Back to California Disability

Emily Parker

Is CASDI deductible on my federal taxes? What I found out

Every year I stare at my W-2 and wonder the same thing about that CASDI line. This year I finally have enough of it to care because I was out for about three months after a pretty rough abdominal surgery and the deduction was noticeably larger than usual. So the question I keep landing on is: is CASDI deductible anywhere on my federal return, and does it matter that I actually collected SDI benefits during the year too? I've seen people say yes, I've seen people say it depends, and I've seen people say California SDI isn't deductible at all federally. My tax software is asking me to categorize it and I genuinely don't know what the right answer is. Anyone sorted this out?

The CASDI line on your W-2 — that deduction funds the state disability insurance program, and California itself does not tax the SDI benefits you received. The federal side is where it gets murkier, and helpers here can point you toward EDD's tax information page and a tax professional for the specifics of your own situation, because how it's treated federally can depend on factors only your preparer can weigh for you.

0 coins

Appreciate that — I'll pull up EDD's tax information page and also flag it for the person doing my return.

0 coins

Had mine done by a CPA last year and she went straight to that federal question too, said it comes down to things she needed to look at across my whole return before she could answer it.

0 coins

Claim start date on mine was something I had to phone EDD about, actually, because SDI Online was showing a date that didn't line up with what my doctor submitted, and I wanted to make sure I was looking at the right tax year for my benefits. Getting through to anyone at 1-800-480-3287 was not happening for me — tried several mornings and kept getting cut off. Ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) and after a bit of waiting I had an EDD agent on the line. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the actual start date they had on record, which turned out to be one day off from what I thought, so I adjusted my records before giving anything to my tax preparer. If you need to reach someone about your own claim dates, that's the route I took. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ

0 coins

Wait, so the claim start date can show differently between what the doctor submitted and what EDD recorded? I hadn't thought about that being an issue for which tax year the benefit falls in.

0 coins

Exactly the problem I ran into — the agent confirmed the date on EDD's end was what mattered for my records, not the date I had written down from when I first filed.

0 coins

Phoning to verify that before filing makes a lot of sense if you're right on the edge of two tax years. Good reason to actually get through to someone rather than just guessing.

0 coins

The CASDI deduction shows up in box 14 of the W-2, and your tax software may give you a dropdown to tell it what that box 14 amount is. For California state purposes, SDI paid in is not an income tax so it isn't deducted on your California return the same way. The federal treatment is a different analysis — EDD's tax information page lays out what they can tell you, and the rest is a question for your preparer.

0 coins

Mine has a box 14 dropdown and one of the options looks right but I'm not 100% sure I'm picking the correct one. I'll ask my preparer to confirm.

0 coins

Same box 14 situation here, and my preparer said the label I picked looked correct but that it barely moved anything on the federal return anyway. Glad I asked though.

0 coins

Okay wait, I thought SDI benefits were taxable the same way unemployment is? Like I got a 1099-G for unemployment one year and assumed disability would work the same way. Am I wrong about that?

0 coins

Those are two separate programs and they're treated differently. California does not tax SDI benefits. The federal question for SDI benefits is its own analysis, and EDD's tax information page and a tax professional are the right places to get that answer for your specific situation — it isn't the same as unemployment across the board.

0 coins

Okay that actually helps because I was filing them the same way in my head. Good to know they're not the same thing.

0 coins

I made that exact mistake my first year receiving SDI, confused myself completely trying to figure out why my numbers didn't add up. EDD's page on taxes straightened it out.

0 coins

Does any of this change if your employer paid part of the SDI premium instead of it all coming off your own paycheck? Mine has some kind of arrangement where the company contributes too, and I'm honestly not sure if my CASDI line reflects the full picture or just my piece.

0 coins

The setup you're describing sounds like it might be a Voluntary Plan, which is an employer alternative to the state SDI fund. How that gets reported and what it means for your taxes is something to take directly to your employer's HR department and your tax preparer — the rules can differ from the standard state plan and EDD's general guidance won't necessarily cover your specific arrangement.

0 coins

Didn't realize there was a whole separate category like that — going to HR first makes sense then.

0 coins

Is there any situation where you'd actually want to claim the CASDI amount as a deduction on the federal side? Like is it even a meaningful number for most people?

0 coins

Whether it's worth claiming and whether there's even a mechanism to do so on your federal return is exactly the kind of question that lands with your tax preparer — it depends on your whole picture, not just the CASDI line. For what it's worth, EDD's tax information page covers what the program itself says about how benefits and contributions are treated, and that's a reasonable starting point before you sit down with your preparer.

0 coins

Fair enough — I'll look at that page before my appointment so I at least know the right questions to ask.

0 coins

Coming at this from a slightly different angle: I'm still out on disability right now, waiting on an extension after my doctor said I need more time following a second procedure. The tax question for me is about benefits I've already received this year, not last year, and I want to make sure I'm tracking it right as we go. Is it generally true that whatever EDD pays out shows up somewhere I can reference at the end of the year?

0 coins

SDI Online and your payment history there is probably your cleanest running record of what's been paid and when. EDD's tax information page will tell you what documentation they provide at year end. For the extension piece, your doctor submits a form to EDD to continue your current claim — no new claim needed — and that keeps the same claim number running.

0 coins

Good to know the extension runs on the same claim. I was worried we'd need to start the whole thing over. I'll keep checking SDI Online for my payment history.

0 coins

That extension process caught me off guard on my own claim — my doctor's office didn't know they had to submit anything additional until I called and asked why payments stopped.

0 coins

For anyone still confused about the California side: EDD is pretty clear that SDI benefits are not subject to California income tax. That part isn't ambiguous. The federal portion is genuinely a 'it depends' situation that belongs with a tax professional who knows your full picture.

0 coins

Okay so I can at least stop worrying about the California state return side of it — that's a relief. The federal question I'll take to my preparer.

0 coins

Knowing the California answer is a hard no helps a lot, honestly. I'd been treating it as an open question on both sides.

0 coins

Yep, California side is settled. Federal is where you need an actual human who knows your taxes.

0 coins

My Notice of Computation came in and I had no idea how to read it — the weekly benefit amount it showed seemed lower than I calculated using the online tool, so I phoned EDD to ask which quarter they'd actually used. The hold times were brutal but I got through eventually using Claimyr (claimyr.com) on a Thursday. The agent went through which quarter of my base period they'd pulled wages from and read me the figure they had, and it matched the notice once she explained which months were included. Helped me understand what number I was actually working with for the year before handing anything to my accountant.

0 coins

The base period quarter thing especially — I had no idea which 12 months they were looking at until the agent walked through my specific claim.

0 coins

How did it end up affecting your taxes? Or was it mainly just about knowing the right number for your records?

0 coins

Mostly records — I wanted to make sure I was accounting for the right amount before sitting down with my accountant, not discover a discrepancy later.

0 coins

Can I ask a dumb question? The CASDI on my paystub and the CASDI on my W-2 — are those always the same number, or can they differ? I've never actually checked.

0 coins

Your paystub deductions across all your pay periods for the year should add up to what's in box 14 on the W-2 — if they don't match, that's a question for your payroll department, not EDD. The W-2 is what matters for your tax return.

0 coins

Never actually added up my paystubs before but now I want to — might do a spot check just to be sure they match.

0 coins

Payroll gave me a corrected W-2 once after exactly that kind of discrepancy. Worth checking early rather than after you've filed.

0 coins

The SDI deduction being funded entirely by workers is something I didn't fully register until I read it somewhere — no employer contribution to the state fund. So in terms of who paid for the benefit, it's your own wages the whole time.

0 coins

Yep, that CASDI line comes entirely from the employee side. The benefit is funded by what you put in over your working years, not a shared contribution.

0 coins

That framing actually makes it easier to think about from a tax standpoint — it came out of my wages before I ever saw it.

0 coins

I went through a whole confusing stretch where I thought my SDI claim and my PFL claim would be taxed the same way, and my preparer had to separate them out. Turns out they're different enough that lumping them together was a mistake. Just flagging it because if you're going from disability into bonding leave after a birth, they're separate claims with potentially separate tax treatment questions.

0 coins

Mine is just SDI, no PFL involved, but good to know for anyone who does both back to back.

0 coins

I did exactly that transition after my second kid and was completely confused about where one ended and the other began on my tax forms. Preparer had to walk me through it.

0 coins

The two being separate always gets people. Even the forms they use are different.

0 coins

Had a coworker who tried to tell me CASDI was deductible on Schedule A as a state income tax. That's the one I'd push back on — SDI is not a state income tax, it's a payroll deduction that funds the disability program. The deductibility question is a different analysis than the state income tax deduction. Your preparer will know the distinction.

0 coins

Right, it's not an income tax. The SDI program is funded by that separate payroll deduction, the CASDI line, and it's categorized differently. The Schedule A question is exactly the kind of thing where your preparer needs to look at your full return to tell you whether it applies.

0 coins

Glad I asked before just copying what my coworker said — different facts, different answer.

0 coins

Something that tripped me up: I was out for a few weeks that crossed two calendar years, and I wasn't sure whether to look for benefits in this year's tax documents or last year's. Ended up needing to check exactly when each payment was issued in SDI Online rather than going by when I was disabled.

0 coins

Payment issued date is what drives which tax year it falls in, not the dates you were disabled. SDI Online payment history shows the issued dates, which is what you'd hand your preparer.

0 coins

Pulling the issued dates from SDI Online was exactly what I ended up doing — once I had those it was straightforward.

0 coins

Crossing calendar years is a whole thing. I had two separate benefit amounts to account for because my claim ran from November through the following February.

0 coins

Which weeks were actually paid on my claim was something I had to untangle after I went back to work part time partway through. SDI Online wasn't making it obvious which weeks had a full benefit and which had been adjusted for my partial hours. Ended up calling EDD — used Claimyr (claimyr.com) and got to an agent — and she went through the payment record with me week by week, confirmed which were full payments and which weeks reflected my reported earnings. I needed that breakdown to give my accountant the right numbers.

0 coins

The partial week situation is specifically what made it complicated — when you're reporting wages, the payment for that week isn't the same as a full benefit week, and my accountant needed to know which was which.

0 coins

Hadn't even thought about partial weeks being tracked differently. I went back part time near the end of mine too and just assumed the total on the payment history was the total to give the accountant.

0 coins

Might be worth verifying the breakdown rather than just using the total — that's what the agent suggested I do.

0 coins

EDD's tax information page is worth bookmarking if you're in the middle of a claim year, not just at tax time. I check it whenever I have a question about how benefits are reported rather than waiting until I'm scrambling in April.

0 coins

Finding it before April when I actually have time to read it rather than when I'm already stressed is probably the smarter approach.

0 coins

I always look at this stuff last minute. Good reminder to get ahead of it.

0 coins

Does the CASDI deduction amount change year to year, or is it a fixed percentage? I noticed mine went up between last year and this year and wasn't sure if that's because I earned more, or if there's a rate change, or what.

0 coins

Your paystub shows the CASDI deduction line, and what shows up there is what your employer withheld based on your earnings. If you earned more this year, the amount withheld would be higher. The actual rate that applies to your wages is something to verify on EDD's site rather than taking anyone here's word for a specific number — EDD publishes that information and it's the accurate source.

0 coins

Earned more this year is probably the main driver then. I'll check EDD's site for the actual rate rather than trying to do the math from memory.

0 coins

DE 2525XX was the form my doctor's office needed to submit for my extension, and there was some back and forth about whether they had to file it on paper or if SDI Online had a way to do it. Spent some time figuring that out before I realized EDD sends that form along with the final payment notice — the Electronic Benefit Payment Notification — so the doctor's office should be getting it prompted from EDD's end. I ended up phoning EDD using Claimyr (claimyr.com) on a Friday afternoon, got to an agent, and she confirmed EDD had sent the DE 2525XX notification to my provider and read me the date it went out. That cleared up the confusion about whether my doctor's office was waiting on something from me or from EDD.

0 coins

It was specifically the question of who sends what to whom that I couldn't figure out from just reading the EDD website — having the agent confirm the date it went to the provider's side resolved it.

0 coins

The extension process caused me more stress than the original claim. Knowing EDD sends that form with the final payment notice is something I wish I'd known earlier.

0 coins

My doctor's office had no idea about the DE 2525XX when I needed an extension. Had to explain the whole thing to them.

0 coins

Can we also just acknowledge that the box 14 dropdown in tax software is confusing for everyone? I've filed with two different programs and neither one makes it obvious which category CASDI falls into, and if you pick the wrong one it might not affect your numbers but you're still left wondering if you did it right.

0 coins

Picked the wrong category my first year and my preparer had to amend it. Wasn't a huge dollar difference but it was the principle — just ask your preparer to confirm the box 14 label before you file.

0 coins

Amending because of a box 14 label is exactly the kind of unnecessary hassle I want to avoid. Flagging it for my preparer next week.

0 coins

My claim ran about seven weeks total and when I added up the payments in SDI Online, the total was less than seven weeks of my weekly benefit amount — took me a while to remember that the first week is the unpaid waiting period, so I was really only getting paid for six weeks. It's not a tax issue exactly, but it affects the number you're accounting for.

0 coins

Oh — I had forgotten about the waiting period being unpaid. So whatever your weekly benefit is, you'd multiply by one fewer week than you were actually out. Good catch.

0 coins

Right, the first seven days of the claim are non-payable — it's not a processing delay or a hold, it's just not a payable period by design. The first payable day is the eighth day of the disability. So if someone is out for seven weeks, they're receiving pay for six of them.

0 coins

I thought the waiting period was just how long EDD took to process things and that you'd eventually get paid for it. So that money is just gone?

0 coins

It's a non-payable period built into every new claim — not processing time, not a delay, just the first seven days EDD doesn't pay. It's not recovered later. Benefits start on day eight.

0 coins

Does your SDI benefit amount show up anywhere before the W-2 arrives, like can you get a year-end summary from EDD without waiting?

0 coins

SDI Online has your payment history and you can see issued payments there. For the official year-end documentation, EDD's tax information page explains what they provide and when. You don't necessarily have to wait passively — SDI Online is accessible year-round through myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/.

0 coins

Logging into myEDD to pull the payment history now rather than waiting sounds much smarter. I'll do that this week.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure