Back to California Unemployment

Brielle Johnson

Does unemployment income reduce earned income credit tax refund? California EDD claimants need to know

Filing my taxes right now and I'm kind of freaking out. Got laid off in March and collected California EDD unemployment benefits for about six months before landing a new job in September. My weekly benefit was around $310 so over those months I pulled in somewhere around $7,400 in unemployment payments total. Here's what's stressing me out - I also worked part of the year and made roughly $19,000 in wages between my old job before the layoff and the new one. I have two kids and I've been counting on the Earned Income Credit to help cover some bills this tax year. But now I'm seeing stuff online suggesting that unemployment benefits might count against me somehow for the EIC calculation and I honestly don't know what to believe. Does unemployment income reduce earned income credit tax refund? Like does the $7,400 in unemployment get added to my earned income and mess up my EIC? Or does it get counted separately and hurt me in a different way? I've been going back and forth reading IRS stuff and EDD stuff and I cannot figure out what actually applies to my situation. Anyone dealt with this while collecting California EDD benefits?

Unemployment payments from that period sitting in my UI Online account showed up on my Form 1099G and I wasn't sure how they'd play into my taxes until I actually talked to an EDD agent about what gets reported where. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through on the phone after the online wait times were brutal - there's a video on reaching a live person at EDD at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed that EDD reports the total unemployment paid to me on the 1099G as federal taxable income, and that nothing gets withheld for California state tax automatically unless I chose it during certification. She also said the 1099G is in UI Online under Payments then Form 1099G by January 31 if I hadn't received it by mail. What she couldn't tell me was how the IRS treats it for EIC purposes - that part is IRS territory, not EDD's.

0 coins

Wait, EDD actually told you they can't answer the EIC part? That seems like a cop-out. Like they know what they're reporting, why wouldn't they know what the IRS does with it?

0 coins

EDD administers California unemployment, not federal tax law. The 1099G is just them telling the IRS what they paid out. What the IRS does with that number for EIC calculations - that's a whole separate thing the EDD agent genuinely isn't trained on.

0 coins

The 1099G being in UI Online is actually useful to know, I always wait for the mail and then panic when it's late.

0 coins

So I had the exact same question last filing season and went down a rabbit hole about this. Here's what I finally understood after talking to a tax preparer: unemployment benefits are NOT earned income for EIC purposes. The IRS defines earned income as wages, salaries, tips, and net self-employment income. Unemployment payments don't fit that definition, so they don't get added to your earned income number when calculating the credit. Your $19,000 in actual wages is what the EIC calculation starts with.

0 coins

Oh that's actually a relief if it's accurate. So the $7,400 in unemployment just doesn't factor into the earned income side of the equation at all?

0 coins

Exactly right. It goes on your federal return as regular income - it's taxable federally - but it doesn't count as earned income for the EIC formula. Your wages are your earned income for that calculation.

0 coins

But doesn't total income affect EIC eligibility at some threshold? Like I thought there was a cutoff for how much total income you can have regardless of what kind it is.

0 coins

Yes that's the part that matters more for someone in this situation. The IRS uses both an earned income limit AND an adjusted gross income limit for EIC, and unemployment does push your AGI up. So it can reduce the credit that way even though it doesn't count as earned income. That's the thing people miss.

0 coins

I thought unemployment counted as earned income for taxes though? My old roommate told me she had to pay taxes on hers and I assumed that meant it was treated the same as a paycheck for everything including EIC.

0 coins

Taxable income and earned income aren't the same category. Unemployment is federally taxable, yes - you have to include it on your federal return and it can bump up what you owe or shrink a refund. But the IRS has a specific definition of earned income for EIC purposes and unemployment isn't in it. Your roommate was right that she paid taxes on it, but that doesn't mean it counted for EIC the way wages do.

0 coins

Oh okay that actually makes sense now, I think I was mixing those two things up. So taxable doesn't automatically mean earned.

0 coins

California EDD unemployment income is exempt from California state income tax, which is a separate thing that sometimes confuses people dealing with both federal and state returns at the same time. So on your CA return you'd subtract it out. The federal return is a different story - it's fully taxable at the federal level unless you proactively chose 10% withholding during each certification.

0 coins

I did not choose withholding, which I'm now realizing was a mistake. So I'm going to owe federal tax on the full $7,400 in unemployment payments?

0 coins

You'd owe federal income tax on it at whatever your marginal rate works out to be for the year, yes. At least you won't owe California state income tax on it since the state exempts unemployment benefits.

0 coins

I made this exact mistake my first time on unemployment. Thought since CA doesn't tax it, federal wouldn't either. Got a nasty surprise in April.

0 coins

I keep seeing people say UI benefits are exempt from CA taxes and I want to double check - does that mean they never show up on the state return at all, or does California still want you to report them and then subtract them out?

0 coins

California has you report the amount and then subtracts it as an adjustment. The end result is the same - you don't pay CA state income tax on it - but it does show up on the return.

0 coins

That makes sense, okay. I was worried I was supposed to just leave the whole amount off my CA return entirely and that felt weird.

0 coins

Does the EIC question change if someone only worked part of the year before collecting unemployment? Like the original poster worked before the layoff and then again after getting a new job in September, so they have wages from two different employers plus the unemployment in between. Does that complicate the EIC calculation?

0 coins

Not really from an EIC standpoint. All the wage income from both employers gets combined as your total earned income - doesn't matter that it came from two jobs. The unemployment sits separately as non-earned taxable income. What matters for EIC is the total wages plus how many qualifying kids, against those IRS thresholds.

0 coins

The two employers thing is what made me nervous because I have W-2s from both plus the 1099G and I wasn't sure if having multiple documents somehow changed how it all worked.

0 coins

Yeah having multiple W-2s is super common and doesn't change the math, you just enter them all in. The 1099G is filed separately since it's a different type of income.

0 coins

Something I genuinely got wrong before my second year on unemployment: I assumed the waiting week that EDD makes everyone serve without payment somehow didn't have to be reported since I got nothing for it. But the 1099G at year end just shows the total they paid out - which obviously doesn't include unpaid weeks - so that part sort of sorted itself out. The waiting week just shows up as a zero in your records rather than a number to track for taxes.

0 coins

I did serve the waiting week and was confused about whether to track it, so this is actually helpful to hear. The 1099G total should just be what was actually paid to me.

0 coins

Exactly. Whatever total is on the 1099G is what EDD reported as paid. The waiting week never paid you anything so it's not in that number.

0 coins

Two weeks into my claim last year I had a different problem - my UI Online kept showing pending weeks and I couldn't tell if EDD had my income information right for the 1099G at all. Went to claimyr.com and talked to an EDD agent who pulled up my claim and saw that my wages from one of my earlier employers hadn't processed correctly into my base period. The agent said to watch for the Notice of Unemployment Insurance Award to see my actual weekly benefit amount and that if anything was off I could appeal within 30 days of the mailing date.

0 coins

Wait, can an employer's wages just not show up in your base period correctly? How does that even happen?

0 coins

EDD pulls wage data from what employers report to the state. If an employer was late filing or filed with an error, it can affect what shows in your base period. The agent said to check the DE 429Z when it arrives in the mail because that shows the wages EDD used.

0 coins

I had no idea the DE 429Z showed that level of detail. I thought it just had the weekly amount.

0 coins

It has the weekly benefit amount and the maximum benefit amount, and you can work backward to see if the wages they used seem right for your situation.

0 coins

For anyone stressing about the federal taxes on unemployment - if you're worried about owing a lot at filing time because you didn't do withholding, you can still make a payment to the IRS before the return deadline to reduce any penalty. I found out after the fact that quarterly estimated payments were an option too, though that ship had sailed for me by the time I figured it out.

0 coins

Can I still choose the 10% federal withholding now even though I'm no longer certifying? I stopped collecting in September when I went back to work.

0 coins

If you're no longer certifying and your claim period is done, that option is behind you. The withholding choice is made during certification, so at this point you'd just owe whatever you owe at filing and pay it then or figure out if you can make a pre-deadline payment.

0 coins

The IRS penalty for not making estimated tax payments is usually pretty small relative to what you owe - worth asking a tax professional but most people in this situation just file and pay.

0 coins

My certification period ran from May through October last year and I had a weird situation where EDD sent me a 1099G that seemed too high - it included weeks I thought I hadn't been paid for because I reported part-time wages. Used Claimyr to get to an EDD agent who went through my payment history with me week by week. She explained that the earnings formula works so that if I earned under 25 percent of my weekly benefit amount in a week, I still got partial payment, and those smaller amounts were all added into the 1099G total. So the number was actually right, I just hadn't been tracking the small partial weeks.

0 coins

How does that earnings formula work exactly? I did some part-time work while on benefits and I'm worried I might have similar confusion about my 1099G total.

0 coins

The way it was explained to me: in a week where you earned some but not full-time wages, EDD doesn't subtract your whole paycheck from your benefit. The first $25 or 25 percent of what you earned in that week, whichever is bigger, isn't counted. The rest gets subtracted from your weekly benefit amount. So you usually still get some payment on a part-time week.

0 coins

I always thought any earnings while on UI just completely canceled the week's payment. The partial benefit thing is news to me.

0 coins

A lot of people think that. The key thing is to report all your wages for the week they were earned, not when you got paid. And full-time work does stop the payment for that week regardless of what you made.

0 coins

Does the EIC thing work differently if you have self-employment income mixed in? The original question is about wages and unemployment, but I did some gig work during my gap period and now I have W-2 income, 1099-NEC from gig work, and a 1099G. Not sure how all three interact.

0 coins

Net self-employment income after expenses does count as earned income for EIC purposes, same as wages. So your gig income, your wages, and your unemployment each go in different buckets - wages and net self-employment combined are your earned income for EIC, unemployment is in your AGI but not your earned income. Three separate documents doesn't mean three separate problems, just three boxes on the return.

0 coins

That's actually clearer than anything I found when I searched for it, thank you. So the gig work helps my earned income number rather than hurting it.

0 coins

As long as it's profitable gig work, yes. Losses from self-employment reduce earned income, which could actually lower your EIC. Worth running the numbers with a tax tool or preparer if the gig income was significant.

0 coins

Heads up for people who didn't choose federal withholding during their claim - EDD gives you the option to change your withholding election during each certification, so if you're in a future claim year you can turn on 10% federal withholding midstream rather than waiting until filing season and getting hit all at once. I didn't know that my first time around and ended up with a bigger tax bill than expected.

0 coins

I wish I had known that six months ago honestly. I genuinely did not think about the tax implications until I sat down to file.

0 coins

Most people don't. You're focused on surviving financially and the certification questions about taxes feel secondary. It's one of those things you only really learn the first time around.

0 coins

Even the second time around I forgot. It's just not front of mind when you're anxious about whether the payment will come through.

0 coins

I'm confused about one thing - the original post says they had a weekly benefit of $310. Is that amount based on what you earned before you got laid off, or does everyone get the same amount?

0 coins

The weekly benefit amount varies by person based on the wages you earned during your base period - specifically the highest-paid quarter of that base period. It runs from $40 to $450 a week in California. EDD's Unemployment Benefit Calculator on their site can estimate yours before you even file. The actual amount shows up on the DE 429Z after your claim is processed.

0 coins

So two people laid off from the same job on the same day could get different weekly amounts if they were paid differently? Or if they had different work histories before that job?

0 coins

Exactly right. Your individual wage history determines your weekly benefit, not what your coworkers earned.

0 coins

The CalJOBS registration thing caught me off guard during my last California EDD claim. My Notice of Requirement to Register for Work said I had 21 days to get my CalJOBS profile and resume up, and I almost missed the window because I didn't realize not doing it could pause payments. That has nothing to do with taxes but it's worth flagging for anyone currently collecting.

0 coins

I actually did get that notice and registered in time, but I didn't understand why it was required. Is that just a California thing?

0 coins

It's specific to California EDD. Most claimants have to do it - EDD will tell you if you're exempt. The idea is you're using CalJOBS to actively pursue work while you're collecting.

0 coins

I forgot about CalJOBS entirely in my second week and then panicked when I saw the 21-day mention again on a later notice. Registered with about two days to spare.

0 coins

Before I could even ask EDD a tax question, my claim had a pending status that had been sitting for three weeks because of an identity verification issue with ID.me. The whole thing was stuck. Claimyr got me to an agent who could see the DE 1326C had been issued and that my ID.me verification hadn't linked to my claim yet. She walked me through what needed to happen on the ID.me side so EDD could see the confirmation.

0 coins

ID.me not linking to the EDD claim is a thing that happens? I thought once you verified with ID.me it was automatic.

0 coins

Apparently there's a step where the confirmation from ID.me has to actually attach to your EDD account, and sometimes there's a delay or something breaks in that handoff. The agent could see on her end that the verification existed but hadn't reflected on the claim yet, and knowing that told me what I actually needed to fix.

0 coins

This is good to know - I always assumed ID.me issues were just about not completing the photo process. Didn't realize it could get stuck after.

0 coins

Quick sanity check on the CalFresh angle - someone said earlier that UI benefits count as income for CalFresh purposes. If I'm getting EIC and also applying for CalFresh during the same period I was on unemployment, does the EIC payment itself count as income when CalFresh evaluates my eligibility?

0 coins

CalFresh eligibility is determined by the county, and they look at ongoing monthly income, not a tax refund you receive once a year. EIC is typically a tax refund, and how a one-time refund is treated versus regular monthly benefit income is something the county CalFresh office would have to answer for your specific case. What California's CalFresh information does say is that unemployment benefits are countable income - so the UI payments during the months you're collecting would factor in. For the EIC piece, ask the county directly.

0 coins

Okay that makes sense, those are really two separate questions even though they happened in the same year for me.

0 coins

Does the EIC question change at all based on when in the year the unemployment happened? Like the original poster got laid off in March and was back to work by September. What if someone only collected for a few weeks in December - does timing affect any of this?

0 coins

Timing within the year doesn't change how unemployment income is treated for EIC. Whether you collected in January or December, the total on your 1099G is what goes on the federal return as taxable income and what affects your AGI. The IRS doesn't weight it differently based on when in the tax year it was received.

0 coins

That's what I figured but I wanted to confirm because someone in another forum said something about 'the month you receive it' mattering and I didn't know what they were referring to.

0 coins

They might have been thinking about estimated tax payment deadlines, which are quarterly and so the timing of income does matter for figuring out which quarter you should have made a payment. But for the actual EIC calculation at year-end, the timing within the year doesn't matter.

0 coins

I was told by someone at work that you could just choose not to put the 1099G on your federal return if the amount was under a certain threshold and EDD wouldn't know. That seems obviously wrong to me but now I'm second-guessing myself.

0 coins

That's not how it works. EDD reports the 1099G amount to the IRS - both you and the IRS get a copy. The IRS is going to match what you report on your return against what EDD told them. If you leave it off, the IRS will catch it and you'll owe back taxes plus interest. There's no 'under a threshold' exemption for unemployment income.

0 coins

Yeah I figured that couldn't be right but I'm glad I asked before trusting it. That would have been a costly mistake.

0 coins

The person at work probably confused it with something like the old COVID-era exclusion that existed for one year only and is long gone. Report the 1099G.

0 coins

Coming back to the original question about whether the EIC actually gets reduced in a real dollar sense - my experience was that the EIC I received while I had a year with unemployment was noticeably smaller than a year where I'd worked the whole year. The earned income part stayed similar but my total AGI was higher because of the UI benefits and that pushed me closer to the phase-out range.

0 coins

That's what I'm worried about - not losing the EIC entirely but losing a chunk of it because my AGI is higher even though my actual wages are similar to past years.

0 coins

In my case I still got the EIC, just less. With two kids and $19,000 in wages like you're describing, you're probably still comfortably within the range, but the unemployment income adding to your AGI does the damage on the edges of the calculation.

0 coins

Okay that's helpful context. I think I'm going to run my numbers through a tax software tool before I file rather than trying to estimate it in my head.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure