Back to California Unemployment

Zainab Ali

Can't open new unemployment claim benefit year not ended new employer - California EDD help

Okay so I'm losing my mind a little bit here. I started a new job back in March after being on UI for most of last year, collected benefits until the claim ran dry basically, and then landed this position at a logistics company. Fast forward to two weeks ago — got laid off again, completely out of nowhere, restructuring they said. So I go to file a new claim through myEDD and the system is basically telling me I can't open a new one because my old benefit year hasn't ended yet. Which makes zero sense to me because I've been WORKING and paying into the system this whole time. The old claim had no money left on it. How can the year still be blocking me? My new employer paid me for about seven months. None of that counts toward a new claim? I'm reading stuff online that's contradicting itself and I can't get a straight answer. Has anyone actually dealt with this scenario where you can't open new unemployment claim benefit year not ended new employer situation and figured out what to do?

Layoffs at a logistics company in October hit me the same way — my benefit year from the previous claim was technically still open when I tried to file, and UI Online kept rejecting the new application. Got through to an EDD agent using Claimyr (claimyr.com), which holds your place in the phone queue so you end up on with a live person. The video explaining how to reach a live person at EDD is at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 if you want to see it first. When I finally talked to the agent, I asked specifically whether my seven months of wages at the new job would count toward a new claim at all, and she pulled up my record and said the benefit year on my old claim would close on its own on a specific Sunday — she gave me the actual date — and that I should file the new application starting that week. She also said the wages from my new employer fall into what they look at for the new claim's base period, so they don't just disappear.

0 coins

The date piece is what I really needed — did she say anything about whether you'd lose those weeks between the layoff and when the benefit year actually closed? Like does EDD backdate at all or are those just gone?

0 coins

EDD's claim starts from the Sunday of the week you apply, not from your last day of work, so the gap weeks before you file are just gone unfortunately. File as soon as the old year closes.

0 coins

Exactly what the agent told me too — she said to apply the moment the year closed, don't wait a week to 'make sure it's clear' because every week you wait is a week you can't get back.

0 coins

The base period thing trips everyone up in this situation. Your new employer's wages probably don't show up in the standard base period for the old claim at all — that claim was built on your older earnings. When the new benefit year opens, EDD looks at a fresh set of quarters, and that's where your logistics company wages should land. The standard window is the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters before your claim starts. So those seven months of paychecks are almost certainly sitting in a quarter that wasn't used for the old claim and will count heavily for the new one.

0 coins

So the wages aren't wasted, they just couldn't be used while the old year was still technically active — is that right?

0 coins

That's basically it. The two claims use different chunks of your earnings history. The old claim's base period is locked in from when you filed it. New claim, new base period window.

0 coins

Worth knowing — if for some reason the standard base period still doesn't have enough wages to make a valid claim, EDD is supposed to automatically check the alternate base period, which uses the four most recently completed quarters instead. You shouldn't have to ask for it.

0 coins

SAME exact nightmare last spring. The EDD system will not let you file a new claim at all while the old benefit year is active, doesn't matter that the money is gone. I kept getting an error and thought I was doing something wrong for a full week before I figured out it was the year end thing. Mark the closing Sunday on your calendar and apply that day, don't wait.

0 coins

How did you find out the actual closing date? Is that somewhere in UI Online or did you have to call?

0 coins

Mine was in UI Online under Claim History — the end date of the benefit year was listed there. If yours isn't showing clearly, the phone line is the other way to get it.

0 coins

My Claim History showed it too, right at the top of the claim summary. Look for the date range on your existing claim.

0 coins

Something I want to flag for anyone reading this later: a benefit year is always 52 weeks from the Sunday the original claim started, regardless of whether you used all the money or stopped claiming early. It doesn't end when your balance hits zero. So someone who filed in, say, early November of last year would have a benefit year running through late October or early November of this year. The balance can be zero for months but the year stays open until that anniversary week.

0 coins

The balance hitting zero part confused me for a long time too. I thought when the money was gone the claim was done. Nope, the year just sits there.

0 coins

That explains the error I'm getting. My original claim started last fall so the year is probably closing right around now. That's actually kind of good news if the timing is close.

0 coins

If your original claim was filed last October or November, you are genuinely right at the edge of it closing. Apply the first Sunday after it expires.

0 coins

Filed a new claim in this exact situation two months ago after going back to work and then getting laid off a second time. The part nobody tells you is that EDD needs enough wages in the new base period to actually make a valid claim. You need at least $1,300 in one of those quarters, or $900 in your highest quarter with your total wages being at least 1.25 times that. Seven months of full-time logistics work almost certainly clears that, but it's worth running your numbers through the Unemployment Benefit Calculator on EDD's site before you file so you know roughly what to expect.

0 coins

I hadn't even thought to check whether the wages were enough — I just assumed seven months of full-time work would be fine. I'll check the calculator.

0 coins

It almost definitely is fine, just good to know going in. The calculator uses your quarterly earnings so have your pay stubs or W-2 handy when you use it.

0 coins

The calculator is pretty accurate in my experience. The actual weekly benefit amount gets confirmed on the DE 429Z notice EDD mails after you file, but the calculator got me within a few dollars of what I actually received.

0 coins

When my restructuring layoff happened in August my benefit year from an earlier claim was still technically open with a zero balance. Spent the better part of two days trying the phone line with no luck. Eventually tried Claimyr and ended up talking to someone at EDD who confirmed my benefit year close date and walked me through what documents to have ready when I refiled. The agent also checked whether my manufacturing job wages from the past year were showing up in EDD's system, which they were.

0 coins

Did the agent say anything about what to do in that window between when you got laid off and when the benefit year actually closed? Like is there any way to get anything for those weeks?

0 coins

She said those gap weeks between the layoff and the year closing just aren't claimable on either claim. You can't claim them on the old one because there's no balance, and you can't claim them on the new one because it doesn't exist yet. File as early as possible once the year closes.

0 coins

That's accurate — there's no bridge between the two. The new claim starts from the Sunday you apply and doesn't reach back to cover the gap.

0 coins

Just want to make sure nobody gets confused by a thing I see repeated sometimes: your new employer did NOT pay into unemployment 'for you' in the sense that it goes into your personal account somewhere. Unemployment is funded by employer taxes and nothing is withheld from your paycheck for it. What matters is that your wages at that job are on record and EDD uses them to calculate your benefit amount when you file a new claim. The wages existing is what matters, not some separate fund you built up.

0 coins

Wait so the CASDI deduction on my paystub — that's not for unemployment?

0 coins

No, the CASDI deduction is for State Disability Insurance and Paid Family Leave, totally separate programs. Unemployment is paid by the employer, nothing from your check goes toward it.

0 coins

This is one of those things that surprises almost everyone. No deduction from your pay for UI, it all comes from the employer side.

0 coins

For the CalJOBS requirement — once you file the new claim, EDD will likely send you a Notice of Requirement to Register for Work (DE 8405). If you get that notice, you have 21 days from the date on it to register in CalJOBS and post a resume, otherwise payments can get held up. Worth doing it right away rather than letting it sit. EDD will tell you if you're exempt.

0 coins

Is that a new requirement since last year? I don't remember doing that for my first claim.

0 coins

It may depend on whether EDD sent you that DE 8405 notice on your original claim. If they didn't require it then, they might this time, or might not. Just watch for that specific notice after you file.

0 coins

They don't send it to everyone. Some people get it, some don't. If you do, the 21-day window is real — don't sit on it.

0 coins

While waiting for your benefit year to close, the one thing you can do right now is get all your paperwork together — last employer's full address, your last day of work, your earnings for the past 18 months by quarter if you can pull them together. The application asks for all of it and having it ready means you can file in one shot the minute the year closes. Also have your ID.me account set up or confirmed if you haven't logged in recently, because identity verification through ID.me can add time if there's a hitch.

0 coins

ID.me from my first claim — does that carry over or do I have to redo it?

0 coins

In my experience it carried over. When I refiled my identity was already verified and I didn't have to go through the photo process again, but it may depend on how long it's been.

0 coins

Mine carried over after about 8 months. If it's been longer there's a chance it needs renewal but usually it recognizes the existing account.

0 coins

My benefit year closed on a Sunday and I filed that same day through UI Online at around 8 in the morning. Processed without any error and I had the DE 429Z in the mail about nine or ten days later. The first certification came up two weeks after filing. The turnaround on the second claim actually felt faster than the first one did.

0 coins

Good to know it can go that smoothly. I've been bracing for a whole mess of adjudication issues but maybe since it's a straight layoff it won't be complicated.

0 coins

Layoffs tend to be cleaner than quits or firings. No phone interview scheduled for me, just a standard processing wait.

0 coins

Same experience here with a layoff — no interview, no adjudication hold, just the usual two to three week wait for the first payment to come through.

0 coins

UI Online had been showing my old claim at zero balance for three months before the year actually closed. When I finally refiled after a second layoff in September, the application went through fine. Had an issue where my wages from the new job weren't pulling up correctly when I used the EDD benefit calculator — called through Claimyr to ask an agent about it, and she looked up my wage records and confirmed EDD had the correct figures from my employer's tax reports. The calculator was just using a different quarterly cutoff than I was.

0 coins

The calculator using a different quarterly cutoff than you expected — did that mean your actual benefit amount was higher or lower than you thought?

0 coins

A little lower than I calculated myself, because I was including a quarter that hadn't closed out yet when I filed. The agent explained which four quarters EDD was actually pulling from and it made sense once she laid it out.

0 coins

Does anyone know if you have to re-do the whole application from scratch or if EDD pulls in info from your previous claim? I'm about to be in this exact situation in a few weeks and I want to know what to expect.

0 coins

Fresh application each time — EDD doesn't auto-populate from the old one. But if your myEDD account is already set up and your identity is verified, the process itself is fairly quick. Have your employer info ready.

0 coins

Took me about 20 minutes to complete the application the second time around since I knew what all the questions were asking. Much less stressful than the first time.

0 coins

The error message you're getting is EDD's system just doing its job, annoying as it is. I hit the same wall and spent a week thinking something was wrong with my account specifically. Nothing is broken, the old year just has to officially expire. File on the right Sunday and it goes through.

0 coins

Knowing it's the system working as designed rather than some flag on my account actually helps a lot.

0 coins

Exactly. No flag, no issue to fix, nothing to call about until the year closes. After that, file and proceed normally.

0 coins

Agreed — I wasted so much energy thinking EDD had blocked me for some reason. It's just the date.

0 coins

After reading through all of this — one thing nobody's mentioned yet is what happens if you served a waiting week on your first claim. For the new claim there's another waiting week. Every new benefit year has its own one-week unpaid waiting period at the start, served on the first eligible week when you certify. The first time you certify it'll cover the waiting week plus one paid week, so the first actual payment is for one week even though two weeks of time have passed.

0 coins

So even with the new claim I'm looking at a gap — the gap between the layoff and the benefit year close date, plus another waiting week at the start of the new claim.

0 coins

Unfortunately yes. That's just how it stacks up in this scenario. The waiting week doesn't eat into your total payout though — the maximum benefit amount stays the same.

0 coins

The waiting week doesn't reduce the total your claim can pay, correct. It's more of a time delay than a reduction in what you'll eventually get.

0 coins

Also just want to confirm that once you refile, EDD notifies your new former employer — the logistics company — with a Notice of Unemployment Insurance Claim Filed (DE 1101CZ), and they have 10 days from that notice's date to respond. For a standard layoff they usually don't contest anything, but it's good to be aware that they're notified. If the employer doesn't respond within that window, EDD just proceeds and the employer loses the right to appeal EDD's decision.

0 coins

Logistics companies doing mass restructuring layoffs almost never contest these because it really was a business decision on their end. You should be fine.

0 coins

Agree, and even if they did respond with some different account of why you left, EDD still makes the final call after looking at both sides. The employer can't deny a claim on their own.

0 coins

My claim history in UI Online showed my benefit year end date right on the main claim summary page — took me a minute to find it because I was looking at the payment history section instead. It's the date range at the top that shows when the claim period opens and closes. Once I found it I just counted to the Sunday after that closing date and applied then.

0 coins

Found mine — it's showing a closing date that is literally this coming Sunday. So I can file starting this Sunday?

0 coins

If the year closes on a Sunday, the new claim would start the following Sunday — the first Sunday of the new benefit year. Apply on or after that Sunday and you're in the clear.

0 coins

Confirm that — the new claim starts on the Sunday of the week you apply, so apply on the first Sunday after the old year expires and that becomes your start date.

0 coins

While you're waiting those few days, go ahead and set up or confirm your payment method in myEDD. You can choose between the Money Network prepaid debit card, direct deposit, or a paper check. If you don't actively pick one, it defaults to the Money Network card. Direct deposit gets the money into your bank but the card works fine too — just make sure whichever you want is set before your first certification goes through.

0 coins

I had the Money Network card from the last claim — does that same card get reactivated or do they send a new one?

0 coins

In my experience the card was still linked to the account and payments posted to it without needing a new card. But check that your payment method in myEDD still shows what you want, since it's been a while.

0 coins

My card from the first claim still worked on the second one. Same card, same account, money just started posting again.

0 coins

For people who end up needing a phone interview on the new claim — which sometimes happens even with clean layoffs if EDD has a question — the interview notice (DE 4800) will come in the mail and the date and time are also on your UI Online homepage. The interviewer phones at the time listed on the DE 4800. Don't miss that window; if you do, phone EDD that same day because otherwise they'll just decide with whatever info they have, which can go badly.

0 coins

How likely is a phone interview for a layoff situation where the employer basically sent everyone a restructuring notice?

0 coins

Pretty unlikely for a mass layoff with documentation. Interviews usually get triggered when there's ambiguity about why someone left — quits, firings, that sort of thing. A restructuring layoff with a clear paper trail is usually processed without one.

0 coins

Had a mass layoff situation with a written notice from the company and no interview was scheduled on my claim. Processed straight through.

0 coins

Just flagging something I see people mix up: reopening a claim and filing a new claim are two different things. If your benefit year is still open and you go back to work and then get laid off again, you reopen the existing claim — not file a new one — through UI Online. But in your situation, where the benefit year is expiring and you have new wages at a new employer, filing a new claim is the right move. The system should let you do that once the old year closes.

0 coins

How do you reopen versus file new — is it a different button or does the system figure out which one applies?

0 coins

UI Online shows a 'reopen' option if your benefit year is still active and you had stopped certifying. If it's a new application, you go through the standard 'file a claim' flow. The system routes you differently based on whether an active year exists.

0 coins

Correct — and once your old year has actually closed, there's no 'reopen' option anymore. The system only lets you file fresh at that point, which is exactly what you need.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure