Back to Covered California

Kayla Morgan

Put on Medi-Cal instead of marketplace plan, how to switch to Covered California

Tried to get a Covered California plan during open enrollment and ended up on Medi-Cal instead. I did not ask for Medi-Cal, I wanted a Silver or Gold plan through the marketplace because I want to be able to keep my current doctors and I make decent income as a self-employed person. The application just routed me there automatically. I do not qualify for Medi-Cal, at least I didn't think I did, so I'm confused about how the system decided that. My projected income for this year went in correctly, I thought, but maybe something is off. Has anyone dealt with this and figured out how to switch to an actual Covered California marketplace plan instead of staying on Medi-Cal?

My application did the same thing two years ago, sent me straight to Medi-Cal even though I entered my income. What I'd do first in your situation is sign back into your Covered California account and pull up the eligibility results. The number it used for your household income is right there, and that's where mine had the problem: I had accidentally entered my monthly income instead of annual, so the system saw a much lower number and shot me to Medi-Cal. Once I corrected the annual figure the account recalculated and I got a Covered California plan. The way it works is one application checks both programs and the system sends you where your income puts you, so if the income on file is too low it assumes Medi-Cal. Fix the number first, then see what comes back.

0 coins

The annual vs monthly thing is exactly what might have happened to me, honestly. I'm going to check the income figure in the account right now. Did you have to start a whole new application or just edit what was already there?

0 coins

You just edit in the existing application, no need to start over. Go into your household summary and update the income section and it should give you new eligibility results without redoing everything.

0 coins

Medi-Cal covers people up to 138% of the federal poverty level for adults, so if your income looked low enough to put you there that's the cutover point. Getting it corrected early in open enrollment is easier than fighting it later.

0 coins

Income showing as lower than it should be was the whole reason I ended up on the phone about my own application. The account kept showing Medi-Cal eligibility and I entered what I thought was right. I let Claimyr (claimyr.com) handle the hold time while I was at work, and ended up talking to a Covered California representative that afternoon. She pulled up my application and read me the income figure on file: it was showing roughly half what I actually put in, which turned out to be a data entry issue on the household size section that made the per-person amount drop. She also confirmed the household size on the application, which had one extra person listed from a previous session I had not finished. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at Covered California: https://youtu.be/9y0sXw7pbJU. I went back into the account after the call, removed the extra household member and corrected the income, and the eligibility results updated to a Covered California plan option.

0 coins

Was the representative able to tell you what was wrong right away, or did they have to look into it for a while?

0 coins

She found it pretty quickly once she pulled the application up. The household size was the first thing she checked because that directly affects the income calculation per person.

0 coins

The household size thing gets people constantly. Even one extra person listed can push the per-person income below the Medi-Cal line and boom, you're sent there automatically. Worth double-checking that section.

0 coins

Covered California's application does count everyone in the household when it figures out what percentage of the federal poverty level your income represents. So if an extra person is in there the percentage drops and Medi-Cal becomes the result. Removing them and correcting the income is exactly the right move.

0 coins

I had a totally different reason for landing on Medi-Cal even though my income should have put me on a Covered California plan: I had not reported a freelance contract I picked up last spring, so my income on file was from the year before, which was a low year for me. The system had my old projected income and that was well under the Medi-Cal threshold. If you're self-employed your income can really vary and the system just works with whatever number you give it. Make sure what you entered this year reflects what you actually expect to bring in this whole year, not last year's total.

0 coins

Self-employed here too, and yes my income varies. The instruction says to use the income I expect to earn this year rather than last year's, right? So I need to put my best estimate for this full year?

0 coins

Exactly right. Best estimate for the current year is what goes in. Covered California is pretty clear that it's what you expect, not what you earned before.

0 coins

And if your income changes during the year you're supposed to report it within 30 days of the change. That can flip you between Medi-Cal and a Covered California plan depending on where your income lands.

0 coins

If your income is genuinely above the Medi-Cal limit and you want to switch, the other thing I'd check is whether you're within the open enrollment window still. Right now open enrollment is running so you should be able to update your application and select a marketplace plan without needing any special enrollment trigger. If the correction to your income results in Covered California eligibility, you pick your plan from there. The switch itself is not super complicated once the eligibility resolves to Covered California, but you do need to make the first payment to your insurance company before the plan activates.

0 coins

We're still in open enrollment so that's a relief. If I fix the income and get Covered California eligibility, do I pick the plan the same way as a new application or does the system walk me through it again?

0 coins

The updated eligibility results should let you go directly into plan selection. Basically it shows you the options and you pick, same flow as selecting initially. Then you pay the first month's premium directly to the insurance company.

0 coins

Pay Now shows up in the Covered California account for the first month's payment only and that goes to the insurance company. After that the bills come from the insurer directly, not from Covered California.

0 coins

Does Medi-Cal actually start automatically once the system sends you there? Because I am worried about the same situation, I entered my income and have not heard anything yet about what happened with my application and I want to make sure I know what I'm dealing with.

0 coins

Covered California's application sends your info to Medi-Cal if your income puts you there, but your county handles the actual Medi-Cal enrollment from that point. You'd get a notice from the county about next steps on the Medi-Cal side.

0 coins

Does that mean I need to contact the county separately if I think the income was wrong, or do I fix it in my Covered California account first?

0 coins

Fix it in your Covered California account first. If correcting the income bumps you out of Medi-Cal range and into Covered California territory, the system reroutes you. If you genuinely believe you don't qualify for Medi-Cal, that correction is the starting point.

0 coins

There is also the case where someone actually does qualify for Medi-Cal based on their income but doesn't want it and wants a marketplace plan instead. I want to be clear: if your income falls below the cutoff, you can't get financial help through Covered California and you'd have to pay the full premium of a marketplace plan out of pocket. So if you're right at the edge of the income levels it might actually be worth checking what your numbers look like with the Shop and Compare tool before deciding you definitely want to switch.

0 coins

My income as a self-employed person should be well above the Medi-Cal line so I think this is a data entry issue on my end. But the point about checking Shop and Compare first is a good one for anyone who's on the borderline.

0 coins

Adults are covered by Medi-Cal up to 138% of the FPL, and Covered California's financial help starts at 100% of the FPL. So there's actually a window between those two where depending on the household it could go either way. You want to understand where your income actually falls before assuming one program is wrong.

0 coins

Exactly. And self-employment income can be tricky because net income after expenses is what counts, not gross revenue. If you deducted a lot of business expenses your net might be lower than you expect.

0 coins

Something that happened in my household: my husband is on a Covered California plan and my two kids ended up on Medi-Cal from the same application because children have a higher income limit for Medi-Cal eligibility. That's apparently normal and is called a mixed-program family. If you're the only person in your household asking for coverage and your income entered correctly you shouldn't land on Medi-Cal unless the number is wrong, so I'd really dig into that income and household section.

0 coins

I am the only person in the household applying, so the mixed-program family thing doesn't apply to me. That does make it more likely this is a data entry error on my end.

0 coins

Mixed-program families are really common and people freak out thinking something went wrong when it's actually working as intended. Kids and adults just have different income thresholds.

0 coins

Yep, the application is designed to put each person where they belong based on the household income and their age. It's not a mistake when kids end up on Medi-Cal, it's just how the cutoffs work for different ages.

0 coins

The special enrollment question is relevant to my situation too. I moved back to California from out of state in October and tried to enroll, and my application also got routed to Medi-Cal even though I had a move as a qualifying life event. I could not figure out whether the move was even on the application correctly as a triggering event. I ended up on the phone with a Covered California representative through Claimyr to ask about the special enrollment window on my case. The representative confirmed the move date was recorded, the special enrollment window was open, and that my income on the application was the figure I had entered. The issue turned out to be that I had not updated my household size after the move, since my domestic partner did not move with me.

0 coins

Did the representative tell you whether updating household size would immediately reopen the plan selection, or did it take a few days for the account to update?

0 coins

She said updating in the account would trigger new eligibility results, and mine did show Covered California options the same day once I removed my partner from the household.

0 coins

I didn't realize household size changes could affect whether you go to Medi-Cal or Covered California that dramatically. Removing one person from the household effectively raises the per-person income percentage.

0 coins

For the self-employed income question that keeps coming up here: net profit from self-employment is what goes in, not your total revenue. So if you brought in a certain amount but spent on equipment, software, supplies, travel for work, that reduces the number. Covered California uses the same kind of income definition as the tax return's Schedule C net profit. If you accidentally entered your gross rather than your net that could also explain a lower figure that pushed you to Medi-Cal even if you thought you entered it right.

0 coins

I may have entered gross without thinking about it. That's another thing to check in my account. Net of business expenses is definitely lower for me.

0 coins

This happened to me in a previous year too, entering gross instead of net. The difference was big enough that it affected which program I landed in.

0 coins

And the flip side is also true: if you entered net but your actual net this year ends up higher because business is good, you're supposed to report that change within 30 days so the financial help adjusts. Getting it wrong in either direction creates a reconciliation headache at tax time with the 1095-A.

0 coins

ok i looked at my own account yesterday and it says medi-cal pending and i have no idea what to do, did anyone actually successfully switch from medi-cal to a covered california plan or does the system just keep you stuck there

0 coins

Switching is definitely possible, you just have to correct whatever made the income fall into Medi-Cal range. Once the account shows Covered California eligibility you can pick a plan. The key is figuring out if it was income entered wrong, household size, or something else.

0 coins

Pending on the Medi-Cal side means it's still being processed. I'd sign into the Covered California account and check what income and household size are on file before anything else. If those look right and it still shows Medi-Cal, calling the service center is the next step.

0 coins

mine shows my income right i think but household has my mom listed and she doesn't live with me anymore so maybe that's it

0 coins

It's also worth knowing that if you genuinely do not qualify for Medi-Cal and think there's an error in the determination, you can file an appeal with Covered California within 90 days of when they mailed your eligibility decision. That's a formal route if the account correction doesn't resolve it. The appeal form goes by mail and Covered California may try to resolve it before it gets to a hearing, but having that option in your back pocket matters if the account fix doesn't work.

0 coins

How does the appeal process work once you file, do they contact you or does it just go into a queue somewhere?

0 coins

Covered California may try to resolve it on their end first after you file. If not, the California Department of Social Services sets a hearing with an administrative law judge, usually by phone. The whole process can take up to 90 days.

0 coins

The appeal is for an eligibility decision you disagree with, so if the fix in the account resolves the issue you probably don't need to go that route. But if the system keeps sending you to Medi-Cal even after correcting your income, that's when the appeal option becomes relevant.

0 coins

My Covered California application got sent to the county for Medi-Cal and the county sent me a letter about enrolling in a Medi-Cal plan. I was confused because I thought Covered California handled everything. Someone had to explain to me that once the application goes to Medi-Cal, the county takes over and Covered California's service center can't make decisions about that case anymore. If you end up in a situation where Medi-Cal is processing and you believe it's wrong, your first call is to the county, not to Covered California, to dispute the determination.

0 coins

So the county Medi-Cal office handles disputes once it's already gone to Medi-Cal, and Covered California handles the application side before that determination?

0 coins

That's how it works from what I understand. The service center can tell you what your application shows, but once it's routed to Medi-Cal the county is in charge of that case.

0 coins

Though if the income on the Covered California application is simply wrong, correcting it in your account may resolve it before the county even processes it fully, depending on timing. It's faster to fix the application than to dispute through the county.

0 coins

I don't want to alarm anyone but I had a situation where I fixed my income in the account, got Covered California eligibility, picked a plan, and then found out I never paid the first month's premium in time and my plan never actually activated. The plan doesn't start until that first payment goes to the insurance company. I thought the monthly APTC payment would handle the first month but it doesn't, you still owe your share directly. Just flagging this because fixing the income and picking the plan is not the finish line.

0 coins

How long did you have to make that first payment before the plan was considered canceled?

0 coins

Covered California says the plan won't cover you until you pay, and if you miss it your coverage can be canceled. I don't know an exact number of days, but I would not wait around once the plan is selected.

0 coins

The Pay Now option in the Covered California account works for that first month only and goes straight to the insurance company. After that the bills come from the insurer, not from Covered California. Set a reminder to pay it right away once the plan is selected.

0 coins

Account locked was my problem when I tried to sort out a similar issue. I could not get into my Covered California account at all to see what income was on file, and the chat was not helping me resolve it. I ended up on the phone with a Covered California representative through Claimyr. The representative confirmed my identity over the phone and unlocked the account, and I was able to sign back in that same day to check the income and household figures.

0 coins

If your account gets locked, is the service center the only way to fix it, or is there a self-service option?

0 coins

The site does have a forgot-password flow for a forgotten password, and a username recovery option if you forgot that. But for a locked account, the service center is what fixed it for me.

0 coins

The sign-in page has the forgot password link, and the username can be recovered with your email address and date of birth. A locked account is a different situation that the service center handles by confirming your identity.

0 coins

If anyone is reading this and has children in the household while they themselves want a Covered California plan, the kids may land on Medi-Cal even if the parent qualifies for a marketplace plan and that is completely normal. The application covers the whole household together and routes each person based on their own situation. It is not a system error when it happens that way.

0 coins

Does that mean the parent is making two separate monthly payments, one to the Covered California insurance company for themselves and separately dealing with Medi-Cal for the kids through the county?

0 coins

Basically yes. The parent's insurance premium goes to the insurance company and the kids' Medi-Cal is managed through the county. Two different systems running at the same time, which can be confusing but it's how mixed-program households work.

0 coins

That is exactly my household right now and yes it feels weird paying a premium for one plan while the kids are on something completely separate, but it's working fine and both are covered. The county handles everything for the kids.

0 coins

Another thing worth checking if you do get a Covered California plan after switching from Medi-Cal: your membership ID card comes from the insurance company after they receive your first payment, not from Covered California. If you have any appointments coming up you can still use the plan before the card arrives, but you'll want to call the insurance company to get your member ID number to give to the provider.

0 coins

Good to know about the ID card timeline. I had assumed it would arrive before my first appointment but sounds like it might not.

0 coins

Exactly, the insurer mails it once payment clears, so if you paid close to an appointment date you may need to phone the insurance company to get the number early.

0 coins

Any questions about the ID card, your benefits, prescriptions, that stuff all goes to the insurance company directly, not to Covered California. Covered California handles the enrollment and financial help side, the insurer handles everything about the actual plan.

0 coins

I want to flag something I see mentioned incorrectly in threads like this: some people assume cost-sharing reductions lower the monthly premium, but they don't. The premium is what the tax credit (APTC) brings down. Cost-sharing reductions lower your out-of-pocket costs when you use the plan, like deductibles and copays, and they only come with Enhanced Silver plans. If someone switches from Medi-Cal to a Covered California plan and picks Silver because their income qualifies, they may get both the premium help and the cost-sharing reduction benefit, but those are two separate things.

0 coins

Is Enhanced Silver the same as regular Silver or is it a different category on the plan selection screen?

0 coins

Enhanced Silver is just what Silver plans are called when they come with cost-sharing reductions because your income is at or below 250% of the federal poverty level. The plan selection shows Silver options and if you qualify the reductions are built in.

0 coins

This tripped me up when I first enrolled. I thought the lower deductible on my Silver plan was a mistake but it was the cost-sharing reduction doing its job. The monthly savings come from the APTC, the lower cost when you use the plan comes from the cost-sharing reduction.

0 coins

Quick update on my own situation from earlier in this thread: I signed into my account and found that my mom was still listed as a household member from two years ago when I first applied. Removed her, updated my income to reflect just me, and got new eligibility results showing Covered California Silver and Gold plan options. Picking a plan now.

0 coins

This gives me hope. Heading back into my account to do the same kind of audit.

0 coins

Old household members staying on the application from previous years is so common. The renewal auto-populates whatever was there before so unless you review it every year things like that stay.

0 coins

And that's exactly why Covered California recommends reviewing your household and income before the renewal deadline every year rather than letting it roll over automatically.

0 coins

For anyone who wants to look at plan options before finishing the correction process, the Shop and Compare tool on Covered California's site lets you enter income and household size without being signed in and get an estimate of what different plan levels would cost with financial help. Good way to get a sense of what you'd be looking at before committing to the switch.

0 coins

Does Shop and Compare show actual plans or just estimates of what a tier would cost?

0 coins

It shows estimated premiums and financial help for different plans available in your area. You enter your zip code, household size and income and it gives you real options. It's not the enrollment itself, just the comparison tool.

0 coins

Used it just now and the Silver plan options in my area look really reasonable with the financial help applied. Definitely motivated to get the income corrected so I can actually enroll in one of those.

0 coins

Something I noticed in my own case that might apply here: when I finally corrected my income and switched to a Covered California plan, the new coverage started the first of the month following my plan selection. So timing matters a bit if you have any healthcare needs coming up. The sooner you fix the income and select a plan, the sooner that coverage start date lands.

0 coins

So if I fix it and pick a plan this month, coverage would start the first of next month in most cases?

0 coins

That's how it typically works, coverage starts the first of the month after you choose the plan. But your eligibility results and the plan selection screen will show the actual start date for your situation.

0 coins

Worth not waiting on this one then. Every week you delay is a week closer to the start date slipping to the following month instead.

0 coins

Coming back to update: I went into my account and found two problems. First, I had my income entered as monthly instead of annual, exactly what someone mentioned early in this thread. Second, there was a household member from an old application still listed. Fixed both and the eligibility results changed completely. I now have Covered California plan options showing. Picking a Gold plan today and paying the first month directly. Thank you to everyone who helped me work through this.

0 coins

Monthly vs annual income is the classic one. Glad you caught it.

0 coins

The household size issue being left over from an old application is really easy to miss because the system just carries it forward. Good catch.

0 coins

Picking Gold is a solid move if the premium works out. Higher monthly cost but lower out of pocket when you actually use it, which matters if you see doctors regularly.

0 coins

Let us know how the first payment goes. Once that's done the plan is real.

0 coins

Related posts

Covered California AI

Expert Assistant
Secure