Back to California Unemployment

Khalid Howes

California EDD payments disqualified after filing new claim with representative

So I hired someone who handles unemployment claims as a rep and they filed a new claim on my behalf because they said my original claim had issues. Now every week I had already certified shows as disqualified and I can't figure out if this happened because of the new claim they filed or if EDD did something else. I was getting paid fine before all this started, $380 a week, and now nothing is going through. Has anyone had their payments disqualified after filing new claim with representative? The rep isn't giving me clear answers and I really don't know if I should appeal or what. My benefit year on the original claim hadn't ended yet so I'm panicking about whether I're messed up my whole claim.

Duplicate filing basically torched my whole claim too. My UI Online Claim History showed every certified week flipping to Pending overnight, and when I called the number on my DE 429Z it just rang forever. Filed a layoff from a warehouse job back in January, weekly amount was $310, and I burned two weeks trying to reach anyone. Ended up getting through to a live EDD agent using Claimyr (claimyr.com) — it basically sits on hold for you so you pick up once a rep is on the line. There's a video on reaching a live person at EDD if you want to see what that's like: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The agent pulled up my account and said the second claim submission had triggered an eligibility review flagging overlapping benefit years, and that I needed to let the original claim's benefit year close before the new one could pay. She also said to keep certifying on the original claim while the review was open or EDD couldn't pay any back weeks. That detail alone saved me a pile of money.

0 coins

Wait, so you kept certifying on the original claim even while everything showed disqualified? I stopped certifying because I figured what's the point if it all says disqualified. Is it too late to certify the missing weeks?

0 coins

The agent told me exactly that — back weeks only get paid if they were certified, so the missed ones are probably gone. Phone EDD as soon as you can and ask about your specific certified weeks, because there may still be open weeks on the original claim.

0 coins

Filing a second claim while the first benefit year is still active is almost always the problem in situations like this. You can't collect on two California claims at the same time and EDD flags it immediately.

0 coins

Had I known that keeping certifications going during a review was important, I would have done it. I stopped too and lost about four weeks.

0 coins

What exactly did your rep file — a whole new initial claim or did they try to reopen the existing one? Those are very different things and EDD treats them completely differently. Reopening a claim that's still in its benefit year just restarts your certifications on the same claim; filing a brand new claim while the first benefit year hasn't closed is what creates the conflict.

0 coins

Honestly I'm not sure. The rep just said they 'filed a new claim' but I never got a new DE 429Z showing a different weekly amount. Does that mean it might have been a reopen?

0 coins

No new DE 429Z is a pretty good indicator it was a reopen rather than a fresh claim, because a new claim always generates a new award notice. Still worth confirming with EDD directly though, because if the rep actually filed a full new claim it changes what you need to do next.

0 coins

Reps vary wildly in how well they know EDD's processes. Some are great, some file things that make situations worse. Always double-check what was actually submitted.

0 coins

Something I didn't understand until my own layoff hit: a California unemployment claim runs for exactly 52 weeks from the Sunday you apply, and you can't have two active claims overlapping. EDD's system automatically flags any new application that shares weeks with an existing benefit year. When that happens, the weeks on the first claim that fall under the second filing get held or disqualified pending an eligibility review. It's not permanent necessarily, but you do need to contact EDD to get it sorted out. The fix usually involves EDD closing or withdrawing the duplicate filing and then processing your original certified weeks. Doesn't happen automatically — you have to push for it.

0 coins

So the disqualification isn't necessarily final? I read 'disqualified' and assumed it was over. Should I still appeal or just contact EDD first?

0 coins

Contact EDD first, before you appeal. If this is an administrative issue from the duplicate filing rather than an actual eligibility decision, an agent can often resolve it without an appeal. If EDD mails you a Notice of Determination (DE 1080CZ), that's when you appeal in writing within 30 days of the mailing date using the DE 1000M.

0 coins

Appeals go on forever though, like months and months. Better to fix it at the EDD level if you can before escalating.

0 coins

Agreed, the appeal route is slower. Direct EDD contact first makes way more sense for a duplicate claim issue.

0 coins

Can you check under Claim History in UI Online and tell us what it actually says for each week? Like is it showing 'Disqualified' or 'Pending' or something else? Because those words mean different things. Pending means EDD is still deciding something. Disqualified usually means a decision was already made, which would mean a Notice of Determination should be coming in the mail if it hasn't already.

0 coins

It literally says Disqualified for every week going back three weeks. I haven't gotten any mail from EDD except my original DE 429Z from when I first filed months ago.

0 coins

If it says Disqualified and no DE 1080CZ has arrived yet, the notice might still be in transit. EDD's mail can lag a week or more behind what UI Online shows. Watch for it every day, because that 30-day appeal window starts from the mailing date on the notice, not from when you receive it.

0 coins

I made the mistake of thinking the 30 days started when I got the letter. It doesn't. Lost eight days assuming I had more time.

0 coins

Authorization form issue tangled up my payments last year after I added a rep on my claim. The DE 429Z I got showed $295 a week, laid off from a hotel job in March. When the rep submitted paperwork, something in the authorization conflicted with my identity verification and EDD froze my certified weeks. I spent a week trying to reach anyone through the main line. Eventually got an EDD agent on the phone through Claimyr and found out the freeze was specifically on the identity side, not an eligibility decision — my ID.me verification had a flag that the rep's submission accidentally duplicated. The agent told me to log into myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ and re-verify through ID.me, which cleared the freeze within two business days.

0 coins

Oh wow I didn't even think about ID.me being involved. I did my verification months ago when I first applied but maybe adding the rep triggered something again?

0 coins

Worth checking your myEDD account to see if there's any identity verification prompt waiting for you. If your status changed when the rep was added, EDD sometimes re-flags identity even on verified accounts.

0 coins

ID.me stuff can be such a headache. I had to redo my verification twice and it kept erroring out.

0 coins

The ID.me angle is a good one to check early. Identity holds look exactly like eligibility holds in UI Online but the fix is completely different.

0 coins

Does your rep have an actual signed authorization on file with EDD? Because if EDD didn't receive or process that authorization, anything the rep filed might be sitting unprocessed or was rejected. I've heard of reps submitting things and EDD not connecting the submission to the actual claim because the authorization wasn't in order first.

0 coins

I signed something with the rep but I never got any confirmation from EDD that the authorization was accepted. How would I even know?

0 coins

You probably wouldn't unless you asked EDD directly. That's another reason to phone EDD — ask specifically whether a third-party authorization is showing on your account and whether the rep's submission is linked to your claim.

0 coins

The authorization paperwork thing is real. I added a union rep to my claim and it took EDD about 10 days to reflect it on the account side. During that time, anything the rep submitted was floating unattached.

0 coins

Weekly amount of $420 from a tech contractor layoff in September, and my situation ended up being about two certifications that slipped through uncertified when my rep thought I was handling them and I thought they were. Spent probably six hours over three days trying to get EDD on the phone. Tried Claimyr and had a live agent in way less time than any of my previous solo attempts. The agent confirmed which specific weeks were still open to certify and which had already closed out, so I knew exactly what I could still fix.

0 coins

How did you know which weeks were actually still certifiable vs. already closed? Is that something you could see in UI Online or did the agent have to tell you?

0 coins

The agent pulled it from the account side — UI Online doesn't show you clearly which certification windows are still open vs. expired. The agent gave me dates and I went from there.

0 coins

The gap between what UI Online shows you and what's actually on the EDD account side is genuinely wild. So much is invisible to the claimant.

0 coins

Filing a whole new claim when a benefit year is still active is something a lot of reps do without fully understanding the conflict it creates. The original claim's 52-week benefit year has to end before a new one can pay. If your rep filed a new claim and it's overlapping your existing benefit year, EDD should actually close the new claim and reinstate the original — but you have to request it. This is a known issue and not your fault, but it doesn't fix itself.

0 coins

I always thought EDD automatically caught these things and fixed them. Finding out you have to request a fix yourself is not a fun discovery.

0 coins

EDD catches the conflict and flags it, but the resolution requires you or your rep to contact EDD and explain what happened. It doesn't get unwound automatically.

0 coins

EDD fixing anything automatically feels like a myth honestly.

0 coins

Are you still certifying every two weeks on the original claim even with the disqualified status showing? A lot of people stop certifying when they see that word and that's actually the worst thing you can do. Even during an eligibility review or adjudication, keeping your certifications current means EDD can release those payments once the issue is resolved. Missing certification windows closes them permanently — EDD can only pay weeks that were actually certified.

0 coins

I stopped after the first disqualified week showed up. How many weeks am I likely to have lost at this point?

0 coins

Depends on how long ago they showed as disqualified and when your certification windows were. EDD Tele-Cert at 1-866-333-4606 can sometimes show which weeks are still open to certify; worth trying that before assuming the missed weeks are all gone.

0 coins

EDD Tele-Cert is an underrated option when UI Online is confusing. Sometimes the phone system gives you information the website doesn't show clearly.

0 coins

My cousin went through something with a rep filing stuff too and EDD sent back a — wait, is the representative you used an actual licensed rep or just someone you found online? Because there's a big difference between a union rep or certified advisor and some random person who charges you money to 'help' with your claim. Some of those people make situations way worse.

0 coins

They're not a union rep, it's an individual who charges a fee. Is that legal? Now I'm worried about more than just the EDD problem.

0 coins

There's nothing stopping someone from helping with a claim and charging for it, but EDD itself doesn't certify or endorse third-party claim services. If the rep gave you bad advice that caused this situation, that's on them, not necessarily fraud on your end.

0 coins

Paid reps are common and can be legitimate. The key question is whether they actually know EDD's rules well enough to not create new problems.

0 coins

Something worth knowing: even if your rep caused this problem, EDD looks at your claim and your actions, not your representative's. So if there's an eligibility decision against you, the appeal needs to explain what happened from your perspective and what you understood the rep was filing. The appeal is your chance to give EDD the full picture — that you had an existing active claim, that you authorized a rep, and that you didn't intend to file a conflicting new claim.

0 coins

Can I appeal even before I get the DE 1080CZ? Or do I have to wait for that notice?

0 coins

You have to appeal a Notice of Determination, so you wait for the DE 1080CZ before you can formally appeal. While waiting, document everything: dates you certified, what the rep told you, what they filed, any texts or emails from them. That documentation is your evidence.

0 coins

Documenting everything is advice I wish I'd gotten earlier. I had to reconstruct a timeline from memory for my appeal and it was a mess.

0 coins

Is there any chance EDD sees the rep's filing as fraud rather than just a mistake? Like if EDD thinks you were trying to double dip on two claims at the same time could that make things worse than a normal disqualification?

0 coins

EDD distinguishes between fraud and non-fraud overpayments and disqualifications. A non-fraud issue — like a rep filing incorrectly — typically results in a disqualification without a fraud penalty. Fraud requires EDD to find that false information was given or withheld intentionally. As long as you reported accurately and didn't direct the rep to do something you knew was wrong, fraud classification would be hard for EDD to establish.

0 coins

That's actually reassuring. I was imagining the worst case scenario where EDD treats the duplicate as fraud automatically.

0 coins

EDD does look at intent when determining fraud vs. non-fraud. An honest mistake by a rep you authorized, with no false information from you on certifications, is very different from intentional double-filing.

0 coins

What does your rep say when you ask them directly what they filed and why? Because their answer (or non-answer) tells you a lot about whether they actually know what they did.

0 coins

They keep saying 'it's being processed' and 'EDD is slow' but won't tell me specifically what claim type they filed or reference any form numbers. That's not great, right?

0 coins

Vague answers like that are a red flag. A competent rep should be able to tell you exactly what they submitted and what form or reference number is attached to the submission.

0 coins

Tried Claimyr myself after my layoff from a retail management job and ended up talking to an EDD agent who confirmed my rep had actually submitted the right form but to the wrong fax number — the submission never arrived. The agent told me what to resubmit and where. Sometimes the problem is simpler than it looks, which you only learn by actually reaching an agent.

0 coins

The 'EDD is slow' excuse gets used to cover up a lot of rep mistakes, in my experience. Push for specifics from your rep.

0 coins

EDD agents CANNOT tell a rep what's on your account without your authorization being confirmed on file. So if your rep is calling EDD themselves to check status and the authorization isn't in EDD's system yet, they're getting zero real information and probably guessing at what's happening. That would explain the vague non-answers.

0 coins

I hadn't thought about the rep's ability to actually check my account. If their authorization isn't confirmed, they might not even know what's happening on my claim.

0 coins

Exactly. And then they give you fake confidence like 'it's processing' because they have no actual account access either.

0 coins

This is why you need to be able to check your own account and reach EDD yourself, not rely entirely on a rep who may or may not have access.

0 coins

Keep certifying. Even if everything looks disqualified, even if the rep tells you to wait, even if you think there's no point — keep certifying every two weeks. That's the single most important thing you can do right now. EDD can only release payments for weeks that were certified. If a resolution comes through and weeks weren't certified, those weeks are gone regardless of what happens with the disqualification.

0 coins

I'm going to certify today for whatever weeks are still open. Can I certify through Tele-Cert even if UI Online is showing disqualified?

0 coins

Yes, Tele-Cert works independently of what UI Online displays. Try 1-866-333-4606 and go through the certification options.

0 coins

Certifying while disqualified showing feels counterintuitive but it's genuinely the right move.

0 coins

EDD phone line 1-800-300-5616 operates Monday through Friday 8 to 5 Pacific, and yes the hold times are brutal but reaching an agent is really the only way to get a straight answer on something this tangled. Online messages through UI Online are slower — you might wait days for a reply. For a situation with active disqualified weeks and a possible duplicate claim issue, the phone is worth the effort.

0 coins

How early do people usually call to get through faster? I've tried at 8am and been on hold for over an hour.

0 coins

8am sharp on a Monday tends to be the worst. Some people have luck mid-morning on Tuesday or Wednesday. There's no magic time but avoiding Mondays and Fridays helps.

0 coins

I called at 8:01 on a Thursday and got through in about 40 minutes once. It really is variable. Just keep trying.

0 coins

Has anyone here had EDD actually reverse a disqualification from a duplicate claim situation? Like once EDD closes the conflicting new claim, do they automatically release the original certified weeks or is that another separate process you have to request?

0 coins

Based on what happened with my layoff claim, it's a separate process. EDD closing the duplicate doesn't automatically release the held weeks. You need to follow up and confirm the original certified weeks are being processed for payment after the duplicate is resolved.

0 coins

This matches what I've seen described in these threads before. Resolution of the duplicate claim issue and release of payments are two different steps, sometimes handled by different departments within EDD.

0 coins

Okay so even after the duplicate is sorted out there's another step. Good to know before assuming payments will just start showing up.

0 coins

Calling EDD once the duplicate is closed to confirm payment release is a good move. Don't assume it happens automatically — confirm it explicitly with an agent.

0 coins

Before assuming the rep did everything wrong: is it possible EDD itself flagged your claim for a reason unrelated to what the rep filed? Sometimes an employer response to EDD triggers an eligibility review that coincidentally happened around the same time as the rep's filing. Worth asking EDD when you reach them whether there's also an employer-initiated issue on the claim.

0 coins

I hadn't considered that. My former employer did get notified when I applied — could they have filed something with EDD that triggered this?

0 coins

Employers have 10 days from the notice EDD mails them to respond about why someone left. If they responded and EDD has a question about your separation, that could be running alongside the duplicate claim issue as a separate flag.

0 coins

Two separate issues showing up at the same time is actually pretty common and can make everything look worse than it is. Untangle them separately — ask EDD specifically what flags are open on the account.

0 coins

CalJOBS registration is another thing to double-check in your situation. If you got a Notice of Requirement to Register for Work (DE 8405) and didn't complete CalJOBS registration and post a resume within 21 days, that can hold payments independently of whatever the rep filed. It's a separate disqualification trigger that often gets overlooked when people are dealing with other claim issues at the same time.

0 coins

I did register on CalJOBS right when I got that notice so that should be fine. But is that something EDD can see on their end, like can they confirm my registration is in their system?

0 coins

Yes, EDD can see CalJOBS registration status when they pull up your account. If you registered, it should show. Worth confirming when you talk to an agent anyway, just so you can rule it out as a factor.

0 coins

CalJOBS registration is one of those things that's easy to do and easy to forget whether you did. Confirming it with EDD takes two seconds while you have them on the phone.

0 coins

Whatever you do, don't let your rep contact EDD on your behalf to 'fix' this until you understand exactly what they plan to say to EDD. If they misrepresent what happened or give EDD inaccurate information while trying to resolve this, that creates new problems on top of what already exists. At minimum, ask them to tell you in writing exactly what they're going to say before they make any calls.

0 coins

This is making me want to take over the whole situation myself and cut the rep out entirely. Is it complicated to remove a representative from a California EDD claim?

0 coins

You can contact EDD and tell them you're withdrawing the rep's authorization. They'll walk you through it. After that, only you can speak to EDD about your claim, which honestly for a situation this tangled might be better.

0 coins

Taking direct control of your own claim is usually the right move when a rep is creating confusion rather than resolving it.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure