Back to California Disability

Amara Eze

Confused about the nituce of computation SDI sends — what does it actually mean?

Got a letter in the mail yesterday from EDD and I had to read it three times before I even figured out what it was. The Notice of Computation showed up maybe a week after I filed my disability claim through SDI Online — I'd had a pretty bad back injury that kept me from doing my warehouse job, so I finally filed after about nine days off. The letter lists a weekly amount and a maximum amount and I genuinely don't know what to do with that information. Does this mean my claim is approved? Am I about to get paid? I didn't see anything that said approved anywhere on it, just numbers. Also the weekly amount listed seems lower than what I expected based on what I was making. Is that normal or did something go wrong when they calculated it? My doctor already submitted the medical certification so I think that part is done. Just really confused about what this document is actually telling me and what happens next.

What does the letter say at the top — does it have a dollar amount for each week listed?

0 coins

Amara Eze

Author

Yeah it has a weekly benefit amount and then a maximum benefit amount. No approval language anywhere that I can see.

0 coins

That's the normal format for it. The numbers are what EDD calculated based on your earnings history, not a final approval stamp.

0 coins

Amara Eze

Author

Okay so it's basically telling me what I could get, not that I'm definitely getting it?

0 coins

I thought the same thing when mine arrived — I was absolutely convinced it was an approval notice and I texted my husband saying we were good to go. Took me another few days to realize the two things are completely separate. The Notice of Computation just shows the potential benefit calculation. Whether you're eligible or not is a whole different determination. Your claim can still be pending or even denied after you get it.

0 coins

Amara Eze

Author

That's actually a relief to hear I'm not the only one who was confused. So I should still be waiting for some other communication?

0 coins

Exactly. The computation notice comes pretty early. The actual decision on whether you get paid comes after EDD reviews everything — your part, the medical certification, all of it.

0 coins

Had the exact same confusion on my pregnancy claim. The letter showed up before I even had my doctor submit anything and I panicked thinking I missed a step.

0 coins

DE 2593 showed up in my mail about ten weeks into my claim and I had no idea what that form was asking or how quickly I needed to respond to it. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get someone on the phone at EDD disability and the agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the form had been received but not yet returned — she told me I had 20 days from when it was sent to get it back or benefits would stop. Got it in that same week. Video on reaching a live person at EDD's disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ

0 coins

20 days is not a lot of time if you're in the middle of recovery and not checking mail every day. Good to know that's the actual window.

0 coins

Right, I'd been out for a rotator cuff surgery and honestly wasn't on top of paperwork. That form catches people off guard.

0 coins

Is that form only for certain claims or does everyone get it after a certain point?

0 coins

The weekly amount on that notice feels low to everyone at first. I had the same reaction — I looked at it and thought there had to be a mistake. What EDD does is look at a specific 12-month window from your past wages, divided into four quarters, and they use the highest single quarter from that period to calculate your rate. So if your highest earning quarter was a while back, or if you had a slow period, the number might not reflect what you're making right now.

0 coins

Amara Eze

Author

My highest earning quarter was actually earlier this year. Is there any way to check what quarter they used?

0 coins

The Notice of Computation should have information about which base period they used. If something looks off you can contact EDD and ask them to walk through the calculation.

0 coins

Mine looked wrong too and it turned out they had the right quarter, my wages were just lower in that stretch than I remembered. The EDD site also has a calculator so you can estimate it yourself before calling.

0 coins

Wait I'm confused — does getting the Notice of Computation mean your doctor's certification already went through? I filed two weeks ago and my doctor's office says they submitted it but I haven't gotten any letter yet.

0 coins

Not necessarily connected that way. EDD typically contacts you about the claim status within about 14 days after the medical certification is received, but the computation notice can come around that same time or even before you hear anything else.

0 coins

So I might get the computation notice and still be waiting on whether the certification matched up? That seems like a lot of overlapping mail.

0 coins

EDD sends different pieces at different points in the process. Getting the computation notice doesn't confirm the medical certification is in — that's worth confirming separately if it's been a couple weeks.

0 coins

Something that tripped me up early on — I kept thinking the waiting period was just while EDD processed everything, like it was their internal delay. Nope. The first seven days of a new claim are genuinely non-payable. Day eight is the first day you can actually get paid for. It doesn't matter how fast or slow EDD moves, those seven days are just gone regardless.

0 coins

Amara Eze

Author

Oh wow I didn't know that. So even if everything goes perfectly, those first seven days just aren't covered?

0 coins

Correct. No processing trick or faster filing makes those days payable. That's the waiting period by design.

0 coins

I made the same mistake and kept expecting payment for week one. When I finally got my Notice of Computation and saw what weeks were payable it finally made sense.

0 coins

Can I ask a dumb question — does the maximum benefit amount on the notice mean that's all you get total for the whole claim, or is that the weekly cap?

0 coins

Total for the claim. The weekly benefit amount is what you'd get each week, and the maximum is the ceiling over the entire claim period. DI can pay out for up to 52 weeks, but your maximum on the notice might mean you hit that ceiling before 52 weeks depending on your weekly rate.

0 coins

Okay that makes a lot more sense. I was calculating weekly times 52 in my head and coming up with a different number.

0 coins

The calculator on EDD's site helps with this — you can plug in your wage info and see how the math works before the official notice even arrives.

0 coins

Had my claim stuck in pending for almost three weeks after the medical certification went in. I kept refreshing SDI Online hoping for an update. Eventually I did get the Notice of Computation and then not long after the first payment came through. For me it seemed like the notice showing up was a signal that things were moving.

0 coins

Amara Eze

Author

How long between the notice showing up and your first payment actually hitting?

0 coins

About five days after I saw the notice in my account. But I've seen people in these forums say it took longer for them, so I wouldn't treat my timeline as a guarantee.

0 coins

Five days sounds really fast actually. Mine has been sitting for two weeks since the notice and nothing yet.

0 coins

Is the Notice of Computation the same as the Notice of Determination? I keep seeing both terms and I can't figure out if they're the same document or two different ones.

0 coins

Two completely different documents. The computation notice shows your potential benefit calculation — the weekly and maximum amounts. A Notice of Determination is what you'd get if EDD decides your claim isn't payable. That one comes with an appeal form. If you got the computation notice and nothing else negative, that's a good sign — it means you haven't been denied.

0 coins

Oh that's a huge distinction. So a Notice of Determination is basically bad news and the computation notice is neutral?

0 coins

Pretty much. The computation notice is EDD doing the math. The determination notice is EDD making a decision against you. You really don't want to get one of those.

0 coins

Notice of Determination landed in my account a few weeks after I filed and I honestly didn't understand what it was saying about why my claim was being questioned. Used Claimyr to get through to a live EDD agent on my own claim, and she explained that there was a question about whether my start date matched what my employer reported. The agent told me the appeal form included with that notice was the DE 1000A and that I had 30 days from the date on the notice to get it in if I disagreed.

0 coins

Amara Eze

Author

That is stressful — did you end up appealing it?

0 coins

Filed the appeal with a detailed explanation of my situation. Still waiting on a decision but at least I understood what I was responding to.

0 coins

The 30-day window on those notices is not flexible so getting that information quickly really mattered here.

0 coins

My weekly amount on the computation notice ended up being lower than I estimated because I had switched jobs about eight months before my claim started and my previous job paid more. EDD used the base period that ended up capturing some of my lower-earning months at the new place. The highest quarter they found wasn't my best quarter — it was just the best one inside that specific window.

0 coins

Amara Eze

Author

That's exactly the kind of situation I might be in. I changed roles within my company earlier this year and my pay went up. If the base period captured mostly the lower-paid months I'd understand why the number looks small.

0 coins

Worth calling EDD if you think there's a discrepancy between what the notice shows and what your W-2s or pay stubs say. They can at least confirm which quarter they used.

0 coins

The base period question is one of the more confusing parts of SDI. The 5-to-18-month lookback window is not what most people expect — everyone assumes it's just your most recent earnings.

0 coins

Has anyone had the situation where the medical certification didn't get linked to the right claim? My doctor's office submitted it but I realized later they might have used the wrong receipt number. I'm worried EDD has a certification floating out there that doesn't match anything.

0 coins

That does happen. The receipt number you got when you filed your Part A is what your provider uses to find the claim in SDI Online and attach the certification to it. If they had a different or old number it might not have linked. Contact EDD or send a message through SDI Online to ask if the certification shows as received on your claim.

0 coins

I'll check SDI Online today and then reach out to the office to confirm which number they entered.

0 coins

Had a close call with this — my provider's office had entered a digit wrong and EDD showed no certification received for almost two weeks. Got it corrected and then things moved fast.

0 coins

Slight correction to something mentioned upthread — I've seen a few people in this forum say their doctor's physical therapist submitted the medical certification on their behalf. EDD's list of who can certify a DI claim doesn't include physical therapists. It needs to be a licensed physician, nurse practitioner, physician assistant, chiropractor, optometrist, podiatrist, dentist, psychologist, licensed midwife or similar. If a PT submitted it thinking they could certify the claim, EDD won't accept it and the claimant may not realize why their claim is stuck.

0 coins

I didn't know PT's weren't on the list. Good to know since my recovery does involve a physical therapist and I could see someone in my situation making that assumption.

0 coins

Exactly the kind of thing that slips through — the PT is seeing you regularly so it feels logical they'd certify it. But the claim needs someone from EDD's approved list.

0 coins

My chiropractor was on the list which surprised me — I assumed it needed to be an MD. Good to have the full list clarified.

0 coins

For anyone who's confused about payments after the Notice of Computation — EDD typically sends payments to a Money Network prepaid debit card unless you set up direct deposit in SDI Online. If you're expecting something to show up in your bank account and you didn't choose direct deposit, it's going on the card instead. I didn't set mine up right and spent three days wondering where my money was.

0 coins

Amara Eze

Author

I did set up direct deposit when I filed. When you say EDD typically sends to a Money Network card — is that a new thing? I keep seeing old posts mentioning Bank of America.

0 coins

The card is Money Network now, not Bank of America. If you set up direct deposit properly you should be fine.

0 coins

Glad I saw this — I hadn't set up direct deposit and was just assuming it would hit my bank.

0 coins

Got through the whole claims process for my second time around and the Notice of Computation arrived much faster than my first claim — I think because I had everything submitted cleanly from the start. Medical certification went in the same week I filed, and I saw the computation notice show up in SDI Online within about a week. Payment followed not long after. The lesson from my first mess was to give the provider the receipt number right at the appointment, before you even leave.

0 coins

Amara Eze

Author

I actually emailed my surgeon's office the receipt number the day I got it. Hoping that helped them match it correctly.

0 coins

That's exactly the right move. Providers don't always know to look for it and sometimes they just log a claim without matching it up properly.

0 coins

Receipt number from my SDI Online filing ended up being the key to a whole mess I had. Used Claimyr to reach EDD and ask why my claim was showing pending so long after the medical certification had already gone in. The agent confirmed the certification was on the claim but told me which weeks were still showing as pending versus which had been released for payment.

0 coins

Amara Eze

Author

Which weeks were pending — did she explain what was holding those specific weeks?

0 coins

She just told me the status of each week on the claim. Didn't go into EDD's internal process, just confirmed what was pending and what had moved. Knowing the specific weeks helped me figure out what to follow up on.

0 coins

Getting that week-by-week breakdown from an agent is genuinely useful — the SDI Online view doesn't always show that level of detail clearly.

0 coins

Bit confused about taxes on this money — does the amount on the Notice of Computation get taxed? I'm trying to figure out whether to set anything aside.

0 coins

California doesn't tax SDI benefits. Federal treatment is a different question that depends on your situation — EDD's tax information page has the details, and a tax professional is the right person to advise you on the federal side. No one here should be giving tax advice.

0 coins

Fair enough, I'll check EDD's site and ask my accountant during tax season.

0 coins

Don't treat the weekly amount on the notice as your take-home — the actual payment might vary slightly, so check each payment when it comes.

0 coins

Had a moment of complete confusion when I thought my SDI claim would just automatically roll into Paid Family Leave after I recovered. Completely wrong. PFL is a separate claim you file for bonding with a new baby or caring for a sick family member — it's not an extension of disability. If you're on disability for a pregnancy and want to bond afterward, you file a new PFL claim. The two programs are separate and have different rules.

0 coins

Pregnancy was my situation and yes — DI ends when you're medically recovered from the birth, then PFL is what you'd file for bonding time. EDD makes it sound connected but they really are two different claims.

0 coins

Does PFL have its own waiting period like DI does? I assumed they were the same.

0 coins

PFL doesn't have that seven-day non-payable stretch — that's one of the differences between the two programs. DI has a waiting period, PFL does not.

0 coins

Two weeks ago my payment was showing issued in SDI Online but nothing had arrived on my card and my account was showing the same balance as before. Used Claimyr and ended up talking to an EDD agent who confirmed the payment had been issued on a specific date and told me the payment method on file was still the debit card, not direct deposit. Turned out I hadn't actually completed the direct deposit setup correctly when I filed.

0 coins

The direct deposit setup in SDI Online has a confirmation step that's easy to skip — a lot of people think they set it up and then find out the card is still the payment method.

0 coins

Exactly what happened to me. Once I confirmed the card was the method, I knew to look for it there instead of my bank.

0 coins

Payment method issues cause so much confusion. The agent being able to confirm exactly what's on file saves a lot of guessing.

0 coins

Does the extension process start automatically after your last payment or do you have to do something? I'm looking at the end of my current approved period and wondering if I need to file something new.

0 coins

You don't file a new claim. When EDD sends the notice of your final payment, they also send a form called the DE 2525XX — that's the supplementary certificate your doctor completes to extend the claim. Your provider needs to submit that form. EDD sends it with that final payment notification so you and your doctor should both be watching for it.

0 coins

So the form goes to my doctor, not to me? Or do I receive it and hand it over?

0 coins

EDD sends the notification and the form info at the same time your final payment comes. Your provider is the one who submits the DE 2525XX to extend — make sure they know to expect it and submit it before your current period runs out.

0 coins

I had to contact my provider proactively because they weren't tracking my EDD end date. Definitely loop your doctor's office in early rather than waiting for them to notice the form came in.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure