Back to California Unemployment

Ingrid Larsson

Can you get charged with fraud for collecting unemployment while working?

Okay so I need some real answers here because I'm kind of spiraling. I got laid off from my warehouse job in September and filed with California EDD. Everything was going fine, I was certifying every two weeks and getting my payments on the Money Network card. Then around week six I picked up some part-time shifts at a friend's restaurant - nothing crazy, maybe 15-20 hours a week - and I honestly did not know I was supposed to report those wages. I just thought since it wasn't a real full-time job it didn't count or something. I did this for about five weeks before my cousin mentioned I was supposed to be reporting everything. Now I'm panicking because I went back and I know I underreported wages on those certifications. I didn't do it on purpose, I genuinely had no idea, but I'm reading stuff online about EDD fraud investigations and I'm scared. Like can you actually get charged with fraud for collecting unemployment while working if you just made a mistake? What's the difference between a fraud case and just an overpayment situation? Do I need to contact EDD now, or do I am I better off waiting to see if anything happens? Really stressed about this.

The DE 429Z award notice I got when I first filed actually had a section about reporting wages, so I'd flip back to that paperwork first if I still had it - it laid out pretty clearly that all work and pay gets reported for the week it was earned. The way EDD draws the line is essentially whether you knew the rule and hid it on purpose versus just not understanding how it worked. Intentionally giving false info to keep getting full benefits is what they call fraud, and that can carry a 30 percent penalty on top of whatever you owe, plus a false statement disqualification anywhere from 2 to 23 weeks, and in serious cases they can pursue it as a felony. A genuine mistake where you didn't realize you had to report shifts is treated differently - that lands as a non-fraud overpayment. You still have to pay back the difference, but there's no penalty added and no criminal exposure. The key thing that matters here is the gap between what EDD paid you and what they would have paid if you'd reported correctly. For part-time hours, the first $25 or 25 percent of your gross for that week - whichever number is bigger - doesn't count against you, and the rest gets subtracted from your weekly benefit amount. So depending on what you earned each of those five weeks, you might not owe as much as you think.

0 coins

The DE 429Z is still in a folder somewhere, let me dig it out. That breakdown of how partial wages reduce benefits instead of wiping them out is actually making me feel a little better - I was imagining I owed back every single dollar I received during those weeks.

0 coins

Flagging something here - I've seen people say non-fraud overpayments don't have to be repaid if you can show you acted in good faith, but that's not right. Non-fraud means no penalty and no criminal charge, but EDD still collects the amount you were overpaid. What can reduce or eliminate repayment is a formal waiver request, which is a separate thing - you'd file the DE 1446UI and EDD considers whether paying it back would cause you extraordinary hardship and whether the overpayment wasn't your fault.

0 coins

DE 1446UI - writing that down. So the waiver is a separate application, not something that just happens automatically if they decide it was an honest mistake?

0 coins

Exactly right, the waiver is never automatic - you have to apply for it and EDD weighs your financial situation against the circumstances.

0 coins

Proactively contacting EDD before they find the discrepancy themselves is genuinely the smarter move here. Report Wages in UI Online lets you flag wages before you certify a new week, but for weeks you've already certified wrong, the right path is reaching out through a message in your UI Online account or phoning EDD directly - 1-800-300-5616, weekdays 8 to 5. Coming forward yourself and showing you're trying to fix it works in your favor when EDD is deciding whether this was intentional or not.

0 coins

Already opened UI Online and I'm looking at past certifications. I don't see a way to edit them, which is what I expected - so the message route or phone call is probably my next step.

0 coins

The Report Wages screen is only for the current period before you submit - you can't use it to amend a week already sent in, correct. A message through your UI Online account creates a written record of when you reached out, which matters if EDD later has to decide how to classify the overpayment.

0 coins

Five weeks of unreported part-time restaurant shifts - my situation was basically the mirror image of this, except I underreported tips on three certifications because I didn't know tips counted the same as hourly wages. UI Online showed my claim as normal for weeks and then out of nowhere I got a letter about a potential overpayment review. Getting EDD on the phone felt impossible at first, so I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) - it held the line for me and I ended up speaking directly with an EDD agent. The agent pulled up my claim, confirmed the specific weeks flagged, and told me the overpayment amount EDD had calculated. She walked me through how to send a message through UI Online explaining the tip reporting error, and said doing that before any formal notice came out would be noted on my file. Here's the video they have about reaching a live person at EDD by phone: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The agent also said she could see no intent indicator had been added to my case, which lined up with it being an honest reporting mistake.

0 coins

Tips counting the same as hourly wages is something I didn't even think about - my friend's restaurant pays cash tips at the end of each shift and I definitely would have underreported those too if I'd kept going. Really appreciate you laying out what the agent actually said.

0 coins

The "intent indicator" detail is interesting. So EDD is literally flagging accounts internally based on whether they think it was deliberate? I'd want to know what that looks like on my own file before anything formal hits.

0 coins

That was my read on what she said - it wasn't framed as a formal fraud finding, more like a marker their reviewers use. She said reaching out proactively was the best thing I could do either way.

0 coins

My layoff was from a retail job and when I picked up seasonal hours the following month I almost made the same mistake. What saved me was reading the certification questions carefully - it literally asks 'did you work or earn wages this week' and the word 'earn' covers tips, cash shifts, everything. If you answer no when you worked, that's where the false statement problem starts. The intent question basically comes down to whether a reasonable person would have understood the question to cover what they did.

0 coins

Reading those certification questions now and yeah, 'did you earn wages' is pretty unambiguous in hindsight. I think I was just mentally categorizing the shifts as informal work because my friend was paying me cash.

0 coins

Cash pay is a really common mental exception people make and EDD has heard that explanation a lot - it's worth noting explicitly when you send your message that the work was cash-paid and you misunderstood its status, not that you knew and hid it.

0 coins

What actually happens after you contact EDD and explain the underreporting? Does EDD automatically classify it as non-fraud or is there still a formal review process either way?

0 coins

There's still a process - EDD reviews the information and mails a Notice of Determination (DE 1080CZ) with their finding. If they classify it as a non-fraud overpayment that's the document that says so, and it also comes with an Appeal Form (DE 1000M) if you disagree with any part of their decision. The claimant doesn't get to just declare it non-fraud themselves, EDD makes the official call.

0 coins

The DE 1080CZ is the same form they send for a straight-up denial? I didn't realize it covered overpayment decisions too.

0 coins

Same form, different reason code - it's EDD's general Notice of Determination that covers any eligibility decision, including overpayment classification.

0 coins

FIVE WEEKS of not reporting is going to look bad no matter how innocent the reason was. I'm not saying this to scare you but EDD has seen 'I didn't know' a thousand times and they're not always sympathetic. Get a written record of everything - when you realized the error, what you earned each week, every step you took to fix it - and keep copies.

0 coins

The documentation advice is solid. Even if EDD ultimately decides it's non-fraud, having a clear timeline of when you found out and when you contacted them helps at every stage including a waiver application.

0 coins

Already pulling together my pay records from those weeks so I can calculate the actual amounts. I'd rather come to EDD with the numbers already worked out than make them do the math themselves.

0 coins

Waiting to see if EDD catches it on their own is a terrible strategy. Employers file quarterly wage reports with the state - EDD cross-checks those against what claimants reported on their certifications. The restaurant your friend runs files those same reports, and that data eventually gets compared to what's in your claim.

0 coins

This is exactly right - the cross-check is how most of these discrepancies surface anyway. The claimant who self-reported proactively and the one who got caught by a wage match look very different in EDD's records.

0 coins

Agreed on this. EDD finding it themselves versus you flagging it first is a meaningful distinction when they're deciding how to classify the case.

0 coins

Okay this is the thing that pushed me from 'maybe wait and see' to 'contacting them today'. I had no idea about the wage cross-check.

0 coins

Trying to work out the actual dollar impact here - for each of those five weeks, take whatever you grossed at the restaurant, subtract 25 percent of it or $25, whichever is bigger, and subtract the remainder from your weekly benefit amount. That's the overpayment for that week. Add up all five weeks and that's roughly what EDD will say you owe.

0 coins

Running through this calculation with my actual numbers and it's much less than I feared. Two of those weeks I earned under $100 at the restaurant and my weekly benefit amount was around $310, so the overpayment on those weeks is pretty small.

0 coins

Right, and the waiver application is worth filing if even that amount would be a genuine hardship - EDD considers inability to pay when reviewing it.

0 coins

The partial earnings formula is something I wish I had understood before I started my claim. I was so scared of losing benefits by working a few shifts that I turned down extra hours that wouldn't have even reduced my payment at all.

0 coins

Does the fraud risk change at all if the employer was also paying under the table? Like if the restaurant friend wasn't reporting those wages to anyone either, is there crossover liability for the claimant?

0 coins

From an EDD unemployment standpoint the claimant's obligation is to report what they earned, full stop - it doesn't depend on what the employer did or didn't file. The tax side of unreported wages is a separate IRS and FTB issue and nobody on a forum can tell you how those interact with an EDD fraud case. For the unemployment question specifically: report what you earned.

0 coins

That separation makes sense. I was mixing up the reporting requirements for two completely different agencies.

0 coins

Overpayment notice arrived two months after I'd wrapped up my claim and I had no idea what triggered it - my situation was different from this thread's but the anxiety of waiting is real. I ended up talking to a live EDD agent through Claimyr after the hold times kept running past my lunch break. The agent looked at my account and told me the specific certification week that had a discrepancy flagged, which let me go back and find my pay stub for that exact period. Knowing the exact week made the whole thing less overwhelming.

0 coins

The 'knowing exactly which week' detail is huge - I'm going in with five suspect weeks and I'd rather have EDD point to the specific ones than defend all five at once.

0 coins

Pay stubs for every week of a claim are worth keeping for exactly this reason. By the time a notice arrives months later most people have already thrown that stuff away.

0 coins

Does self-reporting the overpayment somehow prevent you from also filing for the waiver? I want to make sure coming forward doesn't close off the waiver option.

0 coins

Self-reporting actually supports a waiver application because it goes toward the 'not your fault' and 'not fraud' prongs EDD weighs. You'd still submit the DE 1446UI separately after EDD issues the overpayment notice - the waiver request comes after the determination, not before.

0 coins

Got it, so the sequence is: contact EDD now, wait for the DE 1080CZ, then file DE 1446UI with that waiver application - and appealing the determination itself with DE 1000M is a third separate option if you disagree with how they classified it.

0 coins

That sequence is correct. All three options can be in play simultaneously - appealing the determination and applying for a waiver aren't mutually exclusive.

0 coins

Genuinely curious whether certifying honestly for the rest of the claim while an overpayment investigation is pending is the right move or whether it pauses everything.

0 coins

Keep certifying - stopping doesn't help you and can actually hurt because EDD can only pay back weeks that were certified. If EDD needs to investigate, they'll work through that on their end, but your obligation to certify continues on the normal schedule.

0 coins

The UI Online Claim History showing Pending during a review period is normal then, not a sign that you've been frozen out?

0 coins

Pending in Claim History just means EDD hasn't processed that week yet, which can happen for all kinds of reasons including a pending eligibility review - but keep certifying regardless.

0 coins

My first two certifications I accidentally reported zero wages for a week I'd actually worked a half-day before the layoff went through. Way smaller than this situation but the correction process through a UI Online message worked and EDD adjusted the records without issuing a fraud notice. Using Claimyr later for a different question confirmed the message thread I'd sent was visible on my file when the agent looked it up.

0 coins

The confirmation that UI Online messages show up on the EDD file when an agent looks at the account is exactly the reassurance I needed about that approach.

0 coins

The message thread becoming part of your documented file history is a big reason to use that channel rather than just calling - a phone call doesn't leave the same paper trail on your end.

0 coins

The first week of my claim I had a part-time teaching gig end mid-week and I had no idea how to split the wages between weeks. I ended up at the EDD phone line for a while and eventually got through to an agent using Claimyr after two attempts the regular way. The agent explained that wages go in the week they were earned, not the week the last paycheck came in, and that's how the split worked for my situation. Knowing that rule clearly would have prevented a lot of my own confusion certifying.

0 coins

The 'week they were earned not when paid' rule is something I hadn't thought about for the restaurant shifts - my friend pays out at the end of each week so that happened to line up, but I could see it getting complicated with biweekly payroll.

0 coins

That earned-versus-paid distinction trips people up constantly, especially with jobs that have irregular pay schedules. The person above's agent gave the right answer - EDD cares about when the work happened, not when the deposit cleared.

0 coins

Something worth flagging from earlier in the thread - someone above implied that reaching out proactively automatically leads to non-fraud classification. That's not guaranteed. EDD makes the determination based on the full picture, and self-reporting is a factor in your favor but not a promise of any particular outcome. Document everything and be straightforward about what happened.

0 coins

Fair correction. What proactive contact does is demonstrate the absence of intent to conceal, which is relevant to the fraud versus non-fraud question - but EDD still has to review the actual facts of the case and issue a Notice of Determination.

0 coins

And whatever EDD decides, the 30-day appeal window from the mailing date on the DE 1080CZ is there if you disagree with how they classified it. That window doesn't close just because you reached out first.

0 coins

Does anyone know if EDD gives any weight to whether the employer was a friend versus a formal employer? I'm wondering if the informal nature of the arrangement affects how they look at it.

0 coins

EDD's question is whether you performed work and earned wages, full stop - the relationship between the claimant and the employer isn't what determines reporting obligations. Work done for a friend's business is work, and those wages get reported the same as any other employer.

0 coins

Makes sense, the form doesn't have a 'personal relationship' exception anywhere on it.

0 coins

If anything, cash payments from someone you know are something EDD has seen as a concealment vehicle before - which is another reason being proactive and transparent about the full picture works better than leaving EDD to piece it together.

0 coins

Eight weeks into my own claim right now, working part-time retail, and I've been so paranoid about this exact issue that I've been screenshotting my Report Wages confirmation screen every two weeks. The certification questions about work and wages are the ones I spend the most time on.

0 coins

Screenshotting the confirmation is smart - UI Online doesn't give you a downloadable receipt, so having a timestamped screenshot of the submitted certification is the closest thing to a record.

0 coins

The UI Online Claim History shows the certification was submitted but I wanted something that also showed the wage amount I entered, hence the screenshots. Probably overkill but I'm not taking any chances.

0 coins

Update for anyone who lands on this thread later - I sent the message through UI Online today explaining the five weeks of underreported wages, the amounts for each week as best I could calculate, and that it was a genuine reporting error. I also asked whether a waiver application would be appropriate given the circumstances. No response yet obviously but at least there's a written record of when I reached out. I'll follow up here when I hear back.

0 coins

Calculating the amounts yourself before EDD does shows good faith - when the agent or reviewer looks at your file they'll see you weren't just saying 'I made a mistake' in the abstract, you laid out the specifics. Keep all those pay records.

0 coins

The UI Online message receipt and those pay records are going to be your two most important documents if this goes to a formal determination and you end up needing to appeal or file for the waiver.

0 coins

Appreciate you closing the loop - most of these threads go silent and nobody knows what happened. The step-by-step you laid out is going to help whoever searches this topic next.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure