Back to California Unemployment

Dmitry Ivanov

Notice of determination appeal after already employed - do I keep certifying?

Okay so here's my situation and I genuinely don't know what to do. I filed for unemployment back in August after getting laid off from my marketing job, went through the whole process, had the phone interview because my former employer apparently tried to contest it, and then just... waited. The weeks kept showing Pending in Claim History and nothing moved. Fast forward about six weeks, I found a new job and started working. Great, right? Well now I just got a Notice of Determination in the mail saying I was disqualified for some of those earlier pending weeks. The mailing date on it is from last week. It came with an Appeal Form (DE 1000M). Here's what's confusing me: I already have a job now. The weeks they're disqualifying were from when I was actually unemployed and looking. I know I can appeal within 30 days of that mailing date. But does it even make sense to appeal when I'm working again? And the bigger question - do I need to keep certifying for those old weeks while the appeal goes on, or do I just stop since I'm employed now? I've read conflicting things online. Some people say stop certifying completely once you're working, others say you have to keep certifying during an appeal or you lose the ability to get back pay if you win. I'm really confused about what the right move is here.

Disqualification covering weeks from August - that DE 1080CZ is worth appealing even with a new job locked in, depending on how many weeks and what the weekly benefit amount was. Mine was $390 a week and I had four pending weeks when I got a similar notice, so I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to an EDD agent to ask exactly this question. The video they have on reaching a live person at EDD is at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The agent pulled up my claim and told me my Claim History still showed those weeks as pending under the open benefit year, and that I'd need to certify each two-week period to preserve my right to back pay if the appeal went my way. She also confirmed that filing an appeal on the DE 1000M doesn't pause the certification schedule - the weeks keep rolling whether or not the appeal is active.

0 coins

The part about the certification schedule not pausing is exactly what I needed to know. So even though I'm employed now, I'd still certify for those specific back weeks from when I was unemployed and report my zero earnings for that period?

0 coins

DE 1080CZ is the right form to look at, yes. The appeal is about the weeks listed on that notice, and certifying keeps those weeks in play. If you stop and win the appeal, EDD has nothing to pay because the weeks weren't certified.

0 coins

30 days goes fast, especially with starting a new job and everything feeling chaotic. The mailing date on the front of the notice is what the clock runs from, not when you actually opened it.

0 coins

30 days from the mailing date caught me off guard when I went through mine. By the time I really read the notice carefully I'd already burned like 10 days just sitting there confused. The appeal goes to the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board after EDD reviews it, and an administrative law judge handles the actual hearing. You can represent yourself, it's not some formal courtroom thing.

0 coins

That timeline stress is real. I've already been sitting on this for four days just trying to figure out what to do. Good to know about the CUIAB and the judge - I was picturing something way more intimidating.

0 coins

CUIAB hearings are genuinely less scary than they sound. Testimony is under oath but the judge walks you through it. Having your pay stubs, your certification records, and anything from your former employer helps a lot.

0 coins

the notice has the address to mail the appeal to right on it, people miss that and send it to the wrong place

0 coins

The certifying question has two parts that people mix up. First: certifying for PAST weeks you're appealing - yes, keep doing it, those weeks need to be certified or EDD has no basis to pay them even if you win. Second: certifying going forward now that you're working - if you're working full time you're not eligible week to week, so you'd stop certifying for new weeks. But those old disputed weeks from August? Those need to be certified separately if the schedule still allows it, or you can ask EDD about certifying late for them.

0 coins

Okay this actually clears it up for me. The weeks on the notice are the contested ones from when I was actually laid off. I need to certify for those to protect my appeal. For current weeks where I'm employed full time, I just don't certify because I'm not eligible. That makes way more sense.

0 coins

this is the right breakdown, I wish someone had told me this when I appealed mine last year, I stopped certifying entirely and lost back pay on three weeks I would have won

0 coins

The late certification question is real - if the two-week windows have already passed, you'd want to contact EDD directly about it. UI Online has a message option through your account, or you can call.

0 coins

also worth noting you should report any wages accurately when certifying for those back weeks - even if it was zero earnings, you fill in zero and certify honestly

0 coins

wait so if she already has a job does she even need to bother appealing? seems like a lot of effort

0 coins

The dollar amount matters here. If the disqualified weeks add up to, say, $1,500 or more in potential back pay, the effort of filing a written appeal and attending a hearing is probably worth it. The weekly benefit amount times the number of disqualified weeks - that math tells you whether to push forward.

0 coins

Mine works out to about $1,100 for three weeks. Not life-changing but definitely not nothing. I think I'm going to appeal.

0 coins

always appeal. worst case you lose and you're exactly where you are now. best case you get the back pay. there's no downside to filing the DE 1000M

0 coins

The employer contesting piece is what I want to flag. When a former employer challenges the claim, EDD interviews both sides and then issues the Notice of Determination. The burden is on the employer to prove misconduct if they're saying you were fired for cause - but you said you were laid off, so the employer disputing it probably argued something else. What reason did the notice give for the disqualification?

0 coins

It says something about availability for work - which is bizarre because I was applying everywhere. I did take one weekend trip in September but I was available every weekday and had applied to multiple jobs that week.

0 coins

That availability question is exactly what a hearing is for. You'd present your work search records, explain the trip, show you were still available and looking. The administrative law judge hears your side and the record from the interview.

0 coins

document everything you remember about that week - where you applied, the dates, any email confirmations from employers. judges look for specifics

0 coins

genuinely confused why the determination came so long after the original claim, is that normal? like months later?

0 coins

EDD's adjudication backlog is real. When an employer disputes a claim or there's an eligibility question, the wheels turn slowly. Getting a Notice of Determination months after the fact is not unusual at all.

0 coins

the weeks staying Pending in Claim History for that long is actually the sign that adjudication is happening. once a decision is made, one way or the other, the notice goes out.

0 coins

ok that explains why my own claim has been pending for weeks, good to know its not just sitting forgotten

0 coins

One thing I want to make sure people know: you can write your own letter instead of using the DE 1000M form specifically, as long as it's in writing and mailed to the address on the notice within those 30 days. Some people assume the form is mandatory.

0 coins

true but the form makes it easy because it has prompts. I used mine and just added an extra page explaining my situation.

0 coins

The DE 1000M is in the envelope with the notice, right? I'm going to use it since I have it in front of me already.

0 coins

yes it comes with the DE 1080CZ in the same mailing. fill it out, attach anything supporting your case, mail it to the address printed on the notice.

0 coins

Lost three weeks of back pay on my own appeal two years ago because I stopped certifying when I found work. Nobody told me to keep going. If I'd certified for those contested weeks I would have gotten paid when the judge ruled in my favor. So please, whoever reads this - certify for the disputed weeks even if you're back to work.

0 coins

This is genuinely the most useful cautionary tale in this thread. I'm sorry that happened to you.

0 coins

how were you even able to certify for those old weeks after already starting a job tho? doesnt the system ask if you worked?

0 coins

you answer the certification questions accurately for the week being certified - so for a past week when I had zero work, I'd report zero wages and answer accordingly. the questions are about THAT week, not your current status

0 coins

Availability for work being the disqualification reason is actually something agents can clarify before your hearing. A weekend trip came up on my own claim - my DE 1080CZ said I was unavailable for a week in October. Claimyr got me on the phone with an EDD agent who explained that being out of town on a weekend doesn't automatically make the whole week a disqualified week, and that it comes down to whether I could have accepted a job offer if one had come. That was helpful context going into my hearing. I'd written down my work search activity for that week and the agent confirmed the judge would want to see that.

0 coins

The weekend vs. whole week availability distinction is so important for my situation. I was absolutely able to accept a job offer any day that week. I'll make sure that's very clear in the appeal.

0 coins

does it help to bring printed proof of your job applications to the hearing?

0 coins

My work search record was the main thing I brought. Dates, company names, how I applied, any responses I got. The more specific the better.

0 coins

The 30-day deadline is a hard cutoff. A late appeal can be filed but you'd need to explain why you missed it, and there's no guarantee they'll accept the explanation. Mail it certified with a return receipt so you have proof of the date it was sent.

0 coins

Certified mail is a good call, I hadn't thought of that. How long does it usually take to hear back after filing the appeal?

0 coins

No one can really say - timelines vary. EDD reviews it first, then forwards to the CUIAB, and then you get a Notice of Hearing by mail at least 10 days before the hearing date. Could be weeks, could be longer.

0 coins

keep certifying for those disputed weeks the whole time you're waiting, that's the main thing

0 coins

My cousin told me that if you get a new job you forfeit any pending appeal automatically - is that actually true? Because that would be wild if EDD just cancels your appeal when you're employed again.

0 coins

That is not accurate. Finding new employment doesn't cancel or forfeit an appeal. The appeal is about whether you were eligible during the weeks covered by the Notice of Determination - that determination was about a past period, not your current employment status.

0 coins

okay good, my cousin had a whole theory about this that apparently was completely wrong

0 coins

This is a really common misconception. The appeal and the disputed weeks are fixed in time - what's happening in your life now doesn't erase the question of what happened then.

0 coins

Availability for work questions also sometimes come up around job search requirements - EDD looks at whether you were actively looking during those weeks and whether you were available without restrictions. Keeping a log of applications you submitted is good practice not just for a hearing but in case EDD ever asks. The appeal hearing is where you'd lay all that out in detail.

0 coins

I do actually have email records from job applications during those weeks. That should help demonstrate I was actively searching.

0 coins

Email timestamps showing when you applied, any confirmations you received, any interview requests - all of that builds the picture of active work search. Bring organized copies to the hearing.

0 coins

does anyone know if you have to tell your new employer about an unemployment appeal? feels weird to bring that up at a new job

0 coins

Unemployment appeals are between you and EDD. Your new employer has no involvement in an appeal about your previous employer, and there's no requirement to disclose it.

0 coins

ok major relief, i was overthinking that

0 coins

The notice went to your former employer, not your new one. Your new employer doesn't even enter the picture here.

0 coins

Something that tripped me up: the DE 429Z that EDD mailed when the claim was first processed isn't the same as a decision on your eligibility. I thought getting that form meant I was approved. It just shows the weekly benefit amount and what the claim could pay if EDD decides you qualify - actual eligibility is a separate question.

0 coins

I definitely made that same mistake. Got the DE 429Z and assumed everything was fine, then the weeks just stayed Pending forever and now this determination.

0 coins

Exact same thing happened to me. The DE 429Z is basically EDD saying here's what your wages support as a weekly amount - but it says nothing about whether those weeks will actually be paid.

0 coins

the difference between the award notice and an actual eligibility decision confuses so many people, glad this got spelled out in this thread

0 coins

The hearing itself - for anyone who gets there - the administrative law judge will have the record from the original phone interview EDD conducted. So whatever you said in that interview, the judge will have it. It helps to know what you said going in, so your testimony stays consistent. If EDD mailed you a DE 4800 at the time of the interview, that showed what questions EDD planned to ask.

0 coins

I do remember some of what I said in my interview but not every detail. Is there a way to request the interview record from EDD before the hearing?

0 coins

The Notice of Hearing that the CUIAB mails before the hearing should tell you how to access the case file. That's where you'd find out what documents are in the record.

0 coins

going in knowing what you said originally is huge, inconsistencies look bad even when they're totally innocent memory gaps

0 coins

$1,100 is absolutely worth appealing. People give up on much larger amounts because the process seems complicated. It's a written form, then a phone or in-person hearing with a judge who isn't hostile - they just want the facts.

0 coins

Hearing it put that simply actually helps. I'm mailing the DE 1000M this week.

0 coins

file it, certify the disputed weeks, and show up to the hearing with your documentation. that's the whole process.

0 coins

The certification question during an appeal is something I had to untangle myself. My benefit year was still open when I found work, and I had three weeks on my own DE 1080CZ. Claimyr put me in front of an EDD agent and I asked whether certifying for those specific back weeks would affect my new claim or my new employer in any way. Agent said no - certifying for past weeks under an open benefit year is just preserving eligibility for those weeks pending appeal, it doesn't interact with anything about current employment.

0 coins

Preserving eligibility is the exact phrase I needed. That's what all the certifying during an appeal is doing - holding those weeks open for if the judge rules in my favor.

0 coins

The benefit year staying open is key context here. If the year had closed it's a different situation, but with an open year and contested weeks, you need those certifications in the system.

0 coins

Just want to flag something about the accuracy piece: when certifying for those back weeks from when you were unemployed, make sure the wages you report are exactly what you earned in each week being certified, not a rough estimate. Even small errors in certified wages can create issues later.

0 coins

For those weeks I had zero earnings - I was applying everywhere but had no income coming in. So certifying with zero wages for those weeks is straightforward at least.

0 coins

Zero is a perfectly valid answer - that's exactly what you report if that's what it was. The accuracy requirement is about not rounding or estimating, not about needing income to show.

0 coins

also keep whatever records show you weren't working those weeks, like bank statements showing no deposits, in case EDD ever asks

0 coins

The appeal form asks why you disagree with EDD's decision. Keep that explanation clear and factual - what week is disputed, what the determination says, and why it's wrong. For an availability question, you'd say you were able to accept work, available every weekday, and actively applying. Don't editorialize or get emotional in the written appeal, that's what the hearing is for.

0 coins

Good advice on keeping the written piece straightforward. The hearing is where I can actually explain the full context of that week.

0 coins

Judges hear these all day. Clear, organized, factual gets you much further than a detailed emotional narrative in writing.

0 coins

been following this thread and OP you should actually be in good shape here. availability question for a week where you were applying and your only 'issue' was a weekend trip - judges see that and they're looking at the full picture of the week not just two days.

0 coins

That's genuinely reassuring. The whole situation felt so unfair given I was doing everything right - actively searching, applying constantly, just took a two-day trip.

0 coins

the work search records are your best friend. dates, companies, how you applied. if you have email timestamps even better

0 coins

rooting for a good outcome on this one, update if you can

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure