Back to California Unemployment

Aisha Ali

Notice of determination not eligible - do I have to pay back benefits California EDD?

Got a Notice of Determination in the mail yesterday and my stomach just dropped. It says I'm not eligible for the weeks I already collected - about seven weeks worth. I was laid off from my warehouse job back in the spring, filed right away, certified every two weeks like I was supposed to, did my work search, registered on CalJOBS, the whole thing. Then out of nowhere this notice shows up saying I'm not eligible. No real explanation I can understand beyond some code on the form. I already spent most of what I collected keeping up with rent and utilities while I was job hunting. I did eventually find something new but it's part time and I'm barely getting by. The notice mentions something about an overpayment but I don't know if that means they're coming after me for all of it or what. I didn't lie about anything when I certified. Never had an employer dispute, no fraud, nothing like that. Do I have to pay all of it back? Is there any way to fight this? I'm seeing something on the notice about an appeal but I'm not sure what that actually means in practice or how long it takes. Has anyone else gotten one of these after already collecting and spending the money?

The appeal form is right there on the notice itself - it's called the DE 1000M and there's a 30-day window from the mailing date printed on the notice to get it in. Miss that date and you're fighting uphill to even get heard. Mail it to the address on the notice, not to some general EDD address. I went through a determination denial last year on my retail job claim and the appeal was the only thing that turned it around. The letter from the Office of Appeals comes with a hearing date at least 10 days before the actual hearing, and you go in front of an administrative law judge. You can represent yourself, bring a union rep, or even an attorney if you want one.

0 coins

Aisha Ali

Author

The DE 1000M is actually printed on the bottom of my notice, so that part's easy. My main worry is whether I have to start paying back the money WHILE the appeal is going on, or if I can wait to see what the judge decides.

0 coins

Keep certifying while the appeal runs - EDD can only pay you back for weeks you actually certified, so going silent during an appeal is a mistake a lot of people make and then regret later.

0 coins

Exactly what the person above said. Never stop certifying during an appeal if you're still unemployed or underemployed. Those weeks sit there waiting if you win.

0 coins

Before I figured out what a determination even was, I thought EDD sent those notices to tell you that you got approved. Spent two days relieved before I actually read the whole thing and realized it was a denial. Turns out the DE 429Z that shows your weekly benefit amount is the award notice - the DE 1080CZ, the determination notice, is what comes when EDD has actually decided you don't qualify, and it always comes with the appeal form. The two are completely different documents and I've seen people mix them up constantly on here.

0 coins

Aisha Ali

Author

Oh I definitely had that backwards in my head too. I thought getting paid meant I was approved and that was that. Didn't realize EDD could come back later after I'd already collected.

0 coins

EDD can and does open things back up after payments have gone out, especially if the employer responds late or new info comes in. That's exactly what determinations are for - they're the formal decision after the fact sometimes.

0 coins

yeah i assumed the same thing when i first filed, like once the money hits your card you're good. nope lol

0 coins

Seven weeks of benefits sitting in that overpayment notice is a stressful amount to have hanging over you. Ended up in a similar spot after my distribution center job - EDD issued a determination against me and I needed to know whether my specific situation counted as fraud or just a regular overpayment, because the difference matters a lot for what comes next. Claimyr (claimyr.com) is what I ended up using to actually get through to a live EDD agent on the phone - there's a video there about reaching a live person at EDD if you want to see what that looks like: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The agent pulled up my account and confirmed the overpayment was coded as non-fraud, which meant no penalty on top of the balance, and told me I could request the DE 1446UI waiver form if repaying would be a real hardship. That's the overpayment waiver - it's separate from the appeal and you can ask about both at the same time.

0 coins

Aisha Ali

Author

Non-fraud vs fraud - that's exactly the distinction I needed to understand. I didn't misreport anything so I'm hoping mine would be non-fraud too. Had no idea there was a waiver form separate from the appeal process.

0 coins

The DE 1446UI is the form for the waiver and you have to show it wasn't your fault and that paying it back would cause real hardship. No guarantees EDD approves it but it's worth asking about if you genuinely spent the money on necessities.

0 coins

important to know you can appeal AND ask for a waiver at the same time, they're separate tracks. one doesn't cancel out the other

0 coins

The fraud versus non-fraud question is the first thing to figure out. The notice itself usually makes this clear - if yours says false statement or fraud anywhere on it, there's a 30 percent penalty added on top of whatever you owe, plus a potential disqualification of somewhere between 2 and 23 weeks on future claims. If it's non-fraud, there's no penalty tacked on, just the principal amount. What does your notice actually say about the reason for ineligibility?

0 coins

Aisha Ali

Author

Mine doesn't say anything about false statements or fraud. It references a code that I had to look up and it's something about availability for work. I was available for work every week I certified, I just don't understand what triggered this.

0 coins

Availability issues are one of the most common reasons for a determination denial. EDD sometimes gets information from an employer that suggests you weren't fully available during certain weeks - could be something about a trip, a schedule restriction you mentioned somewhere, or even just how you answered the certification questions. That's exactly the kind of thing worth fighting at an appeal hearing because you can explain directly to the judge what your actual situation was.

0 coins

availability denials are absolutely appealable and judges hear these constantly. bring any calendar records, emails, text messages, anything that shows you were actively looking and available during those weeks

0 coins

Went through almost this exact sequence after losing a hotel front desk job. Notice showed up about two months after I'd already collected five weeks. I panicked and called a family member who told me to just start paying it back immediately and not bother appealing. That was bad advice I'm glad I didn't follow. Appealing first is almost always the right move before agreeing to repay anything, because if you win, there's nothing to pay back.

0 coins

Aisha Ali

Author

The instinct to just pay it and make it go away is real. Good reminder that appealing first actually makes sense before doing anything else.

0 coins

and even if you lose the appeal, you can still ask about the waiver. the two things aren't mutually exclusive at all. a lot of people don't know that

0 coins

Exactly - losing an appeal doesn't close the waiver door. EDD looks at whether the overpayment was your fault and whether repaying it would be an extraordinary hardship. Those are independent questions from whether you qualified for benefits.

0 coins

The 30-day appeal window is firm and people miss it thinking they have more time. The mailing date on the notice is the clock that starts ticking, not the date you received it. If you're close to or past that date, you can still submit a late appeal but you need to explain why it was late and EDD has to find the reason acceptable. Don't sit on this.

0 coins

Aisha Ali

Author

Mine just arrived yesterday and the mailing date is four days ago, so I still have plenty of time. But yeah, good warning - I've been reading it over and over for two days instead of actually acting on it.

0 coins

four days in with 30 days total means you have time to actually put together a decent written statement to send with the appeal form rather than just firing off a quick note. the more context you give the better

0 coins

Agree - attach a written statement with the DE 1000M laying out your specific facts. The form itself is just a few lines but nothing stops you from including a page or two explaining your situation and why you believe the determination is wrong.

0 coins

Something that tripped me up when I got my determination letter was thinking the phone interview I'd already done was the same thing as the appeal hearing. They are completely different. The phone interview EDD schedules when there's a question about your claim - the date and time are on the DE 4800 notice and on your UI Online homepage - is for EDD to gather information before it makes a decision. The appeal hearing in front of the administrative law judge is what happens AFTER the decision if you disagree with it. I'd already been through the interview and thought I'd made my case there, but that wasn't the appeal.

0 coins

Aisha Ali

Author

This cleared something up for me. I did have a phone interview back when I first filed and I think I assumed that was my chance to dispute anything. Didn't realize the hearing is a separate formal proceeding.

0 coins

The hearing is testimony under oath in front of a judge, which sounds intense but most people represent themselves just fine. You can also bring a union rep or an attorney if your workplace had one. The notice of hearing comes by mail at least 10 days before so you get some prep time.

0 coins

The testimony under oath part sounds scarier than it usually is. Basically you're just telling the judge what you told EDD during the interview, but now there's a record and a decision that can go in your favor if your facts hold up.

0 coins

My Notice of Determination came after EDD got information from my former staffing agency employer that conflicted with what I'd put on my certifications. The whole thing was infuriating because I had reported my wages correctly - the agency was reporting numbers on a different schedule than I'd earned them. Used Claimyr to get a live EDD agent on the phone and had them walk through my account week by week. The agent confirmed which specific weeks were flagged and what the wage discrepancy looked like on their end, which let me pull the right pay stubs before my appeal hearing.

0 coins

Aisha Ali

Author

Wage reporting timing is something I hadn't even considered. The idea that an employer's reporting schedule could create a discrepancy even when you did everything right is kind of alarming.

0 coins

It's more common with staffing agencies and gig-type work where the pay cycle doesn't line up neatly with the certification period. Report wages for the week you earned them, not when the check comes - but if the employer is reporting on a different basis EDD sees a mismatch.

0 coins

that explains a situation that happened to a coworker of mine, she reported everything right but the company's payroll timing threw off what EDD was seeing. ended up being resolved at appeal

0 coins

Worth knowing that the appeal hearing has real teeth - an administrative law judge can fully overturn the determination. It's not just an internal EDD review. The case goes from EDD to the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board, which is a separate body. If you lose at that level there's even a second-level appeal to CUIAB itself. I'm not saying you'll need all of that, but the system does have multiple rungs.

0 coins

Aisha Ali

Author

Knowing there's more than one shot at this is reassuring. I was thinking the appeals board would just rubber stamp whatever EDD decided.

0 coins

the judge at the first hearing is an administrative law judge who hears these cases all day, they're not EDD employees and they absolutely do overturn determinations when the facts support it

0 coins

And whatever you do, keep copies of everything you submit. The mailed appeal form, any attached statement, the envelope, all of it. You want a paper trail showing what you sent and when.

0 coins

Had an employer respond to EDD weeks after my claim was filed and it triggered a whole reconsideration that ended in a determination I had to appeal. The employer said I'd quit voluntarily when I'd actually been told my position was eliminated. That kind of factual dispute is exactly what the appeal hearing is for because the judge hears both sides - well, actually EDD doesn't send anyone to argue against you, the judge just reviews the file and takes your testimony.

0 coins

Aisha Ali

Author

Wait, EDD doesn't actually show up to argue the other side? I assumed it was like a court case with two attorneys.

0 coins

Nope, it's you and the judge and the record. EDD's side is basically the file they compiled. Some employers do show up or participate by phone but many don't, especially for smaller claims. Your testimony and any documents you bring are your case.

0 coins

this is actually a lot less intimidating than i thought. i pictured some attorney grilling you about every certification question

0 coins

The overpayment waiver process is worth understanding separately from the appeal. Even if your appeal doesn't succeed, the DE 1446UI waiver is a real option when the overpayment wasn't caused by fraud or intentional misreporting AND repaying it would create an extraordinary hardship. EDD looks at your income, your expenses, your ability to pay. It's not automatic and not everyone gets it, but it's a legitimate path that exists for exactly the situation you're describing - benefits spent on rent and utilities while you were genuinely unemployed.

0 coins

Aisha Ali

Author

This is what I needed to hear. I didn't lie about anything and I genuinely needed that money to stay housed. The hardship is real and ongoing.

0 coins

Document your financial situation carefully when you request the waiver. Income, monthly expenses, what you spent the benefits on. The more concrete your hardship case is, the better EDD can evaluate it.

0 coins

And the waiver request doesn't stop EDD from collecting if they decide not to grant it, so appeal first, waiver request as a parallel track, and then see where things land.

0 coins

okay genuine question bc i'm reading this and panicking a little about my own claim - does EDD always send a determination notice eventually even if you've been getting paid for months? like is this something that can happen to anyone at any time or only if something specific triggers it

0 coins

A determination notice comes when EDD has to formally decide a question about your eligibility - could be triggered by an employer response, a discrepancy in your certifications, an identity issue, whatever. If nothing flags, some people go their whole claim without getting one beyond the initial award notice.

0 coins

okay that's slightly less terrifying. so it's not like a random audit situation necessarily

0 coins

Employers have 10 days from EDD's notice to respond when you file. If they respond late or if something they say contradicts what you reported, that can kick off a review even after you've been paid. That's why employer responses sometimes trigger determinations months into a claim.

0 coins

The hardship argument for the waiver is strongest when you can show the money went to basic living expenses - rent, utilities, food, medical. EDD is weighing whether making you repay would cause extraordinary hardship. That's a higher bar than just saying it's inconvenient, but someone who spent the money on necessities while actively job searching and is now working part time is exactly the kind of situation the waiver exists for.

0 coins

Aisha Ali

Author

Rent and utilities is literally all I spent it on. I have bank statements and receipts that could show that if needed.

0 coins

Hold onto all of that. If you end up pursuing the waiver, being able to show where the money actually went strengthens your case considerably.

0 coins

bank statements showing rent payments and utility charges are probably the most useful thing you can bring to both the appeal and any waiver discussion

0 coins

My determination letter came after a CalJOBS issue - I hadn't posted my resume within the 21-day window on the Notice of Requirement to Register for Work because I didn't understand what the DE 8405 was asking me to do. I thought registering meant just creating the account, not actually posting a resume. EDD flagged it and payments stopped. That one got resolved once I actually completed the registration properly and explained the confusion to EDD.

0 coins

Aisha Ali

Author

I did complete CalJOBS properly, at least I think I did - I registered and put up a resume within the first week. But now I'm second-guessing whether I did it all right.

0 coins

If you registered AND posted the resume within 21 days of the date on the DE 8405, you should be fine on that piece. The requirement is both steps, not just creating the account.

0 coins

a lot of people stop at account creation and don't realize the resume posting is a separate required step. EDD is pretty clear about it on the notice but people miss it

0 coins

Reading through this whole thread because I got a similar notice two weeks ago and was completely frozen about what to do. The appeal part I finally understood - it's the waiver option I didn't know existed until now. The idea that there's a separate form for hardship cases if the appeal doesn't go your way is new information for me.

0 coins

Don't wait on the appeal while you're researching the waiver. The 30-day clock on the determination is firm and those two paths can run at the same time.

0 coins

I still have about 12 days left on my window. Going to mail the DE 1000M tomorrow.

0 coins

Mailing it with proof of delivery - tracked mail from the post office - is worth the small extra cost so you have evidence of when it was sent and received.

0 coins

Something that caught me completely off guard: when I got my determination notice I assumed I'd have to stop certifying while the appeal was pending. Actually kept not certifying for about six weeks because I thought that's what you did during a dispute. By the time I found out I was supposed to keep going, I had uncertified weeks that EDD couldn't pay even when I eventually won the appeal. Don't make that mistake.

0 coins

Aisha Ali

Author

This is the second time in this thread someone has mentioned this and I'm glad because I definitely would have stopped certifying thinking it was the right thing to do.

0 coins

EDD can only go back and pay weeks that were actually certified. Winning an appeal for uncertified weeks gets you nothing. Keep certifying no matter what until the whole thing is resolved.

0 coins

Learned it the hard way. Won the appeal but lost about six weeks of benefits I could have had if I'd just kept certifying through the process.

0 coins

The determination code on my notice pointed to an availability question too, same as the person who started this thread. My situation was that I'd mentioned during my phone interview that I had a doctor's appointment that limited my hours one specific week, and EDD flagged that whole week as me not being fully available. Had to get through to EDD to understand exactly which week was the problem. Used Claimyr and ended up talking to an agent who confirmed it was just that single week in question, not the whole claim period - which was a lot better than I'd feared.

0 coins

Aisha Ali

Author

One specific week being the issue versus the whole claim being invalidated is a huge difference. Knowing which weeks are actually flagged before the appeal would help me prepare so much better.

0 coins

Ask EDD directly which weeks the determination covers and what triggered each one. Having that specificity going into an appeal hearing lets you bring documentation for exactly those weeks instead of guessing.

0 coins

Availability for work is required every week you certify, so if there's a question about a specific week that's what the judge looks at. Being able to show you were available and looking that particular week, with any evidence you have, is the core of an availability appeal.

0 coins

The hearing itself is less formal than most people imagine - you're testifying and explaining your situation to the judge, who already has EDD's file and will ask you questions. Some employers participate by phone, some don't. What you want going in is a clear timeline of what happened, any documents that support your version of events, and a plain explanation of why you believe the determination got it wrong. Judges hear these cases all day and can tell when someone is telling a straight story.

0 coins

Aisha Ali

Author

I have emails from my former employer confirming the layoff, pay stubs, my CalJOBS activity records, and screenshots of my certification history. Sounds like bringing all of that makes sense.

0 coins

All of that is exactly the right material. The layoff confirmation from the employer is particularly useful if the determination is suggesting something other than a layoff as the reason you stopped working.

0 coins

Organize it chronologically before the hearing so you can find things quickly when the judge asks. A folder with everything in date order is worth putting together ahead of time.

0 coins

EDD collecting on overpayments has real reach - they can take it from future unemployment benefits, disability payments, Paid Family Leave, state tax refunds, state lottery winnings. They can also put a lien on things or get a court judgment if it goes that far. I'm not saying that to scare anyone, just so the stakes of actually fighting this through appeal and waiver are clear. This isn't something to just ignore and hope goes away.

0 coins

Aisha Ali

Author

Okay that actually does clarify the stakes. I wasn't going to ignore it but good to understand what 'not ignoring it' actually means in practice.

0 coins

Appeal within 30 days, keep certifying, ask about the waiver - those three things are your active response. Waiting passively while the clock runs is the only genuinely bad option here.

0 coins

the tax refund offset one caught me off guard when I read it on the notice. they're not kidding around about collection if it gets that far

0 coins

My sister told me once that if EDD already paid you then they basically forgive it and don't come back for it - I believed that for way too long and it made me not take my determination seriously enough when I got one. That's just not how it works. The overpayment is real and collectible regardless of how long ago the payments were made or what you spent the money on.

0 coins

i think a lot of people believe some version of that. like once it's in your bank account it's yours. wish that were true

0 coins

EDD sends out determinations sometimes months after you've been paid, the payments don't protect you from an overpayment finding. The only thing that potentially wipes the balance is a successful appeal or an approved waiver.

0 coins

Worth repeating clearly: getting paid is not the same as being approved. EDD pays out pending weeks and can still formally decide later that those weeks weren't eligible. The determination is the formal decision.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure