Back to California Disability

Kevin Bell

Can you get SDI from two jobs including self employment in California?

So I work a regular W-2 job at a distribution center and I also do some freelance graphic design on the side, been doing that for about three years now. Hurt my back pretty badly last month and my doctor says I'm out for at least six weeks. Filed the claim through SDI Online no problem, got my receipt number, doctor submitted the certification already. But now I'm sitting here wondering about the self-employment income. I pay into SDI through my W-2 job obviously but I never opted into the SDI elective coverage thing for the freelance side. Does EDD look at both income streams when they calculate the weekly benefit or just the W-2 wages? And do I need to report the freelance work somewhere on the claim? Can you get SDI from two jobs including self employment or is it only the covered wages that count?

Notice of Computation came and I had the same question on mine, I work construction W-2 and had side cash jobs I reported as self-employment. Ended up calling EDD after three mornings of that line just hanging up on me, finally used Claimyr (claimyr.com) and got an agent on the phone. Video on reaching a live person at EDD's disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. Agent pulled up my claim and said the weekly amount on the Notice of Computation was calculated from the wages that had SDI withheld, which was only my W-2 earnings. The self-employment income I hadn't elected into wasn't in the base period calculation at all.

0 coins

When the agent looked at your Notice of Computation, did they tell you which quarter of your base period had the highest wages, or just give you the final weekly figure?

0 coins

They told me the specific quarter they used and what the wages were from that quarter. The weekly amount on the notice matched what they said.

0 coins

I've been dialing that number since Tuesday, four days straight, can't get past the first thirty seconds before it disconnects. Good to know there's another way.

0 coins

To be clear about how the benefit calculation works: EDD bases your weekly amount on wages that had SDI withheld during your base period. For most W-2 employees you'll see the CASDI line on your paystubs. Self-employment income is only counted if you enrolled in elective coverage and have been paying into SDI on that income. If you didn't elect that coverage, those earnings simply aren't part of the calculation. Your Notice of Computation will show you the potential weekly and maximum amount based solely on your covered wages.

0 coins

So the Notice of Computation isn't actually an approval, it's just showing what I might get based on covered wages? I want to make sure I'm reading that right because I keep thinking it means I'm approved.

0 coins

Exactly right, the notice shows the potential benefit amount but it doesn't confirm eligibility. The actual approval comes through when payments start or if EDD sends a Notice of Determination.

0 coins

I think I confused those two notices the whole first week. I kept waiting for some other letter that said 'approved' and there wasn't one, I think anyway.

0 coins

yeah only the w2 income counts if you didnt opt into elective coverage for the self employed side, my roommate had the exact same setup last year

0 coins

Makes sense, I figured as much but wanted to hear it from someone who'd been through it. The elective coverage thing I'd never even heard of before this.

0 coins

neither had he til he filed honestly, its one of those things nobody tells you about

0 coins

EDD's site spells this out under the DI FAQs: only wages subject to SDI deductions count toward your base period. Self-employed workers can opt into SDI elective coverage voluntarily, but if you haven't been paying into it, that income isn't included. Worth checking your paystubs from the last year or so to see exactly which quarters had CASDI withheld, since those are the ones that feed into your benefit amount.

0 coins

Paystubs are all from the distribution center job, every one has CASDI on it. Zero SDI ever came out of the freelance side, so I think the picture is pretty clear for my claim.

0 coins

Then your Notice of Computation should reflect just those W-2 quarters. Use the calculator on EDD's site if you want to estimate it before the notice arrives.

0 coins

Where exactly is that calculator? I'm on EDD's site and I can't find it quickly.

0 coins

It's on edd.ca.gov, search 'disability insurance calculator' and it comes up under the DI benefits section.

0 coins

My cousin asked me this same thing when she filed, she did hair at a salon W-2 and rented a chair on the side as self-employed. The SDI only pulled from her salon paychecks. She was a little bummed about it but at least she still got something while she was out.

0 coins

Chair rental income adds up though, that stings when it's not counted. Glad she still had the salon wages as a base.

0 coins

Right, it was enough to cover most of her bills, she said the waiting period week was the hardest part just waiting for it to kick in.

0 coins

Elective coverage requires you to apply before you're already hurt. Bit late now, but file for next time.

0 coins

Yeah that ship has sailed, I'm not going to try to enroll now. Lesson learned for when I'm back on my feet.

0 coins

Exactly. Keep the W-2 claim clean and move on.

0 coins

For reference on the base period math: EDD looks at a 12-month stretch of four quarters ending about 5 to 18 months before your disability start date, and they use whichever of those quarters had your highest covered wages. So if your freelance income isn't covered, it doesn't shift which quarter gets picked or inflate the quarterly total. Only the CASDI wages factor in.

0 coins

So even if I had a huge freelance month, that wouldn't bump up my weekly benefit at all if I never paid into SDI on it?

0 coins

Correct. Uncovered income is invisible to EDD's calculation. The benefit amount comes entirely from wages that had SDI deducted.

0 coins

I didn't realize it was that strict. I assumed EDD could see all your income somehow.

0 coins

Weeks-paid question came up on my claim and I couldn't tell from SDI Online which weeks had actually been paid versus still pending, so I used Claimyr and talked to an agent. She pulled up the claim and read off exactly which weeks had been issued and which were still in process. Really helped me stop second-guessing the portal.

0 coins

I want to ask EDD whether my partial-week earnings got reported right, lol, been going back and forth on that one. Going to try Claimyr for it. What should I have ready when I call?

0 coins

Have your claim ID and the specific pay period dates you're asking about. The agent went right to those weeks once I gave her the dates.

0 coins

four days trying that line. every time it just cuts off. maybe ill give that a try too.

0 coins

You also have to report any freelance work you do while you're out on SDI, even if that income isn't part of the benefit calculation. If you keep doing any graphic design jobs during your disability period, tell EDD. Don't just assume it doesn't matter because it's not covered income.

0 coins

Good point. I haven't touched any client work since the injury but I'll keep that in mind if someone sends a quick project my way.

0 coins

Even a small gig counts. Report it and let EDD sort out how the week gets paid. Better than an overpayment notice later.

0 coins

This is a really important one. An overpayment notice is a headache nobody wants at the end of a claim.

0 coins

wait so if you do have elective coverage as self employed, does that change anything about how you file? like do you file two separate claims?

0 coins

You still file one claim. If you have elective coverage, those self-employment wages get included in the base period calculation along with any W-2 wages. It's the same SDI Online process, one claim.

0 coins

oh that's simpler than I thought, thanks

0 coins

Makes sense, EDD isn't going to have you juggle two separate claims for the same disability.

0 coins

The waiting period threw me off at first too! Seven days at the start of a new claim that just don't get paid, it's not a processing delay, it's actually built into the program. After that your payments should start coming through.

0 coins

I thought the waiting period was just EDD being slow, so this is good to know. Day eight is when it actually starts counting?

0 coins

The first seven days are non-payable no matter what. The eighth day is the first day a payment can cover. It has nothing to do with how fast EDD processes anything.

0 coins

Exactly! Once I understood it wasn't just a delay I stopped panicking every time I refreshed SDI Online.

0 coins

What nobody says loud enough: if you have years of self-employment and never enrolled in elective coverage, all of that income is a zero when EDD runs the numbers. I found that out the hard way. W-2 side saved me but it was way less than I expected.

0 coins

That's a rough surprise to get mid-injury. At least the W-2 portion covered something.

0 coins

Barely. First check I thought there was a mistake, then I remembered exactly how much freelance I'd been doing without paying into SDI.

0 coins

Not sure if this is obvious but I'm asking anyway, does it matter how many hours you worked at the W-2 job? Like if someone was part-time, does SDI still cover them?

0 coins

Part-time W-2 wages still count as long as SDI was withheld from them and you earned at least $300 subject to SDI during the base period. Hours don't factor in directly, it's the wage amount that matters.

0 coins

Okay that's reassuring, I was nervous my part-time hours would disqualify me.

0 coins

The minimum is $300 in covered wages in the base period. If you've been paying into SDI from part-time paychecks, you likely meet it.

0 coins

Day 11 since I filed and I still don't have my Notice of Computation yet. Doctor submitted the certification by day 3. Is this a normal wait or should I be doing something?

0 coins

After EDD receives a completed claim, they typically contact you about the status within 14 days. Day 11 is still inside that window. If you hit two weeks and nothing has come through, try reaching out through the Request Claim Update option in SDI Online.

0 coins

Okay, two weeks feels like an eternity right now but I'll give it until then before I do anything.

0 coins

Fourteen days goes fast when you're anxious about it, hang in there.

0 coins

To bring it back to the original question here: California EDD SDI is specifically tied to wages that had CASDI withheld. Self-employment without elective coverage is simply outside the SDI system regardless of how much you earned. The only way self-employment income ever factors into DI is if the person voluntarily enrolled in elective coverage and was actually paying the SDI tax on those earnings.

0 coins

That's the clearest summary I've seen. Basically I'm filing on my W-2 wages only and the freelance side is irrelevant to this claim.

0 coins

Correct, and if you ever want to cover your freelance earnings in the future, you'd need to look into SDI elective coverage enrollment through EDD before any disability starts.

0 coins

DE 2525XX was sitting in my stack of EDD mail and I had no idea if my doctor had submitted the extension or not. Used Claimyr and reached an agent who confirmed the form hadn't come in yet from the provider's office. Told me exactly which weeks were still open and that EDD was waiting on that form before anything else could process.

0 coins

Extensions are exactly what I need to sort out right now, my situation is basically the same waiting on the provider. Used Claimyr once before when my claim dates were off and the agent walked me through what the base period quarter showed. Went right to the doctor's office after and got everything submitted the same week.

0 coins

That line is impossible on a good day, I tried six mornings in a row before giving up for a week.

0 coins

Agent was straightforward, told me which weeks were open and I called the provider's office right after to ask them to submit it.

0 coins

quick thing on the elective coverage, i looked into it once and you have to apply and start paying into it before anything happens, so if youre already out injured theres no enrolling mid-claim

0 coins

Right, elective coverage has to be in place before the disability begins. Can't apply for it after the fact.

0 coins

yeah exactly, found that out the same way most people do, too late

0 coins

my buddy thought he could just add the freelance income on the claim form to get a bigger benefit amount lol that doesnt work at all

0 coins

EDD's system only reads covered wages from the Employment Development Department's own records. Putting uncovered income on the form wouldn't add anything and could cause problems.

0 coins

yeah he figured that out pretty quick when the notice came back way lower than he expected

0 coins

For anyone with a true hybrid situation where both W-2 and elective coverage SDI wages exist, the base period calculation pulls from all covered wages combined across those four quarters. Same formula, same highest-quarter approach, just a bigger pool of covered earnings. But again, only if elective coverage was active and premiums were paid.

0 coins

The EDD calculator on their site can estimate it in either scenario if you plug in just the covered wage amounts.

0 coins

Good to know for the future. For this claim it's W-2 only but I'm seriously considering elective coverage once I'm back working.

0 coins

EDD isn't going to track down your freelance clients to verify income. If it's not in their wage records with CASDI withheld, it doesn't exist for SDI purposes. Simple as that.

0 coins

That's both the fair and the frustrating part of the system honestly.

0 coins

Yeah. Pay in, get out. Don't pay in, nothing to get out.

0 coins

Two jobs with SDI withheld from both W-2 positions would actually add up nicely since both sets of wages go into the base period. It's specifically the unelected self-employment side that gets left out. If you ever switch to full-time freelance, the elective coverage question becomes much more important.

0 coins

Makes me think about my setup differently going forward. If the freelance ever becomes the bigger income I'd want to make sure I'm actually covered.

0 coins

Exactly the right way to think about it. Plan before you need it.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure