Back to California Unemployment

Dmitry Petrov

Overpayment notice after payment was deauthorized what to do with California EDD

Got a Notice of Overpayment from EDD last week that honestly blindsided me completely. Background: I was laid off from my warehouse supervisor job back in March and filed right away. Everything seemed fine for about six weeks, then EDD deauthorized my payment for two of my certified weeks - the money never actually hit my Money Network card. Now, months later, I'm getting this notice saying I owe them back those same two weeks worth of benefits totaling $740. The weeks in question were already pulled back before I ever touched them. How am I supposed to owe money I never received? The notice came with an Appeal Form (DE 1000M) but I don't even understand what I'm appealing because I never saw that money. Has anyone dealt with an overpayment notice for payments that were deauthorized like this? Do I still appeal? Do I contact EDD directly? I'm completely at a loss here.

Deauthorized weeks showing up as an overpayment happened on my claim too, different situation but same kind of confusion. The DE 1080CZ I got listed $680 from two weeks where my payment had been pulled before it posted to my card - EDD's records apparently still counted those as 'paid' on their end even though my Money Network account never showed the funds. I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to an EDD agent about it - their video on reaching a live person at EDD by phone walks you through it: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The agent pulled up my claim and found the deauthorization had been logged but not reconciled against the overpayment calculation, so she flagged it for a manual review. She also told me to appeal within 30 days of the mailing date on the notice no matter what while the review was open, because missing that window would close off that option entirely.

0 coins

The 30-day window on the mailing date - that's what's freaking me out the most. My notice is dated about 10 days ago so I've got some time but not a lot. Did the manual review actually resolve it for you or did you still have to go through the full appeal?

0 coins

The deauthorization not matching the overpayment calculation sounds exactly like what happens when their payment system and their eligibility system don't talk to each other properly. It's a known mess.

0 coins

Flagging it for manual review while also filing the appeal is the right play. Never wait on a review to come back before you file - appeals have hard cutoffs.

0 coins

Your mailing date is the clock that matters here. Whatever date appears on the DE 1080CZ, count exactly 30 calendar days forward - that's your deadline to appeal in writing. Send the Appeal Form (DE 1000M) that came with the notice, or a written letter if you've misplaced it, to the address printed on the notice itself. In your appeal, lay out exactly what you described: the weeks were deauthorized before the funds ever reached your Money Network card, and you're contesting that an overpayment occurred at all when no payment was actually received. Keep a copy of everything you send.

0 coins

Should I include any documentation with the appeal? Like screenshots from UI Online showing the payment never posted, or is the written explanation enough to start?

0 coins

Documentation always helps. UI Online Claim History showing those weeks as deauthorized rather than paid would be exactly what an administrative law judge would want to see at a hearing.

0 coins

The address on the notice matters - don't just mail it to EDD's general address. Some people miss that detail and it delays everything.

0 coins

EDD's overpayment process can flag weeks based on what their system shows as 'issued' even if the payment never cleared on the recipient's end. The DE 1080CZ goes out when their records show an amount was overpaid, but 'issued' and 'received' aren't always the same thing in their system - especially with deauthorizations. That gap is exactly what you'd argue in an appeal: the funds were recalled before you accessed them, so the overpayment amount should be zero.

0 coins

So the appeal essentially becomes an argument that the overpayment calculation is wrong because deauthorized doesn't equal received - is that the right framing?

0 coins

That framing is correct. The deauthorization is your evidence that the payment cycle didn't complete. EDD's own records should show it if they look at the right system.

0 coins

Worth noting that the waiver process (DE 1446UI) is separate from an appeal and is for cases where an overpayment actually happened but wasn't your fault. In this situation an appeal makes more sense because the person is contesting whether an overpayment happened at all.

0 coins

Not exactly the same, but my claim had a week that got flagged as overpaid after a certification issue - my $390 weekly amount for that week was listed on a notice even though the payment had been reversed. Spent three days trying to get through on 1-800-300-5616 and kept hitting the busy signal disconnect. Finally got on the phone with an EDD agent through Claimyr and asked specifically whether a reversed payment should appear as an overpayment on the DE 1080CZ. The agent said the reversal should offset it but that sometimes the system doesn't process that automatically, and she put a note on my account to have it reviewed before the appeal date.

0 coins

Three days of busy signals sounds about right from what I've been experiencing. Getting an actual agent to put a note on the account sounds like it might be more immediately useful than just filing the appeal and waiting.

0 coins

Both - file the appeal AND try to reach an agent. Never treat a pending review as a substitute for filing the appeal in time.

0 coins

The system not automatically processing reversals is a real issue. It's not unique to any one person, it comes up a lot.

0 coins

There's a distinction worth understanding between a fraud overpayment and a non-fraud overpayment, because EDD treats them very differently. A non-fraud overpayment has to be repaid but there's no penalty added. Fraud adds a 30 percent penalty and can bring a false statement disqualification. If your notice doesn't mention fraud or a penalty, then EDD isn't accusing you of anything intentional - they're saying there's a balance discrepancy. That matters for your stress level and for how you frame any communication with them.

0 coins

The notice I got doesn't say fraud anywhere, so it sounds like it's the non-fraud category. That's at least some relief even though the whole thing still feels wrong.

0 coins

Non-fraud designation also means you can ask about the waiver option on the DE 1446UI if the overpayment turns out to be valid after all - but as the comment above said, in this person's case contesting the overpayment entirely via appeal is the right first move.

0 coins

My layoff was from a retail management job and I had a similar situation where EDD sent a notice for weeks I was pretty sure I hadn't been paid for. Went into UI Online and checked Claim History for those specific weeks - each one showed the status of the payment rather than showing it as posted. That Claim History data became the key piece of information when I wrote up my appeal letter. The appeal went to the CUIAB Office of Appeals and an administrative law judge heard it - the hearing notice came about 10 days before the date, and I brought printed screenshots of my Claim History and my Money Network card statement showing no deposit for those weeks.

0 coins

Using the Claim History printout alongside the card statement showing no deposit - that combination makes a lot of sense as documentary evidence. Good to know what the hearing actually looks like.

0 coins

The card statement piece is important because it's from a source outside EDD's own records. It corroborates what the Claim History shows.

0 coins

Testimony at the hearing is under oath - worth knowing going in so you feel prepared. The judge runs it, you explain your situation, and you can represent yourself.

0 coins

Went through a deauthorization mess after my employer dispute on a previous claim - EDD had issued payment for three weeks and then deauthorized them while the phone interview was pending. My weekly benefit amount was $410 and three weeks of that showing up on a DE 1080CZ was not something I was going to just pay. Got through to a live EDD agent via Claimyr and walked through each week with her. She confirmed two of the three had been fully reversed in their system and shouldn't have appeared on the notice, and said to put that in my appeal letter with the week-ending dates spelled out clearly.

0 coins

Spelling out the specific week-ending dates in the appeal letter - noted. I'll pull those from my Claim History so the dates match exactly what EDD has on file.

0 coins

An employer dispute pending during those weeks explains the deauthorization chain. EDD holds payment when eligibility isn't decided yet, then reverses if the payment went out early.

0 coins

The appeal form DE 1000M is straightforward to fill out but the written explanation you attach matters a lot. Keep it factual and chronological: the dates you certified, the weeks in question, when the deauthorization occurred, and the fact that your Money Network card shows no credit for those amounts. Skip any emotional language and stick to what happened and when. The administrative law judge who eventually sees it is looking at the factual record.

0 coins

Factual and chronological - I'll draft it that way. Any sense of how long from filing the appeal to actually getting a hearing scheduled?

0 coins

Nobody can really say how long a decision takes - EDD doesn't publish timelines for that. Just keep certifying if you're still eligible and keep copies of everything.

0 coins

Keeping copies of everything filed, everything received, with the dates you received them - that habit pays off at a hearing where the timeline is disputed.

0 coins

My claim had a flag after some weeks got deauthorized during an identity verification hold. The DE 1080CZ came weeks after the hold was lifted. Used Claimyr to get an agent on the phone and found out the ID.me verification had completed but one week still showed as unreconciled in their system. The agent put a note that the week should be cleared once the payment reversal was matched on their end. I still filed my appeal within the 30-day window because the agent specifically said not to wait on administrative corrections.

0 coins

ID.me holds creating downstream discrepancies in the payment record is something a lot of people run into. The deauthorization happens for the hold, but the system doesn't always clean it up automatically when the hold lifts.

0 coins

Filing the appeal even when an agent says a correction is coming - that's the right call every time. Corrections can fall through cracks, appeals can't be filed late.

0 coins

Before you send anything, double-check that the mailing date on your notice is what you think it is. The 30 days runs from that printed date, not from when you actually received it. Sometimes there's a few days gap between the mailing date and when it shows up in your mailbox, which eats into your window without you realizing it.

0 coins

Looked at it again - the mailing date printed on the DE 1080CZ is about 11 days before today, so I have roughly 19 days left. That's enough time to draft something solid but I'm not going to sit on it.

0 coins

19 days is enough to do it right. Write the appeal, attach your documentation, mail it to the address on the notice, keep a copy, and consider sending it certified mail so you have proof of the date it was sent.

0 coins

Certified mail with return receipt for the appeal is worth the few dollars. If there's ever a question about whether your appeal arrived on time, you have a physical record with the date. The address you mail to is on the notice itself - don't use a general EDD mailing address.

0 coins

Certified mail proof of the send date is especially important when you're close to the deadline. If you're mailing within the last few days of the window, that postmark is what matters.

0 coins

Also keep a photo of the completed form before you seal the envelope - just in case anything is questioned later about what was submitted.

0 coins

Something people sometimes get confused about: a late appeal needs a stated reason for missing the deadline. As long as you're within the 30 days, you don't need to explain why you're appealing late - you just file it. The form or letter just needs to say you're appealing the notice, include the notice date, and explain what you're contesting. You can represent yourself at the hearing if it goes that far.

0 coins

Good to know the late appeal rule - I'm still within the window so it doesn't apply to me right now, but if someone else reading this missed the 30 days they'd need to explain why.

0 coins

The 'you can represent yourself' part is important for people who assume they need to hire someone. A union official or attorney can also appear for you, but it's not required.

0 coins

The overpayment balance on the DE 1080CZ - does it also show on UI Online anywhere? I ask because I had a notice that showed a balance but nothing appeared in my online account for weeks, which made me wonder if EDD had two different records going.

0 coins

UI Online doesn't always reflect overpayment notices immediately. The notice mailing date is what you act on, not when it appears online.

0 coins

The Claim History in UI Online is where you'd check payment status for the specific weeks, not for the overpayment balance. Those are tracked differently.

0 coins

While you're preparing the appeal, keep certifying for any weeks you're currently eligible for. An appeal doesn't put a hold on your ongoing eligibility, and EDD can only issue payment for weeks that have been certified. Missing certifications while dealing with this would just create a separate problem.

0 coins

Still certifying every two weeks - didn't want to stop just because of the notice. Good to hear that's the right approach.

0 coins

EDD can pay back weeks from an appeal only if they were certified - so certifying through the whole process is exactly right.

0 coins

If the appeal goes to a hearing and the administrative law judge sides with you, EDD issues a written decision by mail. If you disagree with that decision, a second-level appeal goes to the CUIAB. But start with the first step - file the appeal, present your Claim History records and your card statement, and let the judge look at whether the deauthorization means no actual payment occurred.

0 coins

Second-level appeal option is good to know about even if I hope I don't need it. Starting with filing the first appeal this week.

0 coins

The judge's written decision being mailed is important - don't expect a phone call or email telling you the outcome. Watch your mailbox after the hearing.

0 coins

Just want to flag something for anyone reading who has a fraud overpayment rather than a non-fraud one: the process is the same (appeal within 30 days with the DE 1000M) but the stakes are higher because fraud adds a 30 percent penalty. The original poster's situation doesn't sound like it involves any accusation of fraud, but someone else searching for overpayment info might need to know the difference.

0 coins

Accurate - and a 30 percent penalty on top of the overpayment amount plus the possibility of a false statement disqualification of 2 to 23 weeks makes it very important to appeal a fraud finding if you believe it's wrong.

0 coins

Whether it says fraud on the DE 1080CZ is usually pretty clear - there's specific language about it. If someone isn't sure, they should read the notice carefully or contact EDD to ask what category the overpayment falls under.

0 coins

EDD can also collect overpayment amounts from future unemployment benefits, state tax refunds, and other state payments if the balance isn't resolved. That's another reason not to ignore the notice even if you plan to appeal. Filing the appeal within the 30 days is the action that protects you while the dispute is open.

0 coins

Collecting from future benefits or tax refunds - didn't know that was an option for them. Filing before the end of this week so there's no risk of the window closing.

0 coins

Appealing within the deadline doesn't stop collection automatically - that's worth checking with EDD - but it does open the formal dispute process which is your strongest position.

0 coins

Has anyone had EDD resolve an overpayment notice for deauthorized payments without a full hearing? Asking because I have something similar starting and I'm wondering if it ever gets corrected administratively before it gets to the CUIAB.

0 coins

EDD does an initial review before sending it to the CUIAB. If your documentation is clear and their records support your position, it's possible the review closes it. But there's no guarantee, and filing the appeal is what triggers that review.

0 coins

My situation resolved at the EDD review stage before it went to an administrative law judge. Having the week-ending dates spelled out and the card statement attached made the record pretty clear.

0 coins

Even if you think it'll resolve at the review stage, file the appeal and keep your documentation. If it doesn't resolve early, you don't want to be scrambling.

0 coins

The Money Network card statement covering those deauthorized weeks is probably your cleanest piece of evidence. If the funds were deauthorized, there will be no credit entry for those dates on the card. That statement plus the Claim History from UI Online showing the deauthorization is a straightforward paper record of what actually happened.

0 coins

Already pulled the card statement for those weeks - exactly as expected, no credit entries for those two weeks at all. That alongside the Claim History printout should tell the story clearly.

0 coins

A clean paper record like that makes the appeal letter easier to write too. You're just describing what two documents already show.

0 coins

After this resolves, one thing worth knowing going forward: if EDD ever deauthorizes a payment while your claim is still active, it's worth contacting them through UI Online messaging or the phone line to get confirmation in writing of what happened with that payment. Having that contemporaneous record makes any future discrepancy much easier to dispute.

0 coins

That's genuinely useful advice going forward. At the time the deauthorizations happened I assumed it would sort itself out without documentation - clearly that wasn't the right assumption.

0 coins

UI Online messages and the Ask EDD form both create a paper trail with timestamps. Using them when something unexpected happens on a claim is a habit worth building.

0 coins

The phone line creates no record on your end unless you take notes. UI Online messaging is better for anything you might need to prove later.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure