Back to Arizona Unemployment

Esmeralda Gómez

Must you seek work unemployment "union" members still have to do in Arizona DES?

So I've been a union carpenter for about 11 years and just got laid off two months ago from a commercial construction project that wrapped up early. My union hall is handling dispatch and I'm on the out-of-work list waiting for the next referral to come through. Filed with Arizona DES and everything looked fine at first, then I get this notice asking me to verify my job search activities. Here's where I'm confused — my union has a hiring hall system. I don't just go apply at random construction companies because that's literally not how union work operates. If I did that I'd be taking non-union jobs and potentially violating my membership obligations. Does Arizona DES actually require union members to do the standard 3-employer-contacts-per-week thing even when you're registered with a union hall waiting on dispatch? I feel like the system wasn't designed with union workers in mind at all. My claim is currently processing and I've been doing my weekly certifications but I honestly don't know if I'm answering the job search questions correctly. Anyone who's been through this as a union member please help me out.

Week 6 of my own claim right now so this is fresh for me — I went through almost the exact same thing as a union electrician. The short version is that Arizona DES does have a provision for union members but you have to actually request it and it's not automatic. What happened in my case was I called and explained the hiring hall situation and they flagged my account for what's essentially a union standby exemption. You still have to certify every week but the job search log requirements work differently. Your union registration counts as your active job search as long as you can show you're on the out-of-work list and in good standing with the hall. The key thing is getting that documentation from your union business rep — a letter on union letterhead confirming you're registered for dispatch. Without that letter on file with Arizona DES, the system just sees you as a regular claimant and flags you for the standard contacts requirement.

0 coins

The letter from the business rep — did you have to submit that through the CACTUS portal or mail it in? I'm trying to figure out the fastest way to get this updated before my next weekly cert is due.

0 coins

Same thing came up for a buddy of mine in the pipefitters union, the letter was the magic piece that made everything click into place for his claim status.

0 coins

I uploaded mine through the CACTUS document upload section. Took about 4 business days to show as received on my end. Mail would probably work but I didn't want to risk the delay.

0 coins

Just got my adjudication cleared last week after dealing with this exact confusion for two months. The union hiring hall question trips up a LOT of people because the Arizona DES weekly cert questions ask if you 'actively sought work' and if you say no because you're waiting on hall dispatch, the system can flag you automatically. What you're supposed to do is answer YES to seeking work because being registered and available through your union hall DOES count as seeking work under Arizona DES rules — you just have to understand how they define it. The mistake I made was overthinking it and answering no, which kicked my claim into adjudication and delayed everything by 6 weeks.

0 coins

Six weeks is brutal. So your interpretation is that checking in with the hall or maintaining your dispatch registration counts as the 'work search' activity for that week?

0 coins

This matches what I've heard too but I'd want to verify with an actual DES rep before relying on it, the weekly cert questions are worded in a way that's genuinely confusing for non-traditional employment situations.

0 coins

Exactly right — any active step you take to pursue work through the union system qualifies. Calling the hall, updating your availability, attending a referral meeting, all of that documents as search activity in my experience.

0 coins

Genuinely did not know this was even a thing. I thought all claimants had the same requirements regardless of employment type.

0 coins

Three weeks into my own adjudication mess when I finally got through to an actual Arizona DES agent and got real answers on this. The only reason I reached an agent at all was because I used Claimyr — it basically works the hold line for you so you end up actually speaking with someone at Arizona DES instead of sitting on hold for 3 hours and getting disconnected. Site is claimyr.com and there's a demo video at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y if you want to see what it does before trying it. What the agent told me directly about union members: Arizona DES recognizes union hiring hall registration as satisfying the work search requirement under a specific provision, but your claim has to be properly coded for it. If it's not coded right in their system you'll keep getting flagged even if you're doing everything correctly. The agent added a note to my account and the flags stopped after my next certification.

0 coins

Properly' coded is exactly the kind of thing I would never know to ask about. That explains so much about why some union members have problems and others sail right through — it probably comes down to whether whoever processed the initial claim knew to set thatup.

0 coins

The hold times are genuinely insane right now. Three hours and disconnected sounds about right for my experience trying to reach anyone at Arizona DES.

0 coins

The agent I spoke with was actually really helpful once I got through. She pulled up my claim right there and fixed the coding issue in maybe 10 minutes. The hard part was just physically getting to that conversation.

0 coins

Had no idea there was a coding difference on the backend for different claimant types. This thread is genuinely eye-opening.

0 coins

My dispatch card has been active through my union hall for going on 8 years, laid off twice during that stretch, so I've navigated this twice now with Arizona DES. First time I had no idea about any of this and my claim got disqualified because I answered the job search questions wrong. Had to appeal, took 11 weeks before I saw any money. Second time around I went in knowing what to do. Here's what I'd tell anyone in a union situation: before you even start the weekly certs, call Arizona DES and explicitly tell them you are a union member with active hiring hall registration and ask them to note it on your claim. Do not wait for them to figure it out. The system is not set up to automatically recognize union work structures so you have to flag it yourself from day one.

0 coins

11 weeks with no money is not something I can survive right now. I need to get ahead of this before it becomes that situation.

0 coins

Twice through this process — that takes some serious patience. The fact that nothing changed between your first and second experience with Arizona DES shows how little the system learns from these cases.

0 coins

It really doesn't change. The rules exist but the front-line system doesn't apply them unless you push. Second time I was on the phone before I even submitted my first weekly cert and it made all the difference.

0 coins

Finishing up my UI claim actually this week — 26 weeks done. I'm a union ironworker and went through the job search question situation early on. What I learned pretty quickly is that there are two different things people conflate: the work search requirement itself, and whether your specific union activities satisfy it. Arizona DES says you need to show you're taking active steps to find employment. For union members with a functioning hall dispatch system, those steps look different than for someone applying to jobs on Indeed. Registering with the hall, keeping your dues current so you stay eligible for referrals, responding when the hall reaches out about available work — all of that is your active search. The confusion happens because the weekly cert interface was clearly designed with non-union employment in mind and there's no union-specific option in the dropdown.

0 coins

The dropdown thing is what gets me. I'm looking at these options and none of them map cleanly onto what I actually do to pursue work through my union.

0 coins

26 weeks and done — congratulations honestly. And that point about the interface design is so accurate, it assumes everyone is on job boards sending out resumes.

0 coins

For what it's worth, I just selected the closest matching option each week and kept a separate personal log of my actual union-related job search steps in case I ever got audited. Never did but felt better having it.

0 coins

The separate personal log is smart. Arizona DES can request documentation going back quite a ways if something triggers a review.

0 coins

Just got a letter from Arizona DES last Tuesday asking me to verify my job search activities for weeks 4 through 7 of my claim. I'm a union plumber and I'm panicking a little reading this thread. Does anyone know if this verification letter is the same thing as being put in adjudication or is it a different process? I've been answering the weekly certs the same way everyone here is describing — noting my hall registration and availability — but now I'm wondering if I did something wrong.

0 coins

Tuesday's letter sounds like a routine audit rather than a full adjudication trigger, at least based on what mine looked like. The audit letter asks for documentation but doesn't freeze your payments the way adjudication does. Do your payments still show as scheduled?

0 coins

Payments are still scheduled so far, nothing has changed on the CACTUS portal yet. That's slightly reassuring.

0 coins

The verification letter and adjudication are different tracks. Verification is basically Arizona DES spot-checking your records. If you have your hall paperwork in order you should be fine responding to it. Adjudication is when they actually freeze things pending a determination.

0 coins

Okay that distinction helps a lot. I'm going to get the letter from my business agent this week and respond to the verification request with that attached.

0 coins

About 4 months ago I was in adjudication for 7 weeks over this exact union work search issue before I finally got it resolved. What finally moved things was talking to an actual agent who understood the union hiring hall provision and updated my file. I'd tried the portal messages for weeks with no response. Someone in another thread pointed me to Claimyr and I'll be honest I was skeptical at first, but I ended up speaking with an Arizona DES agent the same day I tried it. That agent is the one who fixed the coding on my account and cleared the adjudication. No magic, just finally got to the right person. claimyr.com if anyone needs it.

0 coins

Seven weeks in adjudication and portal messages going nowhere — that's the nightmare scenario I'm trying to avoid. Glad you got it sorted eventually.

0 coins

The portal messages are genuinely a black hole in my experience. I've sent three with no response and I'm only on week 2 of my claim.

0 coins

Don't rely on portal messages for anything time-sensitive is my takeaway. They might eventually respond but the timeline is unpredictable and meanwhile your claim just sits there.

0 coins

4 months ago the wait times were especially brutal from what I remember. I think there was some system update that created a backlog around that period.

0 coins

My first week back on a job site in a while — just got a referral through the hall and my claim is wrapping up. Wanted to come back and add something for the thread since I went through the whole union job search question situation from start to finish. The thing nobody tells you upfront is that 'seeking work' under Arizona DES for union members basically means you have to show you haven't just parked yourself and stopped trying. Even with hall dispatch, Arizona DES wants to see that you're still engaged — updating your availability status with the hall, taking any referral calls that come in, not turning down work without a valid reason. If you get a referral and turn it down without good cause, that can be a separate issue entirely for your claim, different from the job search question.

0 coins

The turning-down-work piece is something I hadn't even thought about. What counts as 'good cause' for declining a referral in Arizona DES's view?

0 coins

From what I understand, things like the wage being significantly below your normal rate, the work location being unreasonably far, or the job not matching your skills/classification can qualify. But I'd document every declined referral with the reason so you have a paper trail.

0 coins

The declined referral issue is real and it trips people up. I had a buddy who turned down a referral because the job site was an hour and forty minutes away and he nearly got disqualified. Had to explain and document everything before Arizona DES accepted it.

0 coins

About two weeks ago I got the same kind of notice the original poster is describing. I've been a union sheet metal worker for 15 years and this is my first time ever dealing with unemployment because I've never been laid off this long before. Reading this thread has been more helpful than anything on the actual Arizona DES website, which as far as I can tell has nothing that specifically addresses union hiring hall situations. The FAQ just talks about applying to employers and submitting resumes, none of which applies to how I find work.

0 coins

15 years without needing this system — and then when you do need it the information is nowhere to be found. That's genuinely frustrating.

0 coins

Exactly. And I feel like I should know what I'm doing by now at my age and experience level but this whole system is unfamiliar territory.

0 coins

The DES website is unfortunately pretty generic. The specific union provisions exist in their policy manuals but they don't surface them on the public-facing pages. You'd have to know to ask about them specifically.

0 coins

This is true — I actually found a reference to it in a DES administrative document I stumbled on through a search, not through anything on their main site.

0 coins

Just finished week 11 of my claim as a union boilermaker. Early on I called Arizona DES something like six or seven times trying to get a straight answer about the work search stuff and kept getting disconnected or waiting 2 hours to get to someone who didn't know the answer and transferred me to hold again. By week 5 I finally got a supervisor-level agent who actually knew the union provisions and cleared everything up in one conversation. The difference in knowledge level between different agents is massive. Some know nothing about union hiring hall situations, some know exactly what to do.

0 coins

Six or seven attempts before getting someone useful is demoralizing to even think about. How do you even know when you've finally reached someone who knows what they're doing?

0 coins

Honestly you can usually tell in the first 30 seconds. If they immediately start reading from a script about submitting applications to employers, they don't know the union situation. If they ask which hall and what trade, they're the right person.

0 coins

Asking for a supervisor from the start might be the move then, to skip the line of agents who don't know this stuff.

0 coins

I tried that — sometimes it works, sometimes the supervisor is just as unfamiliar. Really is luck of the draw.

0 coins

My claim was approved about six weeks back after a genuinely confusing adjudication period. I work through the laborers union and my situation was complicated because I had a brief period where I took a small non-union side job while waiting for a hall referral. That complicated the job search question answer because I was doing both — maintaining hall registration AND doing some traditional job applications for the non-union work. Arizona DES wasn't sure how to categorize me and that's what triggered the adjudication. Eventually they determined I could be counted under the union provisions for the periods I was exclusively on hall registration, and as a standard claimant for the period I was doing non-union job searches. Split determination basically.

0 coins

A split determination across different weeks of the same claim — I didn't know that was even possible. That must have been complicated to sort out.

0 coins

It was a lot of back and forth. Definitely not something I'd recommend intentionally getting into. If you can keep your situation cleanly one or the other it's much simpler.

0 coins

This is actually useful information because a lot of union guys do pick up non-union work between referrals. Good to know Arizona DES has a way to handle it even if it's messy.

0 coins

Last month I finally talked to someone at Arizona DES who explained the whole union situation clearly after weeks of getting nowhere on the portal. Used Claimyr to get through — heard about it from someone else who was dealing with Arizona DES hold times. Ended up speaking with an agent who had me sorted out in about 20 minutes. If you're stuck and the portal isn't responding and the hold times are killing you, worth looking at. claimyr.com and there's a video at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y. Specifically for the union job search question the agent told me: your hall registration and active availability status is your work search, full stop, as long as the account is coded correctly and you have your union documentation submitted.

0 coins

Full' stop is what I needed to hear honestly.'I ve been going back and forth wondering if I need to also be doing external applications on top of the hallstuff.

0 coins

The agent was pretty clear — for union members in an active hall dispatch system, external applications are not expected or required as long as your registration is current and you're responding to referral opportunities.

0 coins

This is reassuring. I've been panicking about whether I need to be on Indeed sending out resumes while also maintaining my hall status.

0 coins

Week 3 of waiting on hall dispatch right now. This whole thread answered questions I've been sitting on for days. One thing I haven't seen addressed yet: what about the ARIZONA@WORK registration requirement? I know Arizona DES typically requires new claimants to register with ARIZONA@WORK but I'm unclear on whether union members still have to do that or if the union provisions cover that too.

0 coins

ARIZONA@WORK registration is separate from the job search requirement and as far as I know it's still required for all claimants including union members, unless you have a specific exemption. It's pretty simple to do though — took me maybe 20 minutes to register online.

0 coins

This is correct from my experience. The union provisions cover the weekly job search contacts requirement but the ARIZONA@WORK registration is a baseline requirement that applies regardless. Arizona DES can deny or delay benefits if it's not done.

0 coins

Okay that's clear then — register with ARIZONA@WORK regardless, but the union documentation handles the weekly search activity side of things.

0 coins

ARIZONA@WORK registration is also where you do your skills assessment if they require it. For union trades workers they usually recognize your apprenticeship or journeyman certification as satisfying that piece.

0 coins

Eight days into my claim as a union tile setter and I'll be real, I am completely overwhelmed by all of this. The CACTUS portal looks nothing like what I expected and the weekly cert questions feel like a trap every time I answer them. I answered that I 'did not apply to any employers' last week because I haven't — I've been updating my status with the hall like I'm supposed to — and now I'm scared I answered something wrong.

0 coins

Day 8 is early enough that if something is flagged you can still sort it out before it becomes a bigger problem. The 'did not apply to employers' answer might be fine depending on how the other questions on that cert were answered — does your claim still show as active with payments scheduled?

0 coins

Payments still showing as scheduled, nothing on my CACTUS account looks different. So maybe I'm panicking for nothing.

0 coins

If payments are on schedule and nothing changed on the portal, you're likely fine. The flag usually shows up pretty clearly when something has been triggered. Keep your hall registration documentation ready just in case.

0 coins

I was in the same anxious place two weeks ago when I posted this. The thread has really helped me understand what I'm actually dealing with. Keep your documentation organized and get your business agent letter ready to submit if they ask for it.

0 coins

Just over a month into my claim and I work through a union stage crew — entertainment industry, totally different world from construction but same hiring hall dispatch structure. Everything in this thread applies to my situation too. The job search question issue isn't unique to any one union trade, it's a structural thing about how Arizona DES handles any hiring hall employment model. Nice to know it's not just my industry dealing with this.

0 coins

Entertainment union dealing with the same thing as construction unions — that's a good data point. Makes sense that it's a systemic Arizona DES design issue rather than anything trade-specific.

0 coins

Exactly, and in entertainment the work is even more project-based and irregular than most construction, so the hiring hall model is even more essential to how everyone finds work. The idea of sending resumes to individual employers is completely foreign to how our industry operates.

0 coins

The fact that the same issue shows up across completely different union industries really does suggest this is a gap in how Arizona DES was designed, not an edge case.

0 coins

About 9 weeks into my claim as a union glazier. What I want to add to this conversation is something about timing — specifically about not waiting to get the documentation issue resolved. I waited until week 6 to call Arizona DES about the union coding on my account because I kept thinking it would sort itself out or someone at DES would notice. It didn't sort itself out. If you're on this thread reading and wondering whether to call now or wait a little longer, call now. Every week that passes with the wrong account coding is another week that could get flagged or audited retroactively.

0 coins

Nine weeks in and the advice is to have called sooner — noted. I'm going to get on the phone with Arizona DES this week and get the account coding confirmed before my next weekly cert.

0 coins

That's the move. Even if everything turns out to be fine, you'll know for certain and you won't be guessing every week when you certify.

0 coins

This is the real practical takeaway from the whole thread. Get it confirmed directly, don't assume the system picked it up automatically.

0 coins

Final week of my claim — going back to work Monday on a referral that finally came through after 24 weeks out. Looking back, the job search question was the single most stressful part of the whole process because of exactly this confusion. The union hall provision is real and it protects union members from having to do things that don't make sense for how we find work, but you have to actively ensure Arizona DES knows to apply it to your claim. I ended up having to call twice, with the second conversation being the one that actually fixed things. If you're struggling to get through, Claimyr was what finally got me to that second conversation when I was at my wit's end with the hold times. You end up talking to a live agent at Arizona DES — that's what matters when you need something actually changed in your file.

0 coins

24 weeks and now back on a job site — that's the finish line I'm aiming for. Thank you for coming back to close the loop on your situation, it helps to see the full arc of how it goes.

0 coins

It's a long road but it does end. Document everything, get your union letter submitted early, make sure the account is coded right, and don't let questions sit unanswered — call Arizona DES and get them resolved.

0 coins

24 weeks on a claim is a long time to have everything working correctly. The fact that you managed the process well enough to get through without a major disqualification is genuinely impressive given everything this thread describes.

0 coins

There were a couple of close calls early on. The adjudication scare in week 4 was bad. But once the account coding was fixed it was mostly stable after that.

0 coins

Just starting week 2 of my claim as a union operating engineer. This thread was the first thing that actually explained the union job search situation in plain terms. The Arizona DES website sent me in circles for an hour without answering any of this. My business agent already told me he's written these letters before so at least I know to get one — going to request it tomorrow.

0 coins

Week 2 is a great time to get this sorted. You're early enough that there's nothing to retroactively fix yet — you can get the letter submitted and the account coded before any flags even have a chance to generate.

0 coins

That's the goal. I want to be in a situation where everything is documented and confirmed before week 4 or 5 when it sounds like things can start going sideways if the paperwork isn't in order.

0 coins

Getting the letter from your business agent quickly is the right call. Mine took about a week to get the official letterhead version together so factor that into your timeline.

0 coins

Somewhere around week 7 of my claim right now, union carpenter like the original poster. I had a mini-panic moment reading the part about account coding because I have no idea if mine was set up correctly. Called Arizona DES this morning — first time I'd called, been relying on the portal for everything — and after about 90 minutes on hold I actually got through to someone. She checked my account and said the coding was fine, the union provision was already on there. So sometimes the system does pick it up correctly, it just depends on who processed your initial claim and whether they knew what they were doing.

0 coins

90 minutes is a long hold but at least you got an answer. And good news that it was already set up correctly. That's reassuring that it's not always a problem.

0 coins

Yeah I was braced for bad news and it turned out fine. Still glad I called though — now I actually know instead of guessing.

0 coins

This is a good point. It's not always wrong. But you won't know unless you check, and checking is worth the hold time for the peace of mind.

0 coins

Arizona Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure