Back to California Unemployment

Ayla Kumar

Notice of determination not eligible code section 1253a – should I appeal?

Got my Notice of Determination in the mail yesterday and my stomach dropped reading it. EDD says I'm not eligible and cited code section 1253(a) on the notice. I've never dealt with this before and I honestly don't know if I'm reading it right. Some background: I was laid off from my warehouse job back in mid-October, applied right away, did everything they asked including the phone interview, registered on CalJOBS and posted my resume within the deadline. Now three weeks later this notice shows up saying I'm not eligible. The DE 1080CZ has the Appeal Form (DE 1000M) attached to it. The notice says I have 30 days from the mailing date to appeal. My question is whether it's even worth trying to appeal this or if section 1253(a) is basically a dead end. Has anyone else received this exact notice and what did you do?

Termination date on mine said October 3rd and EDD sent the same DE 1080CZ citing 1253(a) about six weeks into my claim. Got through to an EDD agent using Claimyr (claimyr.com) — their video explaining how to reach a live person at EDD is at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The agent pulled up my account and told me the 1253(a) issue on my claim was flagged because EDD had a question about whether I was able and available for work during a specific week I'd certified. She said the interview notes showed I'd mentioned a doctor's appointment that ran all day, and EDD read that as me being unavailable. I went back through my certification and realized I'd answered a question in a way that made it sound like I wasn't available that entire week. The agent said to appeal in writing within 30 days of the mailing date on the notice, attach anything showing I was available and looking for work that week, and EDD would review it before it went to a hearing.

0 coins

The 'able and available' angle is exactly what I was afraid of. At my phone interview I mentioned I had been dealing with some back pain — do you think that's what flagged it? I didn't say I couldn't work, just that I was uncomfortable.

0 coins

Hard to say without seeing your interview notes, but that kind of language can trip the system. Appeal it and explain clearly you were still able and available for work every week you certified. Attach anything you have — job applications, emails to employers, whatever you sent out that week.

0 coins

1253(a) basically means EDD decided you didn't meet one of the basic eligibility conditions for some week. It's broad enough that it covers able-and-available issues, work search issues, and a few other things. The notice itself should say which condition they're questioning.

0 coins

Filing the appeal is worth doing if you believe the determination is wrong. What I'd do first in your shoes is read every line of the DE 1080CZ very carefully — sometimes there's a sentence buried in the middle that tells you exactly which condition EDD thinks you failed. 1253(a) in California's Unemployment Insurance Code covers the basic eligibility conditions for each week: being able to work, being available for work, and actively looking for work. If EDD decided you didn't meet one of those for a specific week, that's what they'll be looking at in the appeal hearing. Write your appeal letter now, before you even think about what to say at a hearing, because the 30-day clock from the mailing date is real and doesn't get extended just because you're confused.

0 coins

The notice does have a line that says something about 'availability for work' — so I think that's the angle. Does the appeal letter need to be super detailed or can I just say I disagree and want a hearing?

0 coins

You can send a short letter just saying you disagree and want to appeal, and that gets you in the door. But the more specific you are about why you believe you were available and looking for work, the better. Attach any evidence you have from those weeks: job search records, emails, applications. The administrative law judge at the hearing will look at all of it.

0 coins

agreed, don't overthink the initial letter. get it in the mail or submitted before the deadline and then build your case after.

0 coins

MY NOTICE SAID THE EXACT SAME THING last month and I want to scream about it. I had my interview, I was looking for work, I did everything right, and they still sent me that DE 1080CZ. What kills me is that I had no idea what 1253(a) even meant until I found this forum. EDD's notice doesn't explain it in plain English at all, it just cites the code and leaves you to figure it out. I appealed it three weeks ago and I'm still waiting to hear when my hearing is scheduled.

0 coins

How long did it take for them to send you the Notice of Hearing after you submitted your appeal letter?

0 coins

Haven't gotten the hearing notice yet. Someone told me the CUIAB mails it at least 10 days before the actual hearing date, so I'm just watching the mailbox. Keep certifying in the meantime — that's what someone here told me and I've been doing it.

0 coins

Keep certifying is the right call. If your appeal goes your way, EDD can only pay back the weeks you actually certified for. Skipping certifications while you wait means losing those weeks permanently even if you win.

0 coins

DE 429Z came in the mail two weeks before the DE 1080CZ for me, which was confusing because I thought the award letter meant I was approved. Someone here corrected me on that — the DE 429Z just shows what your weekly benefit amount could be and the total your claim might pay, but it isn't EDD saying you've been found eligible week by week. The eligibility decision for each week is a separate thing.

0 coins

I made the same mistake with the award letter. Assumed it meant I was good to go and then got blindsided by an adjudication issue two weeks later.

0 coins

Worth spelling out clearly since this comes up a lot: the DE 429Z is not an approval. It tells you what the claim is worth based on your wages, but EDD still has to decide eligibility for each week you certify. If there's a question about any week, those weeks sit as Pending in UI Online Claim History until EDD resolves them.

0 coins

wait so i could get a DE 429Z and still end up getting denied?? why do they even send that first if its not an approval lol

0 coins

Availability for work questions under 1253(a) come up more than people realize. What I would do first if I got that notice is pull out every job application, every email, every record of any contact with an employer from the weeks in question. EDD's own position is that you must be able to work, available for work, and looking for work for every single week you're certifying — that's just how the program works. If you can show documented job search activity for those weeks, that's your strongest argument at the hearing.

0 coins

The weeks flagged are the ones right after my injury comment at the interview. I do have emails to two employers from those weeks. Is that enough?

0 coins

Two documented contacts is a start. At the hearing you'll want to explain clearly that the back pain didn't stop you from working — it just made you uncomfortable — and that you were actively searching. The administrative law judge hears testimony under oath and weighs all the evidence.

0 coins

something to be careful about: make sure your emails to employers are from the actual weeks in question, not before or after. the ALJ will look at dates closely

0 coins

Appeals Board hearings are less intimidating than they sound. Administrative law judge, testimony under oath, but you can represent yourself — you don't need a lawyer. The Notice of Hearing from CUIAB will come in the mail at least 10 days before the hearing date, and it lays out the process. Some people bring a union rep or an attorney but plenty of people go alone and do fine.

0 coins

Can I bring written documents to the hearing or does it all have to be verbal testimony?

0 coins

Bring every document you have — job search records, the DE 4800 from your phone interview, pay stubs, anything relevant. The hearing is your chance to present your full case, not just answer questions.

0 coins

CUIAB hearings have been going hybrid lately — some by phone, some in person, some video. The notice will say how yours is scheduled. Either way, have your documents ready to reference.

0 coins

Before mailing the appeal, double check the mailing date on your DE 1080CZ — that's the date the 30 days runs from, not the day you received it. Mail sometimes takes several days to arrive, which eats into your window without you realizing it. If you're close to the deadline, the appeal form is DE 1000M and you can mail it to the address on the notice or drop it off. Some people choose to send it certified mail so they have proof of when it was sent.

0 coins

The mailing date on mine is 11 days ago so I still have about 19 days. Sending it certified this week.

0 coins

That's a reasonable window. Get it out as soon as the letter is as specific as you want it to be, don't cut it close.

0 coins

i almost missed my 30 day window because i thought the date to count from was the date i received it. glad someone corrected me before i blew the deadline

0 coins

Waiting week confusion tripped me up early in my claim — I thought the first week showing as Pending meant I'd been denied, but it was just the unpaid waiting period. Ended up spending a week panicking before I understood what was actually going on. Eventually I used Claimyr to get a live EDD agent on the phone because the UI Online status wasn't telling me anything useful. The agent looked up my account and confirmed the first week was the waiting week every claim has, and that the following certified weeks were processing normally. Knowing that, I stopped panicking and just waited for payments to post.

0 coins

i thought pending always meant something was wrong too. good to know it can just be normal processing

0 coins

For a standard new claim, some pending is totally normal. The situation in this thread is different — a Notice of Determination citing 1253(a) is an actual eligibility decision, not just processing status.

0 coins

Mine went from pending to this determination, so it wasn't just normal processing lag for me. EDD clearly made a decision on those weeks and the determination is what came out.

0 coins

One thing that helped me understand my own determination was writing out a timeline: exactly which weeks were in question, what I did for work search each of those weeks, and what I said at the interview. When I could see it laid out that way, I could see where EDD might have gotten the wrong impression and I could build my appeal letter around correcting exactly that misunderstanding. The hearing is basically your chance to give EDD the full picture it didn't have when it made the original decision.

0 coins

That's a really practical way to approach it. I'm going to do exactly that tonight — lay out the timeline and figure out what I actually said versus what I did.

0 coins

The timeline approach is solid. I did something similar for my appeal and it helped me stay on track during the hearing instead of rambling. The ALJ will keep you focused but you don't want to be caught searching through papers.

0 coins

My cousin told me that if you lose the appeal hearing you can't do anything else — I want to flag that this is wrong before anyone takes it as fact. There's actually a second level: if you lose at the administrative law judge hearing, you can appeal again to the full California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board. The ALJ's written decision is mailed after the hearing, and that decision will tell you your options if you disagree.

0 coins

Good to know. I'm hoping it doesn't get that far but it's reassuring that losing the first hearing isn't the end of the road.

0 coins

Most cases don't go to the second level, but it exists. Focus on the first hearing and presenting your case clearly.

0 coins

never knew there were two levels of appeal. this forum is way more useful than trying to find this on edd.ca.gov

0 coins

Section 1253 lays out the basic conditions you have to meet every week to draw benefits. The (a) part specifically is about being able to work and available for work. If EDD flagged something you said at the phone interview about being physically limited, that's almost certainly the angle. What you'd want to show at the hearing is that whatever you said about your back didn't mean you were unwilling or unable to take a job if one was offered to you.

0 coins

That's exactly the distinction I need to make clear. I could have worked — I just had some discomfort. I wasn't turning down offers or refusing to go in somewhere.

0 coins

Then say that plainly at the hearing. The ALJ will ask you direct questions and your answers should be specific: what your physical condition actually was, what kinds of jobs you were applying for, and that you would have accepted a job offer if you'd gotten one.

0 coins

the able and available language is the crux of 1253(a) claims from what i've seen reading these threads. if you can show you would've taken a job, you're making the right argument

0 coins

Employer response timing cost me my first determination. The last day I worked was a Friday and my employer didn't respond to EDD's claim notice within 10 days, so I assumed everything was fine. Then the DE 1080CZ arrived citing 1253(a) and I realized EDD had flagged an availability question from my interview completely separately from the employer side. Got a live EDD agent on the phone through Claimyr and found out there was a note in my file from the interview that the agent said was flagging my availability for two specific weeks. The agent told me exactly which weeks were in question so I knew what to address in my appeal.

0 coins

That's useful — I hadn't considered asking EDD directly which specific weeks the determination is about before writing my appeal. Can an agent actually tell you that over the phone?

0 coins

The agent told me the two specific weeks and what the flag said. That made my appeal letter much more precise than it would have been if I'd just guessed.

0 coins

wish I had done that before writing my appeal letter. I basically addressed all the weeks generally instead of zeroing in on the ones EDD actually had the question about.

0 coins

Certifying is worth emphasizing again because it trips people up during appeals. Keep certifying every two weeks even while your appeal is pending. If the ALJ rules in your favor, EDD will only release payment for weeks you actually certified. Any weeks you skipped because you assumed there was no point — those are gone even if you win.

0 coins

Already kept certifying through all of this. Didn't want to stop in case things went my way.

0 coins

Smart. Plenty of people stop when they get the denial notice thinking it's over. It's not, and those skipped weeks are costly if you end up winning your appeal.

0 coins

i stopped certifying for about three weeks when i got denied thinking it was pointless. cost me those weeks when i eventually won. don't do what i did

0 coins

CalJOBS registration sometimes comes up in 1253(a) hearings if EDD is questioning your availability and work search at the same time. Just make sure your CalJOBS profile is complete and your resume is posted — the DE 8405 you got after applying told you to do it within 21 days. If that deadline passed and you haven't done it, go take care of it now before the hearing.

0 coins

I did register on CalJOBS and post a resume — I mentioned that in my original post. Is there any way EDD can verify that at the hearing?

0 coins

EDD has access to the CalJOBS system and your registration date is in there. If it's completed you should be fine on that front.

0 coins

CalJOBS registration and the work search requirement are separate things in EDD's system. Registration is the account and resume piece. Work search is you actually applying to jobs every week. Both can come up under a 1253(a) availability question so make sure both are covered.

0 coins

Got the DE 1080CZ two months ago for a different reason but the appeal process feels overwhelming when you're already stressed about money. Mailing the DE 1000M felt like a huge step but once it was done I felt better just because I had done something instead of sitting with the denial. Even if you're not sure you'll win, filing the appeal is the only way to get a hearing and have your side heard.

0 coins

That's how I'm feeling too — doing something is better than just accepting a determination I think is wrong.

0 coins

Exactly. EDD makes a decision with the information it has at the time, which is often incomplete. The hearing is your chance to fill in what they missed.

0 coins

Unemployment insurance under 1253(a) requires meeting eligibility conditions for each individual week — that's how EDD thinks about it, week by week, not as a whole claim. So even if your overall claim is valid and your DE 429Z shows a weekly benefit amount, any single week where EDD decides you weren't able and available gets denied. The good news is you can appeal week-specific determinations, and an administrative law judge can reverse EDD's finding on individual weeks if the evidence supports it.

0 coins

so they can deny some weeks and approve others? i didn't know it worked that way. i thought it was all or nothing

0 coins

Yes, it's week by week. A 1253(a) determination might cover multiple weeks but each one is technically its own eligibility question. You could win on some weeks and lose on others at the same hearing, depending on what the evidence shows for each.

0 coins

this is why keeping records for every individual week matters so much. if you're only able to prove work search for certain weeks the ALJ can only rule in your favor on those

0 coins

Something I noticed in my own determination was that the DE 1080CZ listed specific dates — it wasn't vague about which weeks EDD was questioning. When I first read mine I skipped over those dates because I was focused on the code section, but going back and finding them made the whole thing clearer. If you haven't pinpointed the exact dates on yours, that's the first thing to do before writing the appeal.

0 coins

Going to look again tonight. I saw the code section and kind of stopped reading carefully after that — probably missed some detail.

0 coins

The specific dates are usually in the body of the notice, sometimes in a table. Finding them tells you exactly which weeks to build your documentation around.

0 coins

the notice also sometimes describes what EDD believes happened — it won't just cite the code, it'll say something like 'claimant stated' and then quote from your interview. that quoted piece is exactly what you need to address in your appeal letter

0 coins

Hearing from an administrative law judge felt intimidating until I actually got on the call. The judge asked me straightforward questions about what I was doing for work search, whether I had any physical limitations that would stop me from taking a job, and what my job hunt looked like week by week. Having my notes in front of me helped more than I expected.

0 coins

Was your hearing by phone or in person?

0 coins

Mine was by phone. The notice told me in advance and gave me a number to call in. I had all my papers spread out in front of me which you obviously can't do as easily in person.

0 coins

phone hearings actually give you an advantage in that way — you can have all your documents, notes, job search records right in front of you without it being awkward

0 coins

Eligibility under 1253(a) in California means more than just saying you're available — EDD expects that you're available for work you're actually qualified to do, that you haven't placed unreasonable restrictions on the work you'd accept, and that you're genuinely in the labor market. At the hearing, being specific about what kinds of jobs you were applying for and why you were well-suited for them strengthens your case.

0 coins

I was applying for general warehouse and logistics work, same as my background. Nothing weird or overly restrictive about my search.

0 coins

Then lead with that at the hearing. You were searching within your field, you have direct experience, and you would have accepted a job if offered. That's a strong position on the availability question.

0 coins

backing up what 5 said — EDD is wary of claimants who claim to be available but only for one very specific kind of job at a very high salary. showing a broad realistic search helps.

0 coins

genuinely confused by all the code sections and notice numbers in this thread but reading through it made me realize i should appeal the determination i got last week too. mine also said 1253 something. thought it meant my whole claim was permanently denied forever

0 coins

A determination isn't permanent — that's what the appeal process is for. You have 30 days from the mailing date on your notice to get your appeal in. Check the date on the DE 1080CZ and count from there.

0 coins

i have 12 days left apparently. going to send the DE 1000M tomorrow

0 coins

Good — don't cut it closer than that. Mail it tomorrow, keep a copy of everything you send, and keep certifying while you wait for the hearing notice.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure