Back to Arizona Unemployment

Ingrid Larsson

Received both approved and denied letters unemployment what to do next?

So I'm sitting here with two completely contradictory pieces of mail from Arizona DES and honestly I don't even know where to start. Got laid off from my warehouse job about six weeks ago after they cut our whole shift, filed my UI claim pretty much right away. Everything seemed to be moving along fine — I even got a letter saying my claim was approved and my weekly benefit amount would be around $285. Then three days later a SECOND letter shows up saying my claim has been denied due to a separation issue. Same claim number on both letters, same dates referenced. I've been filing my weekly claims this whole time assuming the approval was the right one, but now I'm terrified I've been certifying for weeks on a claim that might be considered denied and I'm going to end up with some massive overpayment bill. Has anyone else run into this situation where Arizona DES sends out conflicting correspondence? Do I appeal the denial even though I also have an approval? Do I stop filing weekly claims? I genuinely have no idea which letter is the real one and the CACTUS portal just shows my account as 'pending' which is not helpful at all. Any guidance would be hugely appreciated because I'm completely lost here.

Claimyr actually saved me when I had a similarly confusing situation with Arizona DES last year — two letters, completely different outcomes, and the online portal showing something that matched neither of them. What finally cleared it up was getting an actual DES agent on the phone who could pull up my full claim history and tell me exactly which determination was the controlling one. The problem is getting through to Arizona DES by phone is basically impossible if you just dial and wait. I used a service called Claimyr (claimyr.com) that gets you connected to a live Arizona DES agent without you sitting on hold for hours. There's a demo video at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y that shows how it works. For a situation like yours where two letters are saying opposite things, you really need a human being at DES to tell you which determination is active — no website or letter is going to sort that out for you reliably.

0 coins

Good point about needing a real person. The portal almost never reflects the actual current status when there's a conflict between determinations, in my experience it just picks one and shows that without explanation.

0 coins

Thanks, will check that out. My bigger worry right now is whether the weekly claims I already filed are going to count against me if the denial turns out to be the one that sticks.

0 coins

Same thing happened to my brother-in-law last spring, the portal showed pending for almost three weeks while both letters just sat there being contradictory. He ended up having to request a formal status review.

0 coins

Two letters arriving days apart usually points to what happened in your situation — your base period wages from the warehouse job qualified you for benefits financially, so the system auto-generated an approval, but then a claims examiner separately flagged the reason you left or were separated and issued a disqualification. Your weekly benefit amount and the monetary eligibility part are determined almost separately from whether the separation itself qualifies. So you can have both letters be technically 'correct' about different things, which is incredibly confusing but unfortunately pretty normal with Arizona DES.

0 coins

Okay so they're addressing different pieces of my claim — that actually makes a little more sense now. Does the denial letter override the approval then, or is it the other way around?

0 coins

This is exactly right. Monetary determination and separation determination are two distinct processes. The monetary one just looks at your earnings history, the separation one looks at why you're no longer working. A denial on separation will block payment even if the monetary side is fully approved.

0 coins

Wish someone had explained this to me when I first filed, would have saved me about two weeks of panicking about which letter was real.

0 coins

Since you mentioned your whole shift got cut — that's actually a really important detail for how Arizona DES will classify your separation. Being laid off due to a business reduction is very different from a quit or a discharge for cause. If the denial letter cites a 'separation issue,' it might mean DES received different information from your former employer about why you stopped working. Employers sometimes report separations inaccurately, either accidentally or not, and that can trigger a disqualification even when you were clearly laid off. The denial letter should have a specific reason code or explanation somewhere on it — what does it say as the basis for the denial?

0 coins

Mine says something about 'voluntary quit without good cause' which is completely wrong, I was laid off, they eliminated the entire third shift.

0 coins

That right there tells you exactly what happened — your employer reported the separation incorrectly to DES. This is fixable but you do need to appeal and provide documentation showing the layoff was employer-initiated. A termination letter, an email from HR, your final pay stub showing the shift elimination, anything like that will help your case significantly.

0 coins

Voluntary quit is one of the most common wrong codes employers submit, it's almost like they don't understand the difference or they just pick whatever reduces their unemployment tax rate.

0 coins

Definitely appeal the denial, do not wait on that. Arizona DES gives you 15 calendar days from the date on the denial letter to file your appeal and that clock doesn't stop ticking just because you also have an approval letter. If you miss the appeal window you lose the right to contest that specific determination and things get way more complicated. You can file the appeal through the CACTUS portal under the appeals section or mail it in but portal is faster.

0 coins

Fifteen days feels really short — my denial letter is already dated eight days ago. I need to move on this today.

0 coins

Claimyr is worth using specifically for this timeline situation — when I was in a similar crunch trying to reach Arizona DES before an appeal deadline, dialing direct was taking 2-3 hours just to get to a queue, and I kept getting disconnected. Claimyr connected me to an actual agent who confirmed my appeal had been received and was in the system. Check claimyr.com or the video at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y, it's the fastest way to get a human at DES when you're racing a deadline.

0 coins

Eight days gone out of fifteen is cutting it very close. File the appeal today through the portal if at all possible, don't wait until you've sorted everything else out.

0 coins

Keep filing your weekly claims throughout all of this — that part is crucial. Even if the denial is the controlling determination right now, stopping your weekly certifications means you permanently lose those weeks and cannot get them back even if your appeal succeeds. Arizona DES can only pay you retroactively for weeks you properly certified, so an uncertified week is a forfeited week regardless of how your appeal turns out.

0 coins

Really glad someone said this clearly. So file the appeal AND keep certifying weekly, got it.

0 coins

This is the most important practical advice in this whole thread. The number of people who stop certifying while their appeal is pending and then win the appeal but can't get paid for those weeks is genuinely heartbreaking.

0 coins

Continuing to certify doesn't mean you'll get paid during the appeal period, the payments will just be held, but at least the weeks are preserved on your record if the appeal goes your way.

0 coins

Your situation with the layoff being coded as a voluntary quit — when you write your appeal statement, focus entirely on the specific circumstances of how the shift elimination happened. Things like whether you received written notice of the layoff, whether HR communicated it to your whole shift at once, whether anyone else from your shift also filed for unemployment, whether you had any choice in the matter at all. DES appeal examiners want a clear factual picture of exactly what your employer did, not just 'I disagree with the denial.' The more concrete details you give them about those last days at the warehouse, the stronger your position.

0 coins

Makes sense to be specific rather than just general. I do have a group text from our shift supervisor announcing the cuts, would that count as documentation?

0 coins

A group text from the supervisor announcing the shift elimination is actually solid evidence — it shows the decision came from the company side and was communicated to multiple employees. Screenshot it and include it with your appeal. If you can also get anyone else from that shift to submit a brief statement corroborating the layoff, that's additional support.

0 coins

Group texts, emails, any written communication from management about the reduction are all useful. The key is showing DES that you didn't choose to leave — the employer removed your position.

0 coins

Something nobody mentioned yet — once you file the appeal, you'll eventually get a hearing notice with a date and time for a telephone hearing in front of an appeals officer. It's not in-person, just a phone call, but it's a real proceeding where both you and your former employer can present your side. Arizona DES takes these hearings seriously and the employer often participates to defend their separation report. Prepare like it matters because it does.

0 coins

Didn't realize the employer could be on the call too — that changes how I need to prepare.

0 coins

Yes, employers definitely show up to appeal hearings, especially when it involves a separation determination because it affects their UI tax rate if you win. Bring every piece of documentation you have and be ready to walk through the timeline of exactly what happened leading up to your last day.

0 coins

The telephone hearing format can feel informal but treat it like a formal proceeding. Answer questions directly, stay factual, don't editorialize. Appeals officers hear dozens of these cases and they respond well to claimants who are organized and specific.

0 coins

Just want to address the overpayment fear directly since you mentioned it in your original post. If you've been certifying weekly and you haven't actually received any payments yet — which sounds like it might be the case since the portal shows pending — you won't have an overpayment situation because no money has actually been disbursed. Overpayments happen when funds are released and then later determined to have been improper. If everything is sitting in pending status while DES sorts out the conflict, the payments are simply on hold, not an overpayment.

0 coins

That's a relief — the portal does show pending with no payment activity, so it sounds like nothing has actually been sent out yet.

0 coins

Pending with no payment activity is actually the safest place to be in this scenario. It means DES has flagged the conflict themselves and held the funds pending resolution. Your appeal will determine whether and when those weeks get paid out.

0 coins

Had a nearly identical scenario last year — pending status, conflicting letters, employer misreporting. Used Claimyr to reach a DES agent who explained that the pending hold was actually protecting me from an overpayment while the appeal was open. The site is claimyr.com and the walkthrough video is at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y — having an agent explain the pending status directly was way more reassuring than trying to guess from the portal.

0 coins

For your appeal statement itself — write it like you're explaining the situation to someone who wasn't there and knows nothing about your workplace. Start with the date your employer notified the shift about the cuts, describe what your supervisor actually said or sent, explain that you had no option to transfer to another shift or position, confirm your last day, and state clearly that you did not resign or quit. Short, chronological, factual. Avoid emotional language even though the situation is frustrating.

0 coins

Short and factual, I can do that — my instinct was to write a long emotional explanation but that probably wouldn't help.

0 coins

Long emotional appeals often actually hurt claimants because the appeals officer has to dig through the emotion to find the facts. Bullet points with dates and specific events are much more effective than paragraphs of frustration.

0 coins

Before your appeal hearing, it's worth trying to get through to an Arizona DES agent to confirm that your appeal was received in their system and to ask whether the conflicting determinations have any notes attached explaining the discrepancy. I had a situation where I filed an appeal but it sat unacknowledged for over a week because of a processing backlog. I ended up using Claimyr at claimyr.com — the video demo is at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y — and within about twenty minutes I was talking to a live agent who confirmed my appeal was logged and explained what to expect next. For something with competing letters on the same claim number, having that verbal confirmation from DES is worth a lot.

0 coins

Confirming the appeal is actually in their system before the deadline passes sounds like a smart move — I'd hate to file it and have it fall through a crack.

0 coins

Appeals do occasionally get lost or not properly linked to the right claim, especially when there's already a conflict in the system. Verifying by phone that it's attached to your specific claim number is not paranoid, it's just being thorough.

0 coins

When you do reach an agent, ask them to confirm both the appeal receipt date and that it's tied to the correct determination — the denial one, not the approval. Getting the appeal linked to the wrong letter is a thing that apparently can happen.

0 coins

Something worth knowing about the CACTUS portal when you have dual determinations — the status displayed isn't always the most recent determination, it can sometimes reflect whichever determination processed last in the queue. So 'pending' on the portal might actually be the system's way of saying 'we see a conflict and we're not showing either result until it's resolved.' Don't read the portal as confirmation of either the approval or the denial being the final answer.

0 coins

Good to know the portal isn't reliable as a tiebreaker — I had been checking it obsessively hoping one letter would become the clearly displayed status.

0 coins

The portal is useful for filing weekly certifications and checking payment history once payments start, but for understanding the status of a conflicted determination it really is just not designed to show you what you need to see. That's why phone contact with an actual agent matters so much in situations like this.

0 coins

I spent two weeks refreshing the portal waiting for it to tell me something definitive and it never did. The resolution only became clear after speaking to someone directly.

0 coins

After your appeal is filed, the typical timeline in Arizona is that you'll receive the hearing notice about two to three weeks out, the hearing itself will happen, and then the appeals officer's written decision usually comes within a week or two after that. Total timeline from filing your appeal to getting a decision is often six to eight weeks. During all of that time, keep certifying every single week without fail.

0 coins

Six to eight weeks is longer than I was expecting but at least now I know what I'm looking at.

0 coins

The timeline can vary, sometimes it's faster, occasionally it stretches longer if the appeals docket is backed up. But certifying weekly throughout the entire process — through the hearing date, through the decision — is non-negotiable if you want to actually collect what you're owed.

0 coins

Keep a written log of every week you certify, including the date you submitted and confirmation numbers if the portal gives them. If there's ever a dispute later about whether you certified a particular week, having your own records is invaluable.

0 coins

One more thing that might matter depending on how your appeal goes — if you win and the denial gets overturned, Arizona DES should release payments for all the weeks you've been certifying since the denial date, going back retroactively. That can add up to a significant amount depending on how long the appeal process takes. So the weekly certifications you're doing right now aren't just about future payments, they represent real money you could receive in a lump or series of payments once the appeal decision comes through.

0 coins

Hadn't thought about the retroactive piece — that's actually a meaningful amount of money if the appeal takes two months to resolve.

0 coins

Retroactive payment after a successful appeal is real and it does happen. I got about seven weeks of back-payments when my appeal went through. DES released them all within about ten days of the written decision coming out.

0 coins

The release of retroactive weeks after an appeal win isn't instant sometimes — make sure you haven't missed any weekly certifications during the entire appeal period because they won't pay for uncertified weeks even retroactively. Every week needs its own certification on file.

0 coins

Don't overlook getting your documentation together now even before the hearing notice arrives. Things disappear — text messages get deleted, email inboxes get cleaned out, coworkers' contact information gets lost. Collect everything that shows the layoff was employer-initiated right now while it's fresh: supervisor messages, HR communications, your termination paperwork if you got any, your final pay stubs, the names and phone numbers of coworkers who were also laid off in the same reduction.

0 coins

Good call to do this now — I still have everything but I hadn't thought to actually compile it somewhere organized.

0 coins

Create a folder right now, digital or physical, specifically for the appeal. Every document, every screenshot, every note. Appeals examiners sometimes ask for documentation to be faxed or emailed within a short window and scrambling to find things at that point adds unnecessary stress.

0 coins

Pulling together what everyone's said — your plan from here: file the appeal today before the 15-day window closes, keep certifying every week throughout the process, gather your layoff documentation now, and try to reach a DES agent by phone to confirm the appeal is linked to your claim. The conflicting letters aren't a sign that your case is hopeless, it's actually a fairly common DES administrative situation and appeals examiners are very familiar with employer misreporting cases involving shift eliminations.

0 coins

This thread has been genuinely helpful — I went from completely panicking to having an actual action list. Filing the appeal today.

0 coins

Good luck — employer misreporting cases where the whole shift was cut are usually strong appeals because there's no plausible argument that an entire shift voluntarily quit simultaneously. Document everything and you're in a solid position.

0 coins

Come back and update when you hear something — these threads help future claimants who end up in the same situation searching for answers.

0 coins

Arizona Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure