Back to California Disability

Elijah Jackson

Filed paid family leave before SDI pregnancy claim by mistake, can I fix it?

So I'm about 32 weeks along and my HR person told me to file through EDD when I get closer to my due date. I went into myEDD and honestly the two options looked really similar and I ended up filing a Paid Family Leave claim instead of a disability claim for my pregnancy. I didn't realize until I got some paperwork back that looked off and I googled what PFL actually is. Disability is what I need first, right? The PFL bonding part comes after the baby arrives? I'm worried I messed up my whole claim and my due date is about six weeks out. Can I cancel the PFL and start a disability claim or does EDD just fix it somehow? Has anyone done this?

Ending up with a PFL claim when you meant to file pregnancy disability is more common than you'd think. Yes, disability is what you want first. The SDI pregnancy disability claim covers you before and after the birth, typically about four weeks before your due date and then six or eight weeks after depending on your delivery. The PFL bonding claim is a separate thing that starts after your disability period ends. What you'll need to do is contact EDD and explain the mix-up so they can sort out which claim is which. Don't just leave the PFL claim sitting there and also file a new DI claim without talking to them first.

0 coins

Thank you, that's exactly what I was afraid of. So I do need to actually call them and not just file the DI claim on top of it?

0 coins

Yes, call or use Ask EDD to explain what happened. Filing a second claim without flagging the first one will just create confusion on their end.

0 coins

I'm in almost the same situation, 29 weeks and I think I picked the wrong option too. Not sure if mine went through yet though, it still says processing.

0 coins

My Notice of Computation came in and the weekly amount on it looked way lower than I expected, so I wanted to get someone on the phone at EDD to go over how they calculated it. Spent a few mornings trying that disability line and kept hitting the same wall. Tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) and actually ended up talking to a live agent. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my base period and walked me through which quarter they used and what the weekly figure came out to. Turned out my highest-earning quarter was from about 14 months back and it was lower than my recent pay, which is just how the base period lands. At least I understood it after that call.

0 coins

I've been hammering that line since last Tuesday, every morning before my kids wake up, and it just rings forever or kicks me out. Hard to believe anything actually gets through on that number. What happened when you tried it, did it just ring for you too at first?

0 coins

Yeah the line itself was the same mess, it's not like Claimyr magically changes EDD's hold situation. What it does is stay on that line for you so you're not the one sitting there, and your phone goes off when an agent picks up. That's the whole thing.

0 coins

Oh so you're not actually on hold yourself the whole time, it does the waiting and then reaches you. That's different from what I pictured. Might try it, I need to ask about why my claim start date is off by a week from what I put in.

0 coins

The waiting period piece confused me too when my notice came. Turns out the first seven days don't pay out, that's just how every new claim works.

0 coins

Wait, so the first week I'm out I get nothing? Is that a processing delay or is it always like that?

0 coins

The seven-day waiting period is not a delay in processing, it's built into every new DI claim by design. The first payable day is day eight of your disability. It's on EDD's site under how DI benefits work. So if someone tells you those days are just slow processing, that's not right, you won't get paid for them regardless of how fast everything else moves.

0 coins

Correct. The Notice of Computation will show your weekly amount but it's not an approval and it doesn't mean the waiting period is waived. Every claim has those seven unpaid days at the start.

0 coins

Nobody told me this when I filed. So I basically lose a full week of benefits no matter what?

0 coins

Yes, every new claim. PFL is different, it has no waiting period, but that's a separate program. For your pregnancy disability claim the first seven days are always non-payable.

0 coins

Okay so even after I get my DI claim sorted I should expect those first seven days to be unpaid. At least I know that now.

0 coins

EDD's whole system for sorting out claim mix-ups is a nightmare. Filed a question through Ask EDD about a PFL vs DI confusion two months before my kid arrived and got a canned response that didn't even address what I asked. Then tried calling. Spent four mornings hitting the same recording. Eventually got through on a Thursday afternoon when I just kept redialing.

0 coins

Thursday afternoon, good to know. Did they actually fix the claim on the spot or just tell you to refile?

0 coins

They flagged it internally and told me to file the DI claim and reference the PFL claim number. Took another two weeks but it got sorted.

0 coins

Ask EDD responses are useless half the time. I always just call.

0 coins

You cannot get paid by both PFL and DI for the same days. EDD won't let that happen, so if the PFL claim is sitting there and you file a DI claim on top without telling them, there will be a problem. Talk to EDD first and explain which one you actually needed.

0 coins

That's what I was worried about. So the overlap would cause an overpayment issue?

0 coins

Could. Better to get it straightened out before any money moves, not after.

0 coins

Agreed. The time to fix a claim mix-up is before payments start, not after you get an overpayment notice.

0 coins

my coworker did this exact thing last year and edd fixed it no problem. she just called and explained and they moved her over to the di claim. wasnt that bad from what she said

0 coins

Good to hear. That said calling EDD is never 'not that bad' in my experience.

0 coins

fair lol she did say it took her like a week to get through

0 coins

Worth clarifying one thing since it came up above: the PFL bonding claim after pregnancy disability is not automatic. After your DI period ends, you file a separate PFL claim if you want to use those bonding weeks. EDD doesn't roll one into the other on its own. I didn't know that until my DI payments stopped and I had to scramble.

0 coins

Yes, exactly right. Two separate claims, two separate filings. The DI claim covers the disability period before and after birth, then PFL starts after that if you file for it.

0 coins

So I'd file the PFL bonding claim myself after the disability period wraps up? EDD doesn't just continue payments?

0 coins

You file it yourself when you're ready to start bonding. The timing is up to you within the allowed window after birth.

0 coins

I didn't know any of this. I thought it was one continuous claim through the whole maternity leave.

0 coins

Weeks nine and ten of my DI claim both showed pending for longer than the ones before them, and I wanted to know if something had stopped or if it was just normal variation. Tried the EDD line a few times before I got through and ended up talking to an agent. Used Claimyr to get there. The agent told me those two weeks were still being processed and that nothing had been flagged on the claim, they just hadn't issued yet. Paid out a few days later.

0 coins

What's Claimyr?

0 coins

It sits on hold with EDD's disability line so you don't have to, and your phone rings when a live person answers. That's really the whole thing.

0 coins

Huh. Mine's sitting at a weird spot too. I'd want to ask about why the base period quarter they picked doesn't match what I expected from my wages.

0 coins

Pending weeks stretching out near the end of a claim freaked me out too. Mine turned out to be normal but I didn't know that until I finally got someone on the phone.

0 coins

Yeah the pending status alone doesn't tell you much. Getting an agent to actually look at the claim is the only way to know.

0 coins

For the original mix-up question: the medical certification is filed by your doctor or midwife after you submit your Part A through SDI Online. If your doctor submitted it tied to a PFL claim number instead of a DI claim number, that's a separate problem from just the claim type. When you talk to EDD, check whether your provider used the right claim. They need your receipt number from your DI filing to find it.

0 coins

I haven't even filed the DI claim yet, so my doctor doesn't have a receipt number for it. Would they have attached the certification to the PFL claim?

0 coins

If you haven't filed the DI claim yet then your doctor has nothing to attach it to on that side. File the DI claim first through SDI Online, get the receipt number, and give it to your provider before they submit the certification. Then sort the PFL issue with EDD separately.

0 coins

The receipt number matching the right claim is important. I've seen people's certifications get lost because the provider used the wrong claim number. Clear that up early.

0 coins

Your doctor or midwife can certify a pregnancy disability claim, including a licensed midwife or nurse-midwife. File your DI claim, give them the receipt number, and have them submit the medical certification for the right claim. Don't wait on that part.

0 coins

I've been seeing a nurse-midwife, so that's good to know she can do the certification herself.

0 coins

Yes, nurse-midwives and licensed midwives are on EDD's list for pregnancy and childbirth certifications.

0 coins

I've been seeing a physical therapist for a pregnancy-related issue, would that count?

0 coins

Physical therapists aren't on EDD's list of who can certify a DI claim. You'd need a physician, nurse practitioner, or one of the other providers EDD recognizes. Your OB or midwife would need to do it.

0 coins

My sister went through this same mix-up and her advice was to contact EDD as soon as possible and be very specific about what you filed and when. The sooner the better since you're only six weeks out!

0 coins

Yeah I'm going to try to reach them this week. Six weeks feels close now.

0 coins

You've got time if you move on it now. The claim can get sorted before your leave starts!

0 coins

To summarize the process cleanly: file your DI claim in SDI Online, save the receipt number, give it to your provider, have them submit the medical certification within 49 days of when your disability starts, then contact EDD about the PFL claim that was filed in error. Don't file the DI claim and walk away hoping the PFL issue resolves on its own.

0 coins

The 49-day window for the medical certification, does that clock start when my disability actually starts, not when I file the claim?

0 coins

Yes, the 49 days runs from when your disability begins, not from when you file. File as soon as you can so your provider has time to submit before that deadline.

0 coins

EDD also says to wait nine days after your disability starts before filing, but then file within those 49 days. So the window is not as wide as it looks if you wait too long at the start.

0 coins

the pfl vs sdi confusion thing catches a lot of people. their names are way too similar for a benefits system tbh

0 coins

EDD's whole interface is a mess. Two programs that look almost identical at the filing screen and they wonder why people pick the wrong one.

0 coins

genuinely cant believe nobody flagged this in like 20 years of the site existing

0 coins

The DE 2525XX, which is the form your doctor submits if you need more time off after your initial claim period ends, came up for me when my recovery took longer than expected. I'd filed a pregnancy disability claim, delivery went fine but the recovery stretched past what my provider first certified. Claimyr got me to an agent when I was trying to figure out why my extension hadn't been processed. The agent confirmed the DE 2525XX had been received and told me it was still pending review.

0 coins

Spent a few weeks trying to get an answer on a payment date for a week that had cleared on my end but EDD hadn't issued yet. Got to an agent through Claimyr too and they found the payment had issued two days prior and gave me the exact date. Ended up on the Money Network card right on schedule.

0 coins

How long had that payment actually been sitting there before the agent found it?

0 coins

Two days from when it issued to when I saw it. The agent said the payment had gone through on their end already, so it was just the card updating. Nothing was stuck.

0 coins

Good to know there's a way to get an actual answer when something seems off with timing. Extensions are going to be relevant to me if recovery takes longer than the standard weeks.

0 coins

Filing a DI claim is in SDI Online inside myEDD, right? Not a separate website? I keep second-guessing myself on where to even start.

0 coins

Yes, you log in at myEDD, open SDI Online from there, and file the claim. It's all under the same login. The address for myEDD is https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ if you need it.

0 coins

Thank you, I've been going in circles on EDD's main site trying to find the portal. That link helps.

0 coins

I filed through there and it was pretty clear once I was actually in SDI Online. The confusing part for me was the program selection at the start, which is how I ended up with PFL.

0 coins

Payments go to a card, right? I saw something about a Bank of America card somewhere but I'm not sure if that's still what they use.

0 coins

The card is Money Network now, not Bank of America. If you file through SDI Online you can also set up direct deposit instead, which I did for my own claim.

0 coins

Oh okay, I'd seen the Bank of America thing mentioned in an older post and wasn't sure if it was outdated.

0 coins

Outdated. Money Network has been EDD's card provider for a while. Set up direct deposit in SDI Online if you want it to go straight to your bank.

0 coins

Six weeks out and dealing with a wrong claim is stressful. Get on the EDD line and get it fixed. The longer you wait the closer you get to actually needing that disability payment to be in place.

0 coins

Yeah the urgency is real. I keep hoping I can just fix it online but sounds like I actually need to talk to someone.

0 coins

You do. Some things can't be patched through Ask EDD, and a claim mix-up between PFL and DI is one of them.

0 coins

My claim started about four weeks before my due date, which is what EDD says is typical. If you have a complication or your provider restricts you from work earlier, benefits can start before that four-week window.

0 coins

Mine could start early actually, I've been having some issues that my midwife is monitoring. She said she might restrict my hours in the next couple weeks.

0 coins

If she puts work restrictions in writing and certifies it, that could move your start date up. Definitely loop her in when you file the DI claim so she can certify the right start date.

0 coins

Yes, work restrictions or reduced hours certified by your provider can move the benefit start date earlier than the standard four weeks before birth.

0 coins

There's a wage requirement too that sometimes surprises people: you need at least $300 in SDI-taxable wages during your base period to be eligible. If you've been working consistently your wages are almost certainly above that, but it's worth knowing the threshold exists. The base period itself is a 12-month stretch from about five to seventeen months before your claim start date.

0 coins

I've been working full time for three years at this job so I think I'm fine, but I've never looked at whether SDI was actually being deducted from my check.

0 coins

Check your pay stub for CASDI, that's the deduction. If it's there, your wages are counting toward SDI eligibility.

0 coins

The CASDI deduction shows up clearly on most pay stubs. If you're seeing it taken out each pay period, your wages are in the base period and subject to SDI.

0 coins

Claim's sitting at week three for me and I still haven't heard anything about the medical certification being received. Getting nervous.

0 coins

After your provider submits, EDD typically contacts you about the status within about 14 days. If it's been longer than that, contact them through Ask EDD or by phone and ask whether the certification was received.

0 coins

My provider said they submitted it last week. So I may still be in that 14-day window.

0 coins

Then give it a few more days before you escalate. If nothing by end of next week, follow up.

0 coins

Overpayment notices after a PFL-DI mix-up are possible if money moves before the claim is corrected. Seen it happen. Fix the claim before any payments go out, not after.

0 coins

Has anyone here actually gotten an overpayment notice from this kind of mix-up? I want to understand how bad the worst case is.

0 coins

Yes. Had to appeal it. 30 days from the date on the notice to file, with the DE 1000A form. Annoying but fixable.

0 coins

An appeal on an overpayment follows the same process as any other EDD appeal. The notice will have the form and the return address. Don't miss that 30-day window.

0 coins

Okay I am calling first thing tomorrow. This thread has made it very clear I can't just leave the PFL claim sitting there.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure