How does SDI work with voluntary plan disability from another employer
Switching jobs has made this more complicated than I expected. My previous employer ran a voluntary plan disability program instead of paying into California's SDI, so when I had to file a claim after starting at my new place, I wasn't sure which pool I was drawing from or whether my old wages even counted toward anything. My new employer does pay into state SDI, but I'd only been there about two months before I had to stop working because of a back issue that's kept me off my feet. I filed through SDI Online and got my receipt number, my doctor submitted the medical certification, and EDD sent a Notice of Computation. The benefit amount was lower than I expected, and I think it's because the wage quarters they used only reflected my new job, not the full year before that including what I earned under the voluntary plan. Has anyone dealt with this transition between a voluntary plan at one employer and state SDI at another? I'm trying to understand how the base period would work in a situation like this, since a chunk of my income during those quarters wasn't subject to the CASDI deduction.
83 comments

Mohammed Khan
Part B came in from my provider on the 9th and SDI Online still showed pending on the 22nd, so I decided to actually get a person on the line. Claimyr (claimyr.com) is what finally got me talking to an EDD disability agent after days of that line cutting out at the half-hour mark. The video for anyone who wants to see how reaching a live person at EDD disability works: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the medical certification was matched and said there were no missing documents on my end, the claim just hadn't moved through yet. That alone was worth knowing instead of guessing for another week.
0 coins
Gavin King
Not sure I believe a live EDD agent is reachable these days, I've dialed that number at 8:01 and 8:03 on three different mornings and the line just ends the call after a while. What actually happened when you tried it?
0 coins
Mohammed Khan
The line rang and an EDD agent picked up, that's it. Not an automated menu at the end, an actual person who had my claim in front of them. I was skeptical it would be different from my own tries too.
0 coins
Nathan Kim
I had a similar situation where I needed to verify that my provider used the receipt number I had from when I filed. The agent I reached through Claimyr looked at the claim and read back exactly which receipt number was on the submitted certification, which matched mine, so I knew it was linked correctly.
0 coins
Gavin King
That receipt number thing is exactly what I'd want to check on my own claim, the doctor's office said they filed but I have no way to confirm the numbers matched. Might give this a try.
0 coins
Eleanor Foster
Wages earned under a voluntary plan at a previous employer are generally not subject to the CASDI deduction, so they wouldn't appear in the base period EDD calculates from for a state SDI claim. The base period draws from wages that had CASDI withheld. If your highest-earning quarters were mostly at the old employer under the voluntary plan, the Notice of Computation would reflect only the state-SDI-covered wages, which could explain the lower amount. EDD's disability benefits calculator on their site can help you map out which quarters would have been counted.
0 coins
Ella Russell
AuthorThat confirms what I suspected. The quarter where I was earning the most was entirely at the old employer, so of course it's not in there. Is there any process to appeal the benefit amount if the base period quarters are just limited like that, or is the Notice of Computation the final word on what the formula produced?
0 coins
Eleanor Foster
The Notice of Computation reflects the wages EDD has on record with CASDI contributions. If you think wages are missing that should have had CASDI withheld, that's worth asking EDD about directly, but wages from a voluntary plan period wouldn't be added in through an appeal because they weren't part of the state SDI system.
0 coins
Ella Russell
AuthorMakes sense. So the lower amount isn't an error, it's just a reflection of only having two months of CASDI wages in the base period. Frustrating but I understand it now.
0 coins
Lucas Turner
The voluntary plan thing catches a lot of people off guard because paystubs look similar either way, the deduction line might say something slightly different but most people don't notice until they go to file a state SDI claim and the wages aren't there.
0 coins
Kai Rivera
yeah i never even looked at what the deduction was called until i needed to file, just assumed it was all the same thing
0 coins
Lucas Turner
Same situation for most people honestly. The time it matters is when you switch employers and need to figure out why the base period is thin.
0 coins
Anna Stewart
Paystub literacy is not exactly something anyone teaches you.
0 coins
Nathan Kim
To add a practical note on the base period itself: EDD looks at a 12-month period made up of four quarters, and the benefit amount is based on the quarter with the highest wages in that window. If your highest quarter happened while you were covered by a voluntary plan, those wages simply aren't in EDD's records for the CASDI calculation. The Notice of Computation will show which quarter was used as the high quarter, and that can tell you a lot about why the amount landed where it did.
0 coins
Ella Russell
AuthorMy Notice of Computation did show a quarter, and it was indeed the two months at my new employer. The high quarter ended up being from wages that were only about eight weeks of work, which explains everything.
0 coins
Layla Sanders
Does the Notice of Computation always show which specific quarter they used? I'm about to file and I want to know what to look for on that form when it arrives.
0 coins
Nathan Kim
Yes, the DE 429D shows the base period quarters and the wages EDD has in each of them, along with the weekly and maximum benefit amounts that result. Read through it carefully when it arrives and compare those quarters to your own pay history.
0 coins
Layla Sanders
Thank you for naming the form number, I'll know what I'm looking at when it shows up in my mail.
0 coins
Morgan Washington
Waiting period burned me before I understood it. Filed my claim, saw nothing for the first week, assumed EDD had lost something. Called them, was told the first seven days just aren't payable, that's how it works on every new state SDI claim. No amount of calling changes that, it's just the design. Used Claimyr to get a person on the line that day, and the agent confirmed the claim was moving and that my waiting period had already run, the first payable day was day eight.
0 coins
Kaylee Cook
What is Claimyr exactly? I haven't heard of it.
0 coins
Morgan Washington
You hand off the hold time, and when an EDD agent picks up your phone rings. That's the whole thing.
0 coins
Kaylee Cook
That would actually help me, I have a question about whether my employer's leave calendar lines up with EDD's waiting period start date and I've been reluctant to sit on hold for hours.
0 coins
Oliver Alexander
The waiting period thing confused me too at first, I kept thinking something was wrong with my claim when really the first week is just not covered no matter what. Good to hear your claim was moving though.
0 coins
Lara Woods
Voluntary plans are run by the employer, not the state. When you leave that employer you leave their plan. If your new employer puts you into state SDI, you're starting fresh with CASDI contributions. That's just how the two systems sit side by side.
0 coins
Adrian Hughes
My foreman actually told me the two overlapped somehow and I believed him for a while. Turns out he had it wrong.
0 coins
Lara Woods
Lots of people think they carry coverage over. They don't. The plans don't talk to each other.
0 coins
Adrian Hughes
Found that out the hard way on my first claim. Would've been better to know upfront.
0 coins
Oliver Alexander
My client came to her appointment panicking because she thought her voluntary plan from her old salon job would cover her new claim at the shop she moved to. I didn't know enough to help her then, but reading through threads like this makes so much more sense now. The base period being tied to CASDI wages specifically is the piece she was missing.
0 coins
Molly Chambers
That's a really common gap in what people know when they switch jobs. The assumption is that disability coverage is portable.
0 coins
Oliver Alexander
Exactly. And both employers call it disability insurance so it sounds like the same thing.
0 coins
Layla Sanders
So if someone spends most of a year under a voluntary plan and then switches to an employer with state SDI right before getting hurt, is their claim going to show almost no wages in the base period? That sounds like it could mean benefits are really low or even that they don't qualify.
0 coins
Eleanor Foster
At least $300 in wages subject to SDI is needed to qualify for a DI claim. If only a couple of months of CASDI wages are in the base period, the benefit amount will be low, but the person could still be eligible as long as that floor is met.
0 coins
Layla Sanders
So technically you could qualify but the weekly amount is basically reflecting only those few months of wages. That's really sobering to think about.
0 coins
Nathan Kim
It is a hard situation, but the Notice of Computation will show the exact figures once EDD processes the claim. No way to know the amount until that form arrives.
0 coins
Ian Armstrong
My store switched from a voluntary plan to state SDI mid-year once and HR sent out a notice about it, but honestly most people threw it away. Nobody thinks about it until they actually need to file lol.
0 coins
Kai Rivera
yeah an hr email about payroll deductions is not what anyone opens first
0 coins
Ian Armstrong
Right, and then one day you need to file and suddenly that email would have been very useful.
0 coins
Eli Butler
Patients leaving one employer for another mid-year often assume coverage is seamless. Worth verifying with the new employer's HR whether payroll is deducting CASDI from day one, before you need to file. That gap in coverage is real.
0 coins
Ella Russell
AuthorMy new employer did have CASDI deducting from my first paycheck, so I wasn't missing anything on the new side. The gap was just that my prior wages weren't in the system at all.
0 coins
Eli Butler
Then the base period being thin is the whole story. The claim is correct, it just reflects limited CASDI wages.
0 coins
Eleanor Foster
Base period quarter calculation is what I needed to verify on my own claim after a similar job switch, so I actually got a person at EDD using Claimyr to walk through it. The agent told me which of the four quarters in my base period had wages on record and what the high quarter figure was. That matched what my Notice of Computation showed, so I at least knew the numbers weren't a data entry problem. For anyone unsure, the base period on most claims covers the 12 months ending about five to seventeen months before the claim start date.
0 coins
Adrian Hughes
I've used Claimyr on my own claim and was glad I did. The agent I reached confirmed my Notice of Computation reflected the right quarter. I hadn't been sure whether the quarter they used was the same one I thought was my highest, and the agent read back the wage figure in that quarter so I could compare it against my own records.
0 coins
Marcus Patterson
Did they tell you what to do if the quarter was wrong or if wages were missing from it, anyway?
0 coins
Adrian Hughes
Agent said to check whether those wages had CASDI withheld. If they should have and weren't showing up, that would be something to raise. Mine matched so that was the end of it.
0 coins
Lydia Bailey
been trying to get through to ask about my own base period for two weeks now, mornings and afternoons, nothing but that recorded message
0 coins
Molly Chambers
Filing the claim is the first step, but the moment the Notice of Computation arrives is when you actually see what the base period produced. For a job-switcher going from voluntary plan to state SDI, that notice is especially worth reading line by line.
0 coins
Ella Russell
AuthorMine arrived and I did read it carefully. The quarter shown was clearly my new job months only. It stings a little but at least I understand why now.
0 coins
Molly Chambers
Knowing the reason doesn't make the amount bigger, but it does mean you're not waiting around wondering if something went wrong.
0 coins
Mateo Warren
Does filing through SDI Online versus paper change anything about which wages EDD pulls for the base period? I always assumed the system just pulled from EDD's own wage records no matter how you filed.
0 coins
Nathan Kim
The base period wages come from EDD's own records regardless of how the claim is submitted. Filing online through myEDD or on paper with the DE 2501 doesn't change which quarters are used.
0 coins
Mateo Warren
That's what I figured but good to have it confirmed!
0 coins
Sofia Price
HR at my company gets this question a few times a year when someone moves over from a voluntary plan employer. The short answer we give is that CASDI wages are what count toward state SDI, full stop. Anything earned while the deduction was going somewhere else is off the table for the base period calculation.
0 coins
Kai Rivera
wish id heard that before i filed and was confused why my wages looked so low on the notice
0 coins
Sofia Price
The Notice of Computation is the moment most people find out. At that point you can at least map your pay history against it to confirm EDD's figures are right.
0 coins
Kai Rivera
yeah i ended up doing exactly that, counting backwards through my stubs
0 coins
Marcus Patterson
Two months into my own claim and I still get nervous every time I log into SDI Online, anyway. Had a voluntary plan at my old delivery company, switched to a warehouse job with CASDI and then hurt my shoulder three months in. Very similar situation, the notice came and the amount was lower than I hoped but it was correct based on only those three months of wages, anyway.
0 coins
Ella Russell
AuthorThree months of wages as the base is tough. Did you at least meet the minimum to qualify without trouble?
0 coins
Marcus Patterson
Yeah, the wages were above $300 in CASDI contributions so I was eligible, just not at a high weekly amount.
0 coins
Marcus Patterson
The waiting period also felt longer because every day off work in that first week I kept expecting a payment that wasn't coming, anyway.
0 coins
Oliver Alexander
That first week being nonpayable is really jarring when you're already stressed about income.
0 coins
Gavin King
If the voluntary plan from the old employer paid out during a disability period at that job, does that payout affect anything when you later file for state SDI at the new employer? I keep thinking there would be some coordination between them.
0 coins
Lara Woods
No coordination happens. The voluntary plan was a private employer plan, state SDI is a separate state program. What the old plan paid has nothing to do with the new state SDI claim.
0 coins
Gavin King
That's actually a relief. I was afraid EDD would somehow count that prior payout as wages or benefits already received.
0 coins
Eleanor Foster
EDD's calculation is based on CASDI wages in the base period, not on what a prior employer's private plan paid out. Those are unrelated figures.
0 coins
Lucas Turner
The thing that gets me is there's no clean handoff between the two systems. You'd think when you leave a voluntary plan employer and join a state SDI employer, there'd be some kind of record transfer so your wage history wasn't just wiped from EDD's perspective. But there isn't, and nobody tells you that at any point in the process.
0 coins
Anna Stewart
The two systems were never designed to talk to each other. That's just the reality.
0 coins
Lucas Turner
I know that's the reality. Doesn't mean it's a good one.
0 coins
Anna Stewart
No argument there.
0 coins
Kaylee Cook
Does your doctor have to do anything differently if you're filing state SDI after coming from a voluntary plan employer? Or is the medical certification process the same?
0 coins
Nathan Kim
The medical certification process through SDI Online is the same either way. The provider uses the receipt number from your filing to submit their part. What type of plan your prior employer had doesn't change how the certification is submitted.
0 coins
Kaylee Cook
Good, my provider already has the receipt number so I'll just make sure they submit through SDI Online before the 49-day deadline.
0 coins
Eli Butler
Remind them of that 49-day window. Some offices get busy and push it off, and missing it creates problems for the whole claim.
0 coins
Lydia Bailey
been dealing with a similar situation, old job had a voluntary plan, new job has state SDI, got hurt in my fourth month and the notice showed a pretty small benefit amount. reading this thread helped me understand it wasnt an error, it just is what it is with that short a contribution history.
0 coins
Molly Chambers
Fourth month in with an injury is rough, especially when the benefit amount reflects such a short window. At least the claim is moving.
0 coins
Lydia Bailey
yeah, it is moving. payments started last week so at least that part worked.
0 coins
Ian Armstrong
Can you go back and ask EDD to recalculate if you think wages are missing from your base period? Not voluntary plan wages, but wages that should have had CASDI deducted at the new employer and maybe weren't captured.
0 coins
Mohammed Khan
If CASDI wages aren't showing up and you have pay stubs showing the deduction, that would be worth raising with EDD. The Request Claim Update feature in SDI Online is one way to flag a question like that, or you can reach a person on the disability line.
0 coins
Ian Armstrong
Makes sense. The route I'd take is SDI Online first and then the phone if I needed a faster answer.
0 coins
Nathan Kim
For anything involving a discrepancy in the wage record, reaching an agent directly tends to be faster than waiting for a written response, in my experience.
0 coins
Layla Sanders
Is there any situation where EDD would reach out to the voluntary plan from the old employer to get wage information? Or does EDD only see what was reported through CASDI?
0 coins
Eleanor Foster
EDD's base period calculation draws from wages reported through CASDI. Wages paid under a voluntary plan were reported through that plan's own system, not through CASDI, so they wouldn't appear in EDD's records for a state SDI claim.
0 coins
Layla Sanders
So EDD doesn't have visibility into the voluntary plan wages at all. The two systems really are completely separate.
0 coins
Lara Woods
Completely separate. That's the whole point of a voluntary plan, the employer opted out of the state system entirely for that period.
0 coins