching a live person at EDD is at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. I asked the agent whether my pending certified weeks would be paid out if I won the appeal, and she told me those weeks stay in Pending status while the appeal is open and that EDD can release them once the CUIAB issues a decision in my favor - but I had to keep certifying every two weeks so the weeks existed to pay. That was the piece I'd been missing.
0 coins
Carmen Ruiz
AuthorKeep certifying during the appeal is exactly what I needed to know. So even with the overpayment notice out there, I should keep certifying?
0 coins
Mei Zhang
Keep certifying without stopping - that's what the agent told me. If you stop, those weeks won't exist for EDD to pay even if you win.
0 coins
Liam McGuire
Certifying through an appeal is something a lot of people don't realize. The weeks only exist to be paid if you certified them.
0 coins
Amara Eze
Voluntary reduction of hours that made the job unsuitable is actually one of the situations where quitting can be treated as involuntary by EDD. My own case three years ago was similar - went from full-time to 12 hours and EDD initially denied me, said I quit. I appealed, brought in four months of pay stubs showing the schedule collapse, and the administrative law judge sided with me. The key framing I used was that the conditions of employment changed so significantly that staying was no longer reasonable. I didn't claim I quit on a whim - I showed the job had effectively ended before I walked out.
0 coins
Carmen Ruiz
AuthorThat framing - that the job changed, not that I just quit - is what I'll build the letter around. Thank you.
0 coins
Giovanni Ricci
Hour cuts that severe really do change the character of the job. That's very different from walking off because you didn't like the manager.
0 coins
NeonNomad
Administrative law judges hear a lot of quit cases. Coming in with documented evidence instead of just your word makes a real difference in how the hearing goes.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Hashemi
Something I got wrong before my own appeal hearing: I thought the burden was on me to prove I had a good reason no matter what, that EDD would fight me in the room. That's not how the hearing works. You present your side, the ALJ asks questions, and they weigh the whole picture. EDD's own language is that if you quit you need to show good reason - and a 74% cut in hours over three months is a pretty strong showing. Bring your texts, your pay stubs, your old schedules. Lay out the timeline month by month.
0 coins
Carmen Ruiz
AuthorMonth by month timeline is a good idea. I'll put that together this week.
0 coins
Zoe Dimitriou
Printed timelines help ALJs follow a complicated work history without losing the thread. Worth the extra page.
0 coins
Dylan Mitchell
While the appeal is pending, you can also ask EDD about an overpayment waiver using the DE 1446UI form. The waiver is for situations where the overpayment wasn't your fault and paying it back would cause real hardship. It doesn't pause the repayment demand on its own, but it's a separate avenue. You'd be saying: I reported everything correctly, I shouldn't be held responsible for EDD's eligibility determination being later reversed. EDD decides whether to grant it; nobody can promise it goes through.
0 coins
Carmen Ruiz
AuthorCan I file the DE 1446UI while the appeal is still going, or do I have to wait for the outcome?
0 coins
Dylan Mitchell
File them on separate tracks - the waiver request and the appeal can run at the same time. EDD handles them separately.
0 coins
Andre Lefebvre
Worth filing the waiver request sooner rather than later in case the appeal takes a while. Gets the paperwork in the queue.
0 coins
Sofia Martinez
OMG I am going through almost the exact same thing right now except my overpayment notice says $3,100 and mine was a firing not a quit. I had no idea you could appeal both the determination AND the overpayment amount on the same form. I thought the overpayment was totally separate. Is 30 days from the mailing date a hard cutoff or is there any flexibility?
0 coins
QuantumQuest
30 days from the mailing date is the deadline, and a late appeal needs a written reason for why it was late. Don't count on flexibility - file on time.
0 coins
Sofia Martinez
Filing mine today then. I've been sitting on it for two weeks trying to figure out what to write.
0 coins
Amara Eze
A short letter that gets there on time beats a perfect letter that arrives on day 31. File first, add detail later when you get the hearing notice.
0 coins
Dmitry Volkov
My neighbor told me EDD automatically forgives the overpayment if you appeal - that's not accurate. The appeal contests whether the money is owed at all by challenging the underlying disqualification. If you win the appeal, the overpayment goes away because EDD finds you were eligible. If you lose, the debt stands. The waiver is the separate process for hardship.
0 coins
Sofia Martinez
Thank you for clearing that up. I had the wrong idea about what an appeal actually does.
0 coins
Dmitry Volkov
A lot of people mix those two things up. Appeal = fight the eligibility finding. Waiver = ask EDD to forgive repayment for hardship. Very different tracks.
0 coins
Ava Thompson
Employer notified when you appeal is something people ask about. EDD notifies the last employer and they can respond; at the hearing both you and the employer can appear. When I had my hearing, my former employer sent a letter but didn't show up. The ALJ still heard their written argument. Having your own documentation - pay stubs, schedules, written communications - matters a lot when the employer isn't there to be cross-examined.
0 coins
Carmen Ruiz
AuthorEmployer's written letter still counts even without them in the room - good to know so I'm not caught off guard if that happens.
0 coins
NeonNomad
Dated texts and emails are hard to dispute in a hearing. If you have written proof of the hour cuts from management, that's strong.
0 coins
Giovanni Ricci
Former employer not showing up is actually fairly common at CUIAB hearings from what I've read. Your own documentation has to stand on its own.
0 coins
CyberSiren
Quick note on what happens to payments during all this: keep certifying in UI Online every two weeks through the appeal, the way the person earlier said. If there's a balance on your claim and EDD later decides you were eligible, they process the certified weeks. Stop certifying and those weeks are gone regardless of how the appeal turns out.
0 coins
Carmen Ruiz
AuthorCertified for this past period yesterday actually, so I'm current. Not stopping until this is resolved.
0 coins
Liam McGuire
Certifying consistently is the one thing completely in your control during a long appeal. Don't let it lapse.
0 coins
Miguel Alvarez
Hour reductions of that scale - from 38 to under 10 - are a documented change in the terms of employment, not just a schedule preference. EDD's own guidance says a claimant who quits needs to show good reason, and courts and ALJs have consistently found that a severe cut in hours changes the fundamental nature of the job. Your situation isn't a close call on the facts; the documentation is what will make or break it.
0 coins
Carmen Ruiz
AuthorPulling together every schedule printout and pay stub I have going back six months tonight.
0 coins
Amara Eze
Pay stubs side by side across those months tell the story without you having to explain much. Numbers speak clearly.
0 coins
Zainab Yusuf
Paperwork for the DE 1446UI waiver request took me a minute to find - it's not in UI Online, you request it through Ask EDD or by calling EDD directly. Had to call EDD to ask about my own waiver situation after getting a notice, and I used Claimyr to actually get through to someone. The agent confirmed that the waiver and the appeal are independent processes and told me my specific weeks that were in question. Filed both the same week.
0 coins
Carmen Ruiz
AuthorRequesting the DE 1446UI through Ask EDD makes sense. I'll do that this week alongside mailing the appeal.
0 coins
Dylan Mitchell
Running both at the same time is exactly the right move. More paths forward the better given the timeline.
0 coins
Giovanni Ricci
Preparing for the hearing itself is worth thinking about now even though it's weeks away. The Notice of Hearing tells you the date, time and format - phone or in person. Practice explaining the hour reduction timeline out loud, clearly and without getting emotional. ALJs hear a lot of cases and a clear, fact-based account with supporting documents lands better than an emotional one.
0 coins
Carmen Ruiz
AuthorPhone hearing or in-person hearing - is there a difference in how I should prepare?
0 coins
Giovanni Ricci
Phone hearing means your documents get submitted beforehand or described verbally. In person you bring hard copies. Either way, have everything organized by date.
0 coins
NeonNomad
Phone hearings are more common. Submitting a clear written summary of the timeline before the hearing date helps the ALJ follow along even before the call.
0 coins
Connor O'Reilly
DE 1101CZ notice went to my employer when I filed my claim, and I found out later they responded with their version of events. I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr before my hearing to find out what documentation EDD had on file. The agent told me EDD had received the employer's response and what the stated reason for separation was, which let me prepare a direct rebuttal. Went into the hearing knowing exactly what I was addressing.
0 coins
Carmen Ruiz
AuthorKnowing what the employer said before the hearing - that's a smart move. I'll ask EDD what's on file once I confirm the appeal is received.
0 coins
Ava Thompson
Calling EDD to ask what's on the claim before the hearing is underused. You can shape your argument around what they actually have.
0 coins
Zoe Dimitriou
Sent my own appeal letter about six months back and want to flag one thing: the CUIAB hearing notice comes by mail at least 10 days before the date, so watch for it - EDD mails things to the address on file, and if your address changed you'll want to update it in myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ before the notice goes out.
0 coins
Carmen Ruiz
AuthorAddress is current in myEDD, confirmed. Good catch though - I'd have been paranoid about that.
0 coins
Sofia Martinez
Updated mine just now after reading this. Hadn't thought about the hearing notice being mailed.
0 coins
Jamal Anderson
Misconduct and voluntary quit are two different EDD standards that sometimes get tangled up in threads like this. Misconduct is EDD's standard for a firing - the employer needs to prove it. For a quit, the burden is on the claimant to show good reason. These are separate tests and your appeal letter should be clear that you're arguing the quit was for good cause due to the hour reduction, not trying to argue misconduct.
0 coins
Carmen Ruiz
AuthorGood point - my letter needs to stay focused on the quit/good cause argument, not drift into misconduct language.
0 coins
QuantumQuest
Mixing those up would confuse the ALJ. Quit cases argue changed working conditions made the job unsuitable. Keep it on that track.
0 coins
Dmitry Volkov
A lot of claimants blur those two terms. The standards and who carries the burden are completely different depending on how the separation happened.
0 coins
Liam McGuire
Waivers aren't automatic even if you win the appeal, but they also aren't the only path. If the appeal succeeds and the overpayment determination is reversed, the debt is eliminated because EDD decides you were eligible all along. The waiver matters most if the appeal doesn't succeed - it's the fallback for hardship. Worth pursuing both so you have options.
0 coins
Carmen Ruiz
AuthorBoth tracks at once makes the most sense then. I'll get the waiver request in while the appeal works through the system.
0 coins
Andre Lefebvre
Two parallel paths is the smart play. Appeal can take months; having the waiver in the queue means something is moving on the financial side too.
0 coins
NeonNomad
Testimony at the CUIAB hearing is under oath, and you can represent yourself - no attorney required. Some people bring a union rep if they have one, or an attorney, but plenty of people go in alone with organized documentation and do fine. The ALJ's job is to find facts; yours is to present them clearly.
0 coins
Carmen Ruiz
AuthorGoing in alone with the documentation I have. I'll make sure it's organized by date and easy to follow.
0 coins
Giovanni Ricci
Self-represented claimants win appeals regularly when the facts are on their side. Documentation and a clear timeline matter more than legal language.
0 coins
Yara Khoury
Overpayment notice language can make it sound like you owe the money right now no matter what. When my own claim had a pending overpayment from a determination I disagreed with, I used Claimyr to get on the phone with an EDD agent and asked specifically whether the repayment demand was frozen while my appeal was open. The agent pulled up my claim and told me which weeks were included in the overpayment calculation and confirmed the specific balance EDD had on record.
0 coins
Carmen Ruiz
AuthorKnowing the exact weeks and balance EDD has on record before the hearing - I'll add that to my list of things to ask when I call.
0 coins
Liam McGuire
Having those specific numbers on hand before the hearing means no surprises about what's actually in dispute.
0 coins
CyberSiren
Final thing worth noting: if the appeal goes in your favor and the CUIAB ALJ issues a decision reversing the disqualification, follow up with EDD to confirm the overpayment record is updated. Decisions don't always flow through the system automatically at EDD's end. A quick message through UI Online or a phone call after you get the written decision makes sure the overpayment is actually cleared on the account.
0 coins
Carmen Ruiz
AuthorFollow up after the decision to confirm the account is updated - noted. I wouldn't have thought to do that.
0 coins
Zoe Dimitriou
EDD processing a favorable CUIAB decision can take a few weeks. Proactively checking makes sure it doesn't sit unactioned.
0 coins
Jamal Anderson
Keeping a copy of the ALJ's written decision forever is a good idea. Proof of the reversal lives in that document.
0 coins