Back to Covered California

Diego Mendoza

Covered subsidy when spouse has Medicare and is not on plan — do I still qualify?

My husband turned 65 in September and switched over to Medicare. We dropped him from our Covered California plan at that point since there was no reason to pay for two coverages. I kept my Silver plan for myself and our two teenagers. When I went into the account to report the change I noticed the premium went down a bit but I'm honestly not sure if the financial help I'm getting is correct now that he's off the plan. My income is the same, he has Social Security income plus a small pension, and he is not on the Covered California plan at all anymore. Does his Medicare and his income still count when Covered California figures out my subsidy? I keep getting different answers from people. Some say Medicare income counts, some say if he's not on the plan his income doesn't matter at all. I need to know if I reported this right and if the financial help on my account is what it should be.

Social Security and pension income do count in the household income calculation even when the person receiving that income is on Medicare and not enrolled in a Covered California plan. The way Covered California figures it: anyone you file taxes with is in the household for income purposes, even if they don't need coverage through Covered California. So your husband's Social Security and pension go into the total income used to calculate your APTC and any cost-sharing reductions. That said, since he's off the plan, he's not counted for the size of the enrolled group, which does affect the calculation differently. I went through this same situation when my mother-in-law aged into Medicare. The final number on my notice changed and I had to compare it against Shop and Compare to make sure it matched up.

0 coins

So his income counts but he is not counted as a person enrolled? That is what I figured but I couldn't get a straight answer anywhere. My notice shows updated numbers after I reported the change, so I guess the account picked it up. I'll check Shop and Compare to see if the estimate there matches what my account shows.

0 coins

Household membership and plan enrollment are two separate things in the Covered California system. Someone can be in your tax household for income purposes but not be on the Covered California plan if they have other qualifying coverage, like Medicare. The income total that feeds the APTC calculation includes everyone you file with, regardless of which program covers them.

0 coins

My husband went on Medicare two years ago and I kept my Gold plan. The representative I talked to at the service center confirmed this, that his Social Security counts toward our combined household income. It did push us up the FPL percentage a little, which slightly reduced my financial help compared to when he was on the plan.

0 coins

Account was locked when I tried to log in to report my own household change, so I had to get to the service center by phone before I could do anything. Claimyr (claimyr.com) sat on hold for me while I was at work, and I ended up speaking with a representative who pulled up my account and confirmed the household had me listed as the sole enrollee while my spouse was noted as a household member not seeking coverage. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at Covered California: https://youtu.be/9y0sXw7pbJU. The representative said the consent to verify information settings needed to be updated for the renewal coming up, so I took care of that in the account after the lock was cleared.

0 coins

Mine wasn't locked, thankfully, but I know how frustrating a locked account is when you're trying to report a change on a deadline. Glad you got someone on the phone.

0 coins

Locked out in October heading into renewal, which is about the worst timing. The service center is the right call in that situation since the account itself can't be opened to do anything.

0 coins

Exactly the worst week for it. The representative confirmed the account after checking my identity and I was back in by that afternoon. Updated the consent setting right away since the renewal deadline was close.

0 coins

60 days from when his Medicare coverage started is the window where you can report the change as a qualifying life event and adjust the plan. It sounds like you already did this, which is good. If you waited beyond that window without reporting, the APTC you received during those months may need to be reconciled at tax time. The Form 1095-A at the end of the year will show the monthly amounts, so when you file you can see how the tax credit lines up with what you actually earned and what your household income was.

0 coins

I reported it within the 30 days the account says to report changes. His Medicare started September 1 and I updated the account before the end of September. I did not realize there was a 60-day window for the qualifying life event angle too. Good to know both clocks were running.

0 coins

Reporting a household change to Covered California and the qualifying life event window are two different things worth keeping separate. The 30-day reporting rule is for income and household changes that affect your ongoing coverage and APTC. The 60-day special enrollment window is about being able to add or change coverage after a life event. Since the spouse moved to Medicare and you were adjusting who is on the Covered California plan, both applied here.

0 coins

Right, and the 1095-A that comes in January will reflect the premium and APTC by month, so if the financial help amount changed in October after you reported, you'll see two different amounts across the year. That's normal and your tax preparer can walk through the reconciliation.

0 coins

Worth double-checking is whether your household size in the account still shows the correct number of people. When a spouse drops off the enrolled plan because of Medicare, some people accidentally remove them from the household listing entirely rather than just marking them as not seeking coverage through Covered California. If the household size drops to fewer people than are actually in your tax household, that can miscalculate the income percentage against the federal poverty level and either over- or under-state your financial help.

0 coins

Went back into the account just now. He is still listed as a household member, just showing as not enrolled in the Covered California plan. The two teens are still on the plan. So household size looks right.

0 coins

Removing someone from the household versus removing them from the enrolled plan is a difference a lot of people miss. The income threshold for financial help at a given FPL percentage shifts with every person in the household, so accidentally shrinking the household count on the account could throw off the APTC significantly.

0 coins

Sounds like the account is set up correctly then. The fact that the premium adjusted when you reported the change suggests Covered California processed it and ran new eligibility. Checking the eligibility results section of the account will show the household size and income percentage they used.

0 coins

I have a question that's related to this: my husband is 63, not on Medicare yet, but he has retiree coverage through his old employer. I dropped him from our Covered California plan last year when he got that retiree coverage. Does his retiree plan income count the same way a Medicare spouse's income counts? Or does the other coverage type change how Covered California treats his income for my subsidy?

0 coins

His income still counts in your household income total for the APTC calculation regardless of what coverage he has. The question of whether having other coverage affects your financial help eligibility is a different issue from whether his income counts, and it gets into details I'd recommend running through Shop and Compare or asking the service center about directly.

0 coins

Shop and Compare was what I used to estimate it last year, and the estimate there matched what my notice said, so I'll run it again with updated income and see if the number is in the same range.

0 coins

The safe move is to report what you know is factually true about your household and income and let the eligibility results show you what Covered California calculated. If it doesn't match what you expected, that's when the service center or a certified enroller can walk through the specifics.

0 coins

Application on my account went to the county for Medi-Cal review instead of opening a Covered California plan, which I didn't expect. I let Claimyr do the waiting while I was on a call for work, and the representative told me the household income entered on the application had come in below 138% FPL, which is why the application routed to Medi-Cal rather than to a Covered California plan. I updated the income on the application to reflect the full household amount and resubmitted. The eligibility results after that showed me in the Covered California range.

0 coins

That's exactly what I was afraid of when I removed my husband from the plan enrollment but kept his income in the household. I didn't want it to accidentally read as a lower income household than we are and push the kids toward Medi-Cal.

0 coins

The income total is the key variable. Kids being pushed to Medi-Cal at a different income percentage from adults is a real thing, and it happened in my household when the income entry was off. The eligibility results section of the account will tell you which program each household member was placed in.

0 coins

Mixed-program families, where the kids are on Medi-Cal and the adults are on a Covered California plan, are common and not necessarily a problem. It depends on whether you want the kids on Medi-Cal or on your Silver plan, and that comes down to their income eligibility and your preference.

0 coins

My Silver plan renewal is coming up and the premium for next year shown in my renewal notice is different from what the account showed me in Shop and Compare. I ran the estimate with my current household — me, my husband on Medicare not enrolled, and one dependent — and the Shop and Compare number was lower than the renewal notice. Not sure if the renewal is using an outdated income figure or if Shop and Compare is just showing an estimate that doesn't reflect the actual renewal calculation.

0 coins

Renewal notices are generated from whatever income and household information was on file when Covered California ran the renewal. If your income changed during the year and you reported it, the renewal might still be based on the number at the time the notice was generated. Updating the income in the account before the renewal deadline is the fix, and then recheck what the APTC shows.

0 coins

Last income update I made was in June when my freelance earnings picked up. The renewal notice might have been generated before that update hit the system. Logging back in to verify the income shown matches what I entered in June.

0 coins

Renewal opens in October and the notices go out then, so if your income update landed after the notice was already generated, the two figures won't match. Updating the income in the account before the renewal deadline is what adjusts the APTC going forward.

0 coins

COVERED CALIFORNIA DOESN'T TELL YOU THIS CLEARLY but if your household income changes because of a spouse moving to Medicare and their income situation changing, like a pension starting or Social Security amounts shifting, you need to update it in the account even if you already reported the household change. I did the household change reporting correctly when my wife started Medicare but I forgot that her first full year of pension income was going to show up in our combined number. My APTC at the end of the year did not match what I was getting monthly and I had to reconcile the whole thing on my taxes. Update income changes separately from the household membership change, they're not the same update.

0 coins

This is really important. I updated the household membership change when he went on Medicare but I haven't thought through whether his pension and Social Security amounts changed at the same time and need their own separate income update. Need to go back through the account and verify the income figure is actually current.

0 coins

Income and household are separate fields in the account. Covered California's guidance is to report income changes within 30 days of when you know about them, not just when you're making a different update like removing someone from the enrolled plan. Good catch.

0 coins

My tax preparer flagged it at filing time, but the right time to fix it was during the year. Reconciling a big gap between monthly APTC and actual income isn't fun when you're facing a larger repayment.

0 coins

Enhanced Silver plans and cost-sharing reductions are worth checking when your household income and size shift. If removing your husband from the plan enrollment changes where your income lands as a percentage of the FPL, you might qualify for a different Enhanced Silver tier than you were on before — or fall out of cost-sharing reduction range entirely. The Silver plan itself stays a Silver plan, but the actual deductibles and copays tied to the Enhanced Silver designation can shift.

0 coins

Had no idea the Enhanced Silver tier could shift mid-year if the income and household size change. I know I'm still on a Silver plan but whether I'm on a 73, 87, or 94 tier is something I should double-check in my eligibility results.

0 coins

The eligibility results in the account after you reported the change should show which Enhanced Silver tier you qualify for, if any. Shop and Compare also shows this when you run an estimate with the current household and income. Changes in the enrolled household size can move you between tiers even when gross income stays the same.

0 coins

Dropped from a 94 to an 87 tier when my husband stopped being enrolled on the plan, which surprised me. The deductible difference was noticeable. Worth checking in the account after any household change.

0 coins

Does the Medicare premium my husband pays come off our household income when Covered California calculates the subsidy? Heard someone say Medicare Part B premiums can reduce the adjusted income used for the APTC. That would actually help us since his Part B amount is not small.

0 coins

How specific deductions are treated in the income calculation for the APTC is a tax question more than a Covered California question. What goes into the income figure Covered California uses is based on the modified adjusted gross income definition, which factors in tax deductions, but how Medicare premiums specifically interact with that is the kind of question for a tax preparer or the IRS rather than the service center.

0 coins

Makes sense that it's more of a tax question than a Covered California question. I'll bring it up with our tax preparer when we sit down before filing. I just wanted to make sure I wasn't leaving something out of my income reporting to Covered California.

0 coins

Covered California tells you to use the income you expect to earn this year, and what qualifies as income versus what gets deducted is part of the MAGI calculation. A tax preparer can confirm what the right number is to enter into the Covered California account for your household.

0 coins

My neighbor is in a similar situation, Medicare spouse not on the plan, and she was told by someone helping her enroll that the spouse doesn't need to be listed in the household at all since he's on Medicare. That doesn't sound right to me. If you're filing taxes together, he's in the household for Covered California purposes regardless of his coverage.

0 coins

That advice is incorrect. Covered California's household definition includes anyone you file taxes with, including a spouse on Medicare. Removing him from the household listing entirely would undercount the household size, which changes the FPL percentage and can produce the wrong APTC amount.

0 coins

That's what I told her. She went back into the account and he was still listed, the person helping her just hadn't removed him. But the advice to remove a Medicare spouse from the household entirely is wrong and worth flagging here in case others heard the same thing.

0 coins

There's a difference between removing someone from the enrolled plan, which is correct when they have Medicare, and removing them from the household member listing, which is wrong if they're part of your tax household. A certified enroller should know that distinction.

0 coins

My covered CA renewal kept my husband on the plan even though I reported his Medicare months ago. The renewal notice just defaulted to including him, which meant the enrolled household count was wrong. Had to call in and also go into the account to remove him from the enrolled plan again for the upcoming plan year.

0 coins

That is a specific thing to watch for. I need to look at my renewal notice carefully to make sure it isn't re-enrolling him. I would have assumed reporting the change mid-year would carry over to the renewal automatically.

0 coins

In my case it did not carry over. The renewal defaulted to what it had on file from the year before, not the mid-year household change. Definitely look at the enrolled members listed on your renewal notice and compare it to what you want going forward.

0 coins

Renewal auto-enrollment uses whatever is in the account from the prior period and doesn't always reflect mid-year updates the way you'd expect. Reviewing the renewal notice carefully and confirming the enrolled household before the deadline is always worth doing.

0 coins

This is a known thing. Reviewing the renewal notice and not just letting it auto-enroll is exactly what Covered California's renewal guidance says to do before the deadline — check the household, check the income, compare the plan.

0 coins

Premium shown on my notice after a household income update didn't change, even though I'd entered a lower income reflecting my spouse moving to Social Security from wages. Called the service center and got nowhere after a long hold. Claimyr held the line for me the next morning and I ended up speaking with a representative. The income and household size on my application showed the original wage figure, not the updated one — the representative said the update may not have fully processed to the application. I went back in and re-entered the income, and the account recalculated the APTC within a couple of days.

0 coins

Premium staying the same after an income update is exactly what I was nervous about. Good to know the application income entry is what drives it and that you can verify what's actually sitting on your application versus what you think you entered.

0 coins

The eligibility results page in the account showed the updated household but the income figure it used for the APTC was the old one. Re-entering it fixed it, but I wouldn't have caught it without the representative confirming what number the application actually had.

0 coins

Happened with my renewal income update too. The account showed the new number in my profile but the APTC in the renewal notice was based on the prior year income. Entering the income update directly in the application flow, not just the account profile section, is what actually changes the APTC.

0 coins

Are cost-sharing reductions tied to the same income and household calculation as the APTC, or are they figured separately? Asking because my income is in the range where I should be getting Enhanced Silver cost-sharing reductions but my plan summary doesn't mention them.

0 coins

Cost-sharing reductions and the APTC come from the same eligibility calculation — both depend on household income and size relative to the FPL. But cost-sharing reductions only apply if you're enrolled in a Silver plan and your income is at 250% FPL or below. If your income is in that range and you're on Silver, the eligibility results in your account should show which Enhanced Silver tier you qualify for.

0 coins

Eligibility results page in the account shows my income at 240% FPL and I'm on a Silver plan. Looking at the results more carefully, it does say Enhanced Silver 87 — I think the plan summary on the insurance company's end just doesn't label it that way. The deductibles shown are lower than a standard Silver plan, so it probably is applied.

0 coins

Enhanced Silver cost-sharing reductions are built into the plan at enrollment. The insurance company applies them through the lower deductibles and copays, so the plan itself reflects the reduction even if it's not labeled 'Enhanced Silver 87' on your member materials. The Covered California eligibility results page is where the designation is confirmed.

0 coins

Has anyone had to deal with the 1095-A showing the wrong premium amount after a mid-year household change like this? I'm already thinking about tax season and whether the form will correctly reflect the household change month by month.

0 coins

Form 1095-A shows each month's coverage, the benchmark premium used for APTC calculation, and the actual APTC paid. If the household change took effect in October, the monthly columns should show different APTC amounts for the months before and after. If the form looks like it's using the wrong household for the wrong months, there's a dispute form on Covered California's site.

0 coins

Good to know the dispute option exists. I won't worry about it until the form actually arrives in January, but I want to know what to look for — specifically that October onward shows the new household size and adjusted APTC.

0 coins

My 1095-A from two years ago had one month showing the full premium before my husband's Medicare change took effect and then lower APTC for the remaining months. That's what yours should look like, and it was correct — it looked confusing at first glance.

0 coins

Medi-Cal handled my husband when I reported he had turned 65 and gone on Medicare. Wait — actually Covered California handled removing him from the plan, but the county Medi-Cal office was involved because we had kids on Medi-Cal at the same time. I keep mixing up which office handles what in a mixed household.

0 coins

In a mixed-program household, Covered California handles everything for the people enrolled in a Covered California plan, and the county Medi-Cal office handles the people on Medi-Cal. Covered California doesn't manage the Medi-Cal side. So removing your spouse from the Covered California plan goes through Covered California, while changes affecting the kids on Medi-Cal go through the county.

0 coins

That's the distinction I kept confusing. The county office handles the Medi-Cal renewals for the kids, which come on their own schedule, and Covered California handles my plan. They don't cross over except that the one application checks both when you first enroll.

0 coins

The separate renewal timelines are what confuse most people. Covered California renewals open in October for the next year. Medi-Cal renewals come on the household's anniversary date through the year. They're on totally different clocks.

0 coins

For anyone getting ready for the open enrollment renewal with a spouse who moved to Medicare this year: before the renewal deadline, update the income in the account to reflect the first full year of whatever income they're now getting from Social Security and pension, compare plans in Shop and Compare with the updated household, and confirm that the enrolled plan for next year shows only the members you want on it. The renewal will default to auto-enrolling the same plan with whatever info is on file, so checking those things yourself is worth the 20 minutes.

0 coins

Wrote this down. Income update with current Social Security and pension amounts, Shop and Compare run with new household, review enrolled members on the renewal before deadline. This is what I needed to hear laid out that clearly.

0 coins

Adding one more: check the Enhanced Silver tier in eligibility results after the income update, because a mid-year change that you reported may have already shifted it, but the renewal may recalculate it again based on next year's income estimate. Better to know the tier before the renewal locks in.

0 coins

The renewal deadline varies and is in the notice Covered California sends. Missing it means the auto-enrollment takes over, which is fine if everything on the account is current and you want the same plan. Not fine if the household or income has changed.

0 coins

Social Security income question that comes up here: Social Security retirement income counts toward household income for the APTC calculation. SSDI also counts. SSI does not count. Worth knowing the difference if your spouse has any combination of these, since the account income entry has to reflect only the countable amounts.

0 coins

My husband has Social Security retirement and also a small SSDI payment left over from before he hit 65. Both count toward the household income I report to Covered California? Or just the Social Security retirement piece?

0 coins

Both are countable income for the Covered California household income calculation. Social Security benefits and SSDI both count. SSI is the one that doesn't. If he has all three, SSI would be excluded but the other two go in.

0 coins

Appreciate the clarification. I had been leaving the SSDI amount out because I wasn't sure, which means the income I reported to Covered California was probably understated. Going to update the account.

0 coins

Appeal option question: if Covered California's eligibility decision after my household update gives me a financial help amount that seems wrong, what are my options? I don't want to just accept a number that might be based on incorrect income or household size in the system.

0 coins

If you disagree with the eligibility decision after a household or income update, you generally have 90 days from the date Covered California mailed the eligibility decision to file an appeal. The appeal form is mailed in. Covered California may try to resolve it before it goes to a hearing. If it goes to a hearing, the California Department of Social Services sets it with an administrative law judge, usually by phone, and the process takes up to 90 days.

0 coins

Mailing the appeal form with a 90-day window from the mailed decision date is the key thing to know. I'll keep an eye on what the eligibility results show after my next update and go from there.

0 coins

Before appealing, also try the online complaint form if the issue is something like a data entry error or a discrepancy between what you entered and what shows in the eligibility results. Sometimes a service center call or a complaint resolves it faster than a formal appeal, and you still have the appeal window open.

0 coins

Finishing with what I think is the clearest way to explain the Medicare-spouse-and-subsidy situation: household size for FPL purposes includes the Medicare spouse even when they're not on the Covered California plan. Their income counts. Their Medicare premium does not reduce the income figure you enter in Covered California (that's a tax-filing question). They should stay listed as a household member. They should be removed from the enrolled plan. The number that changes is the enrolled household for plan purposes, not the tax household for income and FPL purposes. Those two numbers are allowed to be different and that's expected in this exact situation.

0 coins

Clearest summary in the whole thread. Saving this. Medicare spouse stays in household listing, income included, removed from enrolled plan only.

0 coins

Should probably be in the Covered California FAQ for people turning 65 during the year. This comes up constantly and the account itself doesn't explain it well.

0 coins

Certified enrollers handle this question regularly. If anyone is unsure how to enter it in the account, the Find an Enroller page on Covered California's site can connect you with someone who helps for free.

0 coins

Accurate summary. The two separate household counts — tax household for income and FPL, enrolled household for plan — trip up a lot of people and produce incorrect APTC amounts when the account isn't set up to reflect both correctly.

0 coins

Related posts

Covered California AI

Expert Assistant
Secure