Back to California Disability

Ava Thompson

Disability insurance tax in California — what does SDI actually show on your return?

So I've been on SDI for about six weeks now recovering from a back procedure and I just got my Notice of Computation in the mail. Everything looks right with the weekly amount but then someone in my family mentioned I'd have to pay taxes on the SDI payments and now I'm spiraling a little. I honestly never thought about this when I filed. Is California disability insurance tax something I should be setting money aside for? I'm already tight on cash being out of work and the idea of owing a chunk at tax time is making me really anxious. For what it's worth I had the CASDI deduction coming out of my paychecks every month so I figured the tax situation would be fine but I genuinely don't know. Has anyone dealt with this after their SDI claim wrapped up?

California itself doesn't tax your SDI payments at all, so you won't owe anything to the state. The federal side is where people get tripped up and honestly the answer there isn't the same for everyone. I'd point you to EDD's tax information page and if you want a real answer for your situation, a tax professional is the right call. The CASDI deduction you mentioned on your paychecks is what funded the benefit, so you're not alone in assuming it was all settled. It's not a simple yes or no federally.

0 coins

Thank you, that's actually a relief about the state side. So I might still have something to figure out federally depending on my situation?

0 coins

Yeah the federal piece really does depend on specifics. EDD's site has a tax info section that lays out what they can tell you, and from there a tax person can tell you what applies to your year.

0 coins

My claim wrapped up back in the spring after I was out for about ten weeks with a knee thing and I had the exact same question at the end. California definitely doesn't tax it, I confirmed that pretty quickly. For federal I ended up talking to a tax professional because my income situation that year was a bit unusual with some freelance work mixed in and I didn't want to guess. Worth doing rather than just hoping for the best at filing time.

0 coins

Good to know someone else went through this. Did you have to do anything on the EDD side, like request a form from them?

0 coins

EDD has tax information available through their site, so I'd start there. Beyond that it was really between me and the tax person. EDD itself doesn't tell you what your federal answer is.

0 coins

Same boat here, freelance plus SDI in the same year made things complicated. Definitely get a tax professional involved before you file.

0 coins

Notice of Determination landed in my mailbox about three weeks into my own claim, which I was not expecting at all. Phoned EDD at 1-800-480-3287 and couldn't get through for two days straight. Eventually I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) and ended up talking to an EDD agent directly. The agent looked up my claim and told me the determination was because a piece of my certification hadn't been matched yet, and that I had 30 days from the date on the notice to appeal if I disagreed. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. I filed the appeal with the DE 1000A form from the notice and have been waiting since.

0 coins

Wait, so you got a denial notice mid-claim? That's terrifying. Did the certification issue get sorted out before you appealed?

0 coins

The agent couldn't tell me how EDD would decide, just that the certification hadn't matched at that point. I sent in the appeal with a detailed explanation and attached everything I had from my doctor's office. Waiting on the administrative law judge now.

0 coins

30 days from the date on the notice, not the date you received it. That tripped me up once, I almost missed the window because I counted from when it arrived.

0 coins

I'm on week four of my claim right now for a respiratory thing and have been worried about the same tax question. The California piece being zero is reassuring. The federal part I keep reading conflicting stuff about online and I think the honest answer is nobody should be giving you a definitive federal number in a forum because it depends on your own situation, like the person above said.

0 coins

The conflicting stuff online is what got me anxious in the first place. I think I just need to actually sit down with someone who does taxes.

0 coins

Exactly. EDD's tax page is a good starting point to understand what they can tell you, and then a tax professional fills in the rest.

0 coins

Forums are honestly terrible for tax specifics. California no, federal depends — that's as far as a forum should go on this one.

0 coins

My sister told me SDI payments are totally tax free and I took that at face value for a whole year until I actually looked it up. California: she was right, completely untaxed. Federal: that's where her answer broke down because she didn't know about the federal angle. I ended up not owing anything that year but I would not have known that without checking properly instead of just taking her word for it.

0 coins

This is basically my situation except it's a family member who set off the panic. Good to hear the state side is settled.

0 coins

Yeah the state piece is not ambiguous, you're fine there. It's just the federal one that needs an actual professional to look at your income picture.

0 coins

The state one being zero is one of those things that surprises people who see the CASDI line on their paychecks and assume there must be taxes on the benefit too. Completely understandable mix-up.

0 coins

Waiting period question tripped me up early in my claim and it's similar to what you're dealing with — assumptions that turned out to be wrong. I assumed the seven days were just processing time and kept expecting a payment. Actually those first seven days are just unpaid, full stop, no matter how fast EDD processes things. My claim was for a hip thing and I lost a week of benefit because I didn't understand that going in.

0 coins

Good to know, I think I had the same misunderstanding about the waiting period. I thought the payments would cover all the days I was out.

0 coins

Every claim has that first seven days that simply don't get paid. The eighth day is when the payable period starts. I wish someone had told me before I filed.

0 coins

The waiting period being non-payable is one of the most common things people get wrong. It's not a delay, it's just the first week every new claim burns through with no payment.

0 coins

Paycheck CASDI deduction showing up every month for years and then not knowing what happens on the tax side of the benefit — I had the same disconnect. What finally made sense to me: California funded the SDI program through that deduction and doesn't turn around and tax the benefit on the state return. Federal is a different question that your tax situation determines. EDD's site has the info they can provide and a tax professional handles the rest.

0 coins

The CASDI deduction framing actually helps, thanks. I think I was confusing the deduction being taken pre-tax with the benefit being non-taxable, they're different things.

0 coins

They are different things and it's an easy mix-up. How the deduction is treated on your paycheck and how the benefit is treated when you receive it are two separate questions.

0 coins

SDI vs unemployment is another one people get wrong and it matters for taxes differently too. Had a coworker insist I should file for unemployment instead of disability when I was out earlier this year. Those are completely separate programs — you can't get both for the same days, and if you're still unable to work you're on disability not unemployment. Just flagging because I've heard that confusion come up in this kind of thread and the tax treatment question sometimes gets muddled with which program you're on.

0 coins

I hadn't even thought about confusing the two, I knew I was on SDI. But good point that the program matters for understanding what you're looking at tax-wise.

0 coins

Exactly, knowing which program you're on is step one. SDI disability and unemployment are both EDD programs but they're not interchangeable.

0 coins

The 'just file unemployment' advice from well-meaning people drives me crazy. Unemployment requires you to be ready and available to work. If your doctor has you out, you're on SDI.

0 coins

Receipt number was the thing that held up my claim for almost two weeks — my provider's office had filed the certification but used an older form and the receipt number wasn't matched in SDI Online. I tried phoning EDD myself a few times with no luck getting through. Used Claimyr to get a live agent on the phone and the agent told me exactly which receipt number my provider had submitted and that it didn't match what was on my claim. Took the right receipt number back to the office and they resubmitted the same day.

0 coins

Two weeks because of a receipt number mismatch — that's so frustrating. Glad it got resolved once you knew what was actually wrong.

0 coins

The maddening part was SDI Online just said pending and gave no indication what was wrong. Having an agent actually look at the claim and name the specific issue was the only way to know.

0 coins

Receipt number matching is so important and barely explained anywhere. Provider submits the certification, claim gets the certification — but only if the numbers connect.

0 coins

I'm going to push back gently on anyone who says the federal answer is zero across the board. I've seen that claim in other threads and it's not right as a universal rule. California is the confirmed zero. Federal genuinely depends on your situation and I'd hate for someone to skip talking to a tax professional based on blanket forum advice.

0 coins

This is helpful to hear — I'll make sure I actually look into the federal piece rather than assuming it's fine.

0 coins

EDD's tax information page and a tax professional are the two moves here. Not guessing, not forum threads.

0 coins

Agreed. The state answer is unambiguous and can be said clearly. The federal answer is not one-size-fits-all and shouldn't be stated as though it is.

0 coins

Doctor submitted my medical certification for my shoulder claim on a Monday and by that Friday SDI Online still showed nothing had changed. Called the office and they confirmed it went in. Waited another week and it finally showed up. Fourteen days or so seems to be about how long EDD takes to process things after both parts of the claim are in, but it's not guaranteed. The waiting is the worst part.

0 coins

Fourteen days feels long when you're waiting for income. Did your payments show up roughly two weeks after things went through?

0 coins

Pretty close to that timeline, yes. After EDD confirmed the certification was matched the first payment came within about two weeks total. The Notice of Computation came first and then the payment.

0 coins

Notice of Computation is not an approval, just want to flag that. It shows the potential weekly amount but EDD still determines eligibility separately.

0 coins

Payment date on my own claim was confusing me for about three weeks — SDI Online showed a payment issued but nothing had hit my account. Turned out it was a payment method thing, the card I expected wasn't the card being used. I phoned EDD to sort it out. Claimyr got me through to an agent and the agent pulled up my claim and told me exactly which date the payment had been issued and which account it had gone to, and I realized I'd set up the wrong direct deposit when I filed. Fixed it in SDI Online after that.

0 coins

Oh that's a nightmare scenario. Payment issued but nowhere to be found. Glad you got it sorted.

0 coins

Payment information is also on the automated line at 1-800-480-3287, which I didn't know until after. Would have saved me some time. But getting the agent confirmed the specific date and account which the automated line couldn't do.

0 coins

Direct deposit setup is something you can do through SDI Online when you file. If you don't set it up you get the Money Network card instead, which some people don't realize is now the default and not Bank of America anymore.

0 coins

PFL came up at the end of my disability claim and I want to make sure people know it's completely separate. I was out for pregnancy and after my disability period ended my doctor's office mentioned I could then file for PFL to bond with the baby. Different claim, different program, different filing. I mixed up whether the tax rules for SDI disability also applied to PFL and they may not be treated identically, so if that's your situation definitely look into it separately.

0 coins

I'm not in a pregnancy situation but good to know they're separate programs. I'll keep this in mind.

0 coins

They share the SDI umbrella but disability and PFL are filed separately and have their own rules. EDD's site explains both and the tax situation for each is worth checking independently.

0 coins

PFL also has no waiting period, which trips people up when they come off disability and move into PFL bonding — they expect another unpaid week and there isn't one.

0 coins

DE 2593 showed up in my mail at ten weeks on automatic payment and I nearly ignored it thinking it was junk. It's not. You have twenty days to send it back or you lose benefits. Mine came when I was still pretty out of it from surgery and I almost missed it. If you're on automatic payment watch for that form around the ten-week mark.

0 coins

Ten weeks and then you have to send something back — I'll remember that. I'm only at six weeks so I've got some time.

0 coins

Twenty days is not a lot of time if you're not watching for it. Set a reminder around the ten-week mark and check your mail carefully.

0 coins

Not everyone gets the DE 2593. If you're not on automatic payment you get a DE 2500A every two weeks instead to certify. Two different systems, same goal.

0 coins

Benefits I received being partially overlapping with weeks I'd been on unemployment years before made me paranoid about my SDI tax situation. Ended up spending an afternoon on EDD's site and then an hour with a tax professional. The professional confirmed the state answer, addressed the federal question for my specific income picture, and it took way less time than I'd spent worrying about it. That's the move: EDD's tax page first, then a professional for the federal piece.

0 coins

Spending an afternoon worrying and then an hour with someone who actually knows — I recognize myself in that. I'll book time with someone.

0 coins

The EDD tax information page is worth reading first so you go into the meeting with some context. You'll have better questions.

0 coins

Extension form is something I want to mention for anyone whose doctor says they need more time. When my final payment notice arrived it had information about the DE 2525XX, which is what your provider fills out to extend the claim. You don't file a new claim, your provider submits that form. I didn't know that existed until the final payment notice showed up.

0 coins

Good to file away. I'm hoping I don't need an extension but it's good to know the process before I'm in that position.

0 coins

The Electronic Benefit Payment Notification, the DE 2500E, is what comes with the final payment and has that info. Keep an eye out for it near the end of your claim period.

0 coins

Your doctor's office submits the DE 2525XX through SDI Online. You don't file a new claim, same claim number continues. Confirm with your provider that they know to do it.

0 coins

Workers' comp question came up when I first got hurt and I want to put this here for anyone who's on the fence. If your injury happened at work it's workers' comp, not SDI. EDD themselves say it's not common to get both at the same time, with some exceptions. For anything non-work-related SDI is the right program. I went to my employer's HR first and they pointed me to workers' comp because of where I was when it happened, and that was a whole separate process from SDI.

0 coins

Mine was a non-work procedure so I'm definitely in the right program. But good to know the difference.

0 coins

The difference matters because they're completely different claims processes. Workers' comp goes through your employer's carrier, SDI goes through EDD. Trying to file both for the same days gets complicated.

0 coins

And your employer's HR should be your first stop if there's any question about which program applies. They know their own workers' comp setup.

0 coins

About forty-nine days is the window you have for both you and your doctor to get your parts of the claim in, counting from the first day you couldn't work. I almost missed that because I waited until I felt better to even think about filing. Turned out I had just enough time left for my provider to get the certification in before the deadline. File as soon as you can after nine days — don't wait until you're recovered.

0 coins

I filed pretty quickly but I hadn't thought about the provider deadline being the same window. Good to know both have to be in by 49 days.

0 coins

Both the claimant's part and the medical certification have to be in within 49 days of the disability start date. Missing that window can mean disqualification. Your provider needs the receipt number from your filing to find the claim in SDI Online.

0 coins

Nine days is the earliest you can file, 49 days is the outer limit. That's a pretty narrow window if you're seriously out of it early in a disability. File from your phone in SDI Online as soon as you hit that nine-day mark.

0 coins

SDI Online is in myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ for anyone who needs to check their claim status or update payment info. You can also send EDD a message through the Request Claim Update feature inside SDI Online if you have a specific question about your claim and can't get through by phone. I've had mixed results with response time but it creates a paper trail.

0 coins

I've been checking SDI Online regularly but didn't know about the Request Claim Update message feature. That's useful.

0 coins

Pick your claim ID in SDI Online, then find Request Claim Update, choose the type and write your question. It's not instant but it's another option besides the phone.

0 coins

Ask EDD on EDD's site is another contact option. Different from SDI Online's internal message, but another way to get questions in writing if the phone isn't working out for you.

0 coins

My provider listed as a physical therapist on my claim and I had to go back and get my actual physician to submit the certification instead. EDD's list of who can certify a claim doesn't include physical therapists — it has to be a physician, chiropractor, podiatrist, optometrist, dentist, psychologist, nurse practitioner, physician assistant, or a licensed midwife or nurse-midwife for pregnancy-related claims. I lost about a week finding that out the hard way.

0 coins

I didn't know the provider list was that specific. Mine is my regular surgeon so I should be fine.

0 coins

Surgeon absolutely qualifies. The issue mostly comes up when someone sees a physical therapist regularly and assumes that person can certify. They can't under EDD's rules.

0 coins

Good info. Acupuncturist is another one that sometimes comes up — not on EDD's list either. Has to be one of the licensed provider types EDD recognizes.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure