Back to California Disability

Dmitry Ivanov

Is switching from UI to SDI a mistake for work injury in California?

So I hurt my back at work about three weeks ago and filed for unemployment while I was figuring everything out. My HR person said I should actually be on SDI instead, but now I'm reading stuff about workers' comp and I'm panicking a little. I did file a workers' comp claim too but it's been going nowhere. The UI payments have been coming in and I'm honestly scared to mess with that. Is switching from UI to SDI a mistake for work injury situations? I think I might be on the wrong benefit entirely but I don't want to lose what I'm already getting while I sort this out. Has anyone dealt with something like this where the injury is work-related but workers' comp is stalled and you're not sure which program is even right?

Unemployment and disability can't cover the same days, that's EDD's rule. UI requires you to be able to work and looking for work every week, and if you're off because of an injury, you can't honestly certify that. SDI is for when you can't do your regular work due to illness or injury. The tricky part with a work injury is that workers' comp is usually the right lane, but EDD does say there are situations where both SDI and workers' comp come into play. Worth getting that sorted before you keep certifying for UI while you're still unable to work.

0 coins

That's exactly what I was afraid of. I haven't been certifying that I'm able to work, I've kind of been fudging the available question and I'm worried that's going to catch up with me.

0 coins

Don't fudge it. If you can't work, you can't work. File for SDI and let workers' comp do what it does. Certifying wrong on UI is how you end up with an overpayment notice.

0 coins

Wait so if workers' comp is stalled can I still file SDI at the same time? Or does having a workers' comp claim open automatically block SDI?

0 coins

DE 2525XX was what I had to deal with when my claim ran longer than expected. Got an extension submitted by my doctor but had no idea if EDD actually received it. The portal wasn't showing anything new. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get someone on the phone at EDD's disability line, took way too many mornings of dead air before I tried it. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the DE 2525XX had come in and was being processed, so I stopped worrying and just waited for the extension payment.

0 coins

Reads like a paid placement to me. I've never seen anything actually get you through that line. What is that even supposed to be.

0 coins

Thought the same thing before I tried it. It stays on hold with EDD so your phone rings when a live agent picks up. I'd been dialing that 800 number every morning for two weeks straight and getting the same recording. The agent I talked to was EDD, found my DE 2525XX right there on the claim.

0 coins

I was just as doubtful when I saw it somewhere else, but I tried it after my own claim got weird. Agent confirmed the payment method on my claim was still set to the debit card and I hadn't switched to direct deposit like I thought I had. Might give it a shot!

0 coins

Alright, if the agent you spoke to was actually EDD and not some outsourced person, maybe I'll look into it. The line just drops me every time I call.

0 coins

The EDD page on DI is pretty clear that a work injury falls under workers' compensation, not SDI. But there's a line on there that says it's not common to receive both at the same time, which implies it does happen. No one on a forum is going to be able to tell you exactly how your situation lands. The safest move is to contact EDD and your workers' comp carrier separately and ask each one how your case fits.

0 coins

This is the right framing. The 'not common' language is doing a lot of work there. It suggests exceptions exist but EDD isn't going to spell them out in the FAQ.

0 coins

Okay so I shouldn't just assume I can't have both, but I also shouldn't assume I can. Got it. I'll ask EDD directly.

0 coins

Workers' comp adjuster might also know. They deal with this overlap a lot.

0 coins

UI while unable to work is a problem waiting to happen. I went down that road for about two weeks after a knee thing and then had to stop certifying anyway because I couldn't answer yes to the availability questions. At least SDI doesn't require you to be available, it just requires your doctor to say you can't do your job.

0 coins

yeah ui requires you to be available every week thats basically the whole deal

0 coins

Two weeks of wrong certifications is what I'm afraid I already have. Is there any grace period for fixing that before it becomes an overpayment?

0 coins

An overpayment notice comes with an appeal form, the DE 1000A. If you disagree with it you have 30 days from the date on the notice to appeal. Best to sort the certifications now rather than wait for a notice.

0 coins

my wife had a workers comp claim that stalled for months and her doctor ended up certifying SDI in the meantime, anyway the point is the medical certification from the doctor is what gets the SDI claim moving, without that nothing happens regardless of whatever else is going on with workers comp

0 coins

So the doctor files the medical certification separately from whatever the workers' comp side is doing? They're two completely different processes?

0 coins

Completely separate. The SDI medical certification goes through SDI Online, the doctor uses the receipt number from your claim. Workers' comp has its own forms and its own timeline. They don't talk to each other automatically.

0 coins

Okay this helps. So I could potentially file SDI and have the doctor certify it even while workers' comp is pending, and then EDD figures out how the two interact.

0 coins

Claim start date was the thing that tripped me up when I filed SDI after the knee injury. Filed kind of late and I wasn't sure if EDD would honor the date I stopped working or the date I filed. Used Claimyr to get an agent on the line because I'd been trying 1-800-480-3287 for days and it just rang out. Agent looked at my claim and told me the start date they had on file and what week the waiting period ran through.

0 coins

Did they say anything about whether filing late affected your start date at all? That's the part I'd be worried about on a delayed filing.

0 coins

Agent said the start date on my claim matched when I stopped working. Didn't go into the late filing question beyond that, just told me what the claim showed.

0 coins

been trying that number on and off for like three weeks now. still nothing. not even a hold, just the recording and then it ends.

0 coins

Workers' comp stalling is unfortunately pretty normal. Filed one years ago, took forever to get anything from the carrier. In the meantime your doctor can certify you can't work and SDI can pay something while you wait. Doesn't mean you drop the workers' comp claim.

0 coins

Yeah the two claims can run on parallel tracks for a while. Workers' comp carrier will want to know about the SDI but that's their problem to sort out.

0 coins

So I shouldn't feel like choosing SDI means I'm abandoning the workers' comp claim? Those can keep going at the same time?

0 coins

Right. You're not choosing one over the other forever. You're just making sure you have some income while workers' comp drags its feet.

0 coins

The waiting period thing confused me so much when I filed. My first SDI claim I thought the seven days was just how long processing took and I kept checking my portal every day. Turns out those first seven days just aren't payable, full stop, nothing you can do about it. Payments start from day eight.

0 coins

Wait the seven days don't count toward anything? So if I'm out for ten days I only get paid for three of them?

0 coins

Exactly that. The first week is just gone. It's not processing, it's not a glitch, it's built into every new SDI claim.

0 coins

Correct. The seven-day waiting period is per claim, not per year. If you close a claim and open a new one for a different condition later, the new waiting period starts fresh.

0 coins

Knowing that ahead of time makes a real difference. A lot of people get the first payment and think EDD shorted them a week.

0 coins

For anyone wondering about the base period calculation: the weekly benefit amount comes from your highest-paid quarter in the base period, which looks at wages from about five to eighteen months before your claim starts. EDD has a calculator on their site if you want to estimate it, but the real number shows up on your Notice of Computation once the claim processes.

0 coins

The base period thing matters a lot if you recently changed jobs or had a gap in work. Someone who was on UI for a few months before the injury might have a base period that looks different than expected.

0 coins

My injury happened pretty early in a new job. Does the base period go back to my previous employer's wages then?

0 coins

Possibly, since it looks back five to eighteen months. The Notice of Computation will show which quarter was used. If you want to estimate before it arrives, the calculator on EDD's site lets you plug in wages by quarter.

0 coins

Switched from UI to SDI after a shoulder thing. Stopped certifying for UI the week I filed SDI. EDD sorted out the overlap. No overpayment notice came.

0 coins

How long did it take for the SDI to start after you stopped the UI?

0 coins

About two weeks after the medical certification came in. The waiting period ran first, then the first payment.

0 coins

That's cleaner than I expected. I assumed switching programs mid-claim would create some kind of audit.

0 coins

you cant get both ui and sdi for the same days thats just how it is, pick one and go with it. if youre not able to work sdi makes way more sense than ui

0 coins

Worth adding that if someone certifies for UI while unable to work, EDD can come back with an overpayment for those weeks. It's not just an administrative preference, it's an eligibility question.

0 coins

yeah fair point i just meant dont overthink which one to file, the answer is usually obvious from whether you can work or not

0 coins

Notice of Computation on my claim came about a week after the medical certification went in. The number on it was lower than I expected based on what I'd been making. Couldn't reach anyone at EDD to ask about it for days. Tried Claimyr to get an agent on the phone and it worked. Agent read me which quarter of my base period was used and what the wage figure was for that quarter.

0 coins

DE 429D is the one I want to ask about on my own claim. The quarter they picked looks off to me. Going to try Claimyr for it. What should I have ready when the agent picks up.

0 coins

Have your Social Security number, your claim ID from SDI Online, and the specific quarter you think should have been used. Agent can read back what's on the claim and you can go from there.

0 coins

Okay so for a work injury specifically, what does the medical certification even say? Does the doctor have to mention that it's work-related, or do they just certify that you can't do your job?

0 coins

The doctor certifies that you're unable to perform your regular or customary work. The SDI medical certification is about your functional capacity, not about how the injury happened. Workers' comp has its own medical forms for the work-related piece.

0 coins

So the SDI doctor's form doesn't ask about how I got hurt? My doctor knows it was a work injury, I just want to make sure that doesn't disqualify me on the SDI side.

0 coins

SDI eligibility is about whether you can't work, not about whether the injury was work-related. The workers' comp question is separate. That said, EDD's own language about work injuries and SDI is worth reading directly on their site.

0 coins

Filing SDI while workers' comp is unresolved is something a lot of people do. It's not a permanent election, it's just making sure you have some income while the other claim grinds along.

0 coins

That framing actually helps me a lot. I kept thinking of it as an either-or decision.

0 coins

It's not. Workers' comp carrier may have opinions about it but that's between you and them, not something EDD controls.

0 coins

My sister went through almost this exact thing last year! Ended up filing SDI while workers' comp was in dispute, her doctor submitted the medical certification within about a week of her filing, and the SDI payments started coming in while they waited on the other claim. She said the SDI Online portal made the medical certification step pretty simple once her doctor had the receipt number.

0 coins

The receipt number thing is key. So many people file and then don't pass that number to their doctor's office and then nothing happens on the certification.

0 coins

we almost made that mistake, wrote the receipt number on a sticky note and handed it to the front desk person at the doctor's office, anyway they still had to be reminded twice

0 coins

From a practical standpoint: if you're not able to do your regular work, SDI is designed for that. UI is not. The certifying part is just your doctor confirming it in SDI Online. The workers' comp question is real but it's separate from whether SDI applies to your situation.

0 coins

Hearing it that plainly is actually helpful. I've been going in circles between all three programs trying to figure out the perfect answer.

0 coins

There usually isn't a perfect answer with an open workers' comp claim. File SDI, get the medical certification in, and ask EDD about the workers' comp interaction directly.

0 coins

The 49-day window for filing SDI is worth watching. You have 49 days from the disability start date to file without being disqualified. Same deadline for the medical certification from your provider.

0 coins

I'm at about three weeks out from the injury. So I still have time but I shouldn't sit on this much longer.

0 coins

Correct. File through SDI Online in myEDD, then give your doctor the receipt number so they can submit the certification before the window closes.

0 coins

And waiting to file isn't the same as the waiting period. The waiting period is the first seven days of the claim. The 49-day thing is about when you file, completely different clock.

0 coins

PFL is the one people mix up with SDI all the time, they're not the same thing. SDI is when you personally can't work. PFL is for bonding with a baby or caring for a sick family member. For an injury situation you're in SDI territory, PFL doesn't come into it.

0 coins

Thank you for saying this, I saw PFL mentioned somewhere in the EDD pages and started wondering if that applied to me too. So for my husband's work injury, it's SDI we file, not PFL, right?

0 coins

If he can't do his job because of the injury, yes, SDI. PFL would only be relevant if you were the one taking leave to care for him, and even then that's its own separate claim.

0 coins

PFL also has no waiting period, which is one way to tell them apart. SDI has the seven-day waiting period, PFL does not.

0 coins

just want to say switching from ui to sdi mid-injury was the right call for me. stopped certifying ui on a monday, filed sdi that same day, doctor got the certification in that week. no overlap, no problem.

0 coins

Did you have any gap in payments while the SDI processed after you stopped UI?

0 coins

yeah about two weeks of nothing, the waiting period plus processing. it was tight but nothing came back as an overpayment from the ui side.

0 coins

Two weeks is about right. Know that going in so it's not a surprise.

0 coins

Worth pointing out for anyone reading this later: the question of whether workers' comp and SDI can overlap isn't answered with a yes or no on EDD's site. They say it's not common but don't say never. If your workers' comp is genuinely stalled and not paying anything, that's a different situation than if you're receiving workers' comp wage replacement. The specifics matter.

0 coins

EDD's FAQ uses the phrase 'not common to get paid Workers' Compensation and State Disability Insurance at the same time,' which is careful wording. It doesn't say impossible.

0 coins

Carriers are going to have something to say about it either way. But that's between the claimant and the carrier, not EDD's decision to block an SDI claim.

0 coins

My workers' comp hasn't paid a single dollar yet. Everything is still in dispute. That feels like the 'stalled' scenario rather than double-dipping.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure