Back to California Unemployment

Saanvi Krishnaswami

Employee filed for unemployment while still on payroll what employer should do

Running payroll last Friday and noticed something strange - one of my current employees showed up on a Notice of Unemployment Insurance Claim Filed (DE 1101CZ) that came in the mail this week. This person is still actively working for us, still clocking in, still on the schedule. I have no idea if this is a mistake on their end, identity theft on someone else's end, or something I'm just not understanding about how the system works. What exactly am I supposed to do with this notice? Do I respond to it, ignore it, contest it? And what happens to this employee if EDD pays them while they're still earning a full paycheck from us? I don't want to get the company into trouble and I honestly don't want the employee to get into trouble either if they just made some kind of error. Has anyone dealt with this situation from the employer side?

DE 1101CZ we got last spring had the same situation - one of our warehouse workers filed while he was still on our active roster pulling full hours. Claimyr (claimyr.com) got me on the line with an EDD agent after I'd been trying to reach someone for days. The video on how to reach a live EDD person is at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. I asked the agent exactly what our obligation was given the employee was still working. She pulled up the claim and confirmed the weeks in question, then told me the DE 1101CZ response window is 10 days from the date printed on the notice, and that our response needed to show the employee's continuing employment status and wages during the claim period. We submitted that in writing and EDD handled the determination from there.

0 coins

The 10-day window caught us off guard once too. We got the notice on a Thursday and almost missed it because it sat on the receptionist's desk thinking it was junk mail. Responding right away with payroll records for those weeks seems like the fastest path.

0 coins

10 days from the date on the notice - does that clock start from when EDD printed it or when it actually arrived in my mailbox? Because there's sometimes a gap of a few days with mail delivery.

0 coins

Still actively clocking in means you have something really clear to work with here. The DE 1101CZ is EDD telling you they received a claim from someone who listed your company as their last employer, and you have 10 days from the date printed on that notice to respond. What you send back is basically documentation that this person is still employed and what their wages look like. Pay stubs, timesheets, whatever you have showing they worked those weeks. If you don't respond, EDD makes its decision without your side of the story - and your account could end up getting charged for benefits paid out.

0 coins

Charged to our account - is that the reserve account thing I've seen mentioned? I didn't realize the company could actually take a financial hit from this if we just sit on the notice.

0 coins

Reserve account charges are real and they affect what the employer pays in UI taxes later. Responding with proof of continued employment is exactly how you protect that.

0 coins

We didn't respond to one years ago thinking it would sort itself out and ended up with a Notice of Wages Used (DE 1545) that showed us on the hook for payments we had no idea went out. Definitely don't sit on the DE 1101CZ.

0 coins

Something worth separating here: the employee might have made an honest filing mistake, or this could be fraud, or it could be a case of someone who quit and then changed their mind and came back and you're still carrying them. The response you give EDD on the DE 1101CZ is the same either way - accurate employment dates and wages - but what you do internally with the employee might differ. If they're still on payroll and actively working, they don't meet the basic requirement of being out of work, so EDD should sort that out once you respond. Worth having a conversation with the employee too depending on your relationship with them.

0 coins

The honest mistake scenario is more common than people think. Had an employee who thought she could file during a slow month when her hours got cut, then hours went back up and she forgot to report the increase. Those part-time earnings rules are confusing for a lot of workers.

0 coins

Hours getting cut is different though - does a cut in hours actually qualify someone for partial unemployment even while still employed? I genuinely didn't know that was possible.

0 coins

Partial UI while still employed is a real thing - someone working reduced hours can be eligible for partial benefits if the weekly amount works out after the earnings offset. That's a different situation from someone working full time and filing at the same time.

0 coins

From the employee side of this, there's a reporting requirement that people really underestimate. When someone certifies every two weeks they're supposed to report all wages for the weeks they earned them, including from a job they're still at. If your employee got approved somehow and is collecting while also getting a full paycheck without reporting those wages, that's an overpayment situation that EDD will eventually find. The resulting notice can include a 30 percent penalty if EDD decides it was done on purpose. Not trying to scare you but this is why responding with accurate wage information actually helps the employee too.

0 coins

The penalty piece is serious. I know someone who had an overpayment situation that wasn't even intentional and still had to pay back a significant amount. The fraud penalty on top of that would be brutal.

0 coins

EDD distinguishes between non-fraud overpayments, which still have to be repaid but carry no penalty, and cases where they determine the person deliberately withheld information. The 30 percent penalty only comes in the fraud category. Either way the employee is better off if the employer's accurate response stops payments before they build up.

0 coins

So responding quickly isn't just protecting the company's reserve account - it could actually limit how much the employee ends up owing back if EDD determines there was an overpayment?

0 coins

PLEASE respond to that notice by the date it says. I cannot stress this enough. We had an HR coordinator who decided not to respond to one of these because she assumed EDD would figure it out on their own and there was nothing to worry about if everything was above board. What actually happened is EDD issued a determination we weren't part of, benefits went out, and then we got the DE 1545 showing charges to our account. Fighting it after the fact was a whole different and much harder process than just responding the first time around would have been.

0 coins

After-the-fact disputes are brutal. EDD's appeals process for employers is not quick and there's no guarantee of a reversal even with solid documentation.

0 coins

Exactly. And the threshold for reversing a determination you weren't part of is different than the threshold for just preventing it in the first place. Respond to the DE 1101CZ the first time, with everything you have.

0 coins

To directly answer what you should send: gather the employee's timesheet records and payroll documentation showing dates worked and gross wages for every week covered by that claim period. Write a brief statement on company letterhead explaining that the individual remains actively employed, the dates of their continuous employment, and what they earned week by week. Send it to the address on the DE 1101CZ within those 10 days. Keep copies of everything you send. EDD will review both the employee's claim and your response, then issue a determination. If you disagree with the determination, you can appeal within 30 days of the date on the notice EDD sends you.

0 coins

Should this go certified mail or is regular mail fine? I want proof that EDD actually received it.

0 coins

Certified mail with return receipt is the safer call for anything involving a potential dispute. Regular mail works but if there's ever a question about whether EDD got your response in time, you want that receipt.

0 coins

Fax with a confirmation page works too and sometimes gets into EDD's system faster than mail. The notice usually has a fax number on it somewhere.

0 coins

Layoffs we did in spring had a complication where one employee filed before the official termination date was processed in our system, so we got a DE 1101CZ that made it look like they were still active when really it was a timing thing. Used Claimyr to reach EDD directly and walked through the exact dates with the agent - she could see when the claim was filed versus when our separation paperwork went through. Ended up not being an issue once the dates lined up, but I would not have known how to sort that out just from reading the notice.

0 coins

Timing discrepancies between when HR processes a termination and when EDD gets the claim seem like they'd be pretty common. Good to know an agent can actually look at the dates side by side.

0 coins

HR processing lag is real. We had something similar where an employee filed the same week they were let go and the notice came in looking like they were still on payroll because our final paperwork hadn't been entered yet.

0 coins

The notice might also be worth flagging to your HR team as a potential identity theft situation. If this employee didn't file, someone else may have used their personal information to open a fraudulent claim. EDD has a fraud reporting line at 1-866-401-2849. The employee themselves would need to report it if that's what happened, but as the employer you can note in your response that the person is still actively employed and to your knowledge did not separate from the company.

0 coins

How would I even know if the employee actually filed themselves versus someone filing in their name? I guess I'd have to ask them directly?

0 coins

Asking them directly is really the only way to know. If they're genuinely confused about why they'd get unemployment when they're still working, that's a sign it might be fraud by a third party. If they go quiet or vague, that tells you something different.

0 coins

Fraudulent claims filed in an employee's name are unfortunately not rare. Talked to an EDD agent about one on our account - reached them through Claimyr after the hold times were impossible - and the agent flagged it for the fraud investigation team while I was still on the phone. The employee ended up needing to verify their identity through ID.me to protect their own record.

0 coins

Worth noting that EDD notifying the last employer doesn't mean the claim is automatically going to be paid. It's EDD's process for getting your side of the picture before making a determination. A lot of employers panic when they see the DE 1101CZ and assume benefits are already being paid, but at that point it's still in the initial review stage. Your response shapes what EDD decides.

0 coins

This is a really useful clarification. The notice sounds official and alarming but it's essentially just EDD asking for your input before they rule.

0 coins

Right - think of it like EDD giving you a chance to submit evidence before the decision. After the decision is made and you disagree, you're in appeal territory which is a different and slower track.

0 coins

Your employee may genuinely not know there's a reporting requirement during the claim period. Some people think filing means you're just setting up a safety net in case something changes, not realizing that EDD expects them to report ongoing wages when they certify every two weeks. If they filed, got approved, and started certifying without reporting their paycheck, the overpayment could grow week by week. The earlier your employer response stops that, the less they'd potentially owe.

0 coins

The certification piece trips up a lot of people. They don't realize that every two-week certification is a sworn statement about their availability, work search activity, and earnings that week.

0 coins

And once someone has certified incorrectly for several weeks without reporting wages, the total overpayment can get large in a hurry. Even at a modest weekly benefit amount, six or eight uncorrected weeks adds up.

0 coins

EDD also has ways of cross-referencing wage data from employers, so they often catch these things eventually even without the employer actively responding. But actively responding is still faster and cleaner.

0 coins

For anyone reading this who's the employee in this situation rather than the employer - if you filed while still on payroll thinking you were setting something up ahead of a planned departure, you need to contact EDD now. If you haven't started certifying yet, reaching out before you do gives you a chance to clarify the situation. If you have certified and reported your wages correctly, then EDD will sort out your eligibility. If you certified and did NOT report your continuing wages, contacting EDD proactively before they catch it is a much better position to be in than waiting.

0 coins

Does proactively disclosing affect whether EDD treats it as fraud or non-fraud overpayment? Because that distinction seems to matter a lot for the penalty piece.

0 coins

EDD's determination of fraud versus non-fraud looks at whether false information was given or information was deliberately withheld. Someone who comes forward voluntarily is in a different position than someone who keeps certifying and collecting. That said, EDD makes the actual call - no one here can promise how they'd treat any specific case.

0 coins

This is the right advice. Proactive disclosure versus waiting to be caught are genuinely different situations even if the dollar amount owed ends up the same.

0 coins

Benefit year on our last claim overlap situation ran from March through the following February, and we almost missed that the DE 1101CZ covered a period when one employee had briefly reduced hours before returning to full time. Used Claimyr to get through to an EDD agent to make sure our wage reporting for those specific weeks was formatted correctly. The agent walked me through which pay periods to include and confirmed EDD received our previous correspondence on that claim. We hadn't known our earlier fax had actually gone through, so that call settled a lot of questions at once.

0 coins

Not knowing whether EDD actually received your documents is such a stressful part of this. Nice that an agent could confirm the fax was in the system.

0 coins

Exactly - and it meant we didn't re-send documents we didn't need to, which could have created confusion in the file. Having the agent confirm receipt saved us from over-documenting.

0 coins

HR side note: once you've responded to the DE 1101CZ, document that you did it and keep a copy of everything in the employee's HR file. If this ever becomes part of a larger dispute about their employment status or a future UI claim, having that paper trail of your timely response is valuable.

0 coins

Makes sense. So the response to the DE 1101CZ goes in the employee's file even if nothing ever comes of it formally?

0 coins

That's what we do. Even if EDD issues a determination that everything's fine and no benefits get paid, you've got a record showing your company responded accurately and on time. Future audits or disputes don't come with a lot of warning.

0 coins

One thing that sometimes gets missed in this situation is whether the employee is trying to establish a claim ahead of an anticipated layoff they know is coming but that hasn't happened yet. Sometimes workers hear through the grapevine that cuts are coming and try to file early. EDD's claim only becomes active starting the Sunday of the week of application, and eligibility requires actually being out of work at that point. So filing before a separation is official doesn't automatically mean the person gets paid - it just means there's a pending claim that EDD will evaluate.

0 coins

So someone filing early wouldn't necessarily get any money - they'd just have a claim sitting there that EDD would evaluate based on when they actually stopped working?

0 coins

Basically yes. The claim week starts on Sunday, eligibility is determined week by week, and wages earned during a week offset what gets paid. The filing date starts the clock on the benefit year, but money only flows when someone is actually out of work and certifying accurately for weeks they were unavailable and not earning.

0 coins

This is a useful distinction. Some employees may not understand that filing early when you're still fully employed doesn't do what they think it does - EDD still looks at actual employment status and wages for each week certified.

0 coins

Responding to the DE 1101CZ with wage records is straightforward paperwork but make sure whoever prepares it at your company pulls gross wages, not net. EDD works from gross earnings. I've seen employers submit net payroll data and then have to send corrected documentation which burns time you don't have with that 10-day window.

0 coins

Gross wages is exactly right. The earnings offset calculation EDD uses to determine how much, if anything, to pay in a week where someone worked is based on gross weekly earnings, not take-home.

0 coins

Gross vs net - noted. That's the kind of thing I'd have gotten wrong without someone flagging it, honestly.

0 coins

Appeal rights go both directions here. If EDD issues a determination that the employer disagrees with - say they decide the employee is eligible for some weeks despite your documentation - you can appeal within 30 days of the date on the determination notice. The appeal goes in writing and eventually reaches an administrative law judge at the CUIAB if it goes that far. The employer's written submission with payroll records is the foundation of that appeal if it comes to it.

0 coins

Have the employer appeal rights changed at all in recent years? I feel like the window used to vary depending on the type of claim.

0 coins

30 days from the date on the notice is what EDD currently says for employer appeals as well as claimant appeals. Worth reading the determination notice carefully when it arrives because it spells out the deadline and address for that specific case.

0 coins

Does the employer have to appear in person at the CUIAB hearing or can it be done by phone or in writing?

0 coins

CUIAB hearings at the administrative law judge level are conducted by phone now in most cases, and both sides present their information. As an employer you're presenting documentation and testimony about the employment relationship, the work dates, the wages. An attorney can represent the company but isn't required. The judge's written decision comes by mail after the hearing.

0 coins

Phone hearings make it at least logistically easier than having to send someone to a physical location. Good to know that's the current format.

0 coins

The written decision timeline is the hard part - there's no way to predict exactly when it arrives. Keep certifying for any affected weeks during an appeal, and in this case keep all your payroll documentation organized in the meantime.

0 coins

Summary of what I've seen in this thread that's most actionable: respond to the DE 1101CZ within 10 days of the date on it, include gross wage records and dates of continuous employment, send it in a way you can track (certified mail or fax with confirmation), keep copies in the employee file, and if the situation is complicated enough that you want to talk it through with an EDD agent directly, budget time for reaching them because hold times on that main line can stretch.

0 coins

This is the clearest checklist I've seen laid out. Thank you. I'm going to pull our payroll records today and get that response out before the week is up.

0 coins

Get the date on the notice first and count forward from there. If the notice is dated last week and you're already six days in, don't wait until Friday.

0 coins

Also check whether there's a fax number on the notice itself. Some DE 1101CZ notices come with a specific routing fax number that can be faster than mailing to the general address.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure