Pharmacy not billing Medi-Cal secondary claims correctly for dual insured child
My daughter has both her dad's work insurance and Medi-Cal, and we've been running into a wall at the pharmacy every single time we go to pick up her prescriptions. The pharmacist keeps telling me the claim is rejecting when they try to bill Medi-Cal after the primary insurance pays its portion. The first insurance covers maybe 60-70% and there's usually still a balance, but instead of Medi-Cal picking up the rest, the system keeps kicking it back. We set this up months ago and I even reported the other health coverage to the county when she was approved. I have her Benefits Identification Card and she's on a managed care plan. Her pediatrician has no issue — it's only the pharmacy where everything falls apart. The pharmacist at our regular location said they've tried resubmitting twice and it keeps rejecting. One person at the counter told me maybe Medi-Cal doesn't work as secondary for kids. That doesn't sound right to me at all. Has anyone dealt with this? I don't know if I need to call the county, the health plan, or Medi-Cal Rx directly.
68 comments

Beatrice Marshall
Four weeks after I submitted my son's application in BenefitsCal, the pending status hadn't moved and I couldn't get through to anyone at the county. I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through the hold, and ended up talking to a county worker who pulled up the case and told me the application had been received on the date I submitted it and that a Notice of Action would come by mail. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at Medi-Cal: https://youtu.be/NXjJFZObk3g On your actual question — yes, Medi-Cal absolutely works as secondary for a child who has another insurance plan. The private insurance gets billed first, and Medi-Cal is supposed to cover what's left. The issue is usually on the pharmacy's end with how they're entering the BIC information or the other coverage details. Tell them to contact Medi-Cal Rx at 1-800-977-2273 — that's the right number for prescription issues specifically, not the general Medi-Cal line.
0 coins
Melina Haruko
Does the Medi-Cal Rx number work for the managed care plan side too, or only Fee-for-Service? My daughter's plan is through a managed care plan and I'm not sure who actually handles the pharmacy claims.
0 coins
Beatrice Marshall
Managed care plans handle their own pharmacy benefits, so if she's in a managed care plan the right call is the plan's member services line, not Medi-Cal Rx. Medi-Cal Rx is for people on Fee-for-Service. Worth figuring out which category your daughter falls under first.
0 coins
Dallas Villalobos
Billing secondary after primary is something our pharmacy messed up for almost three months before they figured it out. The fix ended up being that they had to enter the other coverage as the primary payer in a specific way in their system. Once they got it right it processed fine. The county had already listed the other insurance on our case because I reported it at renewal.
0 coins
Reina Salazar
The person at the counter who said Medi-Cal doesn't work secondary for kids got that completely wrong. Kids with two coverages happen all the time — one parent has employer insurance, the other has Medi-Cal for the child, and Medi-Cal is designed to coordinate with the first payer. The county requires you to report other health coverage when you apply or whenever a child gets it, and once it's on the case Medi-Cal knows it's secondary. The pharmacy's claim rejection is almost always a data entry issue. They need the BIC number, the plan ID from the managed care plan if she's in one, and the primary insurance's EOB or at minimum the primary payer ID. Some pharmacy systems also need the other coverage entered with a specific coordination-of-benefits code. This is the pharmacy's billing department's problem to fix, not yours.
0 coins
Mae Bennett
AuthorAre the rejections something the pharmacy can see the reason for, like a code they can look up, or do they have to call someone to find out why it's bouncing?
0 coins
Reina Salazar
Pharmacy systems show rejection codes, yes. The pharmacist can read exactly what the rejection says — something like 'other coverage primary' or a coordination code error. If they tell you they don't know why, they're not looking hard enough. Ask them to read you the rejection code and then call Medi-Cal Rx or the plan's pharmacy line to get it fixed.
0 coins
Saanvi Krishnaswami
Had a pharmacist tell me the same thing once, that there was a rejection but they couldn't explain it. I went to a different location of the same chain and that pharmacist fixed it in about ten minutes once she actually called the number on the back of the BIC. Some locations are just more experienced with dual-coverage billing than others.
0 coins
Demi Lagos
Might be worth double-checking that the other health coverage is actually showing on the Medi-Cal side. I had a gap once where I reported it in BenefitsCal but the county took a few weeks to get it updated on the case, and during that window the pharmacy couldn't process anything correctly because the records didn't match up. If your daughter's coverage was recently added or changed, that could be the lag.
0 coins
Mae Bennett
AuthorShe's had both since she was approved about eight months ago and I reported the work insurance at the time. So it should be there, but I honestly don't know how to verify that it's showing on the county's end.
0 coins
Demi Lagos
Calling the county directly would let you ask a worker whether the other health coverage is listed on the case. That's the most direct way to confirm. BenefitsCal doesn't show you exactly what's on the case, only what you've reported.
0 coins
Mason Lopez
The county can confirm what coverage is on file for the child. If the work insurance isn't showing or is listed wrong, the worker can tell you what to resubmit. I had to send in the insurance card and a letter from the employer once to get it corrected.
0 coins
Vera Visnjic
Pharmacies sometimes enter the BIC number wrong or forget to enter the managed care plan ID at all. My son's prescriptions were rejecting for weeks and when I finally sat down with the pharmacist we found out they had an old BIC number in their system from before he switched plans. Once they updated it everything went through. The BIC has the member ID on it — make sure the pharmacy is using the current card, not one they scanned months ago.
0 coins
Mae Bennett
AuthorI brought the actual card in last time and watched them scan it, so I think the number itself is right. But I didn't think about the plan ID — she did switch managed care plans earlier this year.
0 coins
Vera Visnjic
A plan switch would explain a lot. The pharmacy system might still have the old plan's billing info saved. They'd need to delete the old entry and put in the new plan's information from scratch. Definitely worth flagging that to the pharmacist specifically.
0 coins
Jake Sinclair
Plan switches tripped us up too. The new managed care plan sent a new member card but the pharmacy just added it on top of the old file without removing the previous one. It caused claim conflicts for about a month.
0 coins
Brielle Johnson
The renewal envelope sat unopened for about two weeks because I thought it was junk mail, and by the time I found it the due date had almost passed. I let Claimyr hold for me on the county line and talked to a worker who checked the renewal form's due date and confirmed the form hadn't been received yet — so I had time. Got it in through BenefitsCal the same afternoon. For the pharmacy billing issue — if the managed care plan is involved, the plan's own pharmacy benefit is what the pharmacy should be billing after the primary. The plan has a member services line and a specific pharmacy help line. The number is usually on the back of the plan's member ID card, not the BIC. Those are two different cards and both matter.
0 coins
Mae Bennett
AuthorI did not realize the plan card and the BIC were separate things the pharmacy needs. We've only ever handed them the BIC. Could that be the whole problem right there?
0 coins
Brielle Johnson
Possibly. For Fee-for-Service Medi-Cal the BIC is enough, but if she's in a managed care plan the pharmacy needs the plan's member ID card too — the one the managed care plan mailed when she was assigned to them. If you never got that card or can't find it, the plan's member services can give you the member ID number over the phone.
0 coins
Honorah King
Two cards confused me for so long. The BIC proves she has Medi-Cal. The managed care plan card is what the pharmacy actually bills for prescriptions when you're in a plan. Some pharmacies know to ask for both; others only ask for one and then run into problems.
0 coins
Oliver Brown
The other coverage being listed on the Medi-Cal case matters a lot for how the billing flows. DHCS has a whole Other Health Coverage process — when you reported the work insurance, that should have flagged your daughter's case so that Medi-Cal knows to process her claims as secondary. If the flag isn't there, Medi-Cal's system might be rejecting the pharmacy's secondary claim because it doesn't have a record of the primary coverage and doesn't know to expect a coordination-of-benefits submission. If you want to verify what's on the case without waiting on hold forever, you can also try messaging through BenefitsCal — sometimes you get a written response in a few days.
0 coins
Mae Bennett
AuthorI didn't know about the Other Health Coverage flag being a separate thing from just reporting it. When I reported the work insurance at her application, does that automatically create that flag or is it something the county has to set up on their end?
0 coins
Oliver Brown
Reporting it at the application starts the process, but it goes through DHCS's Other Health Coverage team to actually get recorded. If something got missed on the intake, it might not have fully processed. DHCS's line for that is 1-800-541-5555 and they have a whole Other Health Coverage department. Calling them directly might get you further than the county on this specific piece.
0 coins
Mary Bates
The 1-800-541-5555 number took me a while to get through on but once I did the person there was specifically trained on other coverage questions and knew exactly what to look for. The county workers are generalists; the DHCS line has people who handle only this.
0 coins
Clay blendedgen
My kid's pharmacy ran into this and the fix was actually the pharmacist calling the managed care plan's pharmacy help line while I was standing there. The plan walked them through how to enter the coordination of benefits correctly in their system. It took maybe 20 minutes but it was a one-time fix and after that every prescription went through. If your pharmacist is willing to make that call with you there, it's worth asking.
0 coins
Mae Bennett
AuthorTwenty minutes sounds very doable. I'll ask if they'll do it while I'm there instead of telling me to come back.
0 coins
Clay blendedgen
Stand your ground a little — some pharmacies prefer to handle it on their own time, but being there in person makes them more likely to do it right away. Bring both cards, the BIC and the managed care plan card, and the primary insurance card too.
0 coins
Melina Haruko
There's sometimes confusion about whether Medi-Cal or the managed care plan is the one the pharmacy should be calling. For prescriptions when a child is in a managed care plan, the pharmacy deals with the plan for billing, not Medi-Cal directly. The plan coordinates with Medi-Cal on the backend. So 'billing Medi-Cal' as secondary might mean billing the plan, depending on how the pharmacy is thinking about it.
0 coins
Jake Sinclair
That distinction tripped up our pharmacist too. They kept saying they were billing Medi-Cal when really they meant they were billing the managed care plan — and they had the wrong payer ID in the system for the plan. Once someone sorted out exactly who they were actually supposed to be billing and what the right ID was, the rejections stopped.
0 coins
Mae Bennett
AuthorSo the pharmacy might be trying to bill DHCS directly instead of the managed care plan? That would explain why it keeps bouncing — they'd be sending it to the wrong place entirely.
0 coins
Melina Haruko
Exactly. If your daughter is in a managed care plan, the plan is what gets billed for prescriptions, with the other insurance's payment info submitted alongside it. Medi-Cal directly — meaning DHCS's Fee-for-Service — is only for people not in a plan.
0 coins
Ayla Kumar
I went through nearly four months of this with my son before anyone gave me a straight answer. What finally cracked it was calling the managed care plan's member services and asking them specifically: 'What information does a pharmacy need to bill you correctly when there is also primary insurance?' They gave me a document with the exact fields the pharmacy needs to fill in. I printed it and brought it to the pharmacist and she fixed it immediately. The plan has every incentive to get this right because they're billing DHCS for capitation and they need the claims to process. So member services is usually motivated to help.
0 coins
Mae Bennett
AuthorI would never have thought to ask the plan to give me a document to bring to the pharmacy. That's a really practical move.
0 coins
Ayla Kumar
Ask them for it in writing or by email if they offer it. Some plans will email you a quick reference card. It also gives you something to point to if the pharmacist pushes back.
0 coins
Lorenzo McCormick
Asking the plan to tell me what the pharmacy needs was the approach that worked for us too. The plan wants the claims to go through; they'll help figure out why they aren't.
0 coins
Saanvi Krishnaswami
Something people overlook with dual coverage is making sure the primary insurance's explanation of benefits — the EOB — is submitted along with the Medi-Cal secondary claim. The pharmacy's system should handle this automatically, but if they're doing something manual or the system isn't pulling it in right, the secondary claim goes in without proof of what the primary paid, and Medi-Cal (or the plan) rejects it because they can't verify there's something left to cover.
0 coins
Reina Salazar
The EOB piece is exactly right. The coordination of benefits process depends on knowing what the primary already covered. Without that the secondary payer has no way to calculate what they owe.
0 coins
Mae Bennett
AuthorHow does the pharmacy get the EOB — does that come from us or does the pharmacy pull it from the primary insurance electronically?
0 coins
Saanvi Krishnaswami
Pharmacies usually get it electronically through real-time claims adjudication when they submit to the primary. It's supposed to be automatic. If it's not coming through, there's a disconnect somewhere in how they're submitting to the primary, and that's what's causing the downstream rejection on the Medi-Cal side.
0 coins
Carmella Popescu
After a plan switch earlier this year the new managed care plan card never arrived. I let Claimyr hold on the county line for me and talked to a worker who checked and said a new BIC had been sent about two weeks prior. Gave me the date it was mailed so I could figure out if something went wrong with the mail. For the pharmacy issue — the plan switch your daughter had is worth flagging directly to the managed care plan. When a child switches plans mid-year, the new plan's pharmacy records take a little time to fully populate, and some pharmacies bill the old plan by mistake for weeks after. The new plan's member services can confirm whether the pharmacy is listed correctly in their network.
0 coins
Mae Bennett
AuthorThe plan switch was about four months ago, so I assumed everything had settled. But I never actually confirmed with the new plan that the pharmacy is in their network — I just assumed it was.
0 coins
Carmella Popescu
Confirming the pharmacy is in the new plan's network is fast — member services can tell you on the spot. If it's out of network that would explain everything. Some plans have a narrower pharmacy network than others, and your regular pharmacy might not be contracted with the new one.
0 coins
Honorah King
Network confirmation was my first step after any plan change. Had a dentist who was in the old plan but not the new one and got blindsided by a bill. Same risk applies to pharmacies.
0 coins
Kai Santiago
The timing of when the county updates the case after a plan change matters too. There can be a window where the county's records show one plan but the pharmacy is trying to bill another. During that window everything rejects. If you got a Notice of Action confirming the plan change, check the effective date on it — that's when the new plan officially took over according to the county.
0 coins
Mae Bennett
AuthorI do have the Notice of Action from when she switched. I'll check the effective date against when the pharmacy rejections started — hadn't thought to line those up.
0 coins
Kai Santiago
If the rejections started right around the effective date that's almost certainly the cause. Bring the NOA to the pharmacy too — it shows the plan name and effective date, which helps their billing team troubleshoot.
0 coins
Lim Wong
Called Medi-Cal Rx once for a similar issue and they were actually pretty fast to pick up. The person there confirmed the rejection reason within a few minutes once they had the member ID and the prescription date. They told me which field the pharmacy had entered wrong. I passed it back to the pharmacist and it was resolved by that evening.
0 coins
Mae Bennett
AuthorIf the issue is on the Fee-for-Service side that sounds like the most direct route. I'm still not 100% sure if she's Fee-for-Service or through the plan though — how do I figure that out?
0 coins
Lim Wong
The managed care plan card gives it away — if she received one in the mail after approval, she's in a plan. If she only ever got the BIC and no separate plan card, she might still be on Fee-for-Service while waiting for a plan assignment. Health Care Options at 1-800-430-4263 can tell you exactly which situation she's in.
0 coins
Mary Bates
Health Care Options knows immediately when you give them the member ID. They see the plan assignment and effective date right away and can tell you whether a plan is active or whether something is in transition.
0 coins
Mason Lopez
The reporting of other health coverage has another piece people miss — it's not just the county you tell, it's also DHCS directly at 1-800-541-5555 and the doctor's office. The doctor side doesn't apply here since the pediatrician is handling it fine, but the DHCS piece matters. If DHCS's Other Health Coverage records don't match what the pharmacy is submitting, the claim bounces.
0 coins
Demi Lagos
Hadn't realized there were two separate reporting paths — the county and DHCS directly. Does reporting to the county usually flow through to DHCS automatically, or are these two separate steps?
0 coins
Mason Lopez
Normally reporting to the county feeds through, but it can lag. Calling DHCS's number directly at 1-800-541-5555 and asking them to confirm what other coverage is listed on the case is the surest way to know it got there. They can see what's on the case in their system.
0 coins
Lorenzo McCormick
Went through almost this exact situation with my nephew on my household's case. The pharmacy had the right BIC and the right plan card but was submitting the claims with the wrong coordination of benefits code — it was showing Medi-Cal as primary when it should have been secondary. The plan's billing team caught it when we called and they corrected it on their end, which also fixed the submissions going forward.
0 coins
Mae Bennett
AuthorThe coordination of benefits code being wrong sounds like it could be what's happening here too, especially since the pharmacist didn't offer any specific reason for the rejection.
0 coins
Lorenzo McCormick
Ask them to specifically check the COB code on the submission. If the pharmacy doesn't know what that means, the managed care plan's pharmacy team will — they deal with this constantly.
0 coins
Dallas Villalobos
COB code errors are really common when a pharmacy sets up a new dual-coverage patient for the first time. It's a setup problem in their system, not something that happens repeatedly once it's fixed correctly.
0 coins
Mary Bates
For anyone still not sure who to call, the managed care plan's member services number is on the back of the plan's member ID card. For Medi-Cal Rx directly it's 1-800-977-2273. For the Other Health Coverage team at DHCS it's 1-800-541-5555. For plan changes and assignments it's Health Care Options at 1-800-430-4263. Keep all four handy because depending on where the error is, any one of them might be the right call.
0 coins
Mae Bennett
AuthorSaving all four of those. I've been going in circles because I didn't know which number was for which piece of this.
0 coins
Mary Bates
Start with the managed care plan's member services and Health Care Options — those two calls will tell you whether the pharmacy has the right plan and whether the plan assignment is correct. Then if that's all fine, Medi-Cal Rx and DHCS OHC are the next tier.
0 coins
Lim Wong
Having the numbers in order of which to call first is actually the most useful framing here. The plan-level questions come before the DHCS-level questions because the plan is what the pharmacy actually bills.
0 coins
Jake Sinclair
There's also a possibility the pharmacist is confusing which rejection they're seeing. Some rejections mean 'we don't have the right payer info' and some mean 'we have the info but Medi-Cal is saying this isn't covered.' Those are completely different problems with different fixes. If the rejection is a coverage question rather than a billing setup question, the managed care plan's prior authorization team is who handles it.
0 coins
Mae Bennett
AuthorHow would I know which type of rejection it is without being able to read the pharmacy's system myself?
0 coins
Jake Sinclair
Ask the pharmacist to read you the rejection code or message word for word. Then bring it to the managed care plan's member services and ask them what it means. They'll know immediately whether it's a billing setup problem or a coverage determination.
0 coins
Reina Salazar
The rejection code is specific — it's not vague. If the pharmacist is giving you a vague answer about why it's rejecting, they haven't looked at the code carefully. The code itself points directly to the problem.
0 coins
Honorah King
Children with two coverages are genuinely common and pharmacies deal with it regularly. The issue is that some locations have better-trained billing staff than others. If your regular pharmacy keeps failing to fix it even after you give them all the information, you're within your rights to ask the managed care plan to help you find another in-network pharmacy that handles dual-coverage billing without the headaches.
0 coins
Mae Bennett
AuthorHonestly that might be where we end up. This pharmacy is convenient but if they can't get it straight after another attempt I'm not going to keep fighting.
0 coins
Honorah King
Before switching completely, ask the plan to contact the pharmacy on your behalf. Plans sometimes have provider relations teams that can flag a pharmacy with billing issues. It's less work for you and the pharmacy takes it more seriously coming from the plan.
0 coins