Back to California Disability

Jake Sinclair

Can I request alternate base period for SDI paid family leave if my regular base period shows low wages?

So I've been going back and forth on this for days and I'm confusing myself more each time I look it up. I stopped working full time about 18 months ago to take care of a family situation, then picked up part-time hours again about 8 months back. Now I'm pregnant and trying to figure out if I'll even qualify for anything. The base period EDD normally looks at would include all those months I barely earned anything, so I'm worried my benefit amount would be really low or I wouldn't qualify at all. Someone mentioned there might be an alternate base period option that uses more recent wages instead. I've seen that term come up in a few places but I can't tell if it applies to SDI claims and bonding leave or just one of them or neither. Does anyone know if you can request alternate base period for SDI paid family leave, and how that even works? I don't want to file and then get a tiny Notice of Computation that barely covers anything.

The SDI program and Paid Family Leave are actually two separate claims, and that matters a lot for your question. For the pregnancy disability portion, EDD looks at a standard 12-month base period, and for PFL bonding after the birth, the same kind of base period applies. The alternate base period question is worth raising with EDD directly, because the answer can depend on exactly when your wages were earned and how they line up with the quarters EDD uses for each claim type.

0 coins

Wait, so the pregnancy part and the bonding part are completely separate filings? I had no idea they were handled differently. Does that mean I'd have two different base periods calculated?

0 coins

Exactly right, two separate claims and potentially two different computations. The disability portion covers your recovery, and then you'd file the PFL bonding claim separately after. Each gets its own Notice of Computation.

0 coins

That's actually helpful to know before I file. I was going to do it all at once somehow.

0 coins

The standard base period EDD uses covers the 12-month period of four calendar quarters ending about five to seventeen months before your claim starts. So if your part-time work was in the most recent several months, it might actually fall outside that window entirely, which is exactly the kind of situation where the alternate base period question becomes important to raise.

0 coins

Does EDD automatically check the alternate base period, or does the claimant have to specifically request it?

0 coins

From what I've read on EDD's site, EDD will use the alternate base period if the standard one doesn't meet the minimum earnings requirement. But if you have questions about your specific quarters, calling to ask how your wages lined up is probably the clearest path.

0 coins

I keep reading that too but then I second-guess whether it means EDD does it automatically or if you have to ask. Not sure if I'm reading it wrong.

0 coins

A Notice of Determination came for my own DI claim last month showing I didn't meet the base period earnings requirement, which sent me into a panic. Ended up reaching a live EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) after getting nowhere on the phone on my own. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my claim and told me the determination had already been issued and that I had 30 days from the date on the notice to appeal using the form included with it.

0 coins

Claimyr actually worked for my claim too, glad you mentioned it. Phoned in because I needed to find out what start date EDD had on record for my disability claim, since the date in SDI Online didn't match what my doctor's office submitted. The agent confirmed the exact date they had on file. Turned out the date mattered for which base period quarters they were looking at.

0 coins

When the agent confirmed the start date, did they say whether anything needed to be corrected or just that they'd noted it?

0 coins

They told me if the start date was wrong I'd need to appeal the determination once it was issued. So basically wait for the notice, then act on it within 30 days.

0 coins

30 days goes so fast when you're recovering and trying to manage everything else. Good to know to watch for that notice immediately.

0 coins

The EDD disability line is a wall. I've hit redial before 8am and still got the recorded message about high volume and ended up disconnecting. If your earnings question is complicated, you really need to talk to someone because online information only gets you so far.

0 coins

Same thing every morning. Line cuts off before you even get to hold.

0 coins

And it doesn't matter what day of the week. Friday, Monday, makes no difference.

0 coins

The SDI Online message feature through myEDD at least gives you something in writing back, even if it takes a few days. For a wages question that could save or sink a claim it might be worth using both.

0 coins

Base period confusion is common. The main thing to know is EDD looks at wages you paid SDI tax on, the CASDI deduction on your stub. If those months of part-time work had that deduction coming out, they count toward the requirement.

0 coins

My paystubs from the part-time job do show CASDI coming out, so at least I know those wages are in the system somewhere.

0 coins

Then those quarters are there for EDD to see. Whether they fall in the right window is the question, and that's what the base period calculation is about.

0 coins

my coworker had the same thing with low base period wages and edd used different quarters for her, she didnt have to do anything special it just came out that way on her notice of computation

0 coins

It's worth being careful reading that situation, because EDD using the alternate base period automatically depends on whether the standard one comes up short on the minimum earnings requirement. It's not a general option a claimant picks for a higher benefit amount.

0 coins

oh i didnt know there was a difference, thought it was just whichever period was better

0 coins

The alternate base period kicks in when the standard one doesn't meet the minimum, not to get a bigger check. The benefit amount is based on whichever period EDD uses, but you can't choose the more favorable one yourself.

0 coins

When I filed my disability claim for a wrist issue last year, the Notice of Computation showed up pretty quickly and honestly I was shocked at how the weekly amount was calculated. It reflected a quarter from way earlier than I expected. So the base period window isn't always obvious from just looking at your most recent pay.

0 coins

That's what worries me, I can't figure out from my own records which quarter EDD would actually use for me.

0 coins

EDD has a benefit calculator on their site that lets you plug in quarterly wages and get an estimate. I used it before I filed just to have a ballpark.

0 coins

I didn't know there was a calculator there. I'll go find it, that might settle some of my guessing.

0 coins

PFL and SDI are not the same program. If the question is specifically about the bonding leave wages calculation, the answer is the same general framework applies but they're still two separate benefit computations with their own notices.

0 coins

I think I had been treating them as basically one thing in my head, so this is a useful correction.

0 coins

A lot of people do. They're under the same SDI umbrella but filed separately and paid separately.

0 coins

Receipt number on my claim went missing somewhere between my filing and what the provider's office had on record, so nothing matched up and the claim just sat there. Used Claimyr to get an agent and they confirmed the number on the claim was different from what the office had entered. Gave me the correct number to bring back to the provider.

0 coins

Honestly that sounds like marketing to me, like why would a third-party service just get you through when nothing else does.

0 coins

Had the same exact thought when I first saw it mentioned somewhere! But then I tried it myself because my medical certification had been submitted twice by my provider's office and I genuinely could not get through any other way. The agent confirmed they had received the certification and which submission date was on file. After that I actually knew where things stood.

0 coins

Okay, that's more useful context. Might look it up for my own situation.

0 coins

Receipt number thing happened to me too, honestly anyway.

0 coins

Minimum wage requirement for SDI is at least $300 in SDI-covered wages in the base period. If your part-time months got you past that threshold and fall in the right quarters, you likely meet the floor. The benefit amount is a separate question from eligibility.

0 coins

So the $300 minimum is just to qualify at all, and then the actual weekly amount gets calculated on top of that?

0 coins

Right. Eligibility floor is one thing, benefit computation is another. Your Notice of Computation will show the weekly amount once the claim goes through.

0 coins

I didn't realize those were two different hurdles. I kept thinking if I qualified at all I'd get a full payment, not that the amount scales with the wages in that specific period.

0 coins

The timing of when you file also matters, like filing a few weeks earlier or later can shift which quarters fall into the base period window. Worth paying attention to if your wages were uneven across the year lol.

0 coins

That's a good practical point. EDD's standard base period goes back to the second to last completed quarter before the claim's start date, so the claim's start date anchors everything.

0 coins

Yeah and for pregnancy that can actually matter because there's some flexibility on when you start the disability portion if you have complications or work restrictions before the due date.

0 coins

My doctor mentioned I might need to stop earlier than four weeks out depending on how things go, so the start date might not be entirely up to me.

0 coins

Payment date on my claim was showing as issued in SDI Online but nothing had arrived on my Money Network card after several days. Called EDD and reached an agent through Claimyr to ask about it. The agent looked up my claim and told me the payment had been issued on the date SDI Online showed, and that if I still hadn't received it after a few more business days I could contact Money Network directly about the card.

0 coins

What did the agent say about how to reach Money Network, was there a specific number or did they just say to contact them?

0 coins

They said to contact Money Network directly and that the number is on the back of the card. Didn't give me more detail than that.

0 coins

been trying to get through on that disability line for three weeks straight now. mornings, afternoons, same result.

0 coins

Worth noting that the alternate base period still uses the same general formula for calculating the weekly benefit amount. It's not a different calculation method, just a different set of quarters to draw from. So even with the alternate period, your benefit would be 70 to 90 percent of your highest-paid quarter wages in that set.

0 coins

That percentage range is based on income level, right? Higher earners get the lower percentage and lower earners get closer to 90?

0 coins

Exactly. EDD's calculator on their site will show you the estimate based on your numbers. The Notice of Computation is the official figure, but the calculator gives you a reasonable idea before you file.

0 coins

If you use SDI Online through myEDD (https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/) you can send a message directly on your claim once it's filed, through Request Claim Update. For a question about which quarters EDD is using for your base period, that's a reasonable thing to send in writing so you have a record of the response.

0 coins

Can I send a message before I file, or only after the claim is in the system?

0 coins

Only after the claim is filed and you have a claim ID. Before filing, the EDD general contact form, Ask EDD, is an option.

0 coins

Ask EDD takes a few days but the response is in writing which is helpful when you need to reference it later.

0 coins

Filing date, work stop date, those two things trip people up. The disability start date is when you stopped being able to work, and you don't file until at least nine days after that. Getting those mixed up causes problems.

0 coins

I almost filed the same day I stopped working and my doctor told me to wait. Glad I looked it up first.

0 coins

Nine days minimum before filing, 49 days max from when the disability started. Miss either of those and there are problems.

0 coins

My claim has been sitting pending for two weeks and I'm not sure if that's normal or if something is missing.

0 coins

After both the claimant's part and the medical certification are in, most payments come within two weeks. Worth checking whether your provider actually submitted the certification and whether the receipt number they used matched yours.

0 coins

The office said they sent it but I never confirmed the receipt number matched. I'll check that.

0 coins

That's the most common reason for a hang-up. Offices sometimes have an old number or the wrong one.

0 coins

For pregnancy specifically, EDD typically counts four weeks before the due date as the start of when disability benefits can begin. But if your provider documents earlier complications or restrictions, benefits can start sooner than that.

0 coins

My OB has already mentioned she might put work restrictions in my chart, so I might be able to start earlier than four weeks before my due date if that happens.

0 coins

Get that documentation in writing from her and make sure she submits the medical certification reflecting those restrictions. That's what EDD needs to see.

0 coins

The medical certification really is everything in terms of what EDD has to go on. The more specific the provider is about the restrictions, the better.

0 coins

the edd phone line just runs me around and hangs up. been dealing with a pending claim for over a week and cant get anyone.

0 coins

That line does that constantly. No time of day seems to reliably work better.

0 coins

tried right at 8am twice this week. same thing.

0 coins

My provider's office submitted my certification but they did it on paper instead of through SDI Online. Took almost three extra weeks before EDD matched it to my claim, anyway.

0 coins

Paper submissions take longer for EDD to process and match to a claim than electronic ones. If possible, most providers can submit through SDI Online and it goes much faster.

0 coins

Wish I'd known that before they mailed it. Might ask them to do it online for any extension if I end up needing one.

0 coins

my doctor did it online and it matched up in like a few days, definitely push them to do it that way

0 coins

The bonding PFL claim is a whole separate filing after the disability portion wraps up. EDD sends a notice with your last disability payment that includes information about filing for PFL, so keep an eye out for that so you don't miss the transition.

0 coins

The notice comes with the last disability payment? So I don't have to track it separately, it'll just show up?

0 coins

That's been my understanding, yes. The Electronic Benefit Payment Notification, the DE 2500E, comes with the final payment info. It points you toward the extension and next steps.

0 coins

The DE 2500E is also when your provider can submit the extension form if more recovery time is needed before you're ready to transition to PFL. Worth mentioning to your provider in advance so they know to watch for it.

0 coins

appeals deadline is the one that burns people. 30 days from the date on the notice, not the date you receive it, not when you read it. that date on the paper is what counts.

0 coins

I assumed it was from when the letter arrived. That's a meaningful difference if it takes several days to get there.

0 coins

file as early as possible once you have the notice. sitting on it costs days you need.

0 coins

The Appeal Form, DE 1000A, comes with the Notice of Determination. If you've misplaced it, EDD's site has the form available.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure