Back to California Unemployment

Luca Greco

Can I get unemployment after losing part time w2 job with 1099 income - California EDD question

Lost my part-time W2 job at a restaurant last month where I was pulling in about $310 a week. On top of that I've been doing freelance graphic design work - 1099 income, varies a lot, sometimes $200 in a week sometimes nothing for three weeks. The restaurant let go of their whole floor staff due to slow business so it's definitely a layoff situation, not anything I did wrong. My question is whether the 1099 freelance income I still have on the side affects whether I can even file, and if it does, what happens to my weekly benefit amount. I've been reading stuff online and getting completely contradictory answers - some places say the 1099 income disqualifies you entirely, others say you just report it each time you certify. I have no idea which is true for California EDD. Another thing I'm not sure about is what goes into calculating the weekly benefit amount when you have both kinds of income. The restaurant W2 wages are consistent but the freelance was all over the place. Does EDD look at both when figuring out what I'd get paid? I did go ahead and apply through myEDD already because I figured I shouldn't wait around while trying to figure all this out. The application is in, I just don't know what to expect from here.

The 1099 income does NOT kick you off or disqualify you from filing - that's the wrong read a lot of people have. What actually matters for EDD is whether you meet the wage requirements from your base period, which looks at the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters. Your W2 restaurant wages count toward that. The 1099 freelance income may count too depending on whether it was reported as self-employment wages in those quarters. For eligibility your highest single quarter needs at least $1,300, or at least $900 in the highest quarter with your total base period wages at 1.25 times that quarter. Your restaurant work alone might get you there. Once you're collecting, you report all your earnings each time you certify - including what you make from freelance that week. EDD has a formula where the first $25 or 25% of what you earned that week, whichever is bigger, doesn't count against you. The rest gets subtracted from your weekly benefit amount. So if you're approved for say $280 a week and you freelanced $150 that week, 25% of $150 is $37.50, so $112.50 would be deducted from $280, leaving you $167.50 for that week. Part-time freelance doesn't wipe out your benefits, it just reduces them proportionally.

0 coins

So the weekly math - does the 25% apply to what I report as gross freelance income for that week, even if the client hasn't actually paid me yet? My invoices sometimes get paid 30 or 45 days late.

0 coins

EDD goes by when the work was earned, not when the money lands in your account. So if you did the design work in a given week, you report that week's wages even if the invoice doesn't get paid until weeks later.

0 coins

This is the right answer. The 'earned not paid' rule tripped me up early on and I had to contact EDD to sort out a week I'd certified wrong. Report Wages in UI Online lets you work out the numbers before you certify but it won't fix a week that's already been submitted - for that you'd need to message EDD through your UI Online account.

0 coins

Had almost this exact same mix when I lost my part-time catering W2 job last year while still doing some event photography on 1099. Applied through myEDD and got approved without any issue related to the 1099 side. The DE 429Z they mailed me showed the weekly benefit amount EDD calculated - mine came out to about $230. EDD used my base period wages to get there. The 1099 freelance wasn't the dominant factor in that calculation since my W2 wages were more consistent. What actually helped me understand it was talking to a live EDD agent. Getting anyone on 1-800-300-5616 at a reachable time felt impossible for about two weeks. Ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get on the line without camping out all morning - basically it handles the hold so you end up speaking to an actual EDD rep. There's a video showing how reaching a live person at EDD works: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The agent I got pulled up my claim and confirmed which quarters EDD was using for my base period and that my specific freelance setup wasn't causing any eligibility flag on the account.

0 coins

Really glad to hear the 1099 didn't just tank the whole thing. And that call strategy - was there anything specific about how the freelance income was structured that the agent flagged, or was it pretty routine?

0 coins

Routine is a good word for it honestly. The agent said the mix of W2 and self-employment in a base period is not unusual, and what mattered was whether the wage totals cleared EDD's threshold. Mine did from the catering side alone so the photography income was almost beside the point for qualification.

0 coins

The number on the DE 429Z being what your claim can pay maximum vs. what EDD actually decides you're eligible for - that tripped me up. Got my DE 429Z and thought it meant I was approved. It just means EDD processed the claim and here's the range, not that they've ruled on eligibility yet.

0 coins

Something I keep seeing people get wrong in these threads is assuming 1099 income means you're 'self-employed' in a way that blocks a claim. I thought the same thing before my situation. The W2 job is what drives eligibility when you lose it. You lost a W2 position through a layoff - that's the qualifying event. The freelance being 1099 doesn't undo that. The only wrinkle I've heard people run into is if the 1099 work is their main gig and the W2 was truly minimal. But at $310 a week the restaurant work sounds like enough to get you into valid claim territory if it was consistent across the base period quarters.

0 coins

W2 and 1099 income in the same period always makes people assume they don't qualify for some reason. Probably because of how taxes feel different when you're self-employed.

0 coins

Exactly. The two types coexisting during the base period is very normal. What EDD is looking at is whether you had enough covered wages - wages from W2 employment that was subject to California's UI tax - to meet the threshold.

0 coins

Makes sense. The restaurant definitely withheld everything the normal way. I always had the full deductions on my pay stubs so that should count as covered employment.

0 coins

Filed with the same kind of setup three months back - lost a part-time W2 warehouse job while still doing some freelance consulting. EDD asked about all my employment during the last 18 months when I applied, and I listed the W2 employer and also noted I had ongoing 1099 work. The application went through without a phone interview being scheduled, which surprised me since I thought any self-employment would trigger one. Got the DE 429Z about two weeks later. My weekly benefit amount came out at $195, which reflected just my W2 wages since my freelance income during the base period quarters was sporadic and hard to attribute to specific quarters. One thing - when you certify, the questions ask about any work performed and earnings. For the weeks where your freelance was zero, you answer accordingly. For weeks you did design work you report those earnings. It's genuinely week by week.

0 coins

The 'list everything' approach on the application - did you feel like noting the 1099 work caused any delay or additional scrutiny?

0 coins

None that I noticed. Processed in what felt like normal time. Just be accurate - EDD's going to want honest reporting throughout.

0 coins

Agree with the honesty point hard. Trying to minimize or not mention income is where people get into overpayment trouble later. EDD cross-checks.

0 coins

WAIT does anyone know if the base period calculation is different when you have mixed income?? I'm in a similar situation and been told totally different things by people around me, one person said EDD only counts W2 wages and another said they count ALL income you reported to the IRS. Getting worried I'm going to file and then get some weird determination.

0 coins

For California UI, the standard base period looks at wages subject to UI tax - which is W2 employment where the employer paid into California's unemployment insurance system. Pure self-employment 1099 income generally isn't subject to California UI tax the same way, so it may not factor into your base period wage calculation. Apply and let EDD assess it - the DE 429Z will show what wages they used.

0 coins

Okay that makes more sense. So theoretically if someone barely had any W2 income and all their money was 1099 freelance, they might not meet the wage threshold even if they technically 'lost' the W2 job?

0 coins

Right, the threshold has to be met through covered wages. Someone whose W2 work was very minimal might not clear it - which is why applying anyway makes sense because EDD runs the numbers, and there's also the alternate base period if the standard one doesn't work out.

0 coins

CalJOBS registration is something a lot of people forget about and then it bites them. After you apply, most claimants get a Notice of Requirement to Register for Work (DE 8405), and you've got 21 days from the date on that to register on CalJOBS and post a resume. Missing it can stop payments cold. Keep an eye on your mail after you apply.

0 coins

Haven't gotten that notice yet but I'll watch for it. Does having the 1099 freelance work change anything about the CalJOBS requirement?

0 coins

EDD decides if you're exempt from that requirement and they'll say so in writing. If you don't get a letter saying you're exempt, assume you need to register. Best not to assume the freelance side gets you out of it.

0 coins

CalJOBS also has job search tools, workshops, resume help - worth using even beyond just meeting the registration requirement. The America's Job Centers of California run events tied to it.

0 coins

The alternate base period thing the person above mentioned - I genuinely didn't know that existed until months into my claim. My standard base period wasn't strong enough because I'd been doing mostly 1099 for most of that year, then picked up W2 work in the most recent quarters before my layoff. EDD automatically checked the alternate base period (the last four completed quarters instead of the standard first-four-of-five) and that one had enough covered wages. Ended up qualifying where I almost thought I wouldn't.

0 coins

That's actually reassuring for my situation since my restaurant W2 work ramps up in my most recent quarters. Good to know EDD checks the alternate automatically.

0 coins

They do it automatically only when the standard period doesn't produce a valid claim. It never raises your weekly amount on a claim that already qualifies under the standard period - just whether you qualify at all.

0 coins

Learned the alternate base period exists the hard way too. Applied thinking I wouldn't qualify and EDD approved me under it. Worth filing even when you're not sure.

0 coins

Question for anyone who knows - when you're certifying every two weeks and you had a week where your freelance earnings were higher than your weekly benefit amount, what actually happens? Do you just get zero for that week? And does that week still count toward your 26 weeks?

0 coins

Full-time work ends eligibility for that specific week regardless of what it pays. For part-time work where your reduced benefit would go negative after the formula, yes you'd get zero for that week. As for counting toward your 26 - the maximum benefit amount is 26 times your weekly benefit amount or half your base period wages, whichever is less. Weeks where you earn enough to get zero don't use up your benefit weeks in the same way as fully paid weeks.

0 coins

That part about full-time vs part-time mattering makes sense. My freelance is definitely variable - some weeks nothing, some weeks basically a full week of billable hours. Good to know to track which weeks were which.

0 coins

Overpayment from miscertifying that kind of week is real. Had a week early in my claim where my freelance project billing was huge and I didn't flag it correctly. Got a notice about it. Ended up using Claimyr to get through to EDD when the overpayment question showed up - the agent walked me through what had been flagged and what documentation to submit. Avoided a bigger headache by catching it early through that call.

0 coins

The waiting week is something to know about upfront. First eligible week of your claim is an unpaid waiting period - you still certify it, but no payment comes for it. The first actual certification usually covers the waiting week plus one paid week. So don't panic when the first payout seems like it covers two weeks, that's just how it works.

0 coins

How does the waiting week interact with weeks where I had some freelance income? If the waiting week is unpaid regardless, does earnings reporting still matter for it?

0 coins

Still certify it accurately with whatever you earned. EDD uses that information even if no payment is going out that week.

0 coins

Missed this waiting week fact when I first applied and was convinced something was wrong with my claim when my first payment looked short. Spent a whole week trying to figure out if EDD miscalculated. Had wanted to call but kept getting cut off trying to reach 1-800-300-5616. Used Claimyr to get an agent on the phone and confirmed my weekly benefit amount was actually correct - it was just the structure of that first certification period I hadn't understood.

0 coins

For what it's worth, the UI Online live chat is actually useful if you have a simple status question and can hit it between 9am and 2pm weekdays. Got through to an agent via the Help button in my account and they confirmed my identity verification had cleared without me having to wait on the phone. Might be worth trying for basic stuff while you're waiting to hear about your claim.

0 coins

That window is tight when you're picking up freelance shifts during the day. Good to know that's even an option though.

0 coins

Yeah, 9 to 2 is not exactly helpful for everyone. Phone is still the main route for anything more complex than a status check.

0 coins

Live chat dropped on me twice when my issue was complicated. Some things really do need a full phone conversation.

0 coins

Part-time W2 jobs plus 1099 work and suddenly having a layoff was exactly my situation about five months ago. Lost the W2 side, still had the 1099 graphic work trickling in. Applied and got through the process okay but hit a snag mid-claim when my self-employment income spiked one month and I was unsure how to certify a few of those weeks correctly. The DE 429Z had come and shown a weekly benefit amount of $240, which looked right based on my restaurant equivalent wages. Claimyr (claimyr.com) got me to an EDD agent when I had the certifying question - told the agent what my gross freelance earnings had been each week in question and they walked me through how the deduction formula applied to my specific numbers. Filed correctly after that.

0 coins

Really helpful to hear from someone with the same exact setup. Did the agent have any concern about the spike weeks or was it more of a 'here's the math, certify accordingly' situation?

0 coins

Purely 'here's how the formula works for your numbers.' No flags, no escalation. Just confirmed the math and I certified accordingly.

0 coins

The formula confusion during spike weeks is so real. The 25% or $25 whichever is greater thing isn't intuitive until someone does the math with you on actual numbers from your own week.

0 coins

Jumped back to look at this thread because nobody mentioned the work search requirement and it's important. For every week you certify, you have to be able to work, available for work, and looking for work. EDD doesn't publish a specific number of contacts you have to make per week - just that you need to be actively looking. Keep records of where you're applying in case it comes up.

0 coins

Does being a freelancer who's actively pitching clients count as a job search activity? Or does it have to be traditional employment applications?

0 coins

EDD's pages don't break down exactly what counts - they say to be actively looking for work. Worth checking with EDD directly if your freelance pitching is your main search method, since they'd need to assess it for your specific situation.

0 coins

Heard someone say you have to do 3 contacts a week and that number floated around my office when we were all laid off at the same time. Nobody at EDD ever told us that number - I'd be careful about assuming a specific count is the rule.

0 coins

Taxes on the benefits are federal taxable income, just so you know going in. EDD lets you opt for 10% federal withholding each time you certify. California doesn't tax it at the state level. With 1099 work you might already be used to setting aside money for quarterly taxes, so the federal side of UI benefits is worth factoring into that.

0 coins

Good heads up. I already track everything for quarterly estimated taxes so adding UI income to that shouldn't be complicated.

0 coins

Form 1099G from EDD shows the benefit income for the year - it's also in UI Online under Payments if you need it before they mail it. EDD started using Claimyr when I needed to sort out a 1099G discrepancy from a prior year claim - the agent pulled up my payment history and confirmed the total. Straightforward call once I actually got an agent.

0 coins

The 10% withholding option is easy to overlook during certifying when you're just trying to get through the questions. Worth paying attention to that question.

0 coins

I was under the impression that having any self-employment income at all during a claim meant EDD would treat you as 'self-employed' and not eligible. Turns out that's completely backwards - what matters is whether you lost W2 covered employment. The 1099 side continuing doesn't disqualify you, you just report it. Someone corrected me on this in another forum and I'm glad they did or I wouldn't have applied.

0 coins

The 'self-employed = not eligible' myth is really persistent. It comes from people confusing Pandemic-era programs with standard UI rules. Standard California UI is specifically designed for W2 employment loss. Having 1099 side work is very common among the people who collect it.

0 coins

Made me realize I should have just applied immediately when I lost the W2 job instead of waiting three weeks because I thought the 1099 made me ineligible. Claim starts the Sunday of the week you apply so I lost those weeks.

0 coins

Apply the week you lose the job, before you have all the answers. You can figure out the nuances as you go. Waiting costs you benefit weeks you can't get back.

0 coins

Not sure if this is relevant but asked an AJCC career counselor about my similar mixed-income situation before filing. They were helpful with job search stuff, resume coaching, workshops - all really useful. They were clear that they don't process or file claims though, that's EDD's department. Just flagging it because I see people assume AJCC staff can help with the claim itself.

0 coins

Good to know what AJCC can and can't do. Probably worth going in for the resume help since I'm technically also looking for a new W2 job while doing the freelance.

0 coins

Exactly why they're useful even with an active claim. The job search resources are legit especially the workshops.

0 coins

My partner went through this last year with a part-time retail W2 and ongoing photography 1099 on the side. The retail job ended, she applied, the claim went through. The 1099 income got reported each certification period depending on what she actually worked. The weeks she had no photo work she got the full weekly benefit amount, weeks she had some she got reduced, weeks she had a full schedule of shoots she got zero but those weeks didn't eat up her total claim the same way. The whole process was just what everyone here is saying - report honestly and let the formula do what it does.

0 coins

Really reassuring to hear a full arc story like that. Does she still have the same mix or did she land something new?

0 coins

Landed a full-time job about four months in. Filed for the last certification, got paid out the final week, and that was that. Claim closed naturally.

0 coins

The myEDD application itself asks for every employer in the last 18 months, including self-employment. Be thorough there. EDD uses the information to build out your claim and to notify your most recent employer, who gets a DE 1101CZ from EDD and has 10 days to respond. Don't be caught off guard if your restaurant reaches out to you around that time, it's just a standard step in the process.

0 coins

The restaurant knows I was let go for business reasons so I don't expect them to contest anything. Just want to make sure I do my part correctly on the application.

0 coins

Sounds like a clean layoff situation. The process should be straightforward from your end.

0 coins

Employer notified doesn't mean employer contested. Most layoffs where it's clearly business-driven go through without any back-and-forth between EDD and the former employer.

0 coins

One thing nobody's mentioned - if the claim year ends and your weekly benefit amount runs out before you find stable work again, you can't file a new California claim until the benefit year ends. It's been 52 weeks since the Sunday you filed. Plan your 26 weeks of potential benefits with that in mind so you're not surprised if there's a gap before another claim is possible.

0 coins

26 weeks is longer than I expect to need it but good to know the structure. So the 26 weeks doesn't roll over or extend automatically in normal times?

0 coins

No automatic extension right now. Extended Benefits programs exist under state or federal law when unemployment rates hit certain triggers, but that's not the current situation. 26 weeks is what you have to work with.

0 coins

Thought there was still some kind of extension available from a couple years ago. Guess not anymore.

0 coins

Something worth flagging that I ran into: ID.me identity verification. EDD requires it, done through their site. You create an account, take photos of your ID, do the selfie verification. Someone who applies by phone or mail gets a DE 1326C in the mail asking them to verify identity. I applied online and still got held up because my ID.me didn't match right away. Pending weeks in UI Online Claim History while identity is being resolved.

0 coins

Applied online and went through the ID.me step during the application. Seemed to go through - is there a way to confirm it actually cleared?

0 coins

UI Online will show pending weeks if something is still unresolved including identity. If your Claim History isn't flagging anything obvious after a couple weeks you're likely clear.

0 coins

ID.me tripped me up for three weeks. Ended up needing to do a video call verification through them. Worth resolving quickly because pending weeks don't become paid weeks until it's sorted.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure