Back to Arizona Unemployment

Faith Kingston

Is agricultural unemployment tax exempt in Arizona DES? Confused about my farm worker situation

So I've been working seasonal harvest jobs for about six years now, moving between different agricultural operations in Maricopa and Pinal counties depending on the time of year. Last fall I got laid off when the cotton harvest wrapped up and went to file for UI benefits through Arizona DES for the first time ever. The whole process felt like walking into a foreign country. I honestly had no clue what to expect. Here's where it gets complicated: my employer told me before I left that farm workers don't qualify for unemployment because agricultural employment is tax exempt and they don't pay into the system. But then my neighbor (who also does field work) said she collected unemployment last year just fine. Now I'm completely lost. Is agricultural unemployment tax exempt in Arizona? Does that mean I literally cannot get benefits, or does it depend on the size of the farm or how many workers they employ? I submitted my initial claim but I'm worried it's going to get denied because of this exemption thing. Anyone have actual experience with this?

Week three of waiting on my own claim right now, so I've been researching everything I can about how Arizona DES works. What I found about agricultural workers is that it's actually more complicated than a simple yes or no. Arizona does follow federal guidelines that exempt certain smaller farm employers from paying into the UI system, but larger agricultural operations that meet specific employee thresholds ARE required to pay unemployment taxes. So whether you can collect basically depends on who your specific employer was and how many workers they employed.

0 coins

That size threshold piece is exactly what I couldn't find clear info on. Do you know what the actual numbers are for Arizona? Like how many employees does a farm need before they're required to pay in?

0 coins

Jumped on the Arizona DES website after reading this and there's some info buried in the employer section about agricultural exemptions. It basically says something about 10 or more workers in a calendar quarter for 20 weeks, or a certain payroll amount. honestly the wording is confusing

0 coins

Just hit the two-week mark after submitting my own adjudication paperwork and I want to tell you what happened with my farmworker relative's claim last year because it's pretty relevant. Her employer was a large vegetable operation with hundreds of seasonal workers and she had no problem qualifying. The employer absolutely paid UI taxes. Your former employer might just be saying that to avoid any blowback from you filing - some employers don't want their tax rates to go up and they'll say anything.

0 coins

Honestly that crossed my mind too. I figured there might be some motivation behind what they told me. I'm going to push forward with the claim and see what happens.

0 coins

My first week filing I got the same runaround from a farm I worked at. Filed anyway, got approved. Some of these employers count on workers not knowing their rights

0 coins

Yeah the experience with the large operations being covered checks out. The exemption really is targeted at the smaller family farm operations, not the big commercial agriculture businesses running hundreds of acres with large crews

0 coins

Sitting here on day 31 of my own claim being stuck and I want to share something that actually helped me get answers. I'd been trying to reach Arizona DES by phone for literally two weeks with zero luck - endless hold music and then getting disconnected. Someone in another forum mentioned Claimyr, it basically stays on hold with Arizona DES for you so you end up talking to a live agent without spending your whole day on the phone. I found the site at claimyr.com and there's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y. For your situation specifically, talking to an actual Arizona DES agent who can look up your former employer's tax status would give you a definitive answer way faster than guessing online.

0 coins

Day 31 sounds awful, I really hope yours moves soon. I'm going to look at that Claimyr option because I've already tried calling twice and both times I waited over an hour and got nothing. Getting to an actual agent who can check my employer's status sounds like the fastest way to resolve this.

0 coins

Tried calling Arizona DES probably a dozen times myself over three weeks before I found a way through. The hold times are genuinely brutal, especially for agricultural questions which seem to need a specialist anyway

0 coins

Got my claim approved last month and I want to add - when I finally reached an agent they were actually able to tell me right away whether my farm employer had a UI account on file. That five minute conversation cleared up two weeks of anxiety for me. Claimyr is what got me through to that agent after everything else failed, it's worth using if phone access is what's blocking you.

0 coins

I used to think the tax-exempt thing meant ALL farm work was excluded from unemployment - held that belief for years actually, even told other workers the same wrong thing. The real deal is that it's specific employers who may be exempt, not the entire agricultural sector. If your employer met the size or payroll thresholds, they were legally required to pay Arizona UI taxes regardless of whether they told you otherwise. Arizona DES can verify employer tax status directly.

0 coins

This reframes the whole thing for me. My former employer acting like this is some blanket rule makes more sense now - either they genuinely don't know, or they're hoping I don't look into it.

0 coins

Exactly right. And even if the employer somehow slipped through without paying, that's a problem Arizona DES pursues with the employer, not automatically a denial for the worker who files in good faith

0 coins

My adjudication status changed for the first time after five weeks so I finally have headspace to respond to stuff like this. The cotton harvest situation you described is really common in Pinal County. Those operations are almost always large enough to be required contributors. I'd be surprised if a commercial cotton operation was actually exempt.

0 coins

Good to hear from someone who knows that specific area and crop. Cotton harvest operations definitely aren't small family farms, that's for sure.

0 coins

Pinal County ag operations are massive. I grew up out there and the farms running cotton employ hundreds of people per season. No way they're the small exempt type

0 coins

The scale point matters a lot here. Exemptions are really designed around the family farm model, not commercial commodity agriculture

0 coins

got denied once for an ag job and appealed it. turned out my employer HAD paid in, the initial claim examiner just made an error flagging it as potentially exempt. appeals process fixed it in about 3 weeks

0 coins

Really glad to know the appeals process can catch those kinds of errors. I'll keep that in my back pocket if the initial decision goes wrong.

0 coins

Appeals are underused honestly. A lot of people see a denial and just give up, but examiner errors happen and the appeal is specifically there to catch them

0 coins

I thought for a long time that if my employer claimed exemption then Arizona DES just automatically took their word for it. What actually happens is DES has records of which employers have UI tax accounts and they verify independently - the employer doesn't get to just declare themselves exempt at the moment a former worker files. If they were supposed to be paying in and weren't, that's a whole separate enforcement issue.

0 coins

This is an important point. The verification happens on Arizona DES's end, not based on what the employer tells the worker after the fact

0 coins

yeah i learned this the hard way thinking my old boss had any say in whether my claim got approved. DES does their own lookup

0 coins

So basically I should just file and let Arizona DES verify on their end rather than taking my employer's word for it. That's what I should have done from the start instead of worrying.

0 coins

Three letters into my ongoing correspondence with Arizona DES about a separate issue, so I've learned more about their processes than I ever wanted to. For agricultural unemployment specifically, there are also some nuances around which wages count toward your base period calculation. Even if you're eligible, only wages from covered employers count toward your benefit amount calculation. If you had any work at an exempt employer mixed in with covered employers, those wages from the exempt employer won't count toward your weekly benefit amount.

0 coins

Oh that's a wrinkle I hadn't thought about. What if someone has worked at multiple farms, some covered and some not? Do you just get credit for the covered wages?

0 coins

Exactly, only the wages from covered employers factor into the base period. Arizona DES bases your weekly benefit amount on your highest earning quarter from covered employment, so if your best quarter was with an exempt employer those wages would be excluded from the calculation

0 coins

This is actually really useful to know for anyone mixing covered and potentially exempt agricultural work in their history

0 coins

week one of my own claim and already stressed reading all this. does anyone know if the job search requirements work differently for agricultural workers on UI? like do you still have to apply to 3 jobs a week even if you're a seasonal farm worker who plans to go back to harvest work next season

0 coins

Had the exact same question before my standby status got sorted out. If you have a definite return date from your agricultural employer and you can get approved for standby status, the weekly job search requirements can be waived. Without standby approval you do need to meet the regular job search requirements - three employer contacts per week in Arizona.

0 coins

Standby is the key term to look up. Seasonal agricultural workers with return dates are actually one of the clearest qualifying situations for standby status under Arizona DES rules

0 coins

Going to research the standby application process today then. That changes everything for me if I'm planning to go back to the same operation next harvest

0 coins

My initial claim approval came after six weeks of complete silence from Arizona DES so I know that waiting feeling all too well. One thing worth knowing - if you submit your claim and Arizona DES needs to investigate the employer's tax status, that investigation period can add time to your processing. Your claim might sit in adjudication longer than average agricultural claims where the employer status is already clear in the system.

0 coins

Preparing myself for a longer adjudication period then. At least I know why it might take longer rather than just panicking about it.

0 coins

The adjudication timeline for employer verification issues varies a lot. Mine took almost four weeks just for the employer contact portion before my claim moved forward

0 coins

employer told me i couldn't file too. filed anyway got approved in 2 weeks. dont let them scare you

0 coins

Short and to the point and honestly exactly what I needed to hear. Filing and letting the process work seems like the obvious move.

0 coins

Same energy here. Filed despite being told I wasn't eligible for two different reasons. Both were wrong.

0 coins

Month two of dealing with Arizona DES and I want to circle back to the phone access problem because it's genuinely the biggest obstacle for a lot of agricultural workers. Claimyr was the thing that finally got me in front of an actual DES agent - I'd been trying on my own for weeks. For your specific situation where you need someone to look up your employer's tax account status, that phone conversation is probably necessary and claimyr.com makes getting there actually realistic instead of a full day project.

0 coins

Phone access really is the bottleneck for anything that requires actual account investigation. The online portal can only show you so much.

0 coins

Saving claimyr.com for when I hit that wall. Already dreading it based on everything I've read here

0 coins

My appeal decision came through last week after a 6-week process and I want to offer a slightly different take. I initially thought the employer tax exemption question would automatically get resolved in adjudication. But what actually happened with my case is that Arizona DES sent me a questionnaire asking about the nature of my agricultural work - the type of work, duration, number of coworkers, operation size stuff - before they even contacted my employer. So be ready for that if your claim goes into investigation.

0 coins

Really practical heads-up. I'll start gathering that info now so I'm not scrambling if they contact me. I know the operation size, how many workers were on the crew, all of that.

0 coins

The questionnaire piece makes sense because Arizona DES probably uses that worker-side information to build the case for why the employer should have been covered, before formally reaching out to them

0 coins

Just got off the phone with Arizona DES after spending 40 minutes getting through - Claimyr handled the hold time, I just showed up for the conversation when an agent picked up. I'd asked about agricultural exemptions for a friend in basically your exact situation. The agent confirmed that large commercial harvest operations in Maricopa and Pinal counties are virtually always covered employers, and they can verify any specific employer's status in minutes once you give them the employer name and FEIN. Your friend or you just needs to actually get through to them.

0 coins

Knowing they can pull up the employer status that fast is reassuring. The bottleneck really is just getting to the agent.

0 coins

The FEIN thing is useful - if you have any old pay stubs from that employer the FEIN should be on there and that speeds up the agent lookup significantly

0 coins

40 minutes getting through on your own would have been impossible on most days I tried. Any method that gets you past that is worth using

0 coins

Received my determination letter finally yesterday after 7 weeks so I'm posting while it's fresh. The letter actually explained in plain language that my former employer met the 10-or-more-workers threshold and therefore was a covered employer, so my claim was approved. That threshold language in the official letter was the first time I'd seen it spelled out clearly. So for anyone wondering - Arizona DES does explain the employer coverage determination in writing when they send your decision.

0 coins

7 weeks is a long time but getting that clear explanation in the determination letter sounds like it was worth the wait. I'll be looking for that employer coverage language when mine comes.

0 coins

The 10-or-more-workers language in the determination letter is actually really helpful to know exists. At least when you get the decision you understand the basis for it

0 coins

got the same kind of explanation in my determination. much clearer than the portal status updates which tell you basically nothing

0 coins

reading this whole thread because i start my first ever claim tomorrow for pecan orchard work. never done this before and now im worried about everything. do i need to already know if my employer is exempt when i fill out the initial application or does DES figure that out

0 coins

Starting the application without knowing your employer's tax status is completely fine. You fill out what you know - your employer name, your work dates, your earnings - and Arizona DES does the verification on their end. You are not expected to know whether your employer has a UI tax account.

0 coins

Submitting tomorrow then with what I have. That's a relief because I definitely don't have access to my employer's tax records

0 coins

Just make sure your employer info is as complete as possible - full legal name of the business not just a nickname, your dates of employment, your earnings if you have pay stubs. The more accurate your info the faster DES can do the lookup

0 coins

Five months ago I went through basically this exact thing for citrus work in Yuma and want to give the resolution version of the story. Filed despite being told the farm was exempt. Adjudication took four and a half weeks. DES determined my employer was covered. Collected benefits for the full season gap. The employer's claim that they were exempt was just wrong.

0 coins

The Yuma citrus situation being so parallel to mine and resolving the way it did is genuinely encouraging. Four and a half weeks is what I should probably budget for.

0 coins

Citrus and cotton are similar in scale so the coverage result tracking makes sense. These commercial operations aren't the small farm exemption cases at all

0 coins

Writing this down for my own situation tomorrow. Citrus, pecan, cotton - large commercial operations, employer likely covered, file and let DES verify

0 coins

My fourth week of weekly certifications done and I want to mention something nobody's brought up yet. Even while your claim is in adjudication because of the employer coverage question, you should absolutely keep filing your weekly certifications on time. If the determination eventually comes back in your favor, you'll only get paid for the weeks you actually certified. Missing a week during adjudication means missing that week's benefits even after approval.

0 coins

This is critical and I would have potentially missed this. I've been holding off on certifications thinking I should wait for adjudication to resolve first. Certifying now.

0 coins

Cannot stress this enough. Every week you miss certifying during adjudication is a week of benefits you lose permanently, even if your claim gets fully approved

0 coins

The portal lets you file certifications even when your claim status shows as pending or in adjudication. A lot of people don't realize that and wait, then lose those weeks

0 coins

Arizona Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure