Back to Arizona Unemployment

Khalid Howes

Unemployment weekly claim do I answer yes for lump sum severance pay on Arizona DES?

Okay so I got laid off from my logistics coordinator job about six weeks ago and finally got my UI claim approved after a two week wait. Everything was going smoothly until this week's claim and I got to that section asking about income received during the week. Here's my situation - my employer paid out my severance as one big lump sum payment right before I left, like literally my last day they handed me a check for 12 weeks worth of pay all at once. That was before I even filed my claim. Now I'm on week 4 of certifying and I keep second guessing myself on whether I should have reported that lump sum as income on my first weekly claim or what. The question on the weekly claim form asks if I received any wages or income during the claim week - does lump sum severance pay count as something I need to report? I don't want to trigger an overpayment situation down the road but I also don't want to mess up my current benefits by answering wrong now. Has anyone dealt with this exact scenario with Arizona DES?

Week 3 of my own claim when this exact thing tripped me up - severance reporting is genuinely confusing on the Arizona DES weekly certification and I think a lot of people get it wrong in both directions. What I eventually pieced together is that it depends on how your employer characterized the payment and whether it was tied to a specific number of weeks. If they told you it covers 12 weeks of pay, Arizona DES may consider that allocated across those 12 weeks rather than as a lump sum you just ignore. The tricky part is you said you got paid before you even filed, which creates a gray area about which claim weeks it technically applies to.

0 coins

My determination letter from DES is sitting in front of me and there's actually language in there about how 'wages are considered received in the week they are allocated to, not necessarily when paid' - at least that's how mine read. So the week you got the check might not even be the relevant question, it's more about what weeks the employer said the money covers.

0 coins

That allocation thing is exactly what's confusing me. My separation paperwork just calls it 'severance' and lists it as a lump sum with no breakdown by week. So does the absence of a week-by-week allocation mean it doesn't get assigned to specific weeks?

0 coins

mine said the same thing lump sum no allocation and i reported it on week 1 and they just deducted it from that one week's benefit. idk if that was right but nothing came of it so

0 coins

Two weeks into fighting this same question when my buddy told me about Claimyr - claimyr.com - basically it gets you through to an actual Arizona DES phone agent way faster than sitting on hold for 3 hours. There's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y and honestly for a question like this about lump sum severance you really want to hear the answer straight from DES rather than guessing. I called them through it and got an agent in like 20 minutes who walked me through exactly how to report my severance payment. Worth it just for the peace of mind on something that could affect your whole claim.

0 coins

Just pulled up that link and watched the video - I didn't know something like this existed. My last two attempts to call DES I got disconnected after waiting 45 minutes each time. Did the agent you talked to give you a definitive answer on whether the lump sum gets reported as a yes on the income question?

0 coins

The hold music at DES should be classified as a form of psychological torture at this point. I've been on hold three separate times this week trying to ask about my own claim situation. Might have to try this Claimyr thing.

0 coins

Does it matter what week you call through that? Like is there a better time to reach someone about weekly claim questions specifically

0 coins

Forty days into my own UI claim journey here and I want to push back a little on the idea that the lump sum just disappears because you got it before you filed. The $4,200 cutoff I ran into - well not exactly a cutoff but the amount that triggered my situation - was when DES started asking questions. Here's how the agent explained it to me: severance that is paid as wages in lieu of notice basically means your employer is saying 'you're still employed for X weeks, we're just not requiring you to come in.' That gets allocated week by week even if paid as a lump sum. But severance that's framed as a separation bonus or appreciation payment? That often gets treated differently. So what does your paperwork actually call it?

0 coins

Going back through my separation agreement right now - it says 'severance pay equal to 12 weeks of base salary' which honestly sounds like the first type you described. That's making me think I may have answered the weekly claim questions wrong this whole time.

0 coins

My separation docs said almost word for word the same thing as yours and DES told me it should have been reported across the 12 weeks. I had to file an amendment which was a whole process. Not trying to scare you but you might want to get ahead of it.

0 coins

wait so if it says 12 weeks of base salary does that mean you technically weren't eligible to collect UI for those 12 weeks? that seems really harsh for people who already lost their jobs

0 coins

So I'm on week 7 of my claim and went through the exact severance question situation back at the start. The number that shocked me when I finally understood the rule was the weekly benefit amount calculation - because if your severance per week is higher than your weekly benefit amount, you get zero UI for those allocated weeks. Zero. Not reduced. Zero. DES treats the allocated severance as wages for that week and if it exceeds your WBA you get nothing. For me that meant my first 8 weeks of UI were wiped out even though I had already been paid the lump sum months ago. The frustrating thing is you owe that money back if you already received benefits for those weeks.

0 coins

Okay this is making my stomach drop. If my weekly severance allocation would have been say $1,800 per week and my weekly benefit is around $240, I may have gotten benefits for 12 weeks I shouldn't have received anything for.

0 coins

Just got off the phone with Arizona DES - used Claimyr to get through actually - and confirmed that yes this is correct. The agent told me the same thing, severance described as X weeks of pay gets spread across those weeks and reduces or eliminates your benefit dollar for dollar. But she also said there's a process for voluntary repayment that's less painful than waiting for them to send you an overpayment notice. If you get ahead of it and contact them first it can go smoother.

0 coins

This whole thread is stressing me out because I've been in the same situation since week 1 of my claim and just answered no to the income question because the payment was before I filed. Now I'm realizing that might have been wrong.

0 coins

the system really should ask the question better if this many people are getting it wrong

0 coins

Deep in my own overpayment appeal when I want to share something actually useful I found out the hard way. I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to finally get through to DES and the agent told me something that changed my whole approach: Arizona DES has an online message system through the UIBS portal and you can actually send them a written question about how to report severance before you answer the weekly claim question. The agent said they prefer claimants ask first rather than guess wrong. If you document that you asked and they answered, you have a paper trail protecting you. The video at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y shows how to use Claimyr to reach them by phone too if the portal message takes too long.

0 coins

Sent a message through the UIBS portal about an hour ago asking specifically about my situation. Good call on creating a paper trail - I hadn't thought about that angle at all.

0 coins

My inbox on the portal had a response within 48 hours when I sent a question last month. So hopefully OP gets an answer before their next weekly certification deadline.

0 coins

Does the portal message go to an actual person or is it like an automated response system? Mine last time felt like a copy paste answer that didn't address my actual question at all

0 coins

Staring at my own week 6 certification screen and I want to add something that hasn't come up yet - the question on the weekly claim form specifically asks about wages 'earned or received' during the claim week. Arizona DES interprets 'earned' differently from 'received' for exactly this reason. Severance allocated to a specific week is considered earned during that week regardless of when you physically received the payment. That's why the date you got the check doesn't necessarily determine which weeks you report it.

0 coins

Reading the actual question on my weekly cert right now and you're right, it does say 'earned or received' - I definitely read it as just received and didn't think about the earned piece. This is a really important distinction.

0 coins

My first agent explained it this way too - think of it like if you work overtime in December but your company pays you in January, you still report those wages in December because that's when you earned them. Same logic applies to allocated severance, the earning period is what matters.

0 coins

ok but how are regular people supposed to know this without being told? the form doesn't explain the earned vs received thing at all

0 coins

Currently fighting an overpayment notice for $6,750 from last year and my situation started exactly like yours. The deadline that really matters that nobody told me about was the 30 day window to appeal an overpayment determination. If DES decides you owe money back and you disagree or want to explain the circumstances, you have 30 days from the date on that notice to file your appeal or you lose the right to contest it. I wish someone had told me that before I spent three weeks trying to call them about it and missed the window.

0 coins

Genuinely hoping I don't get to that point but writing down that 30 day appeal deadline just in case. Did you have documentation showing how your severance was described in your separation agreement?

0 coins

The 30 day window is brutal because DES can be impossible to reach during that exact period and you're trying to figure out what to do while the clock is running. Happened to my cousin too.

0 coins

Worth mentioning again that this is exactly why I ended up using Claimyr when I got my own overpayment notice - I couldn't afford to waste any of those 30 days on failed phone attempts. Getting through to an agent quickly genuinely matters when you're on a deadline like that.

0 coins

Also document everything in writing if you do decide to appeal. Phone calls are helpful but the written record through the portal or certified mail is what actually protects you in a hearing.

0 coins

week 2 when i got my claim started and my old job gave me severance i just reported it all on week 1 and took the hit for that week. my benefit was like $310 a week and the severance chunk reduced it to basically nothing for week 1. but then weeks 2 through 8 were fine and i got my full benefit. idk if that was technically right but des never came back at me about it. i only got one week's worth of severance tho so maybe that's different from 12 weeks.

0 coins

One week of severance reported in a single week is probably fine since there's a clear one to one match. The 12 week situation is more complicated because you can't just dump all 12 weeks of wages onto week 1, that's not how DES handles it.

0 coins

My severance was two weeks and I did the same thing as you, reported it week 1 and week 2 and then things went back to normal. For a small number of weeks it seems manageable.

0 coins

Literally got a letter from DES two months ago about this exact issue and I want to clear up something I've seen getting confused in this thread. DES doesn't automatically catch severance reporting errors right away - there's often a lag of several months between when you file incorrect weekly claims and when they reconcile with your employer's records and issue an overpayment notice. So don't assume you're in the clear just because nothing happened yet.

0 coins

How long did it take from your incorrect filings to when you got the letter?

0 coins

My separation was in January, I filed for UI in February, the overpayment letter came in October. Eight months later. I had totally moved on by then and it was a shock to see it in the mailbox.

0 coins

Eight months?? That's terrifying honestly. I would have assumed I was fine by then.

0 coins

this is why i'm paranoid about every single question on the weekly cert even after a year of doing it

0 coins

Just passed week 10 on my current claim and want to bring up something adjacent - if you do end up with an overpayment situation and it was an honest mistake (not fraud), DES has a waiver process where you can request they forgive the debt if repaying it would cause financial hardship. It's not guaranteed but especially for people who answered the question incorrectly because the form is genuinely confusing, it's worth asking about. I successfully got a partial waiver on mine after explaining I was living on the UI benefits and had no savings to repay.

0 coins

I didn't know the waiver option existed. That's actually really helpful to know in case this does turn into an overpayment situation for me. What was the process for requesting it?

0 coins

You have to file the waiver request along with your appeal or as a separate form. I found the form through the UIBS portal but I'd recommend calling to confirm the right form number since things change. The waiver basically asks you to show income, expenses, and why repayment would be a hardship.

0 coins

My case worker mentioned the waiver option to me too and said genuinely it doesn't hurt to ask for it. Worst case they say no and you still owe the money.

0 coins

Starting week 1 of a new claim after getting laid off from construction management when I discovered both this thread and Claimyr on the same day, which feels like a sign. The video at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y finally explained to me what Claimyr does and I ended up using it to call DES before I ever submitted my first weekly certification. Specifically asked the agent about my severance situation - I got two weeks paid out as a lump sum. She confirmed I should report it on weeks 1 and 2 of my claim as income and that my benefits would be reduced or eliminated those weeks accordingly. Getting that answer before filing saved me from exactly the situation OP is describing. Claimyr.com is the site if anyone wants to skip the guessing game.

0 coins

Calling before submitting is the right call and I really wish I'd done that four weeks ago. Live and learn I guess. At least I'm dealing with it now rather than when I get a letter out of nowhere.

0 coins

My phone screen has the DES number saved with a little skull emoji next to it because every time I call it's a battle to get through. Might have to try a different approach.

0 coins

Calling first is honestly the best advice in this whole thread. The weekly certification questions look simple but there are like six different ways to interpret the income question alone.

0 coins

About halfway through my benefit year right now and wanted to add that the job search requirement doesn't pause or change based on severance reporting issues - you still have to do your four job search activities every week even during weeks where your benefit might be reduced to zero because of allocated severance. I forgot about this and missed a week of job searches thinking it didn't matter since I wasn't getting paid that week. Got a nasty note from DES about it.

0 coins

Oh I definitely have been keeping up with my job search log every week regardless. Good call flagging that though because it's the kind of thing that could slip through the cracks when you're stressed about the financial stuff.

0 coins

The job search requirement is one of those things DES enforces pretty strictly and inconsistently - some people slip through, others get a determination notice asking for proof. Always better to have your log complete and documented.

0 coins

My job search log is basically a second job at this point, keeping it updated and formatted right. Four activities a week adds up over a full benefit year.

0 coins

on week 5 currently and reading all this is genuinely terrifying. i also got severance but it was just called 'payment for unused PTO' - is that treated the same way as severance for the weekly claim income question?

0 coins

Unused PTO payout is actually treated differently in most cases - it's typically considered a lump sum payment for accrued benefit time and not allocated across future weeks the same way severance pay is. But you should absolutely confirm this with DES directly because individual circumstances can vary and I'm not an expert just someone who went through a similar question.

0 coins

My PTO payout question got a different answer than my severance question when I asked DES - the agent was clear they're separate categories. PTO is generally reported as income in the week you receive it rather than allocated forward.

0 coins

okay that's slightly less terrifying. i reported my pto in week 1 and nothing happened so maybe i'm okay. still stressed though

0 coins

In the middle of my appeal process right now and honestly this thread has been more useful than anything on the actual DES website. Their FAQ page has like four sentences about severance and none of them address the lump sum allocation question directly. It's almost like they want people to mess it up.

0 coins

My exact frustration with the DES website is that everything is written in bureaucratic language that doesn't actually explain what a regular person needs to do in a specific situation. The FAQ could be ten times more helpful with a few real examples.

0 coins

The appeals packet I received had more detail about the rules than anything else I found during the entire claim process. Kind of absurd that you have to get into trouble before the system actually explains itself clearly.

0 coins

i learned more from this thread in 20 minutes than from an hour on the des website, that's just the reality

0 coins

Just hit week 8 of my claim and want to circle back to the original question because I think it got a little buried in all the detail. For the specific weekly claim question about whether to answer yes for lump sum severance - the short answer is yes if the severance is described in terms of weeks of pay. The form question about income during the claim week applies to wages earned in that week even if paid earlier, and severance that's described as X weeks of salary is considered earned week by week. That's the core of it. Everything else in this thread about timing and allocation is just the nuance around that basic yes.

0 coins

Appreciate the summary - it's been helpful to get all the context but you're right that the core answer is probably just yes and then figuring out how to handle the allocation timing. I've sent my portal message and I'll call DES if I don't hear back in 48 hours.

0 coins

this is the tldr version the thread needed lol

0 coins

Even the 'short answer' has exceptions though lol. If the severance is a fixed amount not tied to weeks it might be different. This system really is a lot.

0 coins

Received my first determination letter at week 3 of a previous claim and reading this thread I realize how lucky I was that my severance question was simple - my employer actually wrote in the separation paperwork 'this payment is not wages and is not allocated to any specific week of unemployment.' Apparently that specific language is a magic phrase that means DES can't allocate it. I had no idea my employer had done me that favor until an agent pointed it out.

0 coins

Okay going back through my paperwork one more time - my document does not have anything like that language. It just says severance pay equal to 12 weeks salary. No explicit statement that it's not wages.

0 coins

That language from your employer is rare and genuinely helpful. Most employers don't think to include it and HR departments often don't know it matters. Worth asking your former employer to issue an amended letter if they're willing.

0 coins

My HR person at my old job didn't even know what I was talking about when I asked about the allocation language. Had to send them a link to the Arizona DES employer handbook before they understood what I needed.

0 coins

Week 11 and finally feeling like I understand this process. For anyone just finding this thread - the thing that helped me most was printing out my weekly certification confirmation pages every single week so I had a record of exactly what I reported. When DES later asked me questions about my severance reporting I could show them exactly what I entered and when. No documentation is a nightmare in that situation.

0 coins

Starting to do this going forward - taking screenshots of every weekly cert confirmation screen. I wish I had been doing it from week 1 but better late than never.

0 coins

The confirmation screen disappears pretty fast and there's no way to go back and see it later in the portal as far as I know. Screenshots are the only way to keep a record. Good habit to start immediately.

0 coins

My phone has a folder called DES paperwork that is now about 300 screenshots deep. Future me will thank past me if anything ever goes sideways.

0 coins

Just submitted week 5 of my own claim and sitting here anxious about my previous four weeks because of this whole discussion. I did the same thing the original poster did - got a lump sum severance before I filed and answered no to the income question every week because I thought 'I already got paid before I even started filing so it doesn't apply.' Now I'm not sure.

0 coins

The key thing to do right now is not wait for DES to find the error - contact them proactively and ask. They generally treat honest self-reported mistakes more favorably than errors they catch themselves. It doesn't guarantee anything but it matters.

0 coins

My claim specialist actually said the same thing to me - 'coming to us is better than us coming to you' was more or less how she put it. For genuine mistakes that matters a lot.

0 coins

Proactive contact saved me a lot of additional penalties on my overpayment situation - I got a 10% penalty reduction for voluntary disclosure compared to what my appeals officer said the standard assessment would have been.

0 coins

Okay sending a portal message right now. This thread convinced me to stop waiting and see.

0 coins

Coming back to update everyone - I heard back from DES through the portal message about 36 hours after I sent it. The response confirmed that my severance described as '12 weeks of base salary' should indeed have been reported across those 12 weeks of my claim. They directed me to contact their overpayment unit to work out a voluntary repayment arrangement before they issue a formal notice. The agent I spoke to on the phone was actually really helpful once I got through - I ended up using Claimyr on day 2 when the portal message came back with a next step I didn't understand, and got connected to an actual overpayment specialist within half an hour. It's not a fun situation to be in but I feel way better having actual information than I did spinning out about it for weeks. Thanks everyone for the help on this thread.

0 coins

My bank account is set up for hardship so I know the stress of owing money back to DES. Really glad you got a clear answer and are getting ahead of it - voluntary contact before an overpayment notice really does tend to go better. Good luck with the repayment process.

0 coins

The fact that you got a response within 36 hours through the portal is honestly impressive - mine took closer to a week. Must have been the specific nature of the question. Glad you have a path forward.

0 coins

Thank you for coming back with the update. So many threads on here just end with the question hanging. Hoping the repayment process goes smoothly for you.

0 coins

If the repayment amount creates a financial hardship don't forget about the waiver option I mentioned earlier. Good luck.

0 coins

Arizona Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure