How to challenge SDI benefit amount based on old base period wages
So I finally got my Notice of Computation in the mail and the weekly amount on it looks way lower than I expected. I've been working at this company for about three years and my pay went up significantly in the last year, but it feels like EDD pulled wages from a much older period when I was making less. I had a major back injury that kept me out starting in September and I filed pretty quickly after that. Is there actually a way to dispute the weekly benefit amount if you think EDD used the wrong wages to calculate it? I don't even fully understand what 'base period' means or how they pick which quarter they use. I just know the number on that notice seems really off compared to what I've been earning lately.
78 comments

Skylar Neal
Money Network card showed up before I even figured out the payment situation on my claim, so I ended up phoning EDD about it using Claimyr (claimyr.com). Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my account and confirmed the card was issued to the address on file, which matched, so I knew the payment was actually out. As for your question, the base period is the 12-month stretch of four quarters ending about 5 to 18 months before your disability start date, so your most recent paychecks usually aren't in it.
0 coins
Vincent Bimbach
When you phoned, did the agent actually read you the specific quarters EDD had on file for your earnings, or just confirm the card?
0 coins
Skylar Neal
She told me which address the card shipped to and that the payment had been issued. For the base period quarters I would've had to ask separately, that's a different question.
0 coins
Kelsey Chin
been dialing that number since monday and it either rings forever or the line just drops me. three mornings in a row now.
0 coins
Norah Quay
The base period thing trips a lot of people up. EDD calculates your weekly benefit from wages in the highest-paid quarter of a 12-month base period that ends 5 to 18 months before your claim start. So if your injury was September, your most recent high-earning months may fall outside that window entirely. The Notice of Computation spells out your base period quarters and what wages each one shows.
0 coins
Brady Clean
AuthorSo the most recent year of my higher pay might just not count at all? That explains why the number looked so old. Does EDD ever use a different period if you ask them to?
0 coins
Norah Quay
There isn't an alternate base period for DI the way some other state programs have. If you think EDD recorded your wages wrong in those quarters, that's what you'd challenge. If the wages are right but just from before your raise, that's how the formula works and disputing it won't change the amount.
0 coins
Leo McDonald
The Notice of Computation lists each quarter's wages separately. Worth sitting down with it and comparing those figures to your actual pay stubs or W-2 from that period before deciding what to do.
0 coins
Vincent Bimbach
To actually challenge the benefit amount, the path is to appeal the Notice of Computation within 30 days of the date printed on it. The Appeal Form DE 1000A comes with a denial, but for a Notice of Computation dispute you'd write a detailed letter to the return address on the notice explaining which quarter's wages you believe are wrong and attaching your pay stubs or employer records for those quarters.
0 coins
Brady Clean
AuthorWait, so the appeal form DE 1000A is specifically for denials? For a wrong wage amount I'd just write my own letter instead?
0 coins
Vincent Bimbach
For a Notice of Computation dispute, yes, a detailed letter works. The DE 1000A is what comes stapled to a Notice of Determination when EDD says you're not eligible, that's a denial. A wage discrepancy appeal is still a written request, just not that specific form, sent to the address the notice shows.
0 coins
Norah Quay
The 30-day clock from the date on the notice is the critical part here. If that window closes you need to explain why the appeal is late, and an administrative law judge decides whether to accept it.
0 coins
Jessica Nolan
My pregnancy claim had the same kind of issue where the number felt low. What I did first was dig out all my pay stubs from that base period window and line them up quarter by quarter. The difference between what EDD had and what my stubs showed was pretty clear once I laid it all out side by side.
0 coins
Brady Clean
AuthorThat's what I'm going to try first too. If the quarterly wages EDD has match my stubs then I guess I'm stuck with the amount, but if they don't that's what I'd put in the letter.
0 coins
Angelina Farar
Pulling the stubs before you do anything else is the right move. No point writing an appeal until you know whether the wages EDD recorded actually differ from what you earned.
0 coins
Sebastián Stevens
You said the number 'looks' off. Before going down the appeal road, check your W-2 or old stubs against what the notice actually says for each quarter. Sometimes EDD has it right and it's just the base period math that stings.
0 coins
Brady Clean
AuthorYeah I haven't done that comparison yet, that's honestly my first step. I might be wrong about what I earned back then.
0 coins
Bethany Groves
Find out what's real before you fight anything. Appeals take time.
0 coins
KingKongZilla
Medical certification on my claim sat unmatched for two weeks and I couldn't get anyone on the phone, so I tried Claimyr. The agent found that my doctor had filed under a slightly different claim ID and told me which one was correct. For your wage question, the agent can at least read you which quarters and amounts EDD has on file, which tells you right away if there's a data problem.
0 coins
Rebecca Johnston
I want to know if the wages EDD has for my own base period match what my employer reported. Going to try Claimyr for that. What do you need to have ready when you get through?
0 coins
KingKongZilla
Have your Social Security number, the claim ID from SDI Online, and your pay stubs or W-2 for the quarters in question. That way if the agent reads you a number that's off, you can say so right there.
0 coins
Nathan Dell
two weeks waiting to find out about a certification, that's rough. i've been nervously refreshing SDI Online every day and i'm on day nine.
0 coins
Leo McDonald
To be clear about what an appeal on the benefit amount actually asks EDD to do: you're saying a specific quarter's wages were recorded wrong, not that you disagree with how the formula works. If EDD's quarterly figure matches your employer's records and your stubs, the formula gives the number on your notice and an appeal won't move it.
0 coins
Brady Clean
AuthorThat distinction makes sense. So my argument has to be that EDD has the wrong wage number for a quarter, not just that the amount feels low.
0 coins
Norah Quay
Exactly right. The percentage formula EDD uses is set by law. The only thing to dispute is whether the wage inputs are accurate.
0 coins
Maya Jackson
Yep. 'I make more now' isn't grounds for an appeal. Wrong data is.
0 coins
Nathan Dell
Does EDD ever just fix the wages without an appeal if you send them the right stubs? Like is there a way to correct it outside of the formal process?
0 coins
Leo McDonald
You can submit documentation through SDI Online using the Request Claim Update option, or through Ask EDD, but if you want EDD to actually recalculate and issue a revised Notice of Computation, the formal appeal within 30 days is what forces that review.
0 coins
Brady Clean
AuthorGood to know there might be an informal route first. I might try submitting stubs through SDI Online before writing a formal appeal letter, just to see.
0 coins
Vincent Bimbach
The 30-day appeal window runs regardless of whether you try the informal route first. Don't let the deadline pass while waiting to see if a document submission moves things.
0 coins
Kelsey Chin
EDD's phone line is a joke. I spent four mornings last week hitting that number and either got a busy tone or got cut off after ten minutes of hold music. For a wage dispute you really do need to know what numbers they have on file before writing anything, and that's impossible if you can't get a person.
0 coins
Sebastián Stevens
Same problem here when I had a question about my payment timing. The line just hung up on me twice.
0 coins
Kelsey Chin
and they don't tell you why it dropped or when to try again. you just start over.
0 coins
Angelina Farar
If EDD's line is that bad, the Request Claim Update inside SDI Online at least gets your question on record even if you don't hear back fast.
0 coins
Tristan Carpenter
The benefit calculator on EDD's site is actually pretty helpful for this! You can plug in quarterly wages yourself and see roughly what weekly amount comes out. Run your actual stubs through it and compare to your notice, that'll tell you pretty fast whether EDD's quarterly figures match yours.
0 coins
Brady Clean
AuthorI didn't know that calculator existed, that's really useful. I'll run my own numbers through it tonight.
0 coins
Norah Quay
The calculator gives an estimate; the Notice of Computation is the official figure. But yes, it's a quick way to see if something looks off before spending time on an appeal letter.
0 coins
Sebastián Stevens
Waiting period was the thing that confused me on my own claim and I ended up phoning EDD about it. Used Claimyr to get a live agent, and she confirmed the first seven days of my claim are just non-payable, that's not processing time and there's nothing to dispute. For the wage question, an agent can tell you exactly which quarters EDD has wages for.
0 coins
Jessica Nolan
The seven-day waiting period is the same thing that confused me on my pregnancy claim. I ended up getting through to an EDD agent about a Notice of Determination I'd received, and once they explained the determination I understood what I needed to do next. Getting an actual person on the line makes such a difference when you're trying to read these notices.
0 coins
Amaya Watson
yeah i thought the waiting period was just slow processing too. found out the hard way its just unpaid no matter what
0 coins
Grant Vikers
seven days just gone. that part stings but good to know its not something wrong with the claim.
0 coins
Bethany Groves
Thirty days from the date on the Notice of Computation. That's the window. Miss it and you're writing an explanation for why you were late, which an administrative law judge may or may not accept.
0 coins
Brady Clean
AuthorMine arrived about a week ago so I still have time, but I'm not going to sit on it. Going to do the stubs comparison this week.
0 coins
Giovanni Martello
is the 30 days from when it was mailed or when you got it
0 coins
Bethany Groves
From the date printed on the notice itself, not the postmark or when it arrived.
0 coins
Savannah Weiner
Quarter-by-quarter breakdown on mine looked fine until I noticed one employer's wages were missing entirely from the highest quarter. Phoned EDD using Claimyr and the agent confirmed which quarter of my base period EDD had pulled and what wage total they had for it. The employer's wages weren't in EDD's system yet. That was something I could actually document and dispute.
0 coins
Giovanni Martello
a missing employer's wages sounds like it could be a payroll reporting lag or something. i tried that disability line tuesday and wednesday and both times it rang maybe eight times and disconnected. starting to wonder if getting a person is even possible anymore.
0 coins
Savannah Weiner
The agent said the quarter they had on file was the one before my highest-earning one, which explained the low amount. I sent in pay stubs to document the actual wages for that quarter and filed my appeal letter.
0 coins
Levi Parker
An employer not reporting wages on time is actually a known issue. The stubs are what you'd attach to the appeal letter to show what that quarter should have shown.
0 coins
Rebecca Johnston
What happens if you file the appeal and EDD decides the wages were right all along? Do you get a new notice or does it just stay the same?
0 coins
Leo McDonald
An administrative law judge reviews the appeal and issues a written decision. If the wages are confirmed as correct, your benefit amount stays as is. If the judge finds in your favor, EDD recalculates and you'd get the difference for weeks already paid.
0 coins
Brady Clean
AuthorGood to know there's an actual decision that comes out of it either way. I was worried it would just disappear into EDD without any answer.
0 coins
Amaya Watson
my coworker had a wage dispute last year and said she just sent stubs through ask edd and they fixed it without a formal appeal. not sure if that works for everyone but maybe worth trying first
0 coins
Vincent Bimbach
That can happen but the 30-day appeal window doesn't pause while you wait to see if the informal route works. File the appeal and send the stubs at the same time so you don't lose the option.
0 coins
Amaya Watson
oh that makes sense, do both at once so you dont lose the deadline
0 coins
Libby Hassan
Appeal letter should include your claim ID, the specific quarter you're disputing, the wage amount EDD shows versus what your records show, and copies of the supporting pay stubs or W-2. Send it to the address on the notice, not EDD's general address.
0 coins
Brady Clean
AuthorThis is exactly the format I needed. Claim ID, quarter, their number vs my number, stubs attached. Clear.
0 coins
Norah Quay
Also keep a copy of everything you send. If the appeal goes to a hearing, you want your own record of what you submitted.
0 coins
Angelina Farar
The SDI Online Request Claim Update option is worth using even after you mail the appeal letter. It creates a written record inside your claim that you're disputing the wage amounts.
0 coins
Brady Clean
AuthorDoing both just to cover everything sounds smart. I'll mail the letter and also put something in SDI Online.
0 coins
Leo McDonald
Keeping a paper trail in both places is a reasonable approach, yes.
0 coins
Grant Vikers
does edd notify your employer when you appeal the benefit amount
0 coins
Leo McDonald
For a wage discrepancy appeal, EDD may contact your employer to verify what wages were reported. That's part of how they confirm what the correct figure should be.
0 coins
Grant Vikers
ok. not a problem for me just wanted to know
0 coins
Giovanni Martello
if the appeal takes a long time do you still get paid the original lower amount while it's being reviewed
0 coins
Leo McDonald
Yes, your existing weekly benefit amount continues while the appeal is pending. If the appeal is decided in your favor, any difference for weeks already paid would be issued afterward.
0 coins
Brady Clean
AuthorThat's a relief to know. I was worried payments would stop while I waited for a decision.
0 coins
Angelina Farar
Payments continuing during the appeal is the standard setup. The dispute is just over the amount, not over whether you're eligible.
0 coins
Maya Jackson
EDD's base period math is what it is. Unless they actually recorded your wages wrong, the formula isn't going to change because your situation feels unfair.
0 coins
Brady Clean
AuthorUnderstood. I'm going in with realistic expectations. If my stubs match what EDD has, I'll accept it. If they don't, I'll fight it.
0 coins
Bethany Groves
That's the right frame. Check the data first, then decide.
0 coins
Levi Parker
Compare your Notice of Computation to your pay stubs for each quarter listed. If a number doesn't match, that's your appeal. If it does match, the formula worked correctly and an appeal won't change the outcome.
0 coins
Brady Clean
AuthorThank you. I've been going back and forth about whether to appeal or not, but this makes it straightforward. Check the stubs first, appeal only if something actually differs.
0 coins
Tristan Carpenter
The comparison is so much easier once you have the notice and the stubs side by side. You'll know in about ten minutes whether there's something to dispute!
0 coins
Nathan Dell
not sure if this is a dumb question but can a newer employer's wages get missed if you switched jobs during the base period
0 coins
Savannah Weiner
Each employer reports wages separately to EDD. If you had two employers in the base period and one didn't report on time, that employer's wages could be missing from your quarterly total. Your stubs would show what should have been there.
0 coins
Norah Quay
That's actually a fairly common reason for a lower-than-expected benefit amount. It's also one of the clearer things to document with stubs or a pay record from that employer.
0 coins
Nathan Dell
ok so it could be a reporting lag not necessarily an edd error. still worth checking though
0 coins