Back to California Disability

Bethany Groves

Disability insurance San Diego — filing my first SDI claim from home

Tore something in my shoulder at the gym back in October and my orthopedic surgeon told me I'd be out of work for at least six weeks. I work at a hotel in the Gaslamp and there's no way I can do my job with one arm in a sling. Someone at my job mentioned SDI and I had no idea that even existed. Filed Part A through SDI Online about two weeks ago and my surgeon's office submitted the medical certification the same week. SDI Online still shows the claim as pending and I haven't gotten any letter or notice yet. I don't even know if I did everything right. The receipt number thing threw me off — do I need to do anything else or just wait? Also has anyone in San Diego had issues with how long it takes? Trying to figure out if I should be worried or if this is just how it goes.

Notice of Computation took about 11 days on mine after the medical certification went in. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) when my notice showed a weekly amount that looked way off compared to what I expected — I ended up talking to an EDD agent directly and she pulled up my base period and told me which quarter was used to calculate it. Turned out the system had used the right quarter, I just hadn't accounted for a gap in my hours. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ

0 coins

Ask the surgeon's office to confirm they used the exact receipt number from your SDI Online filing screen. That mismatch is the most common reason a claim sits pending longer than it should.

0 coins

Going to call the office in the morning and double-check the receipt number. I honestly didn't even think to give it to them, I just assumed they knew how to find the claim.

0 coins

My Notice of Computation came on day 13 and I was relieved it wasn't longer. Didn't know the receipt number thing was so important until I read this thread.

0 coins

Pending for two weeks after the certification is in is not unusual — EDD says most payments go out within two weeks of a completed claim, meaning both parts in. The notice comes before any money, so watch for that in your mail first.

0 coins

Makes me feel better. I kept refreshing SDI Online every day thinking something would change but nothing has moved.

0 coins

Refreshing doesn't help but I totally did the same thing my first claim. Felt like watching paint dry.

0 coins

Mail was actually how I found out my claim was moving forward — no alert in SDI Online, just a letter that showed up. Keep an eye on your mailbox too.

0 coins

The receipt number is the key piece a lot of people miss. When you filed on SDI Online, the system gave you a receipt number on the confirmation screen. Your surgeon's office needs that exact number to locate your claim and submit the medical certification on the provider side. If they filed without it or used a wrong one, EDD and the provider can't match the two parts of the claim and it just sits there. If you're not sure, go back into SDI Online through myEDD, find your claim, and there should be a way to see whether the certification was received. If it doesn't show, phone the surgeon's office and give them the number directly.

0 coins

Found the receipt number on the confirmation email. Going to send it to the office today.

0 coins

Phoned the office with mine and they said they had already submitted but with a different number. They resubmitted the same day and my claim updated within about a week.

0 coins

Saving the receipt number to my phone contacts now so I never lose it. Learned that lesson the hard way on my last claim.

0 coins

Waiting is the hardest part especially when bills don't stop. The first seven days of your claim don't pay out — that's just how SDI works, it's an unpaid waiting period before anything counts as payable. Day eight is when benefits can actually start. That part trips a lot of people up because they think the whole time they're pending is just processing, but those first seven days are genuinely not covered no matter what.

0 coins

I thought the waiting period meant EDD was just slow processing. Nobody explained to me it's literally seven days that never get paid. Wish I'd known before I spent two weeks confused.

0 coins

So my payable days start on day eight from when the disability began, not from when I filed? That changes my math on what I'm expecting.

0 coins

Exactly — from the first day you were unable to work, not from when you filed or when the certification came in. The filing date and the disability start date are two different things.

0 coins

Lots of people mix those dates up. Your disability start date is what you put on the claim as the first day you couldn't do your regular work. That's the date EDD uses to count the waiting period.

0 coins

Does anyone know if SDI pays the same as unemployment? My coworker told me they're basically the same thing. I'm kind of wondering if I should have filed for unemployment instead since I got let go last month.

0 coins

They're different programs. Unemployment requires you to be able to work and looking for a job every week you claim it. If you can't work because of your injury, you don't qualify for unemployment — that's exactly what SDI covers. You can't collect both for the same days. If you're still physically unable to work, SDI is the right one.

0 coins

Okay that makes more sense. So once my doctor clears me to go back I could file for unemployment if I still don't have a job?

0 coins

When you're able and available for work again, you can file for unemployment at that point, yes. EDD handles both but they're separate claims with separate rules.

0 coins

My sister tried to claim both at the same time and EDD caught it immediately. Don't do that.

0 coins

Two weeks pending after the cert is submitted is around the outer edge of the normal window but not alarming yet. If it tips past 14 days with no notice, I'd try contacting EDD directly — either through Ask EDD in myEDD, or by phoning 1-800-480-3287. At that point you want to confirm EDD actually received and matched both parts of the claim.

0 coins

Day 13 today and nothing yet. Going to try Ask EDD tomorrow if the notice doesn't come.

0 coins

Ask EDD got me a response in a few days on my pending question. Didn't have to call at all.

0 coins

Phone line is brutal with hold times but the Ask EDD form in myEDD moved faster for me than I expected.

0 coins

Weeks 11 and 12 of my claim showed as paid in SDI Online but I never got any deposit. Ended up getting through to an EDD agent using Claimyr and she went through which weeks had actually been paid out versus which were still processing — turns out two of them were on hold pending a form I hadn't sent back. Got that sorted the same afternoon.

0 coins

What form were they waiting on? Trying to understand if that could be my situation too.

0 coins

It was the DE 2593, a questionnaire EDD sends around the 10-week mark asking if you're still unable to work. I'd missed it in the mail. Had to get a new one and return it fast to avoid losing those weeks.

0 coins

The DE 2593 deadline is 20 days to return it. Miss that and payments stop. I had no idea it was coming until someone mentioned it.

0 coins

For anyone who gets close to the end of their approved period — my doctor told me at my last appointment I needed more time, and I panicked thinking I had to file all over again. You don't. Your doctor submits a supplementary certificate, the DE 2525XX, through SDI Online to extend the claim. EDD actually sends that form with the notice about your final payment so your doctor's office should get it, but remind them it's coming.

0 coins

Had no idea extensions worked that way. I assumed it was a whole new claim process. Good to know before I get there.

0 coins

Remind your doctor's office early. Mine almost missed the DE 2525XX because it went to a staff member who didn't know what it was.

0 coins

How far in advance should I be asking about an extension? My six weeks is almost up and I'm not sure I'll be fully cleared.

0 coins

Bring it up at your next appointment and ask the surgeon to submit it as soon as they know you need more time. They can do it through SDI Online on the provider side.

0 coins

My claim got denied once because my physical therapist submitted the medical certification instead of my actual doctor. I didn't even know that was a problem. EDD has a specific list of who is allowed to certify — physician, surgeon, nurse practitioner, physician assistant, and a few others. A PT is not on that list. I got a denial notice and had to appeal and get my doctor to refile.

0 coins

Physical therapists can't certify SDI claims, that's right. It has to be someone on EDD's approved list — your doctor, a nurse practitioner, a PA, or a few other licensed types. If the wrong person submits it, the cert gets rejected.

0 coins

Appeal went through once my actual doctor submitted the certification. It just added weeks of delay I didn't need.

0 coins

I didn't know that either. My chiropractor mentioned they might be able to do my cert — is that allowed?

0 coins

A chiropractor is on EDD's list, so yes, within the scope of their license. Just make sure they file on SDI Online with your receipt number.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation is not an approval, just want to put that out there because I confused them on my first claim. The notice shows what your weekly amount could be if you're found eligible. You still might get a denial notice separately if EDD decides you don't qualify. Getting the NoC in the mail felt like a yes to me but it's really just the math.

0 coins

Had the exact same confusion. Got the Notice of Computation and went back to work planning, then got a denial for unrelated reasons. The notice is not a green light.

0 coins

Nobody told me that. So I should wait until I actually see payments or a different letter before I assume I'm approved?

0 coins

Payments showing up, or no denial notice after the NoC — those are the signals. If EDD decides your claim isn't payable, you'd get a Notice of Determination with an appeal form inside. You'd have 30 days from the date on that notice to appeal.

0 coins

Automatic payments are nice until the DE 2593 arrives and you don't realize you have to respond. After 10 weeks on automatic, EDD mails that questionnaire and you've got 20 days to send it back. If you don't, the payments stop. I found out the hard way when my direct deposit just didn't come one week.

0 coins

Mark a calendar reminder for around week nine just in case. That form sneaks up on you.

0 coins

Mine arrived on a weird week where I'd been in and out of appointments. Almost missed the whole window.

0 coins

Direct deposit or card — either way the DE 2593 still has to come back. Payment method doesn't change that.

0 coins

For payments, you can set up direct deposit through SDI Online if you filed online — otherwise EDD sends a Money Network prepaid debit card. You can also check payment info on the automated line at 1-800-480-3287 any time, not just during business hours.

0 coins

Set up direct deposit when I filed but I wasn't sure it went through. Good to know I can check the automated line without waiting on hold.

0 coins

I still have an old Bank of America EDD card from a previous claim years ago. Am I going to get a new Money Network card?

0 coins

EDD's card is now through Money Network, not Bank of America. If your new claim issues to a card, it'll come as a Money Network card, not the old one.

0 coins

Is there any difference in how SDI handles claims in San Diego versus like, Los Angeles? I always wonder if location matters for disability insurance San Diego people versus the rest of the state.

0 coins

No difference in the rules — SDI is a statewide program and the same waiting period, benefit calculation and certification rules apply everywhere in California. Where you live doesn't change how your claim is processed.

0 coins

Good to know. I'd heard someone say local offices processed faster but I guess that's not really how it works.

0 coins

Local SDI offices exist and you can find one with EDD's Office Locator, but the actual claim review is handled statewide. You can walk in with questions but the processing isn't location-based.

0 coins

Came back to update: the DE 2525XX my surgeon submitted for my extension got processed and my claim just continued without a gap. What helped was I reminded his office about two weeks before my end date, and they found the form in EDD's notification about my final payment. I also used Claimyr to phone EDD and confirm the DE 2525XX had actually been received — the agent told me it was matched to my claim and the extension period was set. No new claim, no gap in payments.

0 coins

Planning to ask my surgeon at the follow-up next week whether he thinks I'll need an extension. Feels better knowing it's a form submission and not a whole new process.

0 coins

Two weeks out is a good time to bring it up. Gives the office time to file it before your end date.

0 coins

Glad your extension landed without a gap. That was my fear on my own claim — a week with no payment while everything caught up.

0 coins

Is SDI taxable? I've been trying to figure out if I need to report it somewhere. Someone at work told me it's completely tax-free but I don't know if that's right.

0 coins

California doesn't tax SDI benefits. The federal side depends on your situation — EDD has a tax information page and for anything specific I'd talk to a tax professional. I wouldn't rely on a coworker's answer for that one.

0 coins

Fair, I'll check EDD's site. I just don't want a surprise at tax time.

0 coins

EDD's tax page has the breakdown. It's worth reading before you assume anything either way.

0 coins

Filing window is easy to forget when you're dealing with an injury — you have up to 49 days from the first day you couldn't work to file and to get the medical certification in. Miss that and you can be disqualified. The other thing is you can file starting on day nine after your disability begins, not before.

0 coins

Wait so there's a window where you CAN'T file and also a window where you MUST file? That's a lot to track when you're already dealing with an injury.

0 coins

Day one through eight — don't file yet. Day nine — you can file. Day 50 and beyond — you're past the deadline. That's the window. Mark it when you get hurt.

0 coins

My nurse told me to file right away and I did it on day four. Got a rejection and had to refile. The nine-day rule is real.

0 coins

Pregnancy claims work a little differently from injury claims and I see people confuse them all the time. With pregnancy, you typically apply about four weeks before the due date, and you usually get six weeks after a natural birth or eight after a C-section. If there are complications before the birth — like a doctor putting you on reduced hours or restricted duty — benefits can start earlier. That's all still SDI, not Paid Family Leave. PFL for bonding with the baby comes after the SDI part ends.

0 coins

My coworker told me PFL and SDI are the same thing for maternity leave and I just went with it. They're separate claims?

0 coins

Completely separate. SDI covers the period when you physically can't work because of the pregnancy or recovery. PFL covers bonding after that. Two different claims, two different benefit periods.

0 coins

Went through both last year. Filed for SDI first, then PFL right after the SDI ended. The transition was smoother than I expected once I knew they were separate.

0 coins

If EDD denies your claim, the denial comes in a Notice of Determination. Inside it is an Appeal Form, the DE 1000A. You have 30 days from the date printed on the notice to appeal — not 30 days from when you got it in the mail, but from the date on the form. Send the appeal with a written explanation to the return address on the notice. If you've lost the form, a detailed letter works, but mention why you're appealing clearly.

0 coins

Hoping I don't need this but good to have it in my back pocket. How long does the appeal process usually take?

0 coins

How long an appeal takes isn't something I can answer accurately — EDD decides the timeline and it varies. What matters is getting the appeal in before that 30-day mark. Late appeals need an explanation for the delay, which a judge reviews.

0 coins

The 30-day clock from the date on the notice, not the postmark or when you open the mail — learned that the hard way. Date the notice, count from there.

0 coins

For anyone still confused about the weekly benefit amount: EDD looks at your wages from a base period — the 12 months ending about 5 to 18 months before your claim starts, split into four quarters. Your highest-earning quarter is what determines your rate. The estimate comes out on the Notice of Computation, and EDD's site has a calculator where you can plug in your wages and get a rough number before the notice arrives.

0 coins

Tried the calculator on EDD's site and the number was lower than I expected because I had some reduced hours last winter. Makes sense now that I see how the base period works.

0 coins

EDD's calculator matched my Notice of Computation almost exactly. Use it.

0 coins

Didn't know there was a calculator. That would have saved me a lot of guessing when I first filed.

0 coins

Went back to work part time before my SDI ended because my doctor cleared me for light duty at reduced hours. Reported it to EDD like I was supposed to. Got an overpayment notice a few weeks later. Still sorting that out — point is, report your hours when you go back to work part time, and understand that partial weeks may not pay out the way you expect. EDD decides how those weeks are calculated.

0 coins

Reporting is mandatory and the right move even if the math doesn't come out the way you hoped. If you get an overpayment notice you disagree with, you have 30 days from the date on the notice to appeal using the DE 1000A.

0 coins

Already have the notice. Pulling pay stubs and my claim forms together to put the appeal packet in. 30 days from the date on the notice — got it.

0 coins

Keep copies of everything you send, and note the date you mailed it. You want a paper trail if the appeal takes a while.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure