Back to California Disability

Aidan Percy

Why do some SDI claims get automatic payments instead of certification

So my coworker mentioned she never has to certify every two weeks, her payments just come automatically, but I've been filling out the DE 2500A like clockwork since my claim started. We're both out for similar reasons, back issues keeping us from our regular work. Is there some threshold or approval type that puts you on automatic versus manual certification? Trying to figure out if I'm doing extra work for no reason or if there's actually a difference in how EDD handles it.

The certification type does depend on how EDD sets up the claim. On automatic payment, EDD handles the first several payments without requiring you to submit anything biweekly. Around the ten-week mark they send a form called the DE 2593, the Disability Claim Continued Eligibility Questionnaire, and you have 20 days to return it or benefits stop. If you're not on automatic, you get the DE 2500A every two weeks and fill that out yourself. How EDD assigns one or the other isn't something claimants choose, unfortunately.

0 coins

So there's no way to request automatic? I wish someone had told me that at the start, filling out the DE 2500A every two weeks gets old fast.

0 coins

The DE 2593 deadline is real, 20 days goes faster than you'd think. Had mine arrive during a stressful recovery week and almost missed it.

0 coins

Does the DE 2593 come by mail? Or does it show up in SDI Online too? I'm worried about missing it if the mail is slow.

0 coins

EDD's FAQ spells this out. Automatic payment is how they handle certain claims from the start, and those claimants don't certify biweekly, but EDD does send the DE 2593 at the ten-week point. The DE 2500A is for claims not set up that way. Neither is better or worse for how much you're paid, just different processes.

0 coins

Does one pay faster than the other? That's the only thing I'd actually care about.

0 coins

Nothing in EDD's materials says one is faster. Payment timing depends on when EDD receives a completed claim, not which certification type you're on.

0 coins

Payment date on my own claim was a mystery for two weeks. SDI Online showed nothing useful, so I ended up reaching an EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) after getting nowhere with the disability line. The agent pulled up my account and told me the exact date my payment was issued and which week it covered. Video on getting a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ

0 coins

Claimyr just sounds like some marketing thing to me, not sure what it actually does.

0 coins

Thought the same thing honestly. Tried it when my payment date didn't line up with what I expected and ended up talking to an actual EDD person. She told me exactly which weeks had been paid out and which one was still processing. That was more than the automated line ever gave me.

0 coins

Okay, that's more convincing than a vague sales pitch. Might give it a go if my next payment doesn't post when I'm expecting it.

0 coins

The automated line at 1-800-480-3287 at least tells you the last payment amount. Not the same as a live person but it's something.

0 coins

EDD's disability line is a black hole. I called eleven mornings in a row trying to ask about my DE 2500A and either got a busy signal or a recording telling me to try later. No explanation for why I'm on manual certification when my neighbor says she's never had to touch a form since her claim started.

0 coins

Eleven tries. That's brutal. I stopped at six and just mailed the form hoping for the best.

0 coins

the line does that every time. mornings, afternoons, doesnt matter.

0 coins

if you haven't tried the Request Claim Update through SDI Online that might be worth a shot while you keep trying the phone

0 coins

Wait, I think I mixed something up. I thought the waiting period was the same thing as the two weeks before you get paid? Like I told my husband we'd see money in two weeks and now I'm reading that isn't right. Can someone clarify what the waiting period actually covers?

0 coins

The waiting period is the first seven days of your claim, and those days are simply not payable, it's not about processing time. The first day EDD can pay you is day eight. After that, payment timing depends on when EDD gets both parts of your claim, yours and your doctor's certification.

0 coins

So the seven days don't turn into a payment later? They're just gone?

0 coins

Correct, those seven days are never paid. They're a non-payable waiting period by design, not a delay that resolves itself.

0 coins

ugh okay good to know. I told my wife the same wrong thing and had to correct myself later

0 coins

Been on two SDI claims over the years. First one had me doing the DE 2500A every two weeks, second time it was automatic and the DE 2593 came at week ten. Never figured out what changed. Same doctor, same type of work I was out from.

0 coins

That's interesting, so it's not tied to the type of condition or how long the claim is expected to run?

0 coins

Not that I can tell. If there's a formula EDD uses, they haven't shared it with me.

0 coins

Same here, two claims, two different setups, no explanation either time.

0 coins

DE 2593 situation, my claim was automatic and the form showed up around week ten just like everyone says. Phoned EDD through Claimyr about it because I wasn't sure if I'd filled out one field correctly and didn't want to lose benefits over a checkmark. The agent confirmed EDD had received it and that it was complete. Such a relief!

0 coins

What did you have ready when you made that call? I want to make sure I'm prepared when I do the same.

0 coins

Had my claim ID, the date I mailed the DE 2593, and the name of my doctor's office handy. Agent found everything right away.

0 coins

Three weeks of trying that line before I got through once. Good to know there's a way that actually works when the form is time-sensitive like that.

0 coins

Not sure if this is the right place to ask but my claim is for a pregnancy leave and I'm not totally sure when to file. I think I heard four weeks before the due date but what if my doctor wants me out earlier? I'm kind of scared of getting the timing wrong and missing out.

0 coins

Typically you'd file about four weeks before your due date, but if your provider restricts your work earlier, whether reduced hours, modified duties, or stopping work completely, benefits can start from whenever that restriction begins, as long as the provider certifies it.

0 coins

So my doctor can certify an earlier start if she puts me on restrictions at like six weeks out?

0 coins

Yes, the certification just needs to reflect the actual date the restriction started.

0 coins

This is helpful to me too, I had no idea it could start earlier than four weeks. I thought four weeks was fixed.

0 coins

my claim started automatic and i had no idea about the de 2593 deadline. almost threw it out thinking it was junk mail. opened it last second and sent it in with like two days to spare

0 coins

Two days is too close for comfort. That form has a 20-day window and EDD needs it back to keep your payments going.

0 coins

yeah i know now lol. the envelope looked super official but i was out of it from meds and almost missed it

0 coins

Physical mail is so easy to lose track of when you're recovering. Glad you caught it in time.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation is worth reviewing when it arrives. It shows the weekly and maximum benefit amount based on your highest-earning quarter in the base period. It doesn't mean you're approved, just what EDD calculated you'd receive if the claim goes through.

0 coins

Mine showed a weekly amount that looked lower than I expected. Can you dispute that number?

0 coins

You'd want to look at the Notice carefully for which quarter they used and what wages were in it. If you think EDD used the wrong quarter or the amount looks off, reaching EDD directly is the right move.

0 coins

The benefit calculator on EDD's site can give you a rough estimate beforehand so you know roughly what to expect when the Notice arrives.

0 coins

Automatic payments are honestly just easier but that DE 2593 form is deceptively important. Friend of mine missed the 20-day window, her payments stopped and it took a bit to get sorted. Not a fun situation lol.

0 coins

What happened when she missed it? Did EDD restart the payments or was the whole claim closed?

0 coins

Payments stopped until EDD processed what she sent in late. She had to explain why it was late too.

0 coins

Good reason to send that one certified mail honestly.

0 coins

The DE 2593 versus DE 2500A thing is basically EDD's two tracks for continued eligibility. What I haven't found anywhere is whether being on one track changes your maximum claim duration. As far as I can tell, 52 weeks is the ceiling either way, the certification method is just the check-in process.

0 coins

That's correct. EDD's rules set 52 weeks as the maximum for DI benefits regardless of how you certify.

0 coins

Makes sense then that it's purely administrative, not a benefit difference.

0 coins

Notice of Determination arrived on my claim after what felt like a long silence. EDD had denied based on something in my base period wages, and I couldn't tell from the letter exactly which quarter they flagged. Reached an EDD agent through Claimyr about it and she read me the determination details, which quarter was at issue, and said the appeal window was 30 days from the notice date.

0 coins

Base period wage question is exactly what I'd need answered on my claim. Going to try Claimyr for that.

0 coins

Have the notice itself in front of you, the date on it, and your claim ID. That's what the agent pulled up first.

0 coins

30 days from the notice date is tight. good thing you got that info when you did.

0 coins

PFL is different from SDI by the way, no waiting period on that one. I mixed them up at first when my coworker was talking about bonding leave after her pregnancy claim. Took me a while to figure out they're totally separate claims.

0 coins

So after my pregnancy disability ends I'd file a separate PFL claim for bonding time?

0 coins

Yes, they're two different claims filed separately. The pregnancy disability part is SDI, the bonding part after is PFL.

0 coins

Exactly right. SDI covers the period your provider certifies you're unable to work, PFL is a separate program for the bonding period that follows.

0 coins

Manual certification at least keeps you in the loop on your own claim. Automatic feels set-it-and-forget-it until that DE 2593 arrives and suddenly the stakes are high.

0 coins

yeah real talk. i genuinely forgot i even had a claim going until the form showed up

0 coins

The form arriving is a good reminder to check SDI Online too. Sometimes payment details update there before the mail catches up.

0 coins

Workers' comp question, sorry if off topic, but can you have an SDI claim going at the same time as a workers' comp claim? My injury is work-related but someone told me I could also file SDI.

0 coins

EDD says it's not common to receive both at the same time, but there are exceptions. That's about as far as EDD's public guidance goes. Worth asking EDD directly about your specific situation.

0 coins

Okay I'll do that before I assume anything. Didn't want to mess up either claim.

0 coins

Yeah don't take anyone's word on that one including mine. EDD needs to weigh in on the specifics.

0 coins

been on de 2500a since week one and honestly its not that bad once you have a routine. takes five minutes if the information hasnt changed

0 coins

That's reassuring. I was making it into a bigger deal than it is probably.

0 coins

just fill it out same as before and send it in. the hard part is remembering to do it on time

0 coins

Quick question about the medical certification, my doctor's office said they submitted Part B but SDI Online still looks the same. Is there a lag before it updates, or does it reflect right away when EDD gets the form?

0 coins

After the medical certification comes in, EDD typically reaches out about the claim's status within about 14 days. SDI Online doesn't always update the moment a document is received, so some lag is normal.

0 coins

So I shouldn't panic if it still looks pending for a few days after the office says they sent it?

0 coins

Right. And double-check that your doctor used the receipt number you got when you filed your Part A. That's how EDD matches the certification to your claim.

0 coins

Oh I didn't even know the receipt number mattered for that. I'll confirm with the office tomorrow.

0 coins

One thing I keep second-guessing, if you're on automatic payments and something changes, like you try going back to work part time, do you report it the same way as someone on manual certification?

0 coins

Any return to work, even part time, needs to be reported to EDD regardless of whether you're on automatic or manual certification. How they calculate a partial week is EDD's call.

0 coins

So I'd just report it and EDD figures out what I'm owed for that week?

0 coins

Exactly. Don't try to calculate it yourself, just report the work and let EDD apply their formula.

0 coins

Payments go to the Money Network card now right? Not Bank of America anymore? My buddy got confused when his card came and thought it was the wrong thing.

0 coins

Yes, EDD's prepaid debit card is now through Money Network. If you filed through SDI Online you can also set up direct deposit instead, which I'd recommend for anyone who wants the money in their own account.

0 coins

Good to know, I'll tell him. He was about to call and complain about the card before he activated it.

0 coins

Nobody talks about how the disability line doesn't even let you hold sometimes. It just tells you to call back during business hours and hangs up. That's not a busy signal, that's the system refusing to let you wait at all.

0 coins

yeah exactly it just cuts you off. ive had it happen at like 8:05 in the morning

0 coins

every single time. there's no getting in line. it just ends.

0 coins

You can send a Request Claim Update through SDI Online too. Not as good as a live person but it goes somewhere.

0 coins

Ask EDD form on EDD's site also works for non-urgent stuff. Answers aren't immediate but you get something in writing.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure