Back to California Unemployment

Lindsey Fry

Can I get unemployment if fired for not meeting work expectations during probation in California EDD?

So I got let go last week from a job I'd only been at for about 60 days. It was a probationary period position and my manager said I wasn't hitting the performance targets they'd set. No warnings, no write-ups, nothing in writing about what I was supposedly doing wrong - just a meeting on a Friday and then I was out the door. I honestly didn't even know I was in trouble until that conversation. Now I'm trying to figure out if I can even file for unemployment benefits. I've seen a lot of conflicting stuff online. Some sources say getting fired automatically disqualifies you, others say it depends on the situation. I'm especially confused because this was during probation - does that change anything? I did file a claim through UI Online already. My last job before this one I'd been at for about three years, so I have wages from that in my history. The new job only paid me for about 8 weeks worth of work. I'm just trying to understand what to expect from California EDD and whether this whole probation thing is going to be a problem when they look at my case.

Filing was absolutely the right call here. A lot of people assume fired automatically means no benefits, and I used to think the same thing until I went through it myself two years ago. The way it actually works with EDD is they have to look at whether the firing counts as misconduct on your end, not just whether your boss wanted you gone. Missing performance targets during probation is usually not the same thing as misconduct in EDD's eyes, though EDD does the deciding after both sides give their story.

0 coins

Does EDD actually contact my old employer and ask them directly? I'm worried they're going to paint a totally different picture than what actually happened.

0 coins

EDD does reach out to your last employer, yeah. They mail the employer a notice about the claim and the employer has a window to respond. Then if there's a question about why you were let go, EDD schedules a phone interview with you. That's where you get to explain your side of things.

0 coins

Worth knowing that if the employer doesn't respond in time, they lose their chance to give input. Doesn't guarantee you get benefits but it removes their opposition from the picture.

0 coins

Probationary status sounds scarier than it actually is for unemployment purposes. EDD doesn't treat probation like a special category that disqualifies you. What matters is whether your behavior crossed into actual misconduct. EDD's standard is basically whether you intentionally did something wrong or violated a rule you knew about, not just whether you fell short of what the job needed.

0 coins

Is there a difference between just not being good at something versus deliberately doing bad work? Because my situation sounds exactly like OPs and I genuinely was trying my hardest.

0 coins

That distinction is exactly what matters to EDD. Trying your best and not meeting expectations is very different from, say, ignoring a direct policy you knew about. Performance-based firings during probation tend to land on the non-misconduct side more often, though EDD makes the final call after the interview.

0 coins

I got fired from a probationary position two years back and EDD approved my claim. The interview was pretty straightforward, they just asked me what my job duties were and what feedback I'd received.

0 coins

Probationary period listed as the reason on my termination paperwork, and UI Online showed pending for about three weeks after I filed. Getting anyone at EDD on the phone felt impossible, so I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) and ended up talking to an actual EDD agent. I'd been asking whether my previous employer's wages would be used in my base period since the new job was so short. The agent pulled up my file and confirmed the standard base period was pulling from the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters, so the three years at my prior job were right there - the eight weeks at the new place barely factored into the weekly benefit amount calculation. Here's their video if you want to see what reaching a live person at EDD looks like: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. After the call I felt a lot clearer about what I was actually working with.

0 coins

My prior job wages are really what I've been banking on too. Good to know the base period would reach back there. Did the agent say anything about the pending weeks, like why they were showing that way?

0 coins

The agent said pending usually just means EDD is still working through eligibility, especially when there's a termination involved. They told me to watch for a notice in the mail with the interview date and time and to keep my phone nearby at that point.

0 coins

Eight weeks at a new place barely moving the needle on the weekly amount makes sense given how the highest quarter calculation works. Your longer employment history is what really determines what you can get.

0 coins

Nobody told me when I went through this that you have to keep certifying even while everything is pending. I stopped certifying for about a month because I thought the whole thing was frozen and I'd pick it up once it got resolved. Turned out EDD can only pay weeks that you actually certified - they can't go back and cover gaps where you didn't submit anything.

0 coins

Wait, so even though my claim says pending right now I should still be certifying every two weeks?

0 coins

Yes, keep certifying. If your claim gets approved down the line they can pay the weeks you certified. Any weeks you skip are just gone.

0 coins

This is such a common thing people don't realize. The pending status doesn't pause your certification schedule, it just means EDD is still deciding on eligibility for those weeks.

0 coins

I made this same mistake. Lost several weeks because I thought pending meant I was supposed to wait. Certify no matter what the status says.

0 coins

I got it in my head that since I hadn't been at the new job long enough to build up wages there, I wouldn't have a valid claim at all. Spent like a week stressing before someone explained the base period concept to me. The base period looks back at the prior 18 months of employment history, not just your most recent job. If you had three years at your previous employer and earned at least $1,300 in your highest quarter during that window, you've likely got the foundation for a valid claim regardless of how short the new job was.

0 coins

Three years of solid wages at the previous place, so I should be okay on that front. This actually makes me feel a lot better.

0 coins

The DE 429Z is the notice EDD mails out that shows your actual weekly benefit amount. That's the number to look at once it arrives. It comes separately from any eligibility decision.

0 coins

Just to add, the weekly amount tops out at $450 regardless of how high your wages were. A lot of people expect more if they were making good money but that's the current cap.

0 coins

The phone interview is what I was most anxious about when I went through a termination claim. I kept calling it an appeal in my head and mixing up the two completely. The interview is EDD asking you to explain your situation before any decision is made - it's not a hearing or a formal challenge. The notice you get (the DE 4800) will have the date and time, and the interviewer phones at that time. If you miss it, call EDD the same day you miss it or they'll just decide the case without you.

0 coins

What kind of questions do they actually ask in the interview? I want to be as prepared as possible.

0 coins

They typically walk through your last day, what you were told about why you were let go, whether you got any warnings, and what your job duties involved. For a performance-based firing the questions tend to focus on what standards you were held to and whether you knew about them.

0 coins

Keeping any emails or notes from your time there is really helpful for the interview. Not that you need a formal presentation, but having dates and specifics in front of you helps when you're nervous.

0 coins

My ex-coworker filed after a probation firing and was convinced she'd be denied because the company said the word 'probation' in the termination letter. That word by itself means nothing special to EDD. They're asking what actually happened, not what label your employer put on the timeframe. The burden EDD puts on the employer is to show misconduct, not just that performance wasn't where they wanted it.

0 coins

I saw somewhere that probationary employees can't get unemployment but honestly I think that's just a myth that gets repeated.

0 coins

Yep, it's a myth. There's no probationary exemption in California's unemployment rules. The analysis is the same as any other termination.

0 coins

Small correction on how the burden thing works - EDD's approach is that if you're fired, the employer needs to show misconduct. EDD's own language is that the employer must prove misconduct existed. That's different from a quit, where the burden is on you to show you had a good reason. But EDD makes the decision either way based on what both sides say.

0 coins

I want to flag something I saw someone say in another thread about this. Someone claimed that if EDD finds no misconduct they still might deny benefits because of an 'availability' issue. That can happen if someone is on a leave or has restrictions, but just being fired for performance during probation doesn't create an availability problem. You're still able and available for work, which is all they need to see on that dimension.

0 coins

I am definitely able and available, actively looking already. So that shouldn't be an issue in my case.

0 coins

Each week you certify, the questions ask whether you were able to work and available for work and whether you looked for work. As long as you're answering those honestly yes, you're in good shape on that part.

0 coins

My certification question about work search tripped me up at first. I thought EDD tracked your applications through CalJOBS but that's not how it works - CalJOBS is for job searching and posting a resume, not for logging your activity directly into your unemployment claim.

0 coins

Termination paperwork said 'failure to meet probationary standards' and I genuinely thought that meant automatic denial. Sat on my claim for two weeks before I filed, which cost me those weeks since the claim only goes back to the Sunday I applied. Even after filing I had a stack of questions about my base period wages because two of my former employers had weird payroll schedules. Used Claimyr to get through to an EDD agent since the phone line was impossible, and the agent looked at which quarters my wages were actually landing in. Turned out one chunk of pay I thought would help was just outside the standard base period window, so the agent explained that EDD would automatically check the alternate base period if the standard one didn't support a valid claim.

0 coins

The alternate base period is something I hadn't heard about. So EDD checks that automatically if needed?

0 coins

That's what the agent explained - EDD runs the alternate period on its own if the standard one doesn't get you to a valid claim. You don't have to request it. It uses the most recent four completed quarters instead of the earlier window.

0 coins

Important clarification though - the alternate base period only kicks in if you don't have a valid claim under the standard one. It doesn't just get applied to try to get you a higher weekly amount if your claim already qualifies.

0 coins

EDD sends the Notice of Unemployment Insurance Award before they even decide eligibility, and I know a lot of people read that as an approval letter, which it isn't. The DE 429Z just shows what the claim could pay if you're found eligible. Actual eligibility gets decided after the phone interview and any other review. If you're denied, you get a Notice of Determination with an appeal form attached.

0 coins

Okay so the DE 429Z showing up doesn't mean I'm approved, just that EDD is saying 'here's the range if you qualify.' Got it.

0 coins

Exactly right. Keep an eye on your mail for the DE 4800, which is the interview notice. That'll have your interview time on it and the UI Online homepage will show it too.

0 coins

Appeal deadline is 30 days from the mailing date on whatever notice you get. If you get a denial and want to fight it, that clock starts right away.

0 coins

Whether the lack of write-ups works in your favor is worth raising during the interview. EDD tends to look at whether the employer documented performance issues and communicated expectations clearly. If your manager never gave you a formal warning or put anything in writing about what you were falling short on, that's genuinely relevant to whether the firing looked like a sudden termination rather than a managed-out situation.

0 coins

Literally nothing was in writing. No performance review, no written warning, nothing. The first I heard about performance being an issue was the day they let me go.

0 coins

That's worth noting down with dates and details before your interview. The specifics of what was communicated, when, and how help ground your answers.

0 coins

I'm in a similar boat, fired from a 90-day probation with zero written documentation. My interview is scheduled for next week and I've been writing down everything I can remember about what was said.

0 coins

Something I got wrong before my own termination claim - I assumed EDD would see my employer's response and I'd never know what they said, like it was all happening behind a curtain. It's not quite that opaque. If EDD issues a Notice of Determination against you, the notice explains the basis for the decision and the Appeal Form (DE 1000M) is right there with it. You can appeal in writing within 30 days and an administrative law judge handles the hearing, not EDD itself.

0 coins

If I end up appealing, is that like a formal court thing? That sounds intimidating.

0 coins

The hearing is more like a structured conversation under oath. You can represent yourself, have a union rep if you have one, or bring an attorney. The administrative law judge runs it, not EDD. You'd get a Notice of Hearing in the mail at least 10 days before it happens.

0 coins

Appeals can take a while but the win rate for claimants who had a decent case to begin with is not negligible. Worth doing rather than just accepting a denial.

0 coins

My problem was I confused reporting wages with certifying. My first few certifications I thought I had to log in and add all my old wages somewhere separate, and I was digging around UI Online trying to find the right screen. The Report Wages option in UI Online is for entering wages you earned while on a claim - like if you pick up part-time work while collecting benefits. It's not for the wages from before you filed.

0 coins

I was actually wondering about that. I've got some part-time freelance stuff I might pick up while I'm looking. Do I report that?

0 coins

Yes, you report what you earn in the week you earned it, not when you get paid. Part-time income doesn't cut you off but EDD does reduce the weekly benefit by whatever's over the $25-or-25-percent threshold.

0 coins

The formula is whichever is greater - either $25 or 25 percent of your gross weekly earnings - is not counted against your benefit. Anything above that gets subtracted from what EDD pays you that week.

0 coins

Genuinely never thought about what happens if you get a job quickly and then it also ends. If the new job ends before your benefit year runs out, you can reopen the existing claim through UI Online rather than starting from scratch. You don't file a whole new claim - you reopen what's already there.

0 coins

Signed into UI Online just now to check on my own claim and saw this option. Good to know it's right there.

0 coins

Benefit year is 52 weeks from when the claim started, so there's often still time to reopen if something falls apart with a new gig.

0 coins

If the benefit year ends first and there's still money left on the claim unused, that's just gone. Someone who uses up all 26 weeks before the year ends also can't file a new California claim until the benefit year officially ends.

0 coins

The CalJOBS registration piece catches people off guard. EDD sends a Notice of Requirement to Register for Work (DE 8405) if you need to register, and you've got 21 days from the date on that notice to get your CalJOBS account set up and a resume posted. If you skip it, payments can get held up. EDD tells you if you're exempt from this requirement.

0 coins

Haven't gotten that notice yet but I'll watch for it. I'm assuming it comes in the mail?

0 coins

Yes, it's mailed to you. Set up your CalJOBS account at caljobs.ca.gov once the notice shows up, get a resume posted, and you're done with that piece.

0 coins

CalJOBS also has job listings and tools you can actually use while you're searching. It's not just a bureaucratic checkbox - there are real resources on there.

0 coins

Severance pay question from my own situation that ended up being relevant - my probationary termination came with two weeks of severance under the company's standard policy. I was worried that counted as wages and would delay my claim or get subtracted from benefits. Used Claimyr to reach an EDD agent because I couldn't get through any other way, and asked specifically about the severance. The agent told me EDD treats severance paid under a company plan as not wages for UI purposes, so it wasn't going to delay my claim start date, though I still reported it when certifying because it was on EDD's list of pay to report and EDD decides how it affects things.

0 coins

No severance in my case but good to know for reference. So you filed your claim right away even with severance coming?

0 coins

Filed the same day I got the news. The agent confirmed that having severance doesn't mean you wait to file - you apply as soon as you're out of work.

0 coins

Vacation payout is similar territory. I got my remaining vacation hours paid out when I was let go and I was worried about the timing. EDD decides how it's treated but the advice to file right away applies there too.

0 coins

Not getting any written warnings, no performance improvement plan, nothing documented - that's a really common story with probation firings. Companies sometimes use the probationary period as a way to end employment without going through their own formal process. From EDD's angle the question is still whether there was misconduct, and 'we didn't like how they were performing' is a lot harder for an employer to frame as misconduct than 'they violated a known policy.

0 coins

That framing really helps. My job was customer-facing and my numbers weren't where they wanted but I never violated any rules, never missed a shift, never had a write-up. Just wasn't hitting sales targets they set.

0 coins

That sounds like a clean performance-based case to me. Missing sales targets because they're hard to hit is very different from willfully ignoring rules. Present it straightforwardly in your interview.

0 coins

Agreed, though worth letting EDD make that call. Present the facts - no written warnings, no prior corrective action, what your actual job duties were - and let the interview process do what it's designed to do.

0 coins

Waiting week tripped me up early on. I thought the first week I certified I'd see a payment, but EDD has a one-week unpaid waiting period that every claim has. The first certification usually covers the waiting week and then one paid week. So your first payment tends to cover just one week even if you certified for two. It doesn't reduce the total your claim can pay, the weeks just shift forward.

0 coins

So my very first certification I shouldn't expect two weeks of payment - just one week paid and one waiting week accounted for?

0 coins

That's right. After that, each two-week certification should produce two weeks of payment assuming you're eligible for those weeks. The wait just hits at the start. Payments often show up in UI Online within about a day of certifying online once things start processing.

0 coins

EDD Tele-Cert at 1-866-333-4606 (option 2) is the phone alternative if UI Online is ever giving you trouble. Same result, different interface.

0 coins

Coming from a friend's experience here - she got hired at a company, was told during probation she wasn't meeting targets, and EDD actually approved her claim after the interview. What helped was that she kept every email she'd received from her manager during her time there. None of them mentioned performance problems. That absence of documentation ended up being pretty telling.

0 coins

Makes me feel better hearing that worked out. I'm going to pull together whatever I have from my time there.

0 coins

Even text messages if any communication happened over text. Dates of any conversations you remember. The more specific you can be in the interview, the better.

0 coins

Specific is the key word. 'I never received a warning' is good. 'My only review was on day 30 and they said I was progressing well' is better if that's true. Concrete details are more persuasive than general statements.

0 coins

EDD tax situation worth knowing early: unemployment benefits are taxable at the federal level but California doesn't tax them at the state level. When you certify you can choose to have 10 percent withheld for federal taxes. EDD mails a Form 1099G in January showing what you received. If you go paperless it's in UI Online instead. Something to factor in if you end up collecting for a while.

0 coins

I had no idea California doesn't tax unemployment. That's actually useful to know for planning purposes.

0 coins

The 10 percent withholding option is voluntary. Some people prefer to handle it at tax time themselves. Just depends on your preference and situation.

0 coins

If you end up doing any freelance work while collecting, remember those earnings are also taxable, separate from whatever EDD withholds on the benefit side.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure