Back to Tulare County CA Medi-Cal (No Existing Claim)

Mateo Gonzalez

Can I remove baby from employer plan outside open enrollment with Medi-Cal?

My daughter was born in August and I added her to my job's health plan right away because I didn't know what else to do. Now I'm realizing Medi-Cal would actually cover her with no premiums and no copays, and I'm paying a not-small chunk of my paycheck every month to keep her on my employer plan. The problem is open enrollment at my job doesn't come around until next fall. Is there any way to take her off my employer plan now so she can go on Medi-Cal full time? Or am I stuck paying for both until enrollment opens? I already applied for her through BenefitsCal and the county approved her, so she technically has Medi-Cal right now. I just don't know if she can actually use it while she's on my job plan too, or if I have to drop one to use the other.

Having both at once is actually allowed, and your daughter can use her Medi-Cal right now even while she's on your employer plan. The way it works is your job's insurance gets billed first, and whatever it doesn't cover, Medi-Cal steps in for the rest. So she's not stuck waiting and you're not doing anything wrong by having her on both. The bigger question about dropping her from the employer plan mid-year is an HR question, not a Medi-Cal question. Medi-Cal doesn't require you to drop other coverage to use it.

0 coins

That's actually a relief to hear she can use both. I had no idea Medi-Cal worked that way. My HR person made it sound like we couldn't do anything until open enrollment, so maybe that's just about the employer side.

0 coins

Agreed that Medi-Cal doesn't stop you. The employer plan's own rules are what governs whether you can remove a dependent mid-year. That's worth asking HR directly because some employer plans do have a qualifying life event window you might've missed right after the birth.

0 coins

I think I may have missed that window, which is why I'm panicking a little. But at least knowing she can use Medi-Cal now while still on my plan helps. I'll go back to HR and ask what exactly the rules are on our side.

0 coins

To use both you do need to report the other coverage to the county within 10 days of getting it. If you added her to your employer plan in August, that's other health coverage and it goes on her Medi-Cal case. You can do that in BenefitsCal or by calling your county office. The county passes that info along so providers know to bill your job's insurance first.

0 coins

August is a few months back now, so I might be late on that. Do I report it now and just explain it was from August, or is there a penalty for the delay?

0 coins

Report it now regardless. The 10-day rule is about keeping your case accurate, and late is better than never. What comes of a late report is something to ask your county worker directly since the county handles that case by case.

0 coins

Came here to say the same thing about reporting. My case had other coverage listed from a previous job and I had to update it when that job ended. The sooner the better on that.

0 coins

Employer coverage from last spring was still listed as active on my daughter's case even though I had left that job. I let Claimyr (claimyr.com) handle the hold time while I waited for a county worker, and the agent pulled up the case and confirmed the old employer plan was still showing as other health coverage on file. The worker said to report the end of that coverage through BenefitsCal or in person so the county could update it. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at Medi-Cal: https://youtu.be/NXjJFZObk3g. Once I reported the change, the county sent a Notice of Action a couple weeks later confirming the update.

0 coins

The other health coverage piece is what trips a lot of people up. Providers bill whoever is listed first, so if the wrong plan is on file it creates a mess with claims.

0 coins

This is making me realize I definitely need to get my daughter's employer coverage properly reported so the county has it right. I'll try that service if the county line gives me trouble.

0 coins

45 minutes on hold last time I tried the county line. Ended up giving up and mailing a form instead. Good to know that's an option for getting through.

0 coins

You asked whether you can remove the baby from your employer plan outside open enrollment and I want to be clear about something — that decision sits entirely with your employer's plan rules, not Medi-Cal. Medi-Cal will not tell you to drop other coverage and in fact you're supposed to keep other coverage if you have it and just let Medi-Cal fill the gaps. The only way to know whether you can drop her mid-year from the employer plan is to read your Summary Plan Description or talk to HR about qualifying life events. Some plans allow a mid-year drop when a dependent gains other coverage, which Medi-Cal approval might qualify as.

0 coins

So Medi-Cal approval might actually BE a qualifying event for my job's plan? That's something I didn't know to even ask HR. I'm going back to them with that question specifically.

0 coins

Whether Medi-Cal approval counts as a qualifying life event under your employer's plan is genuinely a plan-specific thing. Some do, some don't. HR or your plan documents are the place to check, not the county.

0 coins

Exactly. And if your employer's plan does allow it, you'd drop her from the employer plan and she'd be on Medi-Cal only going forward. If not, you're on both until open enrollment, which still means she has coverage — it's just more expensive for you.

0 coins

I went through almost this same situation two years ago. My son was born and I added him to my work plan automatically, then figured out Medi-Cal had approved him from his birth month. We had him on both for about four months before my job's open enrollment came around. During that time Medi-Cal was listed as his secondary and my employer plan was primary. Every claim went to my job's plan first, and Medi-Cal picked up whatever copays or coinsurance was left. His out-of-pocket costs were basically zero that whole time even though we were paying the premium on the employer plan. It wasn't ideal but it worked.

0 coins

Four months of double coverage while you waited for open enrollment is kind of where I might end up. Good to hear it still worked out without big gaps or billing disasters.

0 coins

No disasters, just the premium out of my check. The providers handled the billing between the two without me having to do much. I did make sure to bring both cards to every appointment though.

0 coins

This is the most useful thing in this thread. Knowing it actually works in practice when you're stuck on both for a while is helpful.

0 coins

Can I ask something that might be dumb but is your daughter on CHIP or on actual Medi-Cal? Because I thought kids' coverage was different. My nephew is on something called Healthy Families and I'm not sure if that's the same thing.

0 coins

Healthy Families was a separate program in California but it ended in 2013 and those kids moved to Medi-Cal. Children's Medi-Cal in California is the state's version of CHIP for most kids, and it runs through the county the same way adult Medi-Cal does. So for California purposes when people say their child is on Medi-Cal, that is the program, and what this thread is describing applies.

0 coins

Ohh okay I didn't know Healthy Families was gone. So my nephew is probably actually on Medi-Cal now and has been for years without anyone noticing the name change. Good to know.

0 coins

Reporting the employer coverage is the right move and you can do it at https://benefitscal.com/Public/login once you log into her case. There's a section for reporting changes to the case including other health coverage. After you submit it, the county processes it and usually mails a Notice of Action confirming the change. That NOA is worth keeping because it confirms what coverage is on file.

0 coins

I've been logging into BenefitsCal for the application but didn't realize I could report changes there too. I'll go in and find the change reporting section.

0 coins

BenefitsCal is where I handle all my updates too. Much faster than mailing a form or waiting on the phone line.

0 coins

The NOA after a change report is easy to miss if you're not watching the mail. It's short but it's the official confirmation that the county got it and updated the case.

0 coins

Nobody told me when my son was born that I had to report any other coverage to Medi-Cal. I found out months later when a claim came back saying Medi-Cal was listed as primary but my job's plan should have been billed first. The provider had to rebill everything and it took forever. Report it now so you don't end up in that situation.

0 coins

That billing mess sounds awful. I'm going to report her employer coverage today, not next week.

0 coins

The earlier the better. It was a headache getting everything straightened out and the provider had to resubmit multiple claims. Medi-Cal and the employer plan both kept pointing at each other.

0 coins

Proof of other health coverage came up on my son's case renewal last spring and I had no idea what documents the county was actually waiting for. I let Claimyr handle the hold time and talked to a worker who told me exactly which document was missing and when it was due. The worker said a letter of coverage from the employer showing the plan name and the effective date was what the county needed, and the due date was about two weeks out. I sent it through BenefitsCal and that resolved it.

0 coins

So the county can ask for an actual letter from the employer plan as proof? I didn't know that. I'll see if I can get one from HR to have it ready.

0 coins

HR pulled mine together in a day. It just needed to show my son's name, the plan name, and the date coverage started. That was enough for the county.

0 coins

The employer letter is usually easier to get than people think. HR departments deal with requests like that for Medi-Cal cases more than you'd expect.

0 coins

My situation going forward when open enrollment finally comes: I'm planning to drop my husband from my work plan because he's been on both for over a year and the premium is adding up. His Medi-Cal covers everything anyway. The employer plan never ends up paying much because his care costs are low, so I'm just paying for overlap. I guess I'll confirm with the county when I drop him that we report the loss of that other coverage too.

0 coins

When he loses the employer plan coverage, that's a change to report to the county within 10 days. You'd report the end of other health coverage the same way you'd report gaining it.

0 coins

Okay good, so it goes both directions. I figured it did but wanted to be sure. I'll do that in BenefitsCal when open enrollment changes take effect.

0 coins

My HR department actually told me Medi-Cal counts as minimum essential coverage and that having a baby get Medi-Cal approved is a qualifying life event to drop them from an employer plan. They were specific about it. I was able to drop my daughter mid-year and it went through. This was at a large company though, and I think smaller employers sometimes run their plans differently.

0 coins

This is exactly the scenario I'm hoping for. My company is mid-size so I'm going to go back to HR with this specifically and ask if Medi-Cal approval counts as a qualifying event under our plan.

0 coins

Worth asking them in writing so you have something to reference. If they say yes, they should be able to tell you the window you have to make the change from the date of the qualifying event.

0 coins

The window is usually 30 or 60 days from the qualifying event date depending on the employer plan. If Medi-Cal approval was in August you might have already missed it, but HR can tell you if there's any flexibility.

0 coins

To the question about whether the baby can actually use Medi-Cal while still on the employer plan — yes, and it's worth calling your daughter's managed care plan to make sure they have the right billing information. Sometimes the plan doesn't get updated when other coverage is added or removed, and you end up with claims going to the wrong place. Your daughter's Medi-Cal plan has a member services line and they can confirm what's on file on their side.

0 coins

I hadn't thought about calling the managed care plan separately. I assumed if the county had it right the plan would too. I'll check with them.

0 coins

They're separate systems. The county decides eligibility and the managed care plan handles the actual claims. Sometimes there's a delay in information getting to the plan, especially with other coverage situations.

0 coins

I ran into this with my son's plan. The plan had an old employer listed as primary for months after I'd already left that job. Had to call plan member services directly to get it corrected on their end, separate from what I'd already reported to the county.

0 coins

Okay so if the baby has BOTH the employer plan AND Medi-Cal, is the BIC card the one you'd bring to doctor appointments or the employer insurance card? Or both? My cousin is in a similar situation and I had no idea which card goes where.

0 coins

Bring both cards to every appointment and tell the provider upfront. The provider bills the employer plan first as primary. Whatever that plan doesn't cover, the provider can then bill Medi-Cal as secondary. Some providers ask to see both at check-in so they have both numbers on file.

0 coins

Okay both cards makes sense. I'll tell my cousin to hold onto both and not leave the BIC at home thinking it doesn't apply.

0 coins

I always brought both and told the front desk right away. Some offices are great at coordinating between two plans and some need a little coaching. Worth being upfront every time.

0 coins

I have a slightly different situation and want to make sure I understand. If the employer plan charges a premium and Medi-Cal is free, is there any rule that says I have to keep the employer plan? Like can I just drop my employer plan voluntarily and go Medi-Cal only?

0 coins

Whether you can drop your employer plan at any given time is up to your employer's plan rules, same answer as this whole thread. Medi-Cal doesn't require you to keep other coverage, but it also doesn't tell your employer to let you drop it outside open enrollment. Those are two separate things and the employer plan's rules are the binding one here.

0 coins

Got it. So Medi-Cal won't penalize me for dropping the employer plan, it's just whether my employer's plan allows it. That makes more sense now.

0 coins

One thing I'd flag is the reporting to DHCS separately from the county. If you have other health coverage you can also report it to DHCS directly at their Other Health Coverage page or at the number on that page, not just through the county. Usually reporting through BenefitsCal handles it, but it's good to know DHCS has its own channel for that specifically.

0 coins

I didn't know DHCS had its own line for other health coverage. I'd always gone through BenefitsCal or the county office. Good to know there's another path if the county line is backed up.

0 coins

Their number is 1-800-541-5555, and they also have a specific Other Health Coverage page on DHCS's site with a way to report it directly. Either path works.

0 coins

Address change and income change both happened for my family in September and I wasn't sure if the county had either one on the case. I used Claimyr and talked to a worker who pulled up the case and said the address update was recorded but the income change hadn't come through yet. The worker told me to submit the income change through BenefitsCal with a recent pay stub showing the new hours. I sent it in that same day.

0 coins

Two changes at once sounds stressful to track. Good that the worker could actually see what was recorded and what wasn't — that would have taken weeks to figure out just from BenefitsCal.

0 coins

Exactly. I didn't want to assume both went through. The income change was the important one because hours went up and I wasn't sure how that affected the case.

0 coins

Reporting income changes within 10 days is the rule and I always worry I'm sending the right document. A recent pay stub showing the new hours sounds like exactly what they want.

0 coins

Something I want to make sure people understand about this double-coverage situation is that Medi-Cal actually requires other health coverage to be reported. It's not optional. And the reason is that Medi-Cal is meant to be the payer of last resort, meaning if there's another plan that should be paying, they want that plan to go first. It protects the program and it's just the rule.

0 coins

Payer of last resort is a phrase I've heard and now it actually makes sense in context. The employer plan goes first, Medi-Cal fills in behind it.

0 coins

Exactly, and it also means your daughter's care is still fully covered either way. The employer plan handles what it covers, and Medi-Cal handles the rest. You're not losing any coverage by having both.

0 coins

Payer of last resort is a good way to think about it. I'm going to remember that phrase for my cousin's situation.

0 coins

November renewals just went out for a lot of people on the county's cycle and I'm seeing questions like this more. If your daughter's first renewal comes up and the employer plan isn't listed correctly on her case, the county may flag it as an issue during renewal. Getting the other coverage reported now means her renewal goes smoother and there's no back-and-forth with the county about what other insurance she has.

0 coins

Her first renewal will probably come up around August or September next year if she was approved this fall. I'd rather have everything clean before then.

0 coins

Exactly the right timeline to think about. Renewals go out in a yellow envelope and if anything is off on the case it usually surfaces there. Clean it up now and the renewal should be a non-event.

0 coins

The county office line in my area is brutal on Monday mornings. I've had better luck calling mid-week around mid-morning but that's just my own experience. BenefitsCal handles most routine stuff without needing to get anyone on the phone, which is why I try to do as much as I can online.

0 coins

Mid-week is my go-to too. Never Monday. Friday afternoons are also rough because it feels like half the staff is unavailable or the system is running slow.

0 coins

BenefitsCal for routine changes and the phone only when something is actually unclear on the case. That's the approach I've landed on too.

0 coins

To circle back to the original question since we're a few hundred comments in — you asked if you can remove baby from employer plan outside open enrollment with Medi-Cal and the answer is: Medi-Cal itself won't do that for you, but your employer's plan might allow a mid-year drop if Medi-Cal approval is a qualifying event. That's the only path to doing it before next fall. In the meantime she can use both and you just need to report the employer coverage to the county.

0 coins

This sums it up well. I'm going back to HR with the qualifying event question, reporting her employer coverage to the county today, and in the meantime she uses both cards at every appointment. That's my action list.

0 coins

That's exactly the right action list. And if HR says no on the mid-year drop, you're not stuck with nothing — you just keep paying the premium until fall and Medi-Cal still helps cover whatever the employer plan doesn't.

0 coins

The only thing I'd add is to keep the Notice of Action from the county confirming her Medi-Cal approval. HR might want to see it as proof of the qualifying event when you make that request.

0 coins

Related posts

Tulare County CA Medi-Cal (No Existing Claim) AI

Expert Assistant
Secure